A false economy?

Daniel Stacey volunteers on a Costa Rican eco-plantation and gets to the dubious roots of the green

My hammock, although it looks the part, is a deathtrap. Woven from synthetic yarn, it is only just wide enough to fit my body, and has already flipped me on to the ground once.

"These hammocks are a bit rubbish."

"Hey, I made that!" says Taylor, a 21-year-old Texan whose thick dreadlocks swing as she turns from playing euchre with friends at the nearby dinner table.

"And that one as well." She points across at Gordon, a middle-aged construction worker from Florida; his leathery body is perched awkwardly on the next hammock along.

At La Iguana - the organic chocolate farm in Costa Rica where I'm staying - many of the fixtures are the products of self-appointed handymen and women. Travellers trade their labour for reduced board as part of the WWOOFing movement (World Wide Opportunities on Organic Farms), working on the cocoa and pineapple plantation, renovating the boarding houses and fixing fences.

On the veranda, Gordon leans over towards me and points at the bamboo roof trusses under which we're lying.

"Bamboo," he says sagely. "You know, you can make almost anything with bamboo if you want to: roofs, walls, floors, supports."

Gordon has come to Costa Rica to set up a sustainable construction business, having packed up his contracting company in Florida following a recent divorce.

"Fourteen years together, married for seven, divorced two and a half months," he says.

Like many of the Americans you meet here, he dreams of buying some cheap, unspoiled land and joining in the green economy. With 12 per cent of Costa Rica's forest designated as national park, and with a peaceful reputation in contrast to nearby Nicaragua and Guatemala, the country has become a playground for US-funded green projects: from environmental courses and workshops to sustainable construction and organic farming. Since February 2006, when the Rainforest Alliance began keeping a database of newly accredited ecotourism ventures for central and South America, 65 of the 166 new entries have come from Costa Rica.

Taylor, idly playing solitaire now that her game of euchre has ended, looks up.

"Who wants to go to the bar?"

We walk in the dark up Mastatal's sole dirt road to la pulpería, the local shop-cum-bar, passing other plantations in this small agricultural village three hours' drive from San José. The group spreads apart, and I find myself talking with Taylor about Rancho Mastatal, the only other place for travellers to stay in the area, run by an American couple, Tim O'Hara and Robin Nunes.

"I wonder if any of the Rancho people will come to the bar tonight," she says as we walk.

"Why wouldn't they?"

"Oh, they have this ridiculous curfew, even though they're adults."

Unlike La Iguana, which is still owned and run by a local farming couple, Lidia and Juan Luis Salazar, Rancho is an architecturally designed ecotourism project that describes itself as an "environmental learning and sustainable living centre". It employs many of the young men in the village on its construction projects, but is detached from the local farming economy, and limits the interaction that its guests have with the local community.

At La Iguana, in contrast, there is a feeling that Lidia and Juan Luis are running their farm much like they always have, with the addition of a dozen or so ecobums. Guests eat with the family and share their kitchen and laundry. The experience is less structured, and there is none of the evangelical atmosphere of Rancho: what one elderly resident at La Iguana witheringly describes as the "Kumbaya spirit".

A year ago, the Englishman Billy Bateman, an ex-financier-turned-globetrotter, helped Lidia and Juan Luis to reconfigure their farm along organic lines to attract WWOOFers. There are still creases to be ironed out, though. When Kat Cline and Doug Christen, organic farmers from Ohio, stayed at La Iguana recently, they discovered that the pineapples were cultivated from cloned stock - a non-sustainable practice. Taylor moans that the compost heap has failed to form decent mulch three times running, due to poor maintenance. Often the farm's green credentials seem to stem more from coincidence than design: mute rusticism and conventional farming methods repackaged as progressive environmental practice. Ecotourism is a draw card for foreigners, and with La Iguana's small crop of cocoa selling for only $1 a bag, and the dozen-odd WWOOFers paying $9 a night for food and accommodation, it is possible that attracting guests here generates more money for the farm than the sale of agricultural produce.

