Registered user login:

A national embarrassment

Rachel Cooke

Published 13 March 2008

Never mind the food, Delia Smith's on-screen manner is hard to stomach
Delia BBC2

It would be easy to crack jokes about Delia Smith's new series for the BBC, but I am going to resist: having watched it, I don't much feel like laughing. How could Delia have failed so spectacularly to judge the times? And why has she been allowed to get away with doing so? Though there has been the odd barbed comment about her new-found love of tinned mince, the mood in general has been respectful and forgiving. If anyone else tried to fill the nation's heads with approving thoughts of bagged salads and ready-made cheese sauce, they'd be the object of derision. But Delia we leave indulgently alone.

In the first part of her series (10 March, 8.30pm), her friend Nigel Slater was wheeled on to give her bizarre new ethos the thumbs-up. Slater, a cookery writer who is always extolling the virtues of farmers' markets and seasonal ingredients, smiled sweetly for the camera and suggested that, in effect, we had "permission from Headmistress" to go wild in the freezer cabinet.

Forgive me if I find this confusing. I have written before about the strange disjunction that exists between the food we eat and the food we watch being prepared on television, but when I suggested that it would be nice if someone tried to close this gap I didn't think that they would just throw in the towel and hurry off to Iceland. Of course, this is not exactly what Delia has done: it's much weirder than that. She isn't in the business of simply heating through a plastic tray of shepherd's pie; no, it's her contention that even playing at cooking is better than not cooking at all. So, instead, she wants us to buy the "cheat" ingredients for a shepherd's pie - tinned mince, discs of frozen mashed potato - and faff about with those instead. Why? I watched her prepare her hot smoked salmon and quail pie - pre-cooked salmon, pre-boiled quail's eggs, cheese sauce in a tub, more potato discs - and wondered why she didn't just serve the salmon with a jacket potato.

I'm not going to harp on here about the number of calories and additives in pre-prepared food, nor about obesity, salt, industrial processes, packaging, air miles and the corrupting power of our supermarkets: I'm supposed to be writing about television, not doing an impression of Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall. Let's simply note that Saint Delia's recipes do carry a certain ethical load whether she likes it or not.

Did it, however, strike no one that this stuff is unappetising? Food programmes are - this is a cliché, but true all the same - a kind of pornography, the oozing yumminess on offer satisfying desires that we didn't even know we had. But these dishes were horrible. The Peruvian concoction that she rustled up from "lightly spiced" frozen potato wedges, eggs, walnuts, chilli and peppers was hilariously bad. Not since the saveloy on lychees served by Aubrey, the restaurateur in Mike Leigh's Life Is Sweet, have I seen anything I wanted to eat less. Was the food stylist suffering from a migraine at the time, or is someone taking the mickey?

I have a hunch that Delia and her team know this is dodgy, not to say surreal, ground. Smith is a touch pursed during her demonstrations; I would think she was defensive if I hadn't heard her on the radio telling us how into factory-farmed chickens she is.

Her director, meanwhile, uses the gaps between the recipes (when the nation reaches for a glass of water and a nausea remedy) to profile Smith, perhaps thinking that if he reminds us of her status as a national treasure we'll forget all about the mash discs. So, we get to see Delia's shed, which contains 35 years' worth of Pyrex casseroles, and we get to meet her husband, Michael, who is Very Influential. We also see Delia in the locker room at Norwich City, in which she is a major shareholder. Dear me. Her flirty ways with the players are excruciating. Not since my mum claimed to have a crush on the man who came to kill the rats in our drystone walls have I felt so mortified, and I was 15 then. Delia's glottal stop is almost as ersatz as her "ingredients" - and that's really saying something.

Pick of the week

The Passion
16 March, 8pm, BBC1
James Nesbitt is Pontius Pilate. No, I can’t imagine it, either.

Gavin and Stacey
16 March, 9pm, BBC3
Hurrah. Return of the incredibly sweet award-winning comedy.

The Curse of Steptoe
19 March, 9pm, BBC4
First in a series about comedy icons, with Phil Davis as Wilfrid Brambell.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

8 comments from readers

dalemorrall
13 March 2008 at 11:31

This has to be one of the best TV shows I have seen on the BBC in a long while. Not for the cooking, good god no, but for the comedy value and the half of hour of pure entertainment and laughter that it provided my girlfriend and I. Every time Delia pulled out some more of those frozen mashed potato discs the show just got funnier and our laughter louder. Having gone from watching the pure brilliance of Master Chef for the past few months to Delia’s "TV Dinners", well what a change to the TV schedule. Many times voted the UK's favourite Television Chef, this show surely hasn't done the woman any favours for this year’s competition. My moneys on James Nathan - Master Chef 2008 Winner!

Dale Morrall

kate A
13 March 2008 at 13:02

All I can say is WHAT THE BLOODY HELL WAS THAT ALL ABOUT! Nay I cant hold back I have more....The sheer amazement and comedy value were the only thing that kept me and my partner (and only because I forced him...believe me at points my partner tried to wrestle the remote of me to turn over and tried to hastily leave the room!!!)) watching the program(BBC ratings people don't be fooled as judging by most of these comments here and elsewhere I would think this is the ONLY reason why more than half of the viewers who stayed tuned in ..We knew where it was going after the first recipe consisted of frozen potato discs but the subsequent production of said discs for EACH AND EVERY recipe (ok bar the one that consisted of wait for it.... frozen potato wedges..but I'll come to that one later..) had us rolling on the floor with laughter!

