Why have we ignored the plight of Palestine’s Bobby Sands?
We honour the memory of many men who took up armed struggle and died on hunger strike for their beli
By Mehdi Hasan Published 23 February 2012
"His calls for freedom deserve to be heard. His valiant efforts should not go in vain. The president calls on all supporters of human rights and freedom, and the United Nations, to take up [his] case." Those were the laudable words of the White House press secretary, commenting on the hunger strike of the Iranian dissident and detainee Akbar Ganji in 2005.
Seven years later, the White House has issued no such statement on Khader Adnan, the detained Palestinian father-of-two who decided to end his remarkable 66-day hunger strike on 21 February as doctors warned he was "in immediate danger of death". Perhaps, just perhaps, the US is silent because his jailers are Israelis, not Iranians. Adnan is being held under Israel's "administrative detention" laws - inherited from the British Mandate era - which allow the military to detain prisoners indefinitely, without charging them or making them stand trial.
The 34-year-old baker from Jenin, who is accused by Israel of being a member of the militant group Islamic Jihad and of undefined "activities that threaten regional security", began his hunger strike on 18 December 2011 - the day after he was detained. He protests against what he says was a violent arrest as well as humiliating and abusive interrogation sessions.
His was the longest hunger strike yet by a Palestinian prisoner - and on 21 February it forced the Israeli authorities to agree not to renew his four-month administrative detention when it expires on 17 April. Yet this "deal" might be coming too late for him: on 17 February, the Israeli branch of Physicians for Human Rights said he had already suffered from "significant muscular atrophy" and was near death. His pregnant wife, Randa, who visited him in hospital, told Reuters that he had lost 35 kilos in weight and had started to vomit blood. It isn't easy to survive after starving for nine weeks.
Without trial
So why did he take such extreme action? "I have been humiliated, beaten and harassed by interrogators for no reason, and thus I swore to God I would fight the policy of administrative detention to which I and hundreds of my fellow prisoners fell prey," Adnan wrote in a letter from his hospital bed. There are 309 Palestinians being held under administrative detention by Israel - up from 219 in 2011 - including 24 Palestinian parliamentarians and one man who has been detained without trial for more than two years.
Will Adnan's bold, if near-suicidal strategy help draw attention to their fate, within Israel and beyond? "It's more important to talk about the issue of administrative detention than his hunger strike," a frustrated Anat Litvin, head of the detainees department at Physicians for Human Rights-Israel, told me.
As is so often the case, international law is not on the side of the Israelis. Article 9 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) - to which the State of Israel is a signatory - makes clear that no person should be "subjected to arbitrary arrest or detention". The ICCPR allows for governments, in narrow and extreme circumstances, to derogate from this obligation temporarily, yet, as Litvin notes, "Israel uses it on a regular basis".
In fact, the UN's Working Group on Arbitrary Detention has condemned Israel's use of long-term administrative detention - in particular, those cases, like Adnan's, in which detainees are held without trial merely for belonging to an "illegal organisation".
Here in the west, however, we have abandoned any moral high ground we may have occupied. The last Labour government interned terror suspects without trial in Belmarsh between 2001 and 2004; the current coalition government's Terrorism Prevention and Investigation Measures allow for indefinite house arrest without charge. In the US, President Obama has signed into law the National Defence Authorisation Act, which permits the indefinite detention in military custody of terror suspects. Habeas corpus has been consigned to the history books.
Shameful silence
Meanwhile, the British media, including the BBC, have been shamefully silent on Adnan's plight. As of 21 February, his detention and hunger strike had been ignored by every single UK newspaper, bar the Guardian and the Independent, which ran a handful of pieces. The latter's Donald Macintyre devoted a full-page, 1,100-word report to Adnan's story, headlined "The West Bank's Bobby Sands" - a reference to the 27-year-old IRA prisoner who died in 1981 after 66 days on hunger strike.
It is an apt analogy. "To us, Khader Adnan just brings back memories of what we went through," Danny Morrison, spokesman for the Bobby Sands Trust, tells me. "The parallels are there for all to see." To Morrison, who was also interned in Northern Ireland, Adnan, like Sands, is driven by "the call of justice". He adds: "This man wants to live but what else can he do? He doesn't have any weapons to fight with so he fights with his own body."
