Provocative policing
It's hard to see the police approach to this year's climate camp as anything other than a bid to pro
By Caroline Lucas Published 07 August 2008 15:04This first of my regular newstatesman.com blogs finds me between my campaign for Brighton Pavilion and protesting in Kingsnorth, where I’ve been heavily involved in attempts to get the police to pull back from their campaign of harrassment of the camp.
Everyone who enters the site is being searched. Police officers are taking anything away that “could be used for illegal activity”, with efforts being made to strip protestors of such hardcore weapons of choice as biodegradable soap and toilet paper!
More seriously, they have raided the camp on a number of occasions, continue to withhold vital equipment such as wooden boards which form part of the toilet infrastructure (an obsession with personal hygiene is only one of the more bizarre police tactics here), and have apparently broken vehicles’ windows before towing them away on the ground that they have been “abandoned”.
It’s hard not to see this as a strategy to try to provoke protestors into less peaceful behaviour.
I was at the camp earlier in the week, and will be back again on Saturday, the main day of protest and non-violent direct action. As on many previous occasions, I will be prepared to be arrested for making a peaceful protest.
Most political leaders try to avoid the obvious tension between being a law maker, and a law ‘breaker’. But I believe that it is everyone’s right, and perhaps duty, on occasion to stand up in the face of actions that could otherwise bring catastrophe.
At Kingsnorth, we face the first in a series of around half a dozen new coal stations, which, if built, will commit the UK to a new generation of climate-busting energy infrastructure.
This will not only prevent Britain from investing in clean technologies, but will undermine all of our attempts to persuade other countries to reduce emissions as well.
Given that scientists are saying that action to reduce emissions in the next ten years will be crucial if we are to avoid runaway climate change, the government’s policy is here not just foolhardy, but a danger to all of our livelihoods.
Kingsnorth is not just a symbol, it is the frontline of the political struggle to avoid climate change. It is of the highest importance that we stop this new generation of coal stations from being built, and that is why I am personally willing to join others in peaceful, but law-breaking, protest.
If I am, as I hope, elected the first leader of the Green party in September, I am totally committed to continuing to protest when it is needed. I believe this type of stance is on occasion essential, not just for us as individuals, but also for society’s leaders, including politicians.
That is why I challenge David Cameron and Nick Clegg to put their alleged commitment to avoiding climate change into practice by supporting the protestors at Kingsnorth, and joining them, maybe you, and myself there on Saturday.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















13 comments
Having just got back from a far-too-short afternoon at the camp, it was pretty clear the policing was aimed at trying to scare people away from the camp and keep it marginalised.
Talking to the Taxi driver who was ferrying groups of people to the station, it seems that this tactic worked to an extent, putting local people off attending the event. But it had also put local people off the police, so hardly a good bit of community policing.
Ultimately, since the direct action part of the event was optional, the police really missed the mark in treating the whole event as a criminal undertaking. They actually seemed to be losing the plot a bit (or making up weird excuses for harassment.)
The taxi guy recounted that a female police officer had explained that they confiscated the soap from the site because they were afraid the protesters would get naked and cover themselves in soap so the police could not catch them. Perhaps the police force spend too much of their time off at Ibiza bubble parties, but this struck me as a bit of a hollow reason to deny people basic personal hygiene facilities.
I was also at the camp for most of the week.
The whole thing was a joy - people from hugely diverse social backgrounds, from all over the country (and some from much further afield) living together with a sense of community, cooperation and mutual support which I have rarely experienced anywhere. Up tp 1500 people lived, ate, slept, met, discussed, watched poets, danced to live music and DJs and generally had an amazing time - and nobody would have noticed if the National Grid went offline for the whole week. The only fossil fuel being consumed was a bit of gas for cooking.
With one exception.
The Police (I saw hundreds of them, from Kent, Essex, London, Wales, Yorkshire - at least) descended on the place in vans and helicopters. Their actions (I shudder to call them tactics - for that would display Machiavellian/Orwellian behaviour I can't believe we could tolerate in the UK) were the only thing which spoiled this event.
