Khao Lak fails the test
Observations on Thailand
By James Montague Published 20 September 2007The phone call came at 7pm, just after I'd clambered into a bath. "Sir, there's been an earthquake in Sumatra: 8.2," crackled through the handset. At first I wasn't clear why I'd been called about tectonic plate movements a thousand miles away. Then the penny dropped. I was on my honeymoon on the west coast Thai beach resort of Khao Lak, with its glass-clear seas and white sand beaches.
Khao Lak took the brunt of the Asian tsunami that hit Thailand in 2004. More than 4,000 tourists and locals, half of Thailand's total loss, perished on its beaches from the aftershock of a large Sumatran tremor. "How long do we have?" I asked. "If it's there, it will be with you by 9pm. Check the BBC on your TV, sir." Click, brrrr.
It has been a long haul getting Khao Lak back on its feet. The 11-metre wave destroyed every beachfront resort, decimating the local economy. A police boat, which was patrolling the waters at the time of the tsunami, still sits marooned three kilometres into the jungle as a monument to the sea's power. The death toll stole the headlines, but the survivors suffered enormously. A 2006 Rutgers University study into the effects of the tsunami noted that tourism made up 6 per cent of Thailand's GDP. That figure rose to nearly 50 per cent for Phang Nga, the province that includes Khao Lak, which had 642, 387 visitors in 2004; in 2005, that figure dropped to almost zero.
"It was very hard," explains Ria Netboot, a Dane who with her Thai husband runs the Viking Steak House on the high street. "We were lucky; the buildings along this street are higher, so we survived."
To reassure locals and potential tourists, the Thai government invested in an early-warning system monitored by the National Disaster Warning Centre north of Bangkok. Two hi-tech sea buoys were placed in the Andaman Sea to monitor sea levels; 30-metre high warning towers - able to raise the alarm in five different languages - were installed along Thailand's west coast beaches. If there was a sniff of anything, evacuations to special shelters in the mountains would begin within minutes.
We rushed to dress, grabbed our passports and joined the chaotic exodus. Hysterical families were running, cycling or driving to the mountains. Then the heavens opened. My wife had a brainwave. "Head for the Viking Steak House. If they survived the last one, they'll survive this one." We drove on our clapped-out moped past crashed motorcycles and trees blown down by the hurricane's gusts. Others had had the same idea and the Viking Steak House was full of soaked tourists, crying Thai families and bemused diners.
The Thai government, and in particular the National Disaster Warning Centre, was nowhere to be seen or heard. The 30-metre beacons stayed silent; no warnings were issued. Survivors from the previous tsunami turned to international news networks.
"I didn't hear any warning so I stayed on the main street here," explained Toom, a Thai who runs an internet cafe . "Everyone else has run up the mountain; there's about 500 people up there."
That Thailand's expensive warning centre failed its first test provoked outrage in the local media. Early tsunami warnings were issued in every country except Thailand - another blow to a government trying to engender trust among its sceptical population. Faith in authority, bar the revered king, is at rock bottom.
Any recovery made by the beleaguered tourist industry will have been further destroyed by this month's horrific plane crash at Phuket airport, which killed at least 89 people.
At the Viking Steak House, 9pm came and we were all still alive. Ria moved from table to table breaking the news: "We've been given the all-clear; there's no tsunami!"
Had the government managed to send word at last? "No," answered Ria. "I heard it on the BBC."
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists


5 comments
We were well informed by the Thai news in advance that there would be no Tsunami in Thailand.
We almost lost our lives in the 2004 Tsunami in Khao Lak and have been back many times since. I genuinely feel that the Thai authorities would be the last people to issue any warning. They seem to put the tourist monetary income before safety. The fact that no information was forthcoming is no surprise to us.
The authorities decided it would be a good idea to build miles of pavements and new road for the 2005 memorial to impress visitors but only a few moths later most of them had collapsed. This was done when local people were still waiting to be rehoused.. Best advice is don't stay on the beach as the Thais lack of organisation and reluctance to panic the tourists may cost you more than an evenings inconvenience...
Since there was no risk of a tsunami in Thailand, there was no warning.
Makes sense to me.
Steven and Chantal, thanks for your comments
Steven, the problem was that the authorities didn't say anything either way. Every other country that had been hit previously had a warning which was then removed when the threat passed. And for an hour there was a very real threat. The NDWC stayed silent and the vacuum caused chaos.
Chantal, Thai news gave the official all clear at 10pm, a full hour after the rest of the world knew.
Sadly-there is no current way to give an authentic advance warning, all wr scientists can do is speculate. We do not know which quake will cause a tsunami or Why.