“Where, one wonders, is the Palestinian Gandhi?" I asked on these pages in 2009. Perhaps he has arrived, in the unlikely guise of an Islamic Jihad activist. Some senior Israeli figures fear that Adnan's defiant - and effective - actions will inspire other Palestinians, frustrated by the political failures of Fatah and the military failures of Hamas, to engage in non-violent, Gandhi-style protests, both inside and outside Israel's prisons. As with all occupiers and oppressors throughout history, the Israelis are fighting a losing battle. Terence MacSwiney was an Irish republican activist and lord mayor of Cork who was imprisoned by the British in August 1920 and died the following October after 74 days on hunger strike. As MacSwiney once remarked: "It is not those who can inflict the most, but those who can suffer the most, who will conquer in the end."
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists


97 comments
jankaas - Your opinion is duely noted but you should note that I don't do requests and I think I explained why I did this. You will also note that it was a Zionist that brought up the holiest of holies on this site not me so I have no intention of apologising to such dross.
The Jewish Holocaust was a terrible crime but that does not prevent Zionists using it for their own ends. You have perhaps read "The Holocaust Industry" by Norman Finkelstein which illustrates this well.
Personally, I don't find the loss of Islamic life at all offensive.
WHAT ABOUT ROCHDALE, EH? ABOUT BLOODY TIME THE ENGLISH WORKING CLASS ROSE UP.
"Jackass you are such a dunce. "
and you are an aggressive ignoramus Miniwilly. pleasantries out of the way, now what?
"Are you saying that Jews stone women to death?"
just educating you about your own jewish faith. that excerpt from the Torah shows it was deemed an acceptable punishment. it used to happen. the fact that right now it doesn't happen misses the point entirely. your religous text allows for it, hence it is entirely possible for Jews to take it up again, and defend it by claiming it is God's will.
same as Muslims apparently, no? as ever I just point out the commonalities in an effort to bring you guys together and remind you that it's the same God you worship.
no need to thank me either...
Oh dear Arminius - 'the failings of Moslem theocracies,' is that an appropriate term to describe mass murder, mass rape, mass executions, the violent persecution of women, the killing of Gays, the mass ethnic clean sings of Christians, Jews, Hindus and Sikhs?
How would you describe the Nazi genocide? Perhaps 'unsatisfactory conduct'?
I'd happily piss on bobby sands grave and piss on this shit. Hopefully he'll starve to death.
I notice the Islamist in the cheap suit seems reticent to mention or attack the murder of gays by Islamic fanatics. What a surprise!
Maximillian - Sorry as hell if my condemnation of Muslim theocracies isn't up to your requirements but you are just some Zionist pea brain on the internet so I really don't give a monkey's what you or your ilk think. You seem to have a few anger issues so perhaps you have had tragedy in your life like the Moil's knife slipping as he docked your Schwanz. Too bad.
Human rights may be thin on the ground in Muslim countries but in Israel they are extended mainly to those of one race. Israel's "Heim ins Reich" policy has brought Jews from all over the World to colonise the Lebensraum won by force of arms and many of them are from countries where democracy and human rights are foreign concepts. Hence the current extremist government ruling the Greater Israeli Reich and the poor treatment of the Palestinian Untermenschen.
No chance of me buzzing of anywhere so Zionis scum will not be permitted to post their poison here unopposed. Get used to it Zhid.
This article by Mehdi Hasan is pure rubbish.
The IRA terrorist Bobby Sands died after a hunger strike.
The Israelis have ordered the release of the Islamic Jihad terrorist Khader Adnan.
So where is there a comparison?
The only story here is why the Israelis have this daft practice of continually releasing violent and dangerous Moslem terrorists.
Elizabeth - "How would you describe the Nazi genocide?" - Incomplete.....
Julie Harris's list should also contain those of Palestinians slaughtered by the might of the Israeli death machine. Palestinians are "unpeople" whose plight does not bother the Julie Harris's of this world. Israel pretends to be a democracy but only the truley credulous believe Jews and non-Jews in Israel are treated equally. "Suicide attacks on civilians" that's bad but blasting them to smithereens with bombs and using gas that sucks the air from their lungs, that's honourable. Please note Julie that under international law, the oppressed have the right to resist, even if this resistance is not pretty. Do some historical detective work and then maybe you'll find out that Israel is a settler state that is still in formation. Muslims killing muslims doesn't warrant moral outrage? It does if the wrong side is doing the killing and that's the same for all uses of 'outrage'.