The individuals I personally encountered - whether when being searched or at the 'front line', a gate to the field where we spent 3-4 days with a line of 20-50 police up against a similar line of protestors in an absolutely farcical, ludicrous stalemate - were all polite, even entertaining company. But the actions I witnessed, of police stupidity and brutality which threatened to escalate into confrontations involving lots of serious injury were an embarrassment to a supposedly civilized democratic society.
I've been talking a lot about the Climate Camp. Despite that John Cleese might advise: “don’t mention the weekend!”
Fuelled partly by pride, (that I attended climate camp) shame (that i didn’t ‘do’ more) and partly by a lingering intense new disillusionment with government and police (and i was there, remember,) i'd like to tell you that the accounts of goings on, that you can find on the Climate Camp website are all honest, decent and ethical.
Plus here are a few paras from me:
In writing this I thought hard how I would have reacted to some dreadlocked tattooed hippy* posting something here...
(* i am officially none of those by the way, i am a 49 yr old ‘establishment’ sort of chap) but we all make up our own stories don’t we.
N.B. There were bankers, consultants, vicars, and probably quite a few eco-professionals there.
For various complicated reasons, including a small yellow streak maybe – the shocking police operation had made me timid (‘in-timid-ate’) – and had made me very very tired after near total sleep deprivation each night by police helicopters, dogs, raids, and psychological operations – i copped out and joined the ‘children’s and novices family fun peace’ march to the camp. The Orange group. (Actually, I went with it in mind, and in heart, that I would readily act as one human shield if any elderly or pre-teen person were to be attacked by a dozen riot police with batons.. )
Here comes the bit you won’t believe. The main group complied with each and every police request during the planning before-hand, however odd.
They asked us not to march through the local village (where we could have been seen and had chats with locals). We complied.
They asked us not to march to outside the main gate of the power station. We complied and went to a back gate. And so on.
All the details of the march were pre-agreed, there were thousands of police present to watch our peaceful march.
(If not locals, we were kept away from them!)
The deal was that we would sit down at the power station gate, eat some lunch, listen to some speeches, before leaving at around 1pm.
Surrounded (and interestingly, visibly penned in) by police in riot gear, with dogs, on horses (by then I’d seen the horses and batons in use), the situation was more than bizarre enough (and terror-fying enough for a novice like me.)
That was before what I was about to hear.
The police helicopter, the one that had been circling directly overhead, (0.5 tonne of CO2 per hour?) not helping my enjoyment of some wonderful speeches, and generally adding to my sense of confusion that i had somehow become a dangerous criminal without me knowing it, turned on its high-fidelity tannoy (i wish the speeches could have used the police sound system) and announced this:
“Please disperse immediately, or the police will use batons, horses and dogs.”
That ‘announcement’ – if you can call it that - was made at 12:50 precisely. Lunchtime. This was ten minutes before we were due to leave. I was surrounded by peace banners, picnics, lovers, women and children. Unsurprisingly, it put quite a few brave (and/or stubborn) souls off leaving. After soul searching, I left, shortly after 1pm, petrified for the safety of some new friends who were staying behind, but conscious that this orange group was committed to peaceful demonstration and that we had actually agreed to leave at 1pm.
But feeling quite sick that this could be happening in the UK in 2008.
So, there’s my account, my witness, my scary thought for the day. I wish it could be more positive.
In fact IT CAN be MUCH MORE POSITIVE – meanwhile, back at camp:
The camp itself was glorious. There was brother-sister-hood, community, passion, life energy, song, dance, poetry, love, education, cooperation and abundance.
There was no conflict. New deep friendships, new life meaning. Call me a sad old man (i’m married) but there were some incredibly beautiful women and men there. Eyes burning bright – fully alive with passion and life.
When you next wonder why the (M or F) supermodels on the catwalk aren’t as attractive as they used to be, consider it may be because they are all down at Climate Camp!
Conversations I’ll remember all my life. Abundance of food, laughter, friends, support, experiences, unity and powerfully expressed difference.
There was a sufficiency of non-carbon energy. Wood for hot water, PV panels everywhere, wind turbines: THE CAMP was off grid, thereby proving that it is totally possible for 1000 people to have the time of their lives (it was immense fun) on zero carbon. Proving that the politicians last spun spectre of the “lights going out” is a spectre of their own making, being used against our best interest.
