The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Why Facebook's rape jokes are no laughing matter

Abuse based on gender is not simply offensive but a hate crime like anything else.

Abuse based on gender is not simply offensive but a hate crime like anything else.

Have you heard the one about the struggling woman and the rapist trying to pin her down? Rape is funny. It's quite the joke, and Facebook apparently doesn't mind if you spend your time swapping fantasised tales of abuse.

In between talk of Greys Anatomy and the annoying ones from X Factor, the global social networking site is home to pages dedicated to discussing rape in a positive light. "You know she's playing hard to get when your (sic) chasing her down an alleyway","Riding your Girlfriend softly, Cause you don't want to wake her up" and other delights have been on the site for for months, places where fans can discuss strategies of forcing women into sex in a so-called "comic" way. That this is, according to Facebook, acceptable, is the truly sick joke.

In response to calls to take the pages down, the site released a statement declaring that "groups that express an opinion on a state, institution, or set of beliefs -- even if that opinion is outrageous or offensive to some -- do not by themselves violate our policies." A quick read of the site's own terms and conditions confirms this is very much not the case. It is there in black and white with, "You will not post content that: is hateful, threatening, or pornographic; incites violence; or contains nudity or graphic or gratuitous violence". According to Facebook, talking about raping your friend's girlfriend to see "if she can put up a fight" is neither violent nor hateful, and advocating such a scenario is a "belief". Not for the first time, we are told rape is something to be trivialised -- the special crime that can be actively promoted with the confidence that few will bat an eye.

It's not a newsflash that the internet is home to some deranged, offensive language -- in many ways, it is the place where good taste comes to die. A distasteful liberation comes from the anonymity, as the author is comforted by the knowledge that they cannot be seen behind the screen. It's a sense of security that is often misleading, it being illegal to stir up hatred on the grounds of race, religion or sexual orientation. When it comes to hatred on the grounds of gender, however, there is no such legislation, with anyone free to whip up misogyny.

Be it Facebook policy or our own laws, abuse against women is treated differently; separated and viewed as lesser than that leveled at other marginalised groups. The rules that would rightly apply if the victim were black, Muslim or gay are deemed irrelevant if the victim is female. The hate spouted based on this factor is not a type that counts. Women, it seems, do not count.

We exist in a culture that views the abuse of women as something less than serious. Rape can be encouraged on global networking sites, just as t-shirts and hair products can be sold based on the concept of coming home to your boyfriend and being smacked round the face. Facebook says it with confidence -- if directed at women, violence is a joke. But abuse is abuse. That which is based on gender should be seen not simply as offensive, but a hate crime like anything else.

Frances Ryan is a freelance writer and political researcher at the University of Nottingham. She blogs at Different Principles and tweets @frances_ryan

43 comments

julesbell's picture

every woman over-- what? 25? has been sexually harassed and intimidated, even made afraid b/c of comments made by men. we have been condescended to and belittled, ridiculed and verbally beaten up...and excuses are made, rationale is given...none of it acceptable. we all know women who say a raped woman was 'asking for it' as she has (like this gerry woman?)been indoctrinated to believe everything is her own weak and flighty gender's fault; we are the silly ones,fluff pieces, fluff-ers, and if you want a man, stfu and deal with it baby. i am saddened to watch young women self-objectify, sad to see men disrespect women so much- we seem to have gone backward in respect of women, feminism often used as the excuse. being called a feminist is meant as a slur from some. not feminine (read: obedient), ugly(read:not feminine).
i think it stems from insecurity and failure w/ the opposite sex, on both sides. but we HAVE to make known the violent act rape is,it is emotional murder. not funny. never funny, no matter how many years have passed, let me tell ya: it never gets funny.

Endilar's picture

Yet another reason not to use Facebook. Never could understand what anyone sees in that soul-sucking monstrosity of a site.

Frances's picture

@acommentor

Somewhat tellingly, the Facebook pages in question make it very clear they are only referring to women (raping your girlfriend as she sleeps; seeing if your friend's girlfriend can put up a fight; chasing a woman; kicking a slut in her vagina) and as such, I only referred to women.

I wonder if male rape had been the target of these groups, Facebook might have seen it as "violence" that needed curbing - maybe you'd find your double standards there.

Gerry Tierney's picture

Scottish, actually.

Gerry Tierney's picture

But your xenophobia is going down a treat.

Flashbuck's picture

Typical fascist left claptrap - pro-abortion but despotic when it comes to a giggle about gang bangs.

