Registered user login:

Where now for the people’s party?

Ian Gibson

Published 08 August 2008

Backbencher Ian Gibson attacks the "faceless" Blairite plotters who brief behind the scenes and urges Brown to a five point pledge plan indicative of Labour values

“The Labour Party is a democratic socialist party. It believes that by the strength of our common endeavour we achieve more than we achieve alone so as to create for each other the means to realise our true potential and for all of us a community in which power wealth and opportunity are in the hands of the many not the few…”

This is the resounding replacement for the old clause 4 on the back of our membership card.

So are we implementing this vision? Have we lost working class support or are we fooled by the ‘we are all middle class now’ pundits. Do we represent those who suffer the inequalities in our society? Or do we really show more support for those who own so much suffer so little and apparently don't recognise the disparities.

From the invasion of Iraq through tuition fees, ID cards, Trident missile renewal, privatisation within education and health we have lost increment by increment the backing of our traditional supporters as well as the 1992-97 converts.

We have lost the sympathy and support of trade unionists and we have depended on Tory votes (with a minor lapse on tuition fees) to saddle the public with our policy.

So as the prime minister returns from Suffolk to address the current problems (he should try the poor railway service from Norwich to Liverpool Street) what advice can I as a mere backbencher give?

I deplore the anonymous briefers the faceless plotters those who are too cowardly to set out their own stall publicly. They know their ultra-Blairite vision of co-payments, partial privatisation of schools and segments of the NHS are unpopular and punitive of those who cannot afford to pay. More of their idle thinking will be dangerous to the future prospects of the Labour party.

Change is necessary but only if it delivers better services for all and is based on the innovation and skills of those in a particular industry. We never wish to see a USA-style health system or education based on what you can pay. These solutions are out of touch with the current mood of what the Labour party stands for. Look at what our membership card says and take steps to eliminate the huge disparities in lifestyles, economic wealth and influence and our social, political and cultural lives. We are many they are few, all policies must now be enacted to restore equality and social justice in the society dominated by the few sharks and vultures .

With Brown as leader we need I believe five pledges. They must be communicated as an illustration of what we stand for, who we represent and they must demonstrate at every opportunity how Tory announcements always leave the door open for ‘Thatcher-like’ policies. As with the Greens, when you press them for concrete proposals there is silence or evasion.

Rejuvenation will mean a selection of deliverable issues which reignite our roots and capture the imagination of other groups. For example addressing the cost of care for the elderly, improvements in public transport, progressive taxation, a real and urgent move on climate change, troop withdrawal from Iraq, and abandonment of the ID card scheme and a genuine way of creating affordable housing for those who need it. We need to put forward bold policies not confusing contradictions.

We have nothing to lose and the prime minister will I hope fight back with real policies which re-connect us with our trade union base and our traditional supporters which will give us political stability.

These core supporters have not left us for the Tories but they cannot bring themselves to vote for Labour in its current state. They will come back if we can show them real change. For too long we have been shoulder to shoulder with our enemies. It’s time for a change of direction in policy. Let’s be ‘aving you!! Oh yes and I am not running for leader!!

Dr Ian Gibson is MP for Norwich North

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

8 comments from readers

bedell
08 August 2008 at 10:31

Are you on crack or something or did you fall and hit your head and miss the last five years?

Labour has spent and misspent an astonishing amount of money chasing after its social engineering goals, leaving many voters with increasingly high tax bills in exchange for ever less basic services. The idea that Labour can solve is recent woes by committing to misspending even more of tax payers money is just plain silly.

brightsider
08 August 2008 at 12:34

Why does every statement by Labour MPs have to be couched in Brownite v Blairite terms? Huge strides have been made in social justice (health waiting lists, education, especially pre-school support, pensions, etc etc - bedell is talking patent nonsense! ) but these do not in themselves win elections.

By all means come up with 5 winning policies - but make them something the party can unite behind and stop bashing each other into oblivion, which is where the party is headed at the moment. Where are the big, new ideas that will differentiate Labour and which Brown implicitly promised? Not in this article.

Extradry Martini
08 August 2008 at 14:50

"... the anonymous briefers the faceless plotters those who are too cowardly to set out their own stall publicly". I can'ty think of a better description of Brownites during the Blair years.

mccardigan@aol.com
08 August 2008 at 16:01

We're screwed if this is the best we can come up with. I am on 30 grand, I'm a teacher so I get 6 weeks off. I cannot afford a holiday as my bills come pouring in twice as big as they were a few months ago, I had to sell my house. And I'm a lucky one. What of those less well off than me? They struggle and 'scrounge', life embittering them and leaving them dispossessed. Under a Labour government! A bloody disgrace. TB is full of the wealthy doing up their homes and we get stories about millionaires enjoying orgies. I say, and I am a party member, scew all the above, let's redistribute, tax 'em til their pips squeak, fine the big companies, hack into their profits, give the low waged and OAPs heavily subsidised heating/electricity. We might as bloody well do something, the Tories are in no matter what. Let's be Labour.

Roland Baker
08 August 2008 at 22:41

Ian Gibson is a sound MP and justified in his article. His warrant is in the Labour Deputy Leadership election results. Jon Cruddas got the highest vote in the first round and was only eliminated after the 4th round of preference allocations by which time he had 30.06% of the party's voters behind him. If the election system for electing the Deputy Labour Leader were the same as the Parliamentary system (block vote), Jon Cruddas would have won it.

Jon Cruddas ran a clean and legal campaign for Labour policies, unlike Hain and Harman who ran dirty, illegally-funded campaigns to put themselves in the waiting room for open Tory defection. In Harman's case, her only platform was to disenfranchise men from the Labour Party - which policy she has implemented - and seek rights for temporary workers equal to those of permanent employees - which policy she has dropped. Johnson was a nonentity throughout and any 'dream ticket' of which he is part will become the nightmare of no Labour seats in Parliament.

People have lost their pensions, they cannot get the NHS to work for them, the hospitals are filthy, schools are becoming universities of crime, people cannot get proper work and they are sick of seeing non-jobs financing Labour sleaze handed out to apparatchiks in think tanks and spinners in the "corporate social responsibility" industry. David Miliband is just typical of that sort of person.

Re-connecting society via social solidarity with rigorously effective public services is vital. In the republic of France they have ministers for social solidarity and national infrastructure even under Sarkozy. Ignore the threats and endless whingeing from the CBI. Get taxes up and use the money to build up society and the country.

john frost
09 August 2008 at 10:12

Yet another bleeding heart identifying with Brown's problems. Yet another voting record that does not match the rhetoric. (according to they work for you.com against an investigation in to Iraq) Odd as this was a Blairite mess. Why not put the boot in on this if you are so sure of yourself ? What are you so scared of. ?History has proved in a remarkable short space of time Blair had more socialism than monetarist Brown. He should be sacked just as any of Brown's monetarist Ciy friends would sack a similarly unelected failing CEO. This fatal combination of Brownite monetarism whilst claiming to be old Labour is demeaning us all.

gnuneo
10 August 2008 at 09:44

ian gibson, good words. Are you what is left of the Left in Labour?

and *why* aren't you running, when the rest of the herd is so godforsaken Tory/technocrat??

sweety
11 August 2008 at 03:21

Gordon Browns politics lie a mouldering in his grave but his body plus capped teeth go marching on! He is now resorting to the buying of the plebs like a post Augustian Roman Emperor.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

Read More

Vote!

Should Darling have been bolder with the 45% tax rate?