As Taylor and I reach la pulpería, we turn off our torches, which have been scanning the ground for the fer-de-lance, a highly venomous nocturnal snake. We settle down on our stools, and after several drinks the guests from Rancho Mastatal unexpectedly veer out of the darkness, dressed in drag. They have just had a cross- dressing bonfire party, and have been "allowed" out for the night. They join the La Iguana crowd and some local young men (none of the tico women is present), dancing the merengue and clutching their spilling fake breasts and false moustaches while amused farmers look on, sipping Imperial beer.

Afterwards, at a party held at the house of a local father of one, the young men of the village make increasingly bold advances towards female volunteers, until one of the girls is accidentally thrown through a bedroom doorway to the floor - and people eventually decide to leave, our group heading back to La Iguana.

That night, another of the local men, Carlos, is caught trying to get into some of the girls' beds, creating a furore the next morning as Juan Luis and Lidia lecture him on sexual etiquette. He is asked to leave, and is obliged to abandon his plans to stay on the farm in a hut with his brother Graben during his holidays.

As I walk into the kitchen for breakfast, I interrupt Taylor telling Lidia and her son Jorge her version of the story.

"And he was right there! Right next to my bed. He was saying, 'Taylor, Taylor, I'm want having sex with you.'"

Sensing trouble brewing, Lidia is already making chocolate fondue.

44 comments

David McEvoy's picture

Here is to Tim and Robin for putting up with all of this shit. It's probably fair for Daniel, as an apparently aspiring quasi-journalist, to offer his opinion. But I am unequivocally in support of the Ranch and their efforts. Tim and Robin are trying to do something great, namely inspiring people to live more considerably. They are having an impact and inevitably changing Mastatal. It cannot be perfect, particularly if perfection is measured against a null effect.

After six years of visits to Mastatal, the Ranch and numerous homestays in the village with my family, I am convinced that they are positively impacting the community and those who visit.

Keep up the good work, Tim and Robin. Doing is difficult. Critiquing is simple. Our family is forever inspired.

David McEvoy

Dave

jbette01's picture

Poor journalism is afoot my friends.

To expound upon others' points with an attempt not to reiterate too much:

The staff at Rancho Mastatal encouraged me during my week long stay to take advatange of the home stay option as much as possible. The exact opposite of the social isolationism described.

"My main concern is that using environmental ideologies as the primary vehicle through which to interact with rural communities like Mastatal often seems unnatural and condescending, considering the economic imbalance between tourists and locals. " -- I suppose Mr. Stacey was able to put his own economic inequity aside while writing this article? If money, skin color, language and tradition do not connect locals and tourists in Mastatal, there is truly nothing simpler than Nature and a desire to utilize its fruits in a shared, sustainable way to connect the two. Indeed, it is IDEALS that connect tourists and locals at Mastatal. Mastatal is not the Mona Lisa; folks do not flock there to take a picture and leave for the sake of saying that they have done so. Outsiders come to Mastatal,often for extended periods at a time, to experience and enjoy the nature that the Ticos cherish so much.

Further, what actually did Mr. Stacey do while in Mastatal? Did he till soil? Harvest? If he was intending to evaluate the roots of the green economy, perhaps he should have gotten some hands in some dirt.

Larissa's picture

I am extremely saddened by the unfair, unresearched, and untrue portrayal of Rancho Mastatal as well as the some of the venomous arguments which have ensued as a result of this article. As someone who has stayed at Rancho Mastatal three times over the past five years, I wish every single day that I could have been there longer and more often. Both Rancho Mastatal and the Mastatal community have provided me with a peek a better world and have truly been an inspiration. Since so many excellent points have already been posted in "defense" of Rancho Mastal, I won't repeat them. However, I will ask you, Daniel Stacey, what, if any, journalism education you received before writing this article and referring to yourself as a "journalist." Did they teach you about objective reporting, fact checking, or libel?

