Registered user login:

We no longer believe old men's myths

Darcus Howe

Published 11 September 2008

In the past fortnight or so, a very old man, startled by an interviewer, blurted out: "It is very easy to sit here in this room (amidst the cobwebs at Cambridge University) and say racism is horrible. But ask me the same thing if a Jamaican family moved next door with six children and they play reggae and rock music all day."

These are the words of George Steiner, a 79-year-old Jewish Cambridge professor possessed of "vast scholarship", we are told in an excellent article in the Guardian of 5 September.

Simultaneously, issues of race and immigration are at large in the national press. A group of MPs has stated that the UK will be overwhelmed with non-EU immigrants in a few years' time. They insist a cap should be placed on the numbers that continue to arrive. "Send them back after a four-year stint," say the parliamentarians. Otherwise, they insist, this tiny island state will be swamped by people of dark skin.

Some 50 years ago, vast numbers of Caribbean men and women responded to Britain's desperate need for immigrant labour and settled in the inner cities of the UK to revive and extend the service and manufacturing industries.

In an atmosphere of palpable ignorance, the myth developed that we played music all day and all night when we were not fucking white women or breeding like rabbits. The 1958 race riots in Notting Hill went hand in hand with these outpourings of racism. Steiner must have been a young man then. His mind is stuck in those early days of mass immigration.

He is joined in the mire by Max Hastings, the bow-tied scribe who recalled in the Daily Mail, only days after Steiner's remarks were published, the life of Elsie the family cleaner, who had to emigrate to Australia because she was hemmed in on both sides of her home in Hammersmith, as "Jamaican neighbours played music full-blast through the night, every night".

It never occurs to Max and George that West Indians (Jamaicans to them) clocked on and off from sunup to sundown at London Transport, post offices, the Peek Freans factory, and every other factory around our capital city.

It is all myth and lies in the tradition of Enoch Powell, who in his bitter anti-immigrant speech in 1968, manufactured an old Englishwoman whom he claimed had been persecuted by grinning piccaninnies at her home in the Midlands.

The oldies are at it again, only now, they cannot muster support in the general population. A new generation of white, inner-city, working-class youth, though its members may stumble and fall on the blade, appears free of the imperial disease that is racism.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

16 comments from readers

terryuno
11 September 2008 at 11:39

These myths are similiar to the ones told by old black men. You know the ones: The police are racist, our children fail because of racism, we act baldly because people expect us to, etc.

Jonny Mac
12 September 2008 at 12:37

"...Elsie the family cleaner, who had to emigrate to Australia because she was hemmed in on both sides of her home in Hammersmith, as "Jamaican neighbours played music full-blast through the night, every night".

It never occurs to Max and George that West Indians (Jamaicans to them) clocked on and off from sunup to sundown at London Transport, post offices, the Peek Freans factory, and every other factory around our capital city.

It is all myth and lies in the tradition of Enoch Powell..."

1. What have Elsie's experiences got to do with the fact that West indians worked/work in factories?

2. Howe accuses either Hastings or Elsie of lying ("It's all myths and lies"), a serious accusation, on absolutely no evidence.

Darcus Howe = sloppy journalism..

anSiarach
12 September 2008 at 13:43

If Darcus Howe wasnt such a determined racist himself he might care to actually research his articles properly. Enoch Powell was not a liar:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-433497/Widow-Enoch...

gnuneo
12 September 2008 at 14:39

DH: alas, racism is still there! However, there has been a change, and i suspect it has to do with the break-up of the link between racism and nationalism - now "dark-skinned" Britons are at the heart of our culture, creating vibrant, cross-community music, creating world-class sports-people, criticising the Govt, schools, bosses, and the media - behaving just as all the other Britons do!

now to be a British Nationalist, one has to accept all the sub-cultures within the UK, not only the white, upper-class sub-culture, but all the ethnically and culturally diverse elements of the modern UK. Would Britain be Britain without DnB? Without Prince Naz? Without its curry houses? Without a Govt that hates and ignores us all? Of course not.

i feel sorry for those cultures that are so rigid they cannot manage to be pluralistic, i feel sorry for the populations there that are denied the creativity, exoticness, the diversity, the Modernness that we in the UK have managed to achieve - ohhh so painfully in some areas.

but we HAVE done it, and this IS something to be proud of, far more than the ridiculous 'millennium dome' and all the other expensive spectacles the various UK Govts have tried to tell us we should be proud about (such as attacking helpless 3rd world countries).

