Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

Why Lib Dems feel they are locked in a brightly lit interrogation room

The mood inside the party is one of grim determination.

"It's so much fun covering the Liberal Democrats at the moment," a political editor said to me at the weekend. I can see his point. He is one of those rare political reporters who would turn up diligently to our press conferences during the 1997 general election. At the time, the party was on 9 per cent in the polls and we would pack the conference with staffers, hoping the broadcast media wouldn't notice the chronic lack of interest from Fleet Street's finest. One of the few journalists would dutifully ask the obligatory question about whatever policy we were promoting and then the rest of the questions would be about the potential of a Lib Dem-Labour deal. So I can understand why it might be a lot more interesting to be a political reporter covering our beat in 2011.

Conversely, I would characterise the mood inside the Liberal Democrat camp in 2011 as a combination of grim determination to keep going and a strong belief in the direction of travel - but, boy oh boy, the potholes and diversions are never ending. Take the past week.

Pryce points

First, there is the nightmare of watching Chris Huhne and Vicky Pryce play out their bitterly fought divorce in public. Anyone who knows the Energy Secretary will be aware that he is not called "Rhino-hide Huhnester" for nothing: he will be coping with this media storm better than most, as his performance in the House of Commons on 17 May demonstrated. He has denied flatly allegations that he asked Pryce to take his penalty points for speeding in 2003 and now waits for the police to come back to confirm his version. Friends of Huhne are confident that neither Nick Clegg nor his team are responsible for whipping up the media storm against their man.

Meanwhile, David Laws has endured a week of leaks over the parliamentary commissioner's report into his expenses and subsequent suspension from the House. His friends are in no doubt that the leaks were generated from two sources: Tory MPs who still hold a grudge over David Cameron's treatment of them when the expenses scandal broke two years ago, and mischief-making Labour insiders who recognise the importance of Laws to both Clegg and Cameron. As Nick Harvey, a former member of the standards and privileges committee, said: "In comparison with others who were proven to be in it for additional funds, this was a very harsh judgement [on Laws]." Even the brief respite that came when the Press Complaints Commission judged the Daily Telegraph to be in "breach of media rules" for its pre-Christmas sting on Vince Cable, proved double- edged, because the ruling gave the paper an opportunity to reprint the whole story in full.

The losses in the local elections on 5 May were keenly felt, but did not come as an overwhelming surprise: midterm elections often prove difficult for a party in power. But the Alternative Vote referendum defeat was a bitter blow as was the rout in the Scottish elections and the subsequent departure of Tavish Scott, the Lib Dem leader north of the border. (The only light relief in that bleak campaign was the moment of bewilderment on the face of Gary Gibbon, political editor of Channel 4 News, as he was encouraged to film Scott with his hand up a sheep's bottom. Not an unusual sightt or a born and bred Highlander such as Tavish, but for Gary all a bit of a shock.)

Behind the scenes, Lib Dems continue to swap old lag stories and remember darker times. "If you think this is hard, try being in the party when the leader was on trial for attempted murder," one peer said to me, recalling the trial of Jeremy Thorpe in 1979. Meanwhile, younger members recall having three different leaders in one year (2007) and the nightmare of the SDP/Liberal Alliance seat negotiations in the 1980s. Paddy Ashdown recalled the moment during his leadership when the party was an asterisk in the polls, within the margin of error of non-existence.

Lib Dems have always had a strong streak of gallows humour. Twice a year everyone gathers on the final night of party conference to sing "Losing Deposits" (to the tune of "Waltzing Matilda"), and other well-known self-deprecating campaign songs.

However, the glare of the spotlight is taking a bit of getting used to; something "we are learning from", as one cabinet minister put it to me. It feels like the bright lights of an interrogation room, built by an extremely hostile right-wing media, which has been unleashed on us ever since Clegg was compared to Winston Churchill in the aftermath of the first leaders' debate in April 2010. The difference now, compared with those grim days from the past, is that the Lib Dems are no longer irrelevant.

The business minister Edward Davey puts it like this: "I've graduated from throwing stones in opposition to building foundations in government and it's exhilarating. You have to be especially dogged to drive through your Liberal Democrat agenda. But the coalition agreement has been key and I think we're achieving an amazing amount of Liberal wins, but we're yet to get the credit." This is a coalition agreement which contains 75 per cent of Liberal Democrat manifesto commitments, compared with only 60 per cent Conservative, according to a University College, London study.

