Registered user login:

When law and order break down

Darcus Howe

Published 29 May 2008

Blood was seen through the white body bags. Relatives surrounded the back of the hearse, demanding that police open the body bags to let them see the bodies

There is not a single Caribbean island state that is not threatened with a tide of violence. Haiti, Jamaica and Trinidad are besieged by murder and mayhem, blood and hellfire. I knew this before I left London for my holiday in Barbados. Being here sharpens in my mind the urgency of the historical moment.

The citizens of these islands are alert to the fact that they are living on the edge of darkness.

Barbados is relatively stable and has a strong economy based on tourism. Even so, the MP for Christ Church East said this about violence in his constituency: "In the Silver Sands/Inch Marlow area there is now a proliferation of intercommunity rivalry [by which he meant gang violence involving guns and knives] . . . and it is reaching dangerous proportions. In Parish Land the same is true, and that has reached boiling point now, where residents are being affected by it." He asked church leaders: "How do we plan collectively a strategy to deal with these issues?"

The words uttered by this Barbadian MP could have fallen equally easily from the mouths of parliamentarians in Trinidad and Jamaica ten or more years ago.

In Trinidad, where I was born, this past month has been described in the press and from the pulpit as the Bloody Month of May. Here is what one of the daily newspapers said on 25 May:

Pandemonium broke out on Saturday as relatives of murdered husband and wife Anthony Charles and Antoinette Nedd demanded to see the bodies of their loved ones. Piercing screams of anguish echoed through the air around 6am as undertakers removed the bodies from the couple's home at Enterprise Village, Chaguanas.

Blood was seen through the white body bags and one of the sons of the couple sat on the hearse, preventing it from moving, as other relatives surrounded the back of the vehicle, demanding that police open the body bags to let them see the bodies. The deaths of Charles and Nedd, along with Moonsie Shadrack, Knolly Nicholas and Deonarine Lata, have now pushed the murder toll to 195 for the year thus far, surpassing last year's total of 113 around this same period.

A group of between five and six police officers was on patrol in Trenchtown, a violent slum of Jamaica's capital city. A posse of young residents stalked the patrol and opened fire. Two officers lay dead, riddled with bullets. Their guns were stolen and their pockets emptied of cash. Be sure that the police will retaliate, executing several young men from that community in revenge.

In the main shopping area of Port-of-Spain, the capital of Trinidad, a shoplifter was seen recently leaving a store without paying for a pair of trainers. A police officer gave chase. He slipped and his 9mm fell from his grasp. The shoplifter turned, snatched the pistol off the ground and emptied the barrel into the policeman.

This is the reality in the Caribbean. These are no longer isolated crimes: they illustrate that social order has broken down completely. In Haiti, officials have given up on the body count and we hear nothing from the governments of the other islands. The Jamaican prime minister, Bruce Golding, sought debt relief from Gordon Brown on a recent visit to England. About the descent into barbarism that these murders highlight, he was silent. He turned his guns instead on homosexuals, who would not be allowed in his cabinet. This is our Caribbean as it stands today.

I had organised the disposal of my late sister's ashes in Trinidad. She passed on in September last year. A weekend in Trinidad would suffice. My brother simply said, "Don't come to come to this horrible place.” I dithered, protesting that I had no enemies in Trinidad. His was a two-word reply: “Collateral damage.”

We are all consumed.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

8 comments from readers

Bajanboy
30 May 2008 at 15:06

Darcus:

I live in Inch Marlow (Barbados) and I find the reality of life here does not mesh with what is presented in your article. There is petty crime and Long Beach (the beach which borders Inch Marlow) is used occasionally to land illegal drugs, but I never feel unsafe here or anywhere else in Barbados.

There are very few violent incidents of crime against tourists, and this is surprising considering that most tourists feel safe to walk around in secluded areas and therefore potentially put themselves in situations where they could be mugged.

Contrast this to Jamaica where most tourists would not consider leaving their hotels at night.

I think the mistake your article makes is lumping the Caribbean together as if it is one homogeneous territory. Life is dangerous in Jamaica, Trinidad and Guyana, but Barbados has largely escaped the violence that plagues its neighbors.

Stanley
30 May 2008 at 16:33

This article borders on calumny or slander. I sincerely hope that the Barbados Tourism Authority make very strong representations to the New Statesman for them to retract this article, and to profusely apologise for the implication that Barbados is not a safe place for tourists. One of the great strengths of Barbados, in comparison to many other tourists destinations, is the stability of the country, and the comparatively low crime rate especially against tourists. Tony Blair, and many other prominent people, have taken their vacations here, they own homes here, and keep returning. TB and his wife were always able to relax with local people in the carnival, on the beaches, and around the countryside. They felt no need to permanently hide in their private residences or hotels.

