'A uniquely horrendous situation'
Veteran Tory politician John Gummer argues the situation's even worse for Gordon Brown than it was i
By John Gummer Published 29 July 2008Gordon Brown is on holiday in my constituency beset by commentators’ suggestions that he uses the time to ponder whether he ought to resign. The very idea shows that none of them have gone on a bucket and spade holiday with two young children! Nor indeed do they realise that this is a part of the country threatened with flooding from river and sea. There will therefore be a large number of my constituents who want to beard the prime minister on the government’s failure to keep up the defences.
I suspect that even the famously workaholic Brown would find more time to think in Number Ten than on the beach at Southwold.
In any case, any such musings would be bound to spoil the family’s vacation and they need time off from what is a quite uniquely horrendous situation.
I fought my first election more than forty years ago and I can’t remember anything comparable. Even as a cabinet minister living through the dying days of John Major’s Government - attacked on every side and beset by swivel-eyed revanchists – it wasn’t like this.
Although people had come to hate the Tories, they didn’t hate Major. He was still seen as a decent chap. It didn’t save him but he escaped the venom for the prime minister you find on the doorsteps to-day.
It’s not just that people see Gordon Brown as strange and alien - although they do - it’s that they really dislike him personally. There’s a sharpness in the attack that even I, a political opponent, find disconcertingly unfair.
Back in 1997, the hatred was palpable, but it was not all-embracing. People grudgingly admitted that Ken Clarke was making a decent fist of the Treasury. Some even gave good marks to the Department of the Environment!
Today, it’s hard to find anyone who has a kind word for any Minister at all. Again, the opposition is so universal that it brushes aside the reasonably competent performance of Milliband at the Foreign Office, Jack Straw at Justice, or Hilary Benn at DEFRA.
Outside the Westminster village, I’ve yet to hear a good word for Hazel Blears, Jacqui Smith, or Ed Balls. There’s a kind of contempt that is seriously corroding and certainly several shades worse than I can remember from twelve years ago.
The contrast that must be the most concerning for Gordon Brown is that John Major was looking at a financial situation that was seriously on the up. So much so, that Michael Heseltine could never really believe that a government, presiding over so strong an economy, could actually lose.
Indeed, despite the polls, the by-election results, the local elections, and the evidence from our constituencies, we never quite gave up hope. And that’s where the real difference lies. There’s a kind of resignation that infuses the whole of this government in a way that I’ve not experienced before.
John Gummer (right) was a cabinet minister under Thatcher and Major
It shows itself in the fact that no-one can make a decision on the smallest matter without it going round and round the machine, backwards and forwards from Number Ten, subject to second and third guessing at every stage. Then, when finally something is decided, it is hung on to with a tenacity reminiscent of a drowning man clinging to a spar.
Consensus is thus avoided and confrontation positively insisted upon. Ministers seem purposely to spurn opportunities for reasonable agreement in favour of wounding fights over unnecessary details.
So the situation is genuinely bad for Gordon but, even so, he should not accept that he is totally lost.
Instead of flailing around as if the answer were action on every front, he should prolong his holiday, concentrate on the economy, ditch the unnecessary, and present a simple front of a government single-mindedly intent on enabling Britain to get out of the recession quicker than the rest of the world.
It may not save him electorally but it could restore his reputation.
That, in itself, would be good for politics and for Britain. The present depth of loathing is doing no-one any good.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists


11 comments
This is another series of flatulent comments from "the detached privileged." If Brown wants to regain some credibility with the Labour voters he needs to start by hauling Blair back to face the music; stop whining about "getting on with the job and concentrating on policies" when we all know he wants to lock "terrorists" up without trial or access to support.
What John 'here bite into this burger' Gummer fails to remember is just how much Major and his cabinet were hated. It may have been fatigue in part but my recollection is of a brand of camp machismo that seemed to revel in how tough they could make it for ordinary people or minorities or women. A swarm of nasty chippy people from start to finish. And Major was the nastiest of all - a scheming little operator alternately arrogant then bitter.
"Today, it’s hard to find anyone who has a kind word for any Minister at all. Again, the opposition is so universal that it brushes aside the reasonably competent performance of Milliband at the Foreign Office, Jack Straw at Justice, or Hilary Benn at DEFRA."
and the same was entirely true of the Major administration as well, and for exactly the same reasons - they were a bunch of out-of-touch technocrats, whose spin had run entirely out of steam with the electorate. They were loathed with a passion you probably never could understand (being one of them), the next morning after the general election, you may forget this 'Burger Gummer' but we don't, the population of England and especially London turned out en-masse to cheer on the new govt - not because we particularly trusted Labour much more, but because simply and straightforwardly - it wasn't YOU.
so please, quit with the rosy specs, because those of us who have longer than the goldfish memories of the murdocracy and the westminster 'village' are really not impressed with such revisionism.
in huge measure, new-labour ARE so despised, because new-Labour ignored those hopes we poured into them, and just continued the same old Tory Thatcherite policies. Now we have the (new-Labour) local Govt minister openly saying that all schools should be privatised, the NHS has suffered ever more amputations, and even the BBC being prepared for takeover!
you wonder why people hate new-Labour? Its because they are YOU in all but name.
and then look at the bunch you disingenuously list as being "capable" - technocrats all, bland corporate stooges who would fit as easily into a camoronite Govt as this supposed Labour one, Straw who was so instrumental in creating and leading the attack on British Muslims by the cabinet, and as for Milliband and Benn - words fail.
the present Govt is detested across the country, but people are not in the slightest enthused about Camoron or the Tories in general - they are simply "not Labour". The absolute, and very clear failure by the British Political class to have any policies that benefit the working people, the absolute and very clear corruption that has enabled so many former ministers to benefit from the privatisations they themselves presided over, the absolute and very clear abdication of our foreign policy to a foreign, warmongering and Imperial Power, and the absolute and very clear destruction of basic British civil rights in this entirely fictional 'war on terror', has led to quite possibly the biggest crime of all - a political vacuum that the far-right are now entering, combined with an economic meltdown of the living standards of the normal Briton, all the provisions in place that ended the Weimar Republic.
do you politicians think we Britons are so god-damned stupid we don't know what's REALLY going on? You arrogant, Public-School educated conceited twats! I think you would be shocked just how much the normal citizen DOES grasp, even those whose brains have been warped and numbed by the murdock media.
perhaps in this election, the British People should collectively vote GREEN - annoying and self-righteous they might sometimes be, at least THEY have some good ideas beyond "let sell it all off to the multi-national corporations", or "lets blame immigrants and minorities for all the problems".
because, so help us all, the Tories and Labour are equally bankrupt, equally corrupt, and equally inadvisable to have anywhere NEAR the corridors of power over the British People.
its now time and past for a REAL change.
wrote that 48hrs into nicotine withdrawal. Wow.
Kids, adults - don't start, seriously.
Gummer: sorry. Although i still agree with what i wrote.
More important is gummer's kid alright or has she started mooing and thinks she is Marie Antoinette
I think she did a Patty Hearst and joined the Fabians
Not the fabianssssssssss.
A mindless sect who prey on young peoples mind and turn them into "socialists" , well perhaps not socialist but certainly a little lefty.
For some reason I have image of mad john swenney losing the plot at small group of bespectacled kids filming a video for Fabian weekly.
Quintus would be proud of them
What?!?
the empire doesn't pay like it used to any more. even if as a stooge to the emperor-in-chief. the is approaching when this criminal gang will have to answer for all their crimes.
It's all very pungent and apposite Im sure but for somebody wondering what has happened to the Labour party in the last few weeks it doesn't help. At all.