We wouldn’t even have noticed if the National Grid had gone down for a week. (And don’t underestimate the comms power we had on site, the media tent was brimming with laptops etc)
Perhaps that’s what the establishment is most scared of, that we don’t need their dirty power any more, and ‘we’re not buying it’.
Dave
If it is true that the police provoked the protest group, then the police are a stupid lot. They should realise that they are breathing the same polutted air and affected by the same weather and yet they are not cooperating with those who are trying to highlight the environmental issues. How stupid can the police be?
I feel compelled to comment again, having had time to reflect on my time at the camp.
It is very strange, when working to prevent a form of Genocide (and climate instability, once transmitted through markets, will be fairly systematic in targeting the poor) to be searched intimately when entering a peaceful protest.
I had more of my inner thigh explored when entering the camp than in any airport I have been through. And what harm could I have caused when I got there?
How many dangerous offensive weapons did the police find? How many injuries on other human beings were inflicted by camp protestors?
And why is a government, which says its is committed to fighting climate change, and also that it wants to see more political engagement, so afraid of this form of direct democracy?
I think Zizecks commments here, even if they do not apply to Haiti (I do not know), certainly ring true when you consider how the camp was treated almost like an infection.
http://www.newstatesman.com/books/2008/08/haiti-aristide-lavalas#reader-...
The UK seems to want immunity from any living political movement. The core of the camp was an approach to direct democracy, something that wider society seems not quite ready for.
I totally agree with Dave and all he says. I went to the Climate Camp for a day - and wrote an article about it for the New Statesman - see Rowena Macdonald's article entitled 'Woolly-Minded Hippies' - NOT that I thought the protesters were woolly minded hippies at all, the sub-editor must have made up that title.
The police presence at the camp was ludicrous. I don't entirely blame the individual police officers themselves, although it is bizarre that many of them do not behave like ordinary human beings and won't tell you why they are doing what they are doing, and insist, if you are a journalist, on referring you to their press office.
Mainly I blame the Home Office, which must have ordered this amount of police to surround the camp.
It created a very bad atmosphere around a camp which was entirely peaceful. Far more peaceful than any football match, festival or other group event I have been to.
It was a complete waste of money and would have certainly put off many people from attending.
I do not have a knee-jerk anti-police attitude, but the way this protest was policed was incredibly disappointing.
The protest was entirely legitimate and to treat people like criminals before they have even entered the camp is appalling.
I see far more unruly, criminal behaviour around Bethnal Green where I live and yet I rarely see anything but Community Police Officers, who are entirely ineffective if you do need them to tackle a crime.
The Home Office needs to get its priority right in terms of policing.
so the police are doing the same as when the old ladies protested aganst live sheep heavy handed then they wonder why we call them pigs
Give the police a break, they're only doing their job and what a good job they are doing. If these stupid protestors got their way then the power station would cease to operate therefore causing a lack of electricity which would in turn cause the country to grind to a halt- and with the economic climate the the way it is at the moment, that's not a very wise idea. The protestors need to look at the bigger picture and stop being fools.
I don't think trying to provoke peaceful demonstrators is doing a good job. It's what happens in countries with repressive regimes. I think it is you jasontimes56 who needs to look at the bigger picture.
We have treated fossil fuel energy as though it was infinite and had no impact when it was burnt. Neither are true and now the consequences are coming back to us: the effect of burning fossil fuels is now impacting the climate and we are also reaching the limits of cheap energy upon which we have built our whole economy and way of life.
Now we need to wake up and take a long hard look at our way of life - it is time to start talking to each other about how we are going to live in an energy scarce world. The days of cheap energy are well and truly over. Start making changes to your way of life before they happen to you.
we dont all call police pigs at all, many hate doing jobs like Kingsnorth, though some seemingly revel in it, especially certain political sections of the metropolitan police who often give all police a bad name. Majority of protesters & police are against agent provocateurs-troublemakers also, whoevers side they are on.
I also wanted to express my anger at the way the police dealt with people attending the Climate Camp at Kingsnorth yesterday, giving the completely wrong impression to others.