Rape - man's right to choose. Fact!

funny girl's picture

I remember when I was raping Gerry's arse to see if he was playing hard to get. The noises he made were almost like words! When I was raping his mums face she couldn't say anything, which made a change. I find that hilarious! How dare he or anyone else tell me I'm being offensive, it's my freedom of speech! You promised you wouldn't censor me when I was pushing your face into the floor Gerry, but now you've 'changed your mind.' No means yes, remember, now back on your knees. Hahahaha, no offense intended.

funny girl's picture

So xenophobia isn't ok but rape jokes are OK. You're a danger to yourself. 1 in 20 men - like you - will admit to rape as long as it's not described as rape. Read this, dolt, about how hilarious rape is

http://fortyshadesofgrey.blogspot.com/2011/10/another-hilarious-t-shirt....

My rubbish joke story won't be a rubbish joke when your arse is raped, Gerry, or your (poor, shamed) mother is raped or if any unfortunate female member of your family is raped. I don't wish that on your family Gerry but if it happens, do remember how fucking funny it is.

Anonymous's picture

How dare anyone claim a firewall on what is funny and anything that has the word rape or women is on the blacklist.

For example I was a long standing victim of child abuse (nothing life threatening but felt like torture for eighteen years) and child abuse jokes are often HILARIOUS and a great way of dealing with our societal problems we've had (btw I'm one of the Irish eigits). BTW I just turned twenty two so its hardly something miles in the past.

Yes I found it hard to deal with if I saw Tommy Tiernans jokes on TV. Some I found funny and some grated. But the difference is I kne, even as a very young child that those gratings were him teaching me that I had something to deal with and tried not to fight it as much.And that has worked for me.

Don't give me your indignant bullshit (not the author, I disagreed a lot but she did not viciously attack the only coherent thinker on this comment thread) and tell me to crawl back in my hole but please god try to tell me where I'm wrong on this issue.

Yours respectfully and FULLY THOUGHT OUT

survivor grrl's picture

Thankfully, I`ve never felt the need to have a Facebook page.
I believe we all should have a right to freedom of speech and expression. However, with every right comes responsibilities.
Spammers spout vile torrents of abuse day in day out, which is their "right", however, as faceless pseudonyms they fail to be accountable for their words.

Gerry Tierney's picture

I've said half a dozen times now that I don't find it funny.

As for "men - like you - " nice weasel words!

There are cogent arguments to be made, mcquade touched on one and Daniele made good, sensible points.

The rest of you are arguing from emotion and with about eighty billion logical fallacies per word.

funny girl's picture

Where's your sense of humour, fun boy?

Gerry Tierney's picture

I don't particularly find logical fallacies amusing. Anyone who does probably needs mental help.

Gerry Tierney's picture

And, for perhaps the septillionth time, I don't find the pages amusing in the slightest. It's the censorship I disagree with.

Gerry Tierney's picture

In fact, and I do apologise for spamming this comment function now, it's only you, between the two of us, who has joked about rape. Only you have had merry japes and stories to hand about it.

Perhaps time to rethink your debating strategy, funny girl, when you're doing precisely what you despise.

I mean you absolutely no ill will; I think we have a major difference of opinion when it comes to freedom of speech, but I won't make up little rape fantasies about you, like you have done about me and those around me.

Have a nice night.

Jade Keeton's picture

These groups violate Facebooks Community Standards and need to be removed. I find nothing funny about rape confessions, rape fantasies, and rape "jokes" and, according to the petition on change.org over 175,000 people agree. The administrator of the Alleyway group stands behind his right to "free speech" yet he threatens and silences those who disagree with his pro-rape stance. Facebook is not a pub and it is not the sidewalk. There are rules which every person agrees to when he or she signs up for an account. If you cannot follow the rules and insist on posting content containing "depictions of sexual assault" which are supposedly banned, then you need to keep off FB. If FB continues to support, promote, and condone rape they are going to lose not only advertisers, but also a significant number of female users. The Alleyway page reads like a rapist's handbook with advice on the best way to rape and get away with it. If the same content were directed at a minority group rather than women there would be community outcry and it would be removed immediately. Women deserve the same protection from hate and violence.

funny girl's picture

Rape fantasies: That's. The. Point.

It's fine for all those women you don't know but not so fine when it's happened to someone you know and love.

Do you also back a lack of censorship around paedophile jokes on tshirts and FB pages? What's the difference?

