Registered user login:

Toys for the boys

Rachel Cooke

Published 19 July 2007

Why has this silly man been given his own, eponymous programme?
James May's 20th Century
BBC2

A lot of people didn't think much of Saxondale, the 2006 sitcom in which Steve Coogan played a bearded ex-roadie who works in pest control (and as there is still no news on a second series, which was supposed to screen this autumn, perhaps this not insubstantial group also includes BBC commissioning editors). I didn't think it was especially funny either, but Coogan's Tommy Saxondale was, if nothing else, an extremely precise impersonation of a certain kind of man. Saxondale Man has bad hair and even worse clothes, and likes beer and fast motors. Women? They have their place, of course. "Nice girls in rubbish cars" are perfectly tolerable, assuming they've got "their own breasts".

Want to know how precise? Well, the above quotation is not from Saxondale, but straight out of the mouth of the charming and debonair James May, the Top Gear presenter. The BBC might be unsure about the future of Tommy, but it is more than happy to employ his real-life counterparts. At first May, like Jeremy Clarkson before him, was confined to driving silly cars too fast while shouting at a dashboard camera. Then, slowly, he was allowed out of his petrolhead pen and given other amusing gigs like Have I Got News For You. Last year, he was sent on a road trip with the wine writer Oz Clark, whose task it was to make him forsake his beloved Virgin's Nipple (or whatever his favourite beer is called) in favour of a nice Sauvignon Blanc. May behaved like a complete baby throughout. I've seen fussy toddlers approach creamed spinach with more style, wit and maturity.

Now he is fronting an Open University production on BBC2: James May's 20th Century (Tuesdays, 8pm), a "personal odyssey" through the greatest inventions of the past century. Needless to say, the inventions on which he is most keen are those that are macho. If an invention necessitates wearing camouflage or a fireproof flying suit, so much the better. Inexplicably, the series is being screened as three double bills and, fool that I am, I watched both programmes for 17 July.

In the first, May set out to show how science has enabled us to push our bodies to their physical limit, by flying in jets or diving deep under the sea. This was unfortunate. No doubt May's blokeish fans found his activities - he tried out a machine that accelerated to mimic G-force - mighty thrilling. But I just wanted the goof to be taught a lesson. "Can I come out, please?" he asked the man controlling this giant spinning wheel, looking green. The guy dutifully pressed the stop button. Why? The correct response would have been a firm: "No! Not until you promise to get a haircut."

Why does the BBC overuse its presenters like this? They end up so ubiquitous - and so obviously ill-suited to the task in hand - that they give me stomach cramps. Alan Titchmarsh used to be a gardening show host; now he is being pushed as he who will one day step into David Attenborough's shoes. James May used to be a car man; now it seems he is the new Heinz Wolff (the professor of bioengineering who used to present a science show, The Great Egg Race). The main trouble with May - apart from the Margaret Rutherford hair and the awful fleeces - is that he cannot, or will not, put his wretched motors behind him. "It's no worse than some Lamborghinis I've driven," he said of a Chieftain tank. While having a hi-tech brain scan, he gazed at a photo of an Aston Martin.

I've no idea how May became such a star that he was given an eponymous series, but I will say that his rise and rise does not bode well for the future of Tommy Saxondale. If May's TV appearances were accompanied by a sharp blast of Jethro Tull, you might not, especially after a few draughts of Virgin's Nipple, be able to tell the difference between them. Then again, as May would no doubt be the first to point out, Saxondale drives a Renault Kangoo - "Kangoo, not kangaroo!" - by day. I can't see May behind the wheel of a Kangoo, can you?

Pick of the week

How Gay Sex Changed the World
24 July, 11.05pm, Channel 4
Brian Sewell and others on the homosexual revolution of 1967.

Absolute Zero
24 July, 9pm, BBC4
Story of science's search for the coolest spot in the universe.

Heroes
25 July, 9pm, BBC2
Much-hyped American saga of ordinary people with super powers.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

13 comments from readers

Life On Mars
20 July 2007 at 10:31

What a load of rubbish!

James May has the aptitude to make a programme easy enough for young ones to understand, but interesting enough for the oldies to enjoy too. Are you related to India Knight? I think you must have been separated at birth.

Some people actually spend their time more constructively and enjoy life, like Mr May.

Something from the sounds of your article you know little about.

Life On Mars
20 July 2007 at 10:39

May is great too. A 21st century Raymond Baxter with added dry wit (and a bit more hair).

Amelia Bachelor-Stevenson
20 July 2007 at 14:51

I'm struggling to see the point you're making here Rachel. Are you complaining about men being men? The success of James May is that he appeals to the vast majority of men as being a jolly nice chap to spend time town the pub with. That's 50% of the population in case you hadn't noticed. It doesn't harm either that James has become the thinking woman's bit of totty.

You might like your men to be metrosexual ponces wearing Hugo Boss suits and regularly check out En Primeur wines at BB&R. Some of us much prefer the type of man who'll throw on tatty jeans and can fix most things under the bonnet of our little Citroëns whilst we keep them supplied with copious amount of tea and cake i.e. real men.