Kingsnorth power station is an important issue for many people. It is a symbol of how we as a nation intend to address, or not in this case, the growing problems caused by CO2 emissions. The protesters, as far as I could see, were both peaceful and in good spirits.
I was attending as Marketing Director for Greenvoice, a new not-for-profit web site that provides campaigning tools for green causes. We host a campaign for the climate camp on our web site and I was attending a day of seminars and workshops by leading experts from the environmental world.
I do understand the need for the police to search people entering the camp. But I find it totally unbelievable that the police were harassing and victimising people in such an unfocused and belligerent way as they were leaving the camp. I missed my train back to London as a result and an another important business engagement.
I really do take issue with the following:
1.Over 300 police stopping about 30 people legally leaving the camp who simply wanted to catch trains home or to buy things like ice creams and milk from the local shop
2.The violent and aggressive technique used by the police. I witnessed some young women being pushed over by police acting more like bouncers on a Saturday night in a cheap night club than The Constabulary
3.The complete disrespect for what people were there to do. The rudeness and utter boisterousness of their approach to what was little more than a small group of young adults
4.The ludicrous decision to insist on searching everyone, which was clearly an issue with the small group outside the Camp. The Constable responsible for this (if there was one?) should have quickly backed down and allowed people through. This created an issue as people were being bullied by the police in what was a really very hot afternoon
5.The complete lack of leadership between the dozens of police forces that were there from Wales, Yorkshire, London and Kent to name a few that were on the front line
6.The over use of surveillance. I counted at least four cameramen and three stills photographers within the police ranks. To what end? Our own camera women was treated very badly and was spoken to extremely rudely
7.The over use of a police helicopter which disturbed many of the high standard workshops
8.The wrong impression that this type of police behaviour gave to locals who went past the camp
9.Allowing locals access to the local golf course alongside people that couldn't go about their business
10.The complete and utter waste of time and money
I reiterate, I do understand the need to police events such as the Climate Camp, but how this was managed yesterday was a shameful waste of tax payers money. It also creates the total wrong impression of what was a very peaceful and constructive camp. I am hoping to get an explanation from my local MP as to why the police got it so badly wrong in Kent yesterday.
Giles Robertson
Well I was there, a first timer, against the better judgement of at least part of me, and I loved it.
So too did bankers, ministers of government, ministers of faith (at least one vicar) and a great many 'people like you' reader, who have simply had enough of being ignored by those currently in power and in oil. Society's old fossils, dead wood now.
My kids life prospects matter to me...
I am not alone in that - I know - we are united...
I predict police scare tactics will backfire.
I predice that future Climate Camps will attract many more people, both 'ordinary people' and the 'privileged' few. Celebs will come! CEOs, VIPs, oil execs, tories, all faiths... The camp will be more and more a vast bio-diverse assortment of society.. all united in their voice... that they care about the children...
It's time to cut the carbon and lead from the front.
Like the camp did.
My initial estimates are that the carbon footprint per capita for those on the camp all week was:
about 24 kilos of CO2.
The per capita footprint of an average UK individual for a week is 240kg.
The per capita carbon per policeman, I estimate at around 2.4 tonnes. Helicopters, floodlights, cars, transport from Wales, Yorks, and other carbon intensive habits conveniently overlooked.
In terms of £££, who knows?
I suspect around £50 spent on the week by campers.
And probably £1500 a head lavished per police.
But the biggest thing I want to say is to ask you not to think you understand it - not until you have seen it.
Go to climate camp - then criticise it.
But you won't - the people food entertainment conversations freedom community and positive energy was off the scale. Who needs dirty power?
There could have been a power cut outside and no one in the camp would have even noticed!
For the first time i saw felt and experienced, what others had tried to explain to me with words before.
It was even a wrench to leave...
Dave is absolutely right.
And once one experiences this kind of police harassment personally, one never feels quite the same way again about the boys in blue...
See my latest blogpost, about a particularly ridiculous episode of harassment that happened this weekend to a friend of mine, here: http://rupertsread.blogspot.com/2008/08/police-arrest-climate-camp-prote...