Could Corbyn win votes from Ukip?

Jeremy Corbyn has that quality that many politicians lack: authenticity, says Ruby Lott-Lavigna.

NS

Sign Up

Get the New Statesman's Morning Call email.

I recently wrote about a brief stint on Tinder where I tried to convince people to vote for Jeremy Corbyn. Although my search for true love continues, what started as a gimmicky article idea actually ended up exposing some interesting perspectives on the leadership race. Admittedly, a lot of people were annoyed I wouldn’t meet up with them, didn’t care who Corbyn was or just ignored me when I started talking about politics. However, whilst right swiping my dignity away, I encountered a pro-Corbyn Ukip voter.

No, you read that right. Voted Ukip; loved Corbyn. He told me the reason he was attracted to Ukip was because of Farage, and the impression he gives of being sincere. “You won’t see him pussy foot around the question like all these politicians and that’s the same with Corbyn, he answers questions straight and that’s what I like about him. I love someone who stands up for what they believe in.” He even said he’d consider joining to vote for Corbyn.

I’ll be honest – I think most people who vote Ukip aren’t actually that committed to their policies. In fact, on average, I suspect if you ask a Ukip voter what’s in their party manifesto they won’t be able to tell you. But they will be able to tell you about Farage – about how he stands up to the bureaucrats in Brussels, about how he speaks his mind, about the way he doesn’t seem like everyone else in politics. People join Ukip – like my tinder match did – because of Farage, because of a leader who convinced them not by what he was saying, but the way he was saying it.

I once read something interesting about the extent to which politicians will have to voice train in order to appear electable. They’ve got to hit the right balance between being friendly and authoritative, repeating the same vanilla diatribes but in a way that sounds like it’s the first time they’ve ever said it. Sounding human, sounding interesting, is so essential to the electability of a politician, and people will work for years on trying to strike the right tone. If this is testament to anything, it’s that appearing charismatic as an MP is a strangely unusual and sought after skill. Natalie Bennett, Ed Miliband, people on the left who have ostensibly good policies, all got slated by the left for their inability to appear convincing. I’m reluctant to admit that politics is a popularity contest where your random genetic combination and socialised charisma skills win you votes over actual intelligence or policy, but maybe for a handful of the electorate - the handful that vote Ukip at least – that’s what it is.

And who can blame them? Politics is boring. Corbyn isn’t just winning because he’s good, he’s winning because no one thought he would win and that’s exciting.  Jeremy Corbyn is an unusual candidate for contemporary politics and it’s why we can’t fully predict the reach of his support. It may seem unlikely that you could convince someone to switch from one end of the political spectrum to the other, but punters had Corbyn at 500/1 and now he’s comfortably ahead in the polls so the unthinkable is happening. And the fact that the unthinkable is happening simply perpetuates this trend – the more Corbyn stands out, the more interesting and invigorating he seems to potential supporters.

Ukip is entry-level politics, capitalising of fear tactics: the cheapest advertisement technique possible. It’s not clever but it’s superficial and gets people listening. But in its essence, in its fragile logic it can easily be broken, all you need is a compelling leader who appears to “stand up for what he believes in.” If you just want someone who takes a stand, breaks the trend and looks vaguely human and less like a cyborg, then Corbyn is the only other well-known politician doing that today. He even doesn’t really like Europe.

Personality politics is not something I endorse. It draws away from the policies and also tends to fall in line with the status quo (old white men = charismatic). Yet, Corbyn’s different. Or at least, he might be different if he’s able to bring Ukip voters to Labour I’ll support personality politics if he can do that.