Whether you know it or not, you do wish me ill will, because you think rape jokes are fine. Again, whether you believe it or not, normalising rape (guess what?) makes it normal.

Sweet dreams

Rob's picture

Maybe Facebook should ban all morons from their site. Should leave one or two people on there at most.

Hayley Amanda Miles's picture

Rape Is No Joke
http://www.facebook.com/rape.is.no.joke

We strongly believe that facebook should include an option to report pages and comments condoning sexual violence and remove such groups for being in breach of the user Terms and Conditions (Section 3: Safety, point 7), which specify that no hateful or threatening comments should be made.

Allowing such groups to congregate serves only to further normalise rape culture and the high instance of sexual violence that exists in society.

The following are some direct quotes - "should rape all the feminists that post pictures", "What's black and blue and hides in the corner? A rape victim", "I'm pro rape. As in, really good at it", "If your tie her up and gag her, she can't run or say no", " I joined this page to support rape", "Only I can rape my mum", "i love raping bitches out in the cool night air, dont complain sluts or your next" ...

Social media has been such a great cause for good in many parts of the world but this abuse has gone too far.

Community Goals and Aspirations
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
1) Our short term goal is to have Facebook change its policies to end allowing pro-rape groups and end allowing pro-violence toward woman and children groups.

2) In the long term we all want to see an end to the prolific rape of women by the human species. Sexual assault of any type is not tolerable and should be left to the past.

3) The past is something we cannot change but we can make certain the truth of it is told and not forgotten.

4) We can also be kind, tolerant, understanding, comforting and a resource for victims of sexual assault.

Some of the big companies that pay Facebook to advertise on the social networking site have asked for their adverts to be removed from one of the pro-rape groups. Sony, American Express and BlackBerry have had their demands answered and in the last few days all advertising has been removed on the group.

There are more groups to go. Congratulations to Sony, American Express and Blackberry. I like those products a lot now.

Sony, American Express and Blackberry have a social conscience. Thank you.

Julia's picture

@ Gerry - so did you actually register your opinion on these pages directly? it might be useful for them to receive your opinion direct? and see what it feels like for you to be on the receiving end of their response.

Katie Alsop's picture

I boycott products advertised on pro-rape content pages of Facebook.

We ask your help.

Effective immediately we are going to begin a boycott and widely promote this boycott of any product advertised on a pro-rape Facebook content page.

When you identify an advertiser on any such page, post the full name of the advertiser and the product here at http://www.facebook.com/rape.is.no.joke Also, if you can post a wall image of a screen capture of the advert and page, that would be awesome.

On the List to Boycott:
IKEA
Samsung

zurich's picture

People have a right to make offensive jokes. Be it against women, Muslims, gays etc. As long as it doesn't actually incite violence, which this Facebook group clearly isn't doing. Whether or not the jokes are funny, or deserve to be scorned and the joke teller themselves ridiculed is up to individuals. I don't want to live in a society where consensus on taste is dictated by the state and regulated by force.

Oh btw I'm an ethnic minority and have a Muslim mum and yes i would defend the right for pple to make racist jokes under principles of free speech. Plus some racist jokes can be funny!

Gerry Tierney's picture

Oh grow a f*cking sense of humour already.

Who are you to draw lines in the sand when it comes to what people think is acceptable joke material or not?

Comedy is entirely subjective, and it's not your business to tell people what not to laugh at.

Also, you're reading far too much into it, in a typical scowling feminazi way. Most of the members of these groups are female, by the way.

A Thinking Human Being's picture

Dear Gerry - fuck off.

Yours,

all men and women who give a shit about each other.

Gerry Tierney's picture

"You promised you wouldn't censor me when I was pushing your face into the floor Gerry, but now you've 'changed your mind.'"

No I haven't.

Your little joke story is rubbish, but it's still fine to spout it.

Ian5's picture

Don't know which is worse, those that post these "jokes", the site that permits them or the belief system that thinks rape is the victims fault? Hena Begum

JJJJS's picture

Gerry?

Shut. THE FUCK. Up.

JP3's picture

Incredibly bad taste certainly, but they have been created as are are intended to be viewed as jokes.

I can understand Facebook's rational.

sianushka's picture

well said. i agree with every word of this article.

Gerry, if you can't see the difference between inciting violence and hate, and a joke, then i worry for you.

Gerry Berry's picture

Why did the orange stop?
It ran out of juice .....

D's picture

One thing I don't get is why some people are so enraged about rape jokes yet have no opinion on murder jokes. I personally find any funny joke funny, regardless of its content.

