I write this column as SW1’s travelling circus of politicians, think-tankers and lobbyists emerge, headachey and fuzzy-tongued, from the autumn party conference season. Many love it – one journalist describes it as “Glastonbury for geeks” – and take a sincere interest in the blast of policy ideas it releases into the political ether.
But a story more central to our future politics, it seems to me, than anything proposed this year by any politician or party could be found on the menu of the Liverpool Albert Dock branch of Pizza Express. Usually a doughy comfort for exhausted Labour conference delegates seeking carbs, this year it felt more like an unwelcome encounter with reality: it now costs £20.45 for a Calabrese pizza on a Romana base.
Forget the personal-allowance threshold or savings from unpicking the pension triple lock – this is the number politicians should keep in mind. After a relative dip, food-price inflation in Britain is expected to rise in the coming months and shoot up next year. Many Brits already feel that holidays, treats and eating out are no longer affordable – a family meal at Pizza Express or McDonald’s is a luxury drifting out of reach. And the cost of a weekly shop is to spike again.
This is the danger zone for an explicitly cost-of-living-conscious government, as Andy Burnham’s has been since he became Prime Minister. Labour’s approach is to give people some immediate relief on their bills and everyday costs to buy goodwill and patience for big structural changes that could repair things long-term – if the party wins the next election. This is the “breathing space” Burnham and his Chancellor, John Healey, talk about: measures to make energy bills and bus tickets cheaper, for example. But what happens when the breathing space is choked on arrival?
Social democratic and socialist governments are particularly susceptible to this affordability trap. Spain’s prime minister, Pedro Sánchez, has just announced an early election for November after his new housing decrees were blocked by opposing right-wing parties. He proposed them in response to widespread protests, triggered by the eviction of an 87-year-old disabled woman called Maricarmen Abascal whose rent had been hiked 230 per cent by the investment fund that bought the Madrid flat where she’d lived for 70 years. Yet Sánchez’s measures to ease the pain of expensive housing – from banning the eviction of vulnerable tenants until 2030 to the automatic renewal of rental contracts – didn’t have sufficient support to pass.
From Spain to Australia to Mexico, centre-left governments are prioritising housing affordability – so central is it to a good life and opportunities for future generations. “But they’re finding that actually the policy answers to that are very difficult when you’ve got housing markets that have been broken for a long time,” says Claire Ainsley, the former policy chief to Keir Starmer in opposition, and a director at the Progressive Policy Institute, where she researches how centre-left parties win back voters they had lost to the populist right.
The Spanish story underscores “how difficult it is to implement domestic policies on key areas of affordability that actually have popular support and change the dial”, she says. “Housing is an area they’ve decided to focus on, but they’ve clearly had these huge increases in house prices and rents that are overwhelming what the government is trying to do positively.”
This is an example of the wider challenge for governments of coming up with cost-of-living policies when the underlying problems are structural and out of their immediate control. To compound the problem, political consensus in a polarised world is harder to reach. The former German chancellor Olaf Scholz failed to push through his budget proposals, leading to the break-up of his coalition and an early election. Emmanuel Macron of France, too, has struggled to pass budgets. Both grappled with problems familiar in the UK today, from welfare payments to the cost of retirement – and school underfunding is now the subject of fervent protest in France. Both had to make compromises.
“Centre-left leaders are finding it really difficult to get wider political support for their answers, which means sort-of-centrist compromises – which might be the right thing to do in policy terms – are sometimes too incremental for the scale of the challenge,” says Ainsley.
Andy Burnham sees housing justice as central to fixing Britain. His first policy announcement on his first day as Prime Minister was to end rough sleeping, and whenever he talks about housebuilding, he specifies that this means “council houses”. But the compromises have already begun. Labour has basically admitted defeat on its 1.5 million-homes-a-year target; it is yet to “abolish leasehold”; and most of the funding for social and affordable homes released so far has been for housing associations, which are private bodies rather than councils. A new Help to Buy-style scheme – though we don’t yet have the details – risks mimicking the Tories by juicing demand among first-time buyers without supplying enough housing stock.
Britain is not Spain; Labour has a large majority. But we are more exposed to energy price shocks, given how much gas we import. When promising to make daily life – from nights out to having a roof over our heads – easier to afford, Burnham must beware of forces beyond his control that could wipe out even piecemeal progress. Perhaps he should get himself down to the docks and order a Calabrese.
[Further reading: Zack Polanski has better things to do than lead the Green Party]
Content from our partners
This article appears in the 07 Oct 2026 issue of the New Statesman, The Suspicious Relationship






Join the debate
Subscribe here to comment