As a blogger in Barbados has said, this article is ill-informed, biased and deliberately intended to denigrate Barbados.

David Spieler
30 May 2008 at 17:46

I operate a small tourist attraction called Earthworks Pottery in Barbados and read the article above linked in by Barbados Freepress.Though one cannot dispute that a Bajan MP did complain about a few groups of youths who sometimes fight over drugs and money this is NOT what happens in Barbados. Murders and grisly scenes are not the norm.

The quote from the Barbados MP is posted out of context-it is not entirely clear that the gruesome murder described is in Trindad, not Barbados.

Barbados is a very stable, welcoming place. We take the greatest pains and go to every length to welcome vistors. We are one people- Bajans working honestly and peacefully in one of the most stable democracies in the world. The Royal Barbados Police Force and the Barbados Defense Force are here to protect the law-abiding. It is never long before the few bad ones that try to go outside the law are caught and brought to justice, because in a small island there are many observant eyes.

Sincerely yours,

David Spieler.

www.earthworks-pottery.com

Pat
30 May 2008 at 22:29

I see nothing inaccurate in the article. He is not saying that those things happened in Barbados. He outlined what happens in Jamaica and Trinidad. I take this to mean that if Barbadians do not smarten up, they will be at that crossroads in ten years. He tried to put it positively by saying that we are where Trinidad was ten years ago. His quotation of what the Minister said is used only as an example to show how small time crime can grow to the level that not exists in Haita, Ja, and Trini.

Matallie
31 May 2008 at 00:33

MATALLIE

Judging by the above comments for and against Darcus' article, quite frankly I fall short of condemnation on his part.

The mere fact the MP for Christ Church East made the published remarks leaves one (Darcus or anyone else) to interpret the his utterance in a manner that can compare Barbados with the other islands mentioned in the article.

However, in my view I think the Christ Church East MP committed the cardinal sin by not being more specific.

Mark W
31 May 2008 at 03:54

The murder rate in Barbados last year was 10.6 per 100,000. This was around 50% higher than the USA, five times most European countries, and about the same as Trinidad in 2000. Jamaica is in a league by itself, and has not seen a rate this low since 1975.

Small and apparently peaceful islands can be surprisingly dangerous places. St Vincent and St Kitts last year had murder rates higher than Trinidad, and more than three times as high as Barbados.

The MP was quite right to point out the danger of violent youth gangs.

In all the islands, Trinidad and Jamaica included, almost all the violence is gang-on-gang.

swatantra nandanwar
31 May 2008 at 11:53

Sounds like everyday life on the streets of Brixton. Why is it that crime and criminal elements, are allowed to export their violence from the WI to here?

Divadialect
01 June 2008 at 16:27

Mark W - there are lies, damn lies and statistics. Nearly all Caribbean islands have tiny populations, hence a few murders can seem like so much more when you start quoting 'per 100,000'. For instance a few years ago Montserrat had the dishonour of having the world's highest crime rate - because there had been one murder there. Mind you it was the first murder in about a decade, but because Montserrat's population was about 3000 people (yes, you read right) when it was adjusted to reflect 'per 100 000' it made it seem as if Montserrat was a most monstrous place to live, more terrifying than states like Somalia or Colombia.

I notice that Mr. Howe is referred to as a writer and social commentator. Thank God he was not referenced as a journalist for this article goes against all journalistic principles - he has simply taken a quote and twisted it and then blithely compared Barbados to states like Trinidad and Jamaica when the comparison is completely inaccurate.

I have lived in Jamaica for several years and I have lived in Barbados most of my life. A large part of the reason for Jamaica, Mr. Howe's native Trinidad and Haiti's crime rates is the huge social gap. There are no or few opportunities for those in the lower echelons of society to advance or lift themselves up so crime is a viable alternative lifestyle and criminals an alternative authority source.

Unlike the other islands mentioned, Barbados does not have nearly so large a gap because we have had free AND universal secondary education for decades and free university education. Barbadians are not nearly as inclined to turn to crime because unlike in our larger (and in the case of Trinidad wealthier) neighbours, our people have options.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

About the writer

Darcus Howe

Darcus Howe is an outspoken writer, broadcaster and social commentator. His TV work includes ‘White Tribe’ in which he put Anglo-Saxon Britain under the spotlight. He also fronted a series called Devil’s Advocate.

Read More

Vote!

Is this the worst economic situation for 60 years?