Gerry Tierney's picture

This comments section reads like the Daily Mail, which is rather horrifying.

I never said the jokes were funny, I didn't say they were in good taste.

What I did say is that it's wrong to tell people what they can and can't say, under the old "incitement to hate" card.

How are these comedic groups incitement to hatred, exactly?

Freedom of speech is alive and well, despite extremists on either wing wanting it crushed.

Swagga's picture

@ Gerry crawl back under your fucking rock where you you belong. There is no humour in rape & the brutalisation of woman end of story!!!!!!!

Swagga's picture

@ Gerry Freedom of speech is your best argument to validate rape jokes..thats fucked may be you should visit a woman's crisis center or an institution that deals with rape victims. I am all for freedom of speech but I wonder where do you draw the line Gerry? racist jokes about minority groups anti semetic jokes ,anti islam, homophobic jokes?. Freedom of speech is what exactly..to say anything that can hurt someone..?

JP3's picture

Swagga, there is humour to be found in literally anything, it's actually a very potent way of dealing with terrible occurrences.

Also; "I am all for freedom of speech but I wonder where do you draw the line Gerry?" No, you're obviously not.

acommentator's picture

No mention whatsoever of male rape, only rape of females.

No double standards there, huh?

And before any idiot bothers whining, ALL rape is abhorent. Only rape of females, however, seems to be of concern to some...

Daniele1's picture

"freedom of speech" is not what it is cracked up to be.
There is no where on earth where total freedom of speech would be tolerated.Such freedom is unworkable in a functioning society.
See, there is FREEDOM TO.. and FREEDOM FROM... and this is where the ideological clash occurs.
Personally I think freedom from..is more important than freedom to..
For example in the case being discussed I think women's right to be free from abuse and threat is much much more important than one individual man's freedom to say horrendously offensive and dangerous stuff.
In other words the rights of the group are more important than the rights of individuals.
The Anglo-Saxons' idea of freedom is individual freedom. Other cultures favour the protection of the rights of minority groups at the expense of individual freedom.
That is why the French liberals and French feminists are in favour of the banning of the burka, which is clearly suppressing the rights of some individual Muslim women,in order to protect the image of women in general as free citizens which they feel is more important.
Facebook should definitely ban this stuff.

Gerry Tierney's picture

Where do you stand on freedom from censorship?

You can call me anything you please, but Anglo-Saxon would be an untruth, seeing as I'm a Celt.

I'm also a Marxist, and an atheist, and an equalist.

As I said, I don't find the pages particularly amusing, but nor are they in any way "dangerous" any more than games with fighting in are "dangerous".

No-one who thinks rape is appalling is going to be convinced otherwise by the setting up of a subjectively humorous page on a social networking site. Nor will anyone disinclined to rape (the vast majority) have their minds changed either.

There is no danger, no incitement to hate and no real issue besides that of the emotive.

paul(a)?'s picture

It's a small step from saying you dislike something to saying something should be done about.

And therein is the death of liberty.

-paraphrase of i forget who said it.

mcquade's picture

"Most of the members of these groups are female, by the way."

And you've got some specual talent for reading through pseudonyms, have you Gerry.

Crawl away into your sordid little corner of a life and wither away. You're a disgrace to human kind.

Clare's picture

Gerry, I'm interested if you would accept that Facebook should also allow 'humourous' sites making light of racially motivated or homophobic attacks on the grounds of freedom of speech? As an 'equalist' I'm sure you would be as quick to defend the free expression of racists and homophobes as much as you do misogynists? And if so, then why do you suppose Facebook holds such double standards? Rather than taking cheap swipes at 'feminazis'(you have more in common with the Daily Mail than Marx as far as I can tell) you'd do well to remember that people can find it hard to laugh at things they genuinely fear or have experienced - sorry it that's too 'emotive' for you.

Al4's picture

@Gerry T

"I'm also a Marxist"

So you really are on another planet then. Then again, Beria was a Marxist and he enjoyed picking up young women in Moscow and taking them back to his flat to rape, torture and murder them (btw Beria was NKVD head under Stalin).

mcquade's picture

Gerry, you clearly have a limited understanding of the full responsibilities that comes with the freedoms we enjoy. As the great libertarian and defender of free speech, J S Mill put it, one man's freedom to swing his fists stops before the end of another man's nose. But heck, why should I expect an Irish eejit to know that?

Latest tweets