DrKatHalloran's picture

Wow, Daniel. I am sure at this point after realizing your gross error in judgment and clearly poor reporting, you are severely embarrassed. Let this serve as a lesson to write in the future from a place of integrity and love, not cynicism and sensational one sided gossip. Jeez. I'm dumbfounded and feel really bad for you. I hope your job is not too severely jeopardized. But hey, look at the bright side. This could launch you out into the job market to do a whole other article on how tough it is to interview and land a high quality job. God bless Tim O'Hara and Robin Nunes for the Unconditional Love, Blood, Sweat and Tears and Long Hard Days of work they offer to preserve the rainforest, teach fellow humans how to Love our Planet and leave a little something more for our children, and collaborate in a win-win style with their community which they call home. Best of luck Daniel in your new job search. I imagine it will be rather humbling and I wish you well.
Much Love, Dr Kat

volunteer's picture

Ive spent a few months working with the family of la iguana and have truly enjoyed my stay. very relaxed atmosphere, and a great way to experience rural costa rica. Also ive visited rancho mastatal a few times, spoken to many volunteers, and listend to countless stories from the town gossips. But the only thing i can say for sure is when on the property i feel like i have stepped into a cult, based off the white mans burden. All the volunteers seem to feel that they are part of something grand, benefitting the world, and improving the lives of the poor little ticos. They speak so confidently about all the good they are doing hiring locals, and how they dont have chickens so that they can buy eggs and support the farmers. But what the ranch seems to forget is that they have only been there for 5 or so years. before them this community was just fine. somehow they managed to govern themselves. Also ive witnessed how the ranchos economic power had bred disharmony in the community. families fight over buisness, with the ranch occasionally putting stipulations on the people whos eggs they buy.
Also all the people of iguana engage with the locals. whereas there are very few rancho volunteers that ever step outside the gates. once i was talking to a voluntter from the rancho, and i was shocked to find it had 35 people...i had only seen three outside the gates during the last week. But i do understand the Racho owners desire to keep all volunteers hidden away. Its dangerous to pump such a small community with so many foreigners, because too much foreign influence does have a negative effect on the community. But i do not feel the answer lies in discouraging interaction between locals and volunteers, but rather decreasing the amount of volunteers accepted. Not building yet another volunteer house to add the the empire.

carolinebkennedy's picture

I have stayed on three occasions at Rancho Mastatal and have enjoyed the atmosphere, camaraderie and enthusiasm of the younger volunteers. I have not stayed at La Iguana yet but know Billy Bateman well. He is extremely talented in working with bamboo and, had the author of this biassed article, bothered to learn from Billy during his time as a volunteer he would have acquired a skill far greater, far more worthwhile and far more lucrative than his writing talents.

Unique4now's picture

As a University of Washington graduate, I am off struck at the level of nonsense displayed in this article. During my stay at the ranch I learned many things about community, environmental building, and sustainability. Tim and Robin work hard to build relations within the community in which they live. Now while it may seem objectionable (to you) to ask volunteers to respect a simple guideline, what they really are asking is that they respect the community in whole. I figure you probably feel that letting gringos and ticos party it up until 2-3 in the morning is a healthy arrangement for the community. Alcoholism is very prevalent in Costa Rica and Mastatal is no different. While it may seem harsh (in your eyes) it is a matter of respect for the families living close to the Pulperia, for the wives who have to deal with their hung over husbands, and for the community that is not benefited from over indulgence. From what I have read in your article respect alludes you.

planeta's picture

Question - Are these establishments listed in Rainforest Alliance's database? If so, did the author send a complaint about the less than eco practices he witnessed and what was the response?

daniels_email's picture

Tim, try this email

d.stacey@newstates.co.uk

It does not bounce and it is most likely him.

daniels_email's picture

ooops

d.stacey@newstatesman.co.uk

Latest tweets