The children of Gaza

Five years to the day after her son was killed by an IDF sniper, Jocelyn Hurndall writes on the deat

Today, faced with the killing of more than 300 Gazan children in barely a fortnight, I can’t help but replay the image of my son, Tom, reaching out to three Palestinian toddlers sheltering from Israeli sniper fire behind a mound of rubble in Rafah.

In his Middle East journal Tom wrote, “Strange, isn’t it, that no matter what the hardship suffered by children in London, it will never compare with what is experienced in Baghdad, Cairo or Amman. The world is clearly an unfair place and the loudest call is for self-preservation. Without the sight of the suffering that exists elsewhere being forced on us, we don’t even contemplate it.”

Over the last two weeks, seldom has it been more tragically apparent that innocent children are completely unprotected when bombs start to fall. With mounds of rubble being turned into mountains, ambulances are unable to collect injured children or those buried beneath their own homes.

Other children, ordered by Israeli forces to take refuge in a school with their families, are then shelled, left to cling to the bodies of their dead mothers for days. Meanwhile, the Israelis repeat their mantra that they are taking the greatest possible pains to avoid civilian casualties. Is it difficult for Israeli pilots and artillerymen to avoid coordinates unconnected to Hamas? It is not. And yet they bomb them. We are forced to draw our own conclusions as to whether the Israeli forces are systematically inept…or callous beyond comprehension. Or both.

We each agonise over what can be done to stop this great loss of innocent life - and for those who manage to survive, the loss of their childhood innocence. It is unfathomably frustrating that we can’t seem to do more to safeguard the children of Gaza.

In the weeks following Tom’s shooting we had to make sense of what had happened emotionally, politically, diplomatically, legally, and medically. It became quickly apparent that we were going to get no help from the Israelis. We had to quickly develop an insight into the intention behind what people said, or were pointedly not saying to us. The Israelis wouldn’t meet, discuss evidence, or even gather any. Instead, they produced a report that was a fabrication and a cover up.

Right up until the moment they charged an Israeli Defence Force (IDF) smiper with shooting an unarmed civilian - my son, they insisted that they were really shooting at a gunman. The Israelis asked the British coroner for all the information we had gathered from the British pathologist and the British police before Tom’s inquest was held. In return, they refused to disclose a single shred of their own evidence.

What this experience showed us is that where their own actions are concerned the Israelis are not greatly interested in truth or justice, or even apology. For them, anyone injured or killed by their forces is de facto a militant, or a terrorist, or an associate of terrorists. Very occasionally they allow that an innocent has been caught in crossfire between their soldiers and terrorists, though often with an imputation that said victim should not have been so close to terrorists to have been caught up in the battle. In the current offensive, innocents have died in such horrific numbers that they have even stopped saying this.

I remember the journey to Be’ersheva from Ben Gurion airport back in 2003. The well-informed British Military Attache turned to me and said, “I have to warn you, don’t expect too much of the Israelis”. It made me recall the time I was Tom’s age, when I was working on a kibbutz, and a kibbutznik told me that Israel had ‘the most moral army in the world’. I’d thought at the time, why should an army of a democratic country claim morality as its badge of honour? It rang hollow even then. As everyone except the most cynical spin doctor knows, “morality” and “army” should never knowingly be uttered in the same sentence. War has rules but no morals. It would be a start if Israel even acknowledged the rules.

Yesterday, I spoke to my good friend, Erella, an Israeli who lives on a kibbutz outside Be’ersheva. I asked her about the reaction of the Israeli public to the killings in Gaza. She replied, “best not to talk about the Israeli public. More and more people are against the war, but the media is creating reality and people don’t know what’s really going on. Even though the Gazans don’t have electricity, some of the homes have their own generators and so they manage to send emails, but not many.” She can hear every bomb that falls on the Gaza Strip. While the people paying the price are innocent children she isn’t interested in who is right and who is wrong. She speaks with her friends in Gaza each day, who say, “We are sitting in our house, waiting our turn”.

With all the clarity of a young voice, Nour Kharma, from Gaza writes: “Today is the eighth day of this horrible war. To me yesterday was the worst day of all. When I woke up in the morning one of my friends called, his voice was very weird. He told me Christine died. I was in a big shock, and till now I don’t believe it. I threw the phone and started crying. Her parents did the best they can do, but it wasn’t enough so the result was dying. What if my parents couldn’t protect me and give me the support I need...will I die too? What I can say now is that my future is almost destroyed. An Israeli rocket hit my school this morning, and the school was destroyed completely. I really can’t imagine how come they’re bombing mosques, schools, and universities. In every explosion we feel our house shaking and about to be destroyed; what about the people that already lost their homes? I’m crying for the loss of one of my friends... what about the people that lost at least five of their relatives? Depression and fear are filling our souls and surrounding our homes…what’s next? I actually don’t wish for anything as much as I wish that this war will end soon and that the Palestinian people can live like any other people and Palestinian children can enjoy their childhood like any children in the world. Help us because we’re all human beings”.

I am often asked, what is it like to lose a child? It’s like this. Between the instant of receiving the news and the next instant in which you have to comprehend it, you somehow realise that every cell in your body is about to be shaken furiously, and you freeze to