The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Theresa May blocks Gary McKinnon extradition on "human rights" grounds

Home Secretary finds that the Human Rights Act isn't so bad after all.

Gary McKinnon attends a press conference in London
Gary McKinnon attends a press conference in London, on 15 January 2009. Photograph: Getty Images.

In a statement to the House of Commons, Theresa May has just announced that she has blocked the extradition of computer hacker Gary McKinnon to the US on the grounds that there was a serious risk that he would kill himself. To applause from MPs, she said:

[A] decision to extradite would be incompatible with Mr McKinnon’s human rights.

There is, as the Lib Dems will no doubt reflect, much irony in the Home Secretary invoking the Human Rights Act that she has so often reviled.

16 comments

William Brown's picture

The right decision made for all the wrong reasons.

The duplicity of the politically motivated timing by the tories and the fawning to the US of the previous labour government, cost this man 10 years of his life.

There should never have been a question of extraditing anyone to the USA for a 'crime' commited on UK soil. Our justice system is bad enough, but the US increasingly bears more resemblance to those of the despots they are currently at war with.

Stuart Eels's picture

For this issue to hang over the bloke for ten years, it's amazing that he hasn't had an heart attack. Let's not forget the way he got into their "attack proof system" in the first place by typing in password for the password, whichever idiot who thought up that should have been put on trial.

Then we get one of George W Bush's ex aides shouting that they should cut all ties with the UK and end the special relationship, if only, if only, if only!!!!!!!!!!!

Alana Lentin's picture

I am delighted for gary McKinnon. However let it be clear that Theresa May waited barely two weeks after Talha Ahsan and Babar Ahmad were safely extradited to the US on 'terrorism' charges they deny before appealing to the Human Rights Act if all things to keep McKinnon in the UK. Ahsan also has Asperger's syndrome so are we saying that we only protect the mentally ill if they are white and not Muslim? Lets not forget Talha and Babar who, as we speak, are in solitary confinement with no contact with the outside world. They have been allowed to disappear into the black hole of the US prison system by their own government. Shame on the government and on Britain for this shameless hypocrisy!

philjxn's picture

A good decision by Theresa May, but not from compassion, but political expediency and an awareness of the growing unease at the "special relationship" with the U.S. that might just be a damn sight to special. UK airspace used for rendition, UK troops deployed for american adventures in both afghanistan and Iraq. So...Yes the McKinnon decision is good, but what of Talha Ahsan...?

Mckinnon asserted his guilt, Ahsan had not, both men had/have Aspergers, both men were never tried it the UK. Ahsan's lawyers have barely even seen the charges against him. This is racism ...the cases are almost mirroring ...and if they are not why not. Yes some may say, well Talha is accused of running a website that sought funds for the taliban..something that is yet to even be proven, but lets just say...ok if this true, then what is he guilty off other than bad timing and not reading the political terrain. The Taliban were a creation of the U.S. attempts to overthrow and destabilise a russian control in afghanistan, whitehall and the white house didnt simply run a website, they sent plane loads of arms, the u.s. made multi million dollar payments, ...the west armed the taliban...the level of utter hyprocrisy, racism and double standards with regard to the Talha Ahsan case is beyond words. Britannia waives the rules....for Muslims.

Hikaru22's picture

George,

I would say that the photographs of Gary McKinnon - at the top of your post and elsewhere on this site - show, to me, a man who is very nearly at the end of his tether. I doubt if any person of sensibility could fail to see that. And those who have been responsible for drawing out his fate, for the past ten years, really do have some serious soul-searching to do. We need to know the reasons why this particular buck was passed, from Home Secretary to Home Secretary, and from government to government, for so long. And Parliament needs to take the necessary steps to ensure that this situation is never repeated in the future.

Peter Grant's picture

Shame of New Labour and Alan Johnson for putting this poor man through this.

Peter Grant's picture

Totally disgusted by Alan Johnson and the other New Labour stooges who wanted to send this poor man to an American jail. Shame on Labour!
I am no fan of this government but totally appalled by Labour on this. Shows how in the pockets of shadowy transatlantic networks many of the New Labour crowd are.

Livers's picture

Double standards -- what about Ahsan and Ahmad. Wrong colour skin I assume.

Posh Tosh's picture

I am having a Theresa May moment - going to the bathroom, I may be a while.

First sign that I have seen that this corrupt government has a Minister without all the cultural mat-praying to the old Uncle Sam attachments that they have, as both Clegg and Cameron have in abundance. It states lesser in morals about the 'people's Party' Labour whom done zilch to end the intolerance to one of our own and yet swam rivers to protect the right's of terrorists in their homelands from being returned to face justice and kept in million pound +++ houses with £200,000 income a year, and they hated this corrupt Western nation whilst at the same time using all its laws to circumvent justice for their crimes.

Well done Home Secretary, I feel nearly British for once!

Marathonman's picture

I was just saying thats all. But the facts are the facts. He broke the law didn't he?

So take it easy with your puffed up, leftier than thou phoney outrage.

Normo84's picture

Dont know about Asperger syndrome I presume MARATHONMAN? I hope so anyway as to excuse your blanket ignorant statement. I suggest you educate yourself on the facts of a case in future so you don't look as stupid.

Normo84's picture

Dont know about Asperger syndrome I presume MARATHONMAN? I hope so anyway as to excuse your blanket ignorant statement. I suggest you educate yourself on the facts of a case in future so you don't look as stupid.

Normo84's picture

Dont know about Asperger syndrome I presume MARATHONMAN? I hope so anyway as to excuse your blanket ignorant statement. I suggest you educate yourself on the facts of a case in future so you don't look as stupid.

Normo84's picture

Dont know about Asperger syndrome I presume MARATHONMAN? I hope so anyway as to excuse your blanket ignorant statement. I suggest you educate yourself on the facts of a case in future so you don't look as stupid.

Marathonman's picture

Yes. But he did break the law though didn't he?

Hikaru22's picture

Both Parliament and the Prime Minister need to ask themselves this question:

Have they been elected to represent the interests of the British people, or those of the American government?

Sophie Elmhurst:

'McKinnon was surprised at how easy it was to enter the US networks. There were no firewalls and many government staff did not even have passwords. He left notes as he went, pointing out (their) security deficiencies.'

And that, one feels, was his real crime - pointing out, to the Americans, their own stupidity and incompetence.

Unfortunately, what the last ten years have demonstated is the cowardice and lack of principle of the politicians involved - from Blunkett (who never should have been entrusted with the Home Office in the first place), to John Reid, Jacqui Smith and (as Elmhurst's piece demonstrated) right through to "Nice" Nick Clegg and "Diddy" David Cameron. A pox on all their houses.

To my mind, after the emotional and psychological trauma of the past ten years, it is unthinkable that Gary McKinnon should now face further trial and punishment in this country. That would constitute very "cruel and unusual" treatment indeed.

Latest tweets