Murph
20 July 2007 at 17:48

Erm, could you be any more wrong? Perhaps you may wish to do a bit of research in future about a person before you attempt to do a character assasination of them. Your ignorance on the subject you are writing about does you no favours and is clear for all to see. Never mind the intelligent and charming Mr May, 'Why has this silly woman been given her own column?' is the question that sprung to my mind.

gadders
20 July 2007 at 17:53

What a terrible review. The reason men and women like James is because he's just a normal bloke and someone who can explain things in a non-condescending and easy to understand way.

How sad that you have such a hang-up on his looks too. I think this just about sums up all that is wrong with society - an obsession with style over substance.

gadders
20 July 2007 at 18:14

What? Were you wtching the same program as us? I thouhgt it was brilliant and i'm not man - a 19 yr old girl if you must know who thinks James is gorgeous. I learnt loads of intersting stuff and it always helps to have a bit of eye-candy. Agree with all the commenrts above.

lizzy
20 July 2007 at 18:33

Ms Cooke what drugs were you on when you watched James May? must have been good ones because you certainly did not have any grasp on reality whilst watching this superb new series. And as for the insulting comments on his appearance - little bit of advice- how about you look in the mirror?

Jan A
20 July 2007 at 20:00

Good lord woman. For your information, some women actually do find science, planes and cars, etc, quite interesting. This is an Open University programme which from the comments of other people, of different sexes, and different ages, appears to be both educational and entertaining. Your comments on the personal appearance and behaviour of the presenter reveal a shallow personality and one which would therefore be more suited to writing for a tabloid newspaper.

Bunty Sheldon
21 July 2007 at 12:20

'How did Mr May get his own eponymous series?'

Because he is intelligent, witty, entertaining, amusing, educated....the list goes on.

Television is a sea of mediocrity, where blonde bimbos rule and with a worrying epidemic of metrosexual males, being subjugated by feminist women trying to stamp out all the things we like best in a *real* man.

Some of us, at least, will continue to enjoy this programme in all its good-old fashioned, blokey, non-PC glory.

LW
21 July 2007 at 16:20

"" At first May, like Jeremy Clarkson before him, was confined to driving silly cars too fast while shouting at a dashboard camera ""

Clearly you don't watch Top Gear, and know very little about James May. If you'd bother to do some homework you would know he is actually nicknamed 'Captain Slow', because unlike the other two he is a calmer and more 'sensible' driver', and does not 'shout at the dashboard camera', as you yourself put it in your rather poor attempt at reviewing his programme.

Jake
14 August 2007 at 13:17

I'm not sure how a "bearded ex-roadie who works in pest-control" is an "extremely precise impersonation " of a man like James May. He appears to be an erudite, intelligent, widely-read, charming and yes, "manly" kind of man. Your piece didn't seem to apply much original thought, and was more a vehicle to express your own personal distaste for this kind of man. You're in a minority. Which should please you.

babyjayne
02 October 2007 at 19:52

Ms Cooke, I am struggling to understand where you are coming from with these thoughts on James May, I am a fifty year old woman who did sit, as a child, transfixed by the late, and much lamented Raymond Baxter, I have now found another intelligent, educated and extremely gifted man, who can make the sciences of invention interesting and easy to understand, the fact that James is also easy on the eye is an added bonus. My 73 year old mother and her 77 year old sister who both lament the lack of decent and watchable TV found the program whilst surfing the channels, and then begged me to video the rest of the series for them, and neither of them have any interest in Top Gear, in other words, to quote my father, you are opening your mouth and letting you belly rumble.

Caroline Blake
15 March 2008 at 19:38

The whole basis for this rather silly - yes far sillier than the programme itself - review was that James May had been given a programme to present. Rachel needs to do a little more research in future and get her facts straight. James May was not just the presenter of this programme. He wrote it. He has been involved in writing and presenting several history-theme programmes for the BBC. He does of course appear on Top Gear, which is indeed rather a silly show - basically a comedy programme (but fun Rache - honest, let yourself go!) but Mr May isn't silly at all. He has a music degree, writes beautifully (far far better than our Rachel!) and is actually a rather erudite and articulate individual. I heard him by chance on Radio 3's Private Passions a while back and found him intelligent and charming. And Rachel, judging him by his hairdo or any other aspect of his looks or style is skating on thin ice isn't it? James has been voted one of the sexiest men in the world by the Pink Paper and Weird Crush of the year by Heat magazine. He is clearly attractive to quite a lot of people. I have studied your likeness at the top of the page Rachel. Enough said eh?

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

About the writer

Rachel Cooke

Rachel Cooke trained as a reporter on The Sunday Times. She is now a writer at The Observer. In the 2006 British Press Awards, she was named Interviewer of the Year.

Read More

Vote!

Should Darling have been bolder with the 45% tax rate?