I wonder how much Delia/BBC were paid to endorse said offending items? as no one can like frozen potatoe discs THAT much! ..Can they??? The recipes looked ghastly which brings me back to the frozen potato wedges recipe that looked like it was covered in something that had been thrown up eaten and thrown up again....and as for the recipe that included prime tinned dog food ... oops sorry minced lamb...don't get me started!!

The BBC in the past few months have given us exceptional cookery programs like Master chef and an average but passable Nigella Lawson which come to think of it this is a very poor version off!

No one can be that busy in their lives and have such incomparable palates that they have to resort to cooking like this! My mother used to work two jobs and be able to provide us with a tasty fresh cooked meal cooked from scratch! I come home late from work each day and can still russle up something of taste and nutritional benefit to my body.

And just who is this program aimed at?? not to the lower income family (I don't expect there are many who favour buying quails eggs and smoked salmon fillets with their giros alongside their bulk buy value processed products) and certainly not the middle income nay people in general who like to experiment with ingredients and take pleasure in cooking for themselves and guests ala master chef style.

I could go on...but I will leave that for the many other out there (and I am sure there are MANY) I can only congratulate the BBC on producing the funniest programme in a looooong while! (although as funny as it was i will NOT be tuning in next week) has Delia ever thought of turning her hand at comedy???

v069238
13 March 2008 at 20:38

Totally agree with everyone. It was the most ridiculous cooking program i have ever seen. It is just a joke (as others noted, we also just watched it just to see with which other ridiculous dishes she can come up with). Delia is the most boring presenter i have ever see as well (i don't mean to be offensive but just look at Nigella! she is a delight to watch!) and what was that all about her football club! I am not interested in football, i am interested in cooking!

I agree with it being the funniest cooking program though!

sandy
15 March 2008 at 17:32

I was initially skeptical about this. We eat no ready meals at all but I accept most do. Delia has the guts to propose a half-way house that might in the end introduce ready meal addicts to oputting dishes together themselves. Why do we kid ourselbves that we are so superior? A middle class failing. At least she is honest which is more than be said for the celebrity chefs that are all ego. I am a foodie and think Delia has something to offer. Oh, how easy it is to mock. I wonder if the mockers are such good cooks or is it that all they can do is turn on a microwave.

kate A
17 March 2008 at 15:22

In response to comment from Sandy: I speak for myself when I say I mock because I AM actually a very good cook and a very good cook who can prepare quality, tasty, good looking nutritious meals using quality fresh & frozen ingredients from scratch without the expense. It REALLY is neither difficult, time consuming or expensive unless I am going out of my way to prepare something elaborate. It’s not about superiority or class but about love of good tasting food and an awareness of what we put in our bodies! The only think I turn to a microwave for is to heat up the delicious leftovers of what I have prepared!

Carl Jones
17 March 2008 at 22:27

Kate A (star), you are nothing but a snob. YOU, you and you. I can, I do (lol@u).

I know people in London who are earning over £400k are eating takeaways most nights...but THATS THEIR CHOICE. So what about single mothers with children, some with learning disabilities, or disabled children, or those who are carers? Many young people have never known fresh food prepared in the home environment.

I suppose everyone should be sitting around a dining table when they eat....I do with the rest of my family, but many families don`t. In the UK we see people eating on buses, eating while walking down the street... I`ve never seen this in France, so why do we Brits do it?

Britain is a mess on multiple fronts, Delia, like Oliver is doing her bit, its such a shame when people can`t look six inches beyond their big wooden spoon.

kate A
18 March 2008 at 11:52

In response to comment form Carl Jones.

I was bought up in London in a large family where money was often tight but where my mother who worked still managed to prepare tasty fresh nutritous food for all of us. Coming from a large family cooking was about providing tasty meals which we all enjoyed that were nutritious using as good frozen and fresh ingredients as we could afford but obviously to our budget! I was bought up to appreciate taste and to appreciate value for money and as I took part in the cooking to appreciate food! And no we didn’t always sit around the dining table!

Believe it or not I know a wide spectrum of people from single parent, to very high earners to average earners but their eating habits do not resort to opening multiple cans and packets of pre cooked processed often overpriced ingredients. And who doesn’t eat the odd takeaway!!! It’s not about “me me me or I can I do” as you say! This is a comment page to give our comments after all!... I give my opinions to point out to people that I know there are other options to tasty healthy nutritous eating, so that WE do not become a nation of people who think food comes from a can, or packet. Have you never been to the many street markets (and I’m not talking about Borough market) many situated around the less than affluent areas of London i.e. Brixton, Tottenham, Walthamstow etc etc where you can pick up fresh fruit and veg, fish and meats for less than the cost of these pre packaged products?

You make the comment “Many young people have never known fresh food prepared in the home environment” isn’t that a pity and isn’t that the point of this “argument”??

Of course it’s about choice and I know what I am sure many other would choose!

Carl Jones
18 March 2008 at 18:15

kate A; , you miss the point. Your criticism of Delia was total and unfair. Frozen mash, is frozen mash. You can`t expect decades of poor eating to be turned around overnight...look at the backlash against Oliver, but he`s right. If Delia can get people to turn on the hob, its a good start.

Remember Beeching`s axe? Shun rail, get people buying and drving cars....why did ""home economics" stop at school? Why were the supermarkets allowed to manufacture so many ready meals with all the food miles involved? Maybe the governments wanted to expand fast food and the growing employment which came with it. They say the childern of today, will have a shorter life expectancy than their parent....

.....I would contend this was all by NWO design.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

About the writer

Rachel Cooke

Rachel Cooke trained as a reporter on The Sunday Times. She is now a writer at The Observer. In the 2006 British Press Awards, she was named Interviewer of the Year.

Read More

Vote!

Should Darling have been bolder with the 45% tax rate?