One day, a scholar somewhere will decide that The Newer World marked a cultural watershed. In 2026, they will declare, a white Irishman named Sebastian Barry wrote a book about a black ex-slave and nobody minded. They’ll set it off against the response to Jeanine Cummins’s contentious 2020 contemporary migration novel American Dirt. The comparison suggests a cultural sea change, they’ll say. Surely Barry sounded the death knell for that whole cultural appropriation debate.
But don’t fetch your Apache headdress down from the loft just yet. For starters, Barry has pulled this off before, writing from gay and native American perspectives. And while he was one of many writers to speak out in Cummins’s defence, there are a number of ways Barry’s new book does not resemble hers. First, Barry is a more sensitive writer. Second, Cummins’s book was about migration in a way that Barry’s is not about slavery. His book is really about Tennyson Bouguereau.
Tennyson, a former slave with a sweet voice, was present in Barry’s previous adventures through 19th-century America, Days without End (2016) and A Thousand Moons (2020). Now, despite the warnings of his publishers, Barry has written his life story.
The Newer World begins with Tennyson’s birth in the narrow window between his father’s execution and his mother’s murder, before breezing through his childhood and the events of A Thousand Moons. After the adult Tennyson’s singing voice earns him a place at a school for freedmen, the narrative blooms into a late-onset Bildungsroman. Tennyson discovers opportunities to learn, travel and love. The school’s choir takes Tennyson through the states surrounding Tennessee and, in one of the book’s defining episodes, all the way to England. Scenes of army life then follow, in which Barry largely retreads ground covered in Days without End, with the subtle difference that Tennyson views the killing of native Americans through the lens of liberty: “That was our work. To cancel freedom,” he remarks. “A thought to crush your heart.”
Barry’s now well-practised voice, which blends lofty musings with a twangy, idiomatic rhythm, again proves the perfect register for this version of 19th-century America, with its wide, unreal vistas and banal killings. On the death of a fellow soldier, Tennyson remarks: “Death had marked his dancing card, and took the dance.” Note-perfect turns of phrase like this are offered up almost every other line.
More awkward are Barry’s occasional, uncertain attempts to address the cultural appropriation question. In one instance, Tennyson declares that professional opera singers could never match his choir of freed men: “You had got to have those hard times in you. And we did.” This note of apparent deference from Barry is made murkier when Tennyson overhears a Confederate soldier singing a slave song: “What was it doing in the mouth of a butternut soldier?” Tennyson asks. “For all that, none of us could have sung it better.” Does the soldier have those hard times in him then? Does Barry?
Otherwise, though the author works within the context of slavery, there is never a sense that Barry is cashing in on others’ suffering. The novel dutifully addresses pain and violence, but it also indulges in kinship, love and hope.
As he travels, Tennyson considers these latter themes in relation to the books he has read, particularly the Odyssey. While he won’t concede that Hades could be any worse than Mississippi, he recognises some truth in Odysseus: “I was like him in this one hard thing. The longing. The sickness of returning home.” The difference is that Tennyson has no Ithaca to return to.
In that respect, he is perhaps closer to the Odysseus depicted by his namesake Alfred, Lord Tennyson in Ulysses, the poem from which Barry requisitions the phrase “newer world”. That Odysseus can find no rest; his home lies always over the next horizon. Tennyson Bouguereau, first because of his race’s persecution, but increasingly because of his own desires, is much the same.
When Barry at last lays down his pen, the end of Tennyson’s journey remains out of sight, but what is sparklingly clear is Tennyson himself. He is an endearing, memorable character, and Barry’s best defence against any would-be detractors. Even the most warlike cultural critic would hesitate before suggesting he shouldn’t have been written.
The Newer World
Sebastian Barry
Faber & Faber, 272pp, £20
Purchasing a book may earn the NS a commission from Bookshop.org, who support independent bookshops
[Further reading: Tolkien’s legends are truer than our own]
Content from our partners
This article appears in the 21 Oct 2026 issue of the New Statesman, Sally Rooney is a writer, not a terrorist






Join the debate
Subscribe here to comment