how many medals in Beijing would the UK have won without the immigration of the last 100yrs? Would British music be celebrated around the world? British (& English, Welsh, Scottish) culture has never been so vibrant and strong, we are not in danger of being "swamped" - the World is in danger of being converted to us! LOL :D

cj61
13 September 2008 at 03:28

Ah yes, Elsie and all the other ten pound migrants who flocked to enjoy the dying years of Australia's White Australia Policy. And then never bothered to become Australian citizens because, after all, Australia is just a miniature britain anyway. Well, they managed to resurrect some of it by voting johnny howard in for 11 years of 1950s nostalgia, but it was too late, and they are now wondering where the last white corner of the world is... hopefully they'll find it soon and leave us in multicultural peace.

Riaz Ahmad
13 September 2008 at 11:36

End of the day, both Britain and Europe are living through a time bomb of aging populations. In order to keep the industries and economies alive, they have to rely on immigration to save them from economic decline. The centre of gravity of economic power has already shifted to Asia. It will be the darker skinned who will be pulling the international financial and industrial purse strings. As for the racist minorities in Europe, the white man's burden is over, give or take another fifty years it will be more like the dark mans burden.

BillN
13 September 2008 at 12:35

terryuno - I didn't realise Macpherson was an old black man.

terryuno
14 September 2008 at 10:50

@BillN

terryuno - I didn't realise Macpherson was an old black man

No, he just a stupid politically correct, guilty white liberal who perpetuates these myths. I suppose he had no choice really, a politically expedient report lessens the possibility of any rioting or looting. Still, these myths do give people a chance blame other people for their own failings.

bumchum
15 September 2008 at 04:30

Darcus Howe = sloppy journalism..

This man is the Frankinstein's Monster of British Imperialism.

explodingbadger
16 September 2008 at 04:45

Unfortunately the UK is an extremely racist place.

Its deeply saddening to read the comments here.

If only all our racists could be shipped off to ther other side of the world.

terryuno
17 September 2008 at 18:39

@explodingbadger

Totally agree with you but we are a civilised country and we can't just ship people like Darcus off to Australia, just because we don't like his views.

gnuneo
18 September 2008 at 02:53

Riaz Ahmad: "As for the racist minorities in Europe, the white man's burden is over, give or take another fifty years it will be more like the dark mans burden."

there are racists everywhere, in every land. And the "White Man's Burden" is a darkly humorous allegory about Class rule, that again, in a wider sense than yours, transcends race and culture.

no-where
18 September 2008 at 03:39

Unfortunately the UK is an extremely racist place.

The first person to be convicted for racist comments, under new anti racist legislation, a few years back,was a black man I believe!

yawnketia
27 September 2008 at 12:10

britain will be a vibrant culturally and be more productive if they accepted other people. unfortunately, what we have is a society that grudgingly receives but treats badly when people are not looking. it appears the norm is: you can hold your racist views in your bedroom and say them as long as you are among people who think like you.

St. Augustine/David Craig
29 September 2008 at 08:14

People should have a chip implanted in their brain to stop them mouthing racist views in their bedrooms. Eventually people will realize the true benefits of a multicultural society and we will have a nation of coffee (fair trade) coloured people. We on honey dew have fed and drunk the milk of paradise!

gnuneo
01 October 2008 at 03:43

"it appears the norm is: you can hold your racist views in your bedroom and say them as long as you are among people who think like you."

that is absolutely correct. You are also entitled to whatever other opinions you wish to have as well, just as in Apartheid South Africa people of all colours were able to have negative opinions about the Apartheid regime... in the privacy of their bedrooms.

racism, the bigotry of weakness and secret inferiority complexes, cannot be excised through totalitarian thought-police measures, only through honest and authentic dialogue and discussion - "freedom of speech" in a catchy phrase.

if you gag people, you cannot hear what they think and why - and then you cannot debate it, cannot understand it, and can only dehumanise your 'opponents'. That's as weak and pathetic as racism itself is.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

About the writer

Darcus Howe

Darcus Howe is an outspoken writer, broadcaster and social commentator. His TV work includes ‘White Tribe’ in which he put Anglo-Saxon Britain under the spotlight. He also fronted a series called Devil’s Advocate.

Read More

Vote!

Should Darling have been bolder with the 45% tax rate?