No-chicken delight

So relevance and resilience are the watchwords of the party. In conversation with Clegg last week, friends of his were struck by his respect at how the party continues to hold its nerve. The day after the 5 May elections he hit the phones, calling group leaders and parliamentary candidates. What he found was a party that remains steadfast. Even the commentators have been surprised at the minimal fallout from those election results.

“We've had a hard knock but what has been really impressive over the last two weeks is that folk have not run around like headless chickens," one cabinet minister told me. "If anything, experiences like this tend to bind the party more tightly, particularly the parliamentary party. Even when we do argue, they remain policy-based like the NHS, never personality driven."

On the night of the election results, I read a tweet, from the Edinburgh Central candidate, Alex Cole-Hamilton, to Paddy Ashdown : "If my defeat tonight is part payment so that no child will spend another night in a detention centre then I accept it, with all my heart." We both agreed with Alex.

Tags: Liberal Democrats

31 comments

Tom Papworth's picture

@Paul Hillyard/Gerry Tierney: To say that the Lib Dems "In the election campaign ...were with Labour on the need to reduce the deficit over a reasonable time and to ensure the least vulnerable were hurt least" is a gross simplification. Both Clegg and Cable were clear that "a reasonable time" meant "what the economic experts recommended", and criticised both Labour and the Tories for setting timetables before the election. Once in government, the Lib Dems listened to the advice of the Governor of the Bank of England who said that the deficit was the top priority and should be brought down ASAP.

@matthew fox: Clegg has nothing to apologise for. The plan is to eliminate the STRUCTURAL deficit by 2015. There was always a recognition that there would be a cyclical deficit.

Most of the commentators above are in denial about the economic realities facing the country. If Labour has any chance of winning in 2015 it is by persuading the public that their fantasy economics can wish away the public debt and carry on spending.

Paul Hillyard's picture

The biggest U turn has been the sellout over the deficit. Forget the student fees, its the acquiescence to Osborne that should really hurt them.

In the election campaign they were with Labour on the need to reduce the deficit over a reasonable time and to ensure the least vulnerable were hurt least.

All the other promises pale into insignificance behind this volte face and as a result will be destroyed at the next election.

Gerry Tierney's picture

They have flip flopped on practically every single promise.

As Paul said, the biggest issue was their collapse over the deficit. More than half of votes voted for parties which supported a slower and less draconian way to deal with the deficit.

Thanks to the Lib Dem traitors, we're now stuck with growing unemployment, stagflation and less than zero growth over the past 6 months.

While you're brown-nosing them, Olly, could you tell Clegg that "staying the course" when the course is going to crash us right onto the rocks is not the sensible thing to do, no matter how macho you want to look.

trev1959ad's picture

Dennis said 'just watch the Libs save the NHS. Although I personally think the Libs are dead men walking I have to say that it is my contention that,short of leaving this Coalition,the next best thing they can do is,indeed save the NHS from the likes of Lansley and Gideon.If they can achieve that one thing then I think the British people will,probably,forgive all else.SO DO IT AND DO IT NOW.

martybee's picture

Why Lib Dems feel they are locked in a brightly lit interrogation room...soon to be telephone booth

Actionfitz's picture

Enjoy it while it lasts.
come the next election the Lib Dems will fall back into obscurity, having been used up by the torys to take the flak for their ideological economic policy and having abandoned any hope of ever appealing to the student vote.

hugh markey's picture

Look! Maybe he does watch the 'Jeremy Clarkson Show'. But that proves nothing! Will you turn that b***** light off!

Stig

Amanda's picture

I agree with Tom. Labour had an opportunity to work with the LDs, they ducked it in favour of opposition because they can't take the hard, big desicions that are needed to tackle the deficit. But let's not forget the LDs inject fairness in every sense into the coalition whilst the Tories wanted an inheritance tax cut, the LDs stopped this is in favour of a tax cut for the least well off in our society. When Labour abloished the 10p tax in favour of a middle class tax cut, they showed they aren't the champions of fairness.

McDuff's picture

RIP Lib Dems - as even Cameron said, his favourite joke was Nick Clegg

McDuff's picture

DVD alternative ending to OG's piece...

On the night of the election results, I read a tweet, from the Edinburgh Central candidate, Alex Cole-Hamilton, to Paddy Ashdown : "If my defeat tonight is part payment so that Nick Clegg can have his ministerial Jaguar then I accept it, with all my heart." We both agreed with Alex.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets