It was the biggest consultation any British government has ever conducted. With more than 200,000 responses, Shabana Mahmood’s plans to change the path to settled status drew an unprecedented reaction when put to the British public. And inside the Labour Party, there have been open letters, speeches, and pointed comments from senior figures about the plans for over a year.
Now, the Home Secretary has revealed her hand: she has scrapped her plans for foreign care workers to wait 15 years for settlement, diluted rules for dependents and made some other tweaks on things like volunteering requirements. But the main thrust of her proposals – including parts that have been controversial among her colleagues – still stand.
Mahmood is ultimately still going ahead with a very significant reform to how many immigrants achieve “settled status” and thereby the right to reside in the UK. From a system in which this right to live, work and study in this country permanently without any time limit on their stay was granted almost automatically after five years, the Home Secretary is moving to an “earned settlement” path, where the greater the contribution, the quicker a migrant can achieve settled status. Doctors, nurses and high earners, for example, can settle after five years, while the new norm will become ten years, and those with criminal records are barred completely. At the sharp end, refugees who arrive on small boats and have not entered work or study will wait 30 years for settled status. (See below for the new model in more detail.)
Mahmood’s shift on care workers is a significant one, and a victory for Angela Rayner, who first raised her concerns about the “un-British” proposals as a backbencher earlier this year. Rayner reiterated her concerns as recently as September, having rejoined the cabinet under Andy Burnham. She argued that care workers from overseas had been invited to this country by Boris Johnson’s care visa scheme to look after our loved ones in a sector that had been ravaged by the pandemic, only to find the goalposts shifted.
Mahmood and Burnham now agree, and have shifted policy and tone accordingly. They met last week to agree the approach, and he owns this move with her. For a Prime Minister who has made social care a priority – and who has spoken movingly about the foreign care workers who looked after his father as he died of Alzheimer’s – there was probably no other option. Care workers were also, according to the Home Office, the subject of the vast majority of respondents to this huge government consultation.
But care was not the only concern among Mahmood’s cabinet colleagues. Miatta Fahnbulleh, now Energy Secretary, previously expressed concerns that making people wait decades in limbo before achieving settled status would be a disaster for integration. Many others in the Labour ranks have previously expressed worries about “moving the goalposts”, concerned that Mahmood is proposing to change the rules for settled status for hundreds of thousands of people who arrived in this country expecting a different system.
Mahmood is digging in on that point. Her consultation response and her statement to the House of Commons both emphasised that “being in the UK does not give someone an automatic right to settle under the rules that existed when they first arrived”. By law, what matters are the rules when the settlement decision is reached.
Some of what happens next will be determined by the Home Secretary’s tone and engagement with colleagues – and the signs so far are that she intends to do things more constructively than a year ago. Meanwhile, the Rayners and Fahnbullehs of this world will now have to hold their tongues. It would have been eccentric for Andy Burnham to keep Shabana Mahmood as Home Secretary without supporting her on the main thrust of her changes. By appointing her and working with her to arrive at this conclusion, Burnham will hope – and expect – the matter is now settled. Now his cabinet must fall into line behind.
Will the same be true for Labour MPs? With an all-powerful new Prime Minister backing her, a whipping system determined to do things differently and a Home Secretary clearly intending to engage with Labour MPs constructively, it seems like Shabana Mahmood’s revised plans will land better than they did a year ago. But these are still difficult plans for parts of the Labour Party to swallow.
The new rules
Legal migrants will settle on the following timelines:
- 3 years: additional rate taxpayers earning over £125,141, and the highly skilled on routes such as Global Talent and Innovator Founder.
- 5 years: higher rate taxpayers earning over £50,271, and skilled public service workers such as doctors, nurses and teachers, refugees arriving on safe and legal routes.
- 10 years: the new standard route for everyone else and refugees who move into work and study. Settlement stays open to them, but they must show a sustained contribution.
- 20 years: anyone who claims certain benefits while in the UK or commits a visa offence.
Refugees will settle on the following timelines:
- 5 years: those who arrive on safe and legal routes.
- 10 years: those who did not arrive by small boat and have entered work or study.
- 20 years: those who did not arrive by small boat and have not entered work or study.
- 20 years: those who arrived by small boat and have entered work or study.
- 30 years: those who arrived by small boat and have not entered work or study.
[Further reading: Andy Burnham’s small victory]






Join the debate
Subscribe here to comment