Registered user login:

Welcome to the EcoMosque

Ziauddin Sardar

Published 05 June 2008

The hope is that the first ecomosque it will act as an inspiration and model for future mosques

A new mosque will be opening this month in Levenshulme, Manchester. Nothing unusual in that, except that al-Markaz al-Najmi Mosque is eco-friendly. It is built with recycled materials and generates part of its energy from solar panels. British mosques are not re nowned for their friendliness by any barometer, so this is an event worth celebrating.

What I can say about mosques in Britain with some certainty is that they are all hideously ugly. There are about 1,700 in total, and I've seen quite a few of them. The ones converted from churches and synagogues look out of sync, like square pegs in round holes. The purpose-built ones, like Birmingham Central Mosque or the Hanfia Mosque in Bradford, seem to me to be products of an imagination devoid of aesthetics.

And that is what they are: these masjids were built by a generation of elders more concerned with dubious piety and obscurantist modes of behaviour than grace or beauty. London Central Mosque, designed in 1969 by Sir Frederick Gibberd (who also designed Liverpool's Roman Catholic Cathedral) and built at great expense from 1974, resembles a gold fish tank. Its gold dome looks like a panama hat, and its horseshoe balcony recalls a recital hall rather than a place of worship. These mosques are designed to be unfriendly to women. Most of them lack appropriate places for cultural or youth activities. And all of them fail to meet basic standards of sustainability. In other words, they reflect the unhealthy state of Britain's Muslim community.

What is worse is that Muslims want to build more places of this type. The emphasis is on bigger, uglier and louder. The controversial propo sal for a "mega-mosque" near the Olympic Village in east London is a case in point.

Fortunately, there are Muslims, most of them young, who recognise that mosques must evolve. If the Muslim community is to regenerate itself, its mosques will have to become much more than simply places of worship, devoted to particular sects to the exclusion of all others.

They have to provide Muslims living locally with a welcoming space for neighbourhood activities, social gatherings, teaching, counselling and lifelong education. They have to create a sense of identity and moral responsibility. They need to treat women with equality and dignity, not as lesser humans who have to be ushered in through the back door. They have to be able to cope with radicalised young people and be able to redirect their anger in positive directions. They have to be connected to mainstream British society and welcoming of outsiders.

This is a tall order, but it is the basic philosophy behind EcoMosque. Developed by Regenesis², a Muslim social enterprise based in Manchester, the EcoMosque concept aims to transform British masjids into dynamic and effective vehicles for social change. "The idea is inspired by the first mosque in Islam, built by the Prophet Muhammad in Medina as the hub for a thriving, socially conscious community," says Zahid Hussain, chief operating officer of Regenesis². Like the Prophet's mosque, EcoMosque emphasises self-reliance and social enterprise while adding the new goal of sustainability.

The first fully fledged EcoMosque will be built on the banks of the River Irwell at the University of Salford. The hope is that it will act as an inspiration and model for future mosques. It will also provide a framework that existing mosques could use to change and adapt in order to play a more meaningful role in society.

I am sure it will be resisted by the rusty generation, which feels more at home in ugly, isolated and sectarian places of worship. But EcoMosque is the kind of idea that young British Muslims will embrace and run with.

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

5 comments from readers

Sharif
05 June 2008 at 12:10

Mr. Sardar: The sentence "They have to create a sense of identity and moral responsibility. They need to treat women with equality and dignity, not as lesser humans who have to be ushered in through the back door. They have to be able to cope with radicalised young people and be able to redirect their anger in positive directions. They have to be connected to mainstream British society and welcoming of outsiders." is a music in my ears. It would be great to have such ideals. And if majority accept the above, I might join the faith again after all. But that is tall order. Let us hope for the best. Expect very little.

Iftikhar
06 June 2008 at 16:45

Salaam

Every Masjid must have a state funded Muslim schools with bilingual Muslim teachers as role models. A Masjid is not only a place for worship but also imparting education to elders as well as young children.

Bilingual Muslim children must learn and be well versed in standard English to follow the National Curriculum and go for higher studies and research to serve humanity. They must learn and be well versed in Arabic to recite and understand the Holy Quran. They must learn Urdu and other community languages to enjoy the beauty of their literature and poetry and to keep in touch with their cultural roots.

Migrant Muslims arrived with a faith, cultures and languages. All of them go hand in hand. A human being is the product of his /her culture, language and faith. One can't live by bread alone.

Sharif
07 June 2008 at 07:48

Iftikhar: You claim that man cannot live by bread alone and forget that the journey of our first generation to the west was just that: bread, or as i might put it: Search for jobs and financial security. Your second point is culture identity. For the 2nd and 3rd generation the culture should be that of west. They must grow up to be a product of their home country which is west. When people went to USa, they became Americans. Religion is a different matter altogether. Whereas for the 1st generation, the new surroundings are 'Imaginary Homelands', as Salman Rushdi put it in his book, for those born here are real. I admire Lahiri's books which describe the adjustment of the new to the real world we have HERE. The rest is all baloney.

Salim Al-Hassani
09 June 2008 at 00:48

I presume Professor Serdar is not aware of the Istanbul Suleimaniye Mosque, built in 1550 by Sinan, where the smoke form the 1000s of candles and oil lamps was channelled aerodynamically onto a filter room before it left the building to the atmosphere. The soot was then collected from the filter to convert it into ink ☺. I wish Muslims learn form this example.

Mind you. When I first landed in the UK in 1960, I was sent to do my A levels at Stoke on Trent. There were days when one could hardly breathe due to the heavy smog from industrial chimnies spreading poisonous smoke into the atmosphere causing buildings to be covered in black and people suffered from chest disease. Despite the enormous reduction of smoke, we still generate CO2 in dangerous quantities. .

Professor Serdar should remind Muslims of the saying of Prophet Mohammed that "if one has a seedling to plant and the end of the world has come, one must not hesitate to plant it." Can you imagine the positive impact on our Echo-system will be if every Muslim on this planet was to plant a tree each year? So may be we should encourage Mosques to keep the trees in their gardens instead of uprooting them to make space for car parking.

Salim

ismail
10 June 2008 at 21:43

I'm are realy happy to see that such experience are also developped in U.K. In Belgium and in France, I have see that an office specialised in construction of mosque, propose the High Environemental Quality (french norm ) for building mosque. This office fight also against "copy and past" model of mosque from the original countries of the migrant population. They use to create architecture according to the local context. It is like a renewal of religious architecture in Europe.

Joel PRIVOT, one of the founder of this office has made a presentation of these methods last month at the European parliament in Brussels. See this link to read the abstract : http://www.comece.org/comece.taf?_function=news&_sub=&id=2&l...

This office is called "EXPERT-is". The web site is: www.expert-is.eu

For example, I have read that they prepare the great mosque of Bordeaux in France, one of the future greatest mosque in Europe (more than 200m long, 50m large and 15m high), the cost is estimated at 25.000.000 € ! They also prepare several mosque in Brussels.

We can enjoy to see that in Europa, different offices try to developpe such method for building mosque. I think taht the most difficult is not to create good and integrated architectural mosque but to change mentalities of people in muslim community.

Ismail.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

About the writer

Ziauddin Sardar

Ziauddin Sardar, writer and broadcaster, describes himself as a ‘critical polymath’. He is the author of over 40 books, including the highly acclaimed ‘Desperately Seeking Paradise’. He is Visiting Professor, School of Arts, the City University, London and editor of ‘Futures’, the monthly journal of planning, policy and futures studies.

Read More

Vote!

Is this the worst economic situation for 60 years?