Return to: Home | World Affairs

We are winning the propaganda war

Marcus Brogden

Published 04 October 2007

Marcus Brogden talks to the veteran activist Aung Zaw who says though the military junta has clamped down on the uprising the pro-democracy forces have been boosted

After almost two weeks of street protests in Rangoon and Mandalay, monks and fellow protesters are winning the information war, believes a high-profile activist who left Burma after martial law was imposed in 1988.

Aung Zaw, who now campaigns for human rights within Burma from Chiang Mai in northern Thailand, told me that although the military junta has clamped down on Burma's democracy movement for the time being, the pro-democracy forces have been strengthened.

"I have spoken to people [from the Burmese democracy movement] today and though they have said we are down, I think once they get past the initial dejection they will realise how much the world has learned about their suffering through being able to see the dramatic images and digital footage that have been broadcast worldwide," he said.

"The media have played a very important role. People [worldwide] already knew about the military junta, but I don't think they had seen such powerful images before. The images have changed the situation a lot."

Zaw, 39, now edits Irrawaddy, a not-for-profit news magazine that he founded in 1993 and which focuses on developments in Burma. The magazine's website has carried daily reports of the protests and news of solidarity action outside Burma. On 2 October, the anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi's birthday, the magazine ran reports of a rally in Chiang Mai outside the Indian embassy. Irrawaddy has been particularly critical of India's stance. The junta crackdown came, it reported, on 26 September, the day an exploration agreement was signed between India's Oil and Natural Gas Corporation and Myanmar Oil and Gas Enterprise.

At the height of the protests against the military junta, the magazine's online portal claimed to have received roughly 31 million hits, "a monthly record and an indication of the huge worldwide interest in what is happening in Burma", said Zaw. Many of the magazine's images were supplied by those inside Burma who had joined the protest marches.

Despite international efforts pushing for action in recent weeks, Zaw told me he believed change "will have to come from within". The marches led by monks had shaken the regime's confidence and injected energy into the democracy movement, he said. "The Burmese people have shown that they are very disciplined and very peaceful, especially in the way in which they have communicated with the outside world."

Despite the junta's attempts to close down internet channels and ban media from reporting from inside the country, journalists returning from Burma have said they believe the troops were reluctant to directly confront people they suspected of being press.

All independent press is banned in Burma, many journalists have been imprisoned, censorship is strict and journalists' work visas are issued by invitation only. Most news organisations, including the BBC, have been denied entry. Nonetheless, roughly 30 photographers have managed to enter Burma as tourists in the past few weeks and some continue to work there.

One photographer, Patrick Brown, who was in Rangoon for Germany's Stern magazine, told me the troops knew what the visitors were up to: "We knew that they knew exactly who we were.

"The troops were more concerned with the marchers," said Brown, who thought the soldiers deliberately fired over their heads. "The only time we were in danger of being shot was when we mingled with the marchers."

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

2 comments from readers

Douglas Chalmers
06 October 2007 at 18:26

Quote photographer, Patrick Brown: "The troops were more concerned with the marchers," said Brown, who thought the soldiers deliberately fired over their heads. "The only time we were in danger of being shot was when we mingled with the marchers...."

Rubbish! Try the Japanese photographer's version!!! Brutality in Burma http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LymH0aPenBM

Zatoichi
08 October 2007 at 12:28

Douglas,

Brown's observation is not "rubbish" as you so eloquently put it. Of the 30-odd "foreign" journalists who managed to get into Burma only one - so far - has been seriously physically harmed. The debate is also open as to how he came to lose his life. Many suspect that the soldier - no doubt poorly educated, extremely wired, unable in the midst of such chaos to distinguish between a Japanese and Burman, and faced with a sole figure standing in his way while everyone else ran - panicked and opened fire. Do you really think that the average uneducated Burman village kid dragged into the military at the age of 14 has been trained to distinguish in the heat of the moment between the poise of a protestor and a cameraman? The loss of any life – Burman, or media - is deplorable; however from the video posted one would be hard pressed to argue with Brown's observation that the troops did not specifically target media as a whole. Face it, the soldier panicked when suddenly faced with “someone” standing his ground, raising something - anything - at him. The Japanese photographer was sadly in the wrong place at the wrong time. If you want to blame the photographer’s death on the “brutal” junta, because of it’s closed door media policy and the poor training of it’s “brutal” soldiers, you’d be on far stronger ground. However, to suggest Brown’s personal observations from inside the country - where he was faced with the daily carnage and soldiers, while working with other “unharmed” western media, - as “rubbish”, as you’ve spotted the horrific -- yet solitary -- death of a cameraman on youtube, is naïve to the extreme.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

Read More

Vote!

Will China rule the world?

Suggest a question

View comments

© New Statesman 1913 – 2009

Tracker