The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

The inflation hawks were wrong

As NS economics editor David Blanchflower predicted, inflation has plummeted in the last year.

The Bank of England building on Threadneedle Street in London.
The Bank of England building on Threadneedle Street in London. Photograph: Getty Images.

Last year, as inflation rose to more than 4 per cent (it eventually peaked at 5.2 per cent last September), a band of right-wing commentators and economists demanded that the Bank of England hike interest rates in an attempt to bring prices down. Andrew Sentance, then a member of the Bank's Monetary Policy Committee (MPC), bemoaned "the lack of a substantive policy response to persistent above-target inflation" and warned that "if we do not start to raise UK interest rates gradually soon, we risk having to do so more aggressively in the future". A fearful leader in the Spectator declared: "Inflation is back with a vengeance...Britain is once again in an inflationary cycle...For how much longer can high inflation be described as a blip?"

Others, however, including New Statesman economics editor David Blanchflower, argued that the spike was largely due to temporary factors such as the VAT increase, higher global commodity prices, and the depreciation of sterling, and predicted that inflation would fall back in 2012. In February 2011, in a piece entitled "Stop worrying about inflation", Blanchflower wrote:

Inflation is going to collapse in 2012 when the impact of the one-off increase in VAT, oil and commodity prices and the exchange-rate depreciation mechanically drop out of the inflation calculations. As Mervyn noted in his recent speech, these three items alone account for 3 per cent of the current 3.7 per cent CPI inflation rate.

Well, the results are in and it looks like Blanchflower was right again (as I've noted before, he was one of the few economists to warn that George Osborne's excessive austerity measures would trigger a double-dip recession). Inflation, as measured by the Consumer Price Index, was just 2.2% last month, the lowest level since November 2009 (see graph below) and only 0.2 per cent above the Bank's target rate.

Inflation is expected to rise over the next few months as this year's round of energy price increases take effect, but it is still likely to remain close to the 2 per cent target rate (which should, in any case, be raised). This should prompt the Bank to keep interest rates at their record low of 0.5 per cent and consider a third round of quantitative easing. As in the US, where Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke has pledged to keep rates near zero until at least mid-2015, sustained monetary stimulus is needed to support growth and employment, not least when the government's fiscal policy remains so determinedly self-defeating. While it appears that the economy returned to growth in the third quarter, the danger of a contraction in the fourth quarter (a triple-dip recession) remains. Had the Bank listened to the inflation hawks and hiked rates, the UK would have suffered an ever deeper double-dip.

It was already clear that the Hayekian right was disastrously wrong about fiscal policy; now it's clear that it was wrong about monetary policy too.

9 comments

mike555's picture

Inflation has been way above target for years, the damage of years of ultra low rates is already done, hurting the poor the most, plus we still have ridiculously high house prices, anyone remember what caused this mess? The housing market is being artificially propped up with all time low rates and reckless QE, I wish people would realise the impact the cost of housing has on peoples lives and the effect this continual cycle of heavy debt has on peoples finances and the overall economy.

The multi property owning landlords are doing very well out of all this, and with rents on the rise thanks to ever increasing demand, the future looks bleak for the poor and young.

The lesson to draw from all this is borrow and spend because the system will bail you out and penalise you if you're sensible with money, a dreadful message to send future generations. Let's see where it gets us.

BigC's picture

"these three items alone account for 3 per cent of the current 3.7 per cent CPI inflation rate"

So according to David then inflation should be about 0.7% now....err....wrong!

"he was one of the few economists to warn that George Osborne's excessive austerity measures would trigger a double-dip recession"

Yes he was, but he was "predicting" it for 2 years!...keep saying something long enough in economics and it'll probably come true! (how long a gap is it before a double dip isn't a double dip anyway?)

Lets look at another of his "predictions" as well shall we?...

Unemployment to top 5 million....currently 2.53 million (and falling)...hmmm...wrong! He even tweeted the day before the latest figures came out to say he thought they would increase! Lol!

So much for him being "right again"!

bill23's picture

One thing is sure, massive inflation will have to happen in order to pay off our criminal overlords, the banksters.

A Sentance's picture

In case you haven't noticed, inflation is still above the 2% target and is set to rise in the months ahead with higher energy and food prices. Inflation has not collapsed in the way D Blanchflower and others predicted - we are still waiting for that forecast to come true, about 5 years after it was first made!

Barrie J's picture

I couldn't care less what predictions economists make, neither do I care what inflation figures the government's lap dog the ONS record.
What does worry me however is the ever increasing cost of education, childcare, food, fuel, energy costs, travel etc., etc.
The fact that we are supposed to believe that 'inflation' is coming down, when the cost of everything is so obviously going up is a conundrum I cannot fathom.
Perhaps some of these people need to 'shop'.

Lucidus's picture

"The fact that we are supposed to believe that 'inflation' is coming down, when the cost of everything is so obviously going up is a conundrum I cannot fathom."

The RATE of inflation is going down but this just means prices are going up more slowly. Only when inflation is 0% will prices stop going up.

Danny Blanchflower's picture

The CPI measures the change in prices of a basket of goods based on people's consumption patterns. Just because the price of beer rises doesnt mean inflation has risen as people can buy wine. Remember the prices of many goods has fallen - computers and TVs are an example. Even if the price remains the same if quality rises then this is equivalent to a price drop. Finally, it is too hard to work out what has happened to inflation in your head.

Note also that the CPI measures price changes so if oil prices rise this year that gets reflected in this year's increase. But next year, even if oil prices remain at that level and are high but dont change then the effects of the price change a year ago drops out. This is one of the big reasons why the CPI dropped a lot this month - due to what are called base effects
DGB

nourredine's picture

Yes! where are you Indu incompetent?
You can eat your vomit, all by yourself and no one will disturb you.

FormerLibDem's picture

Where are the anti-Blancheflower trolls...very quiet today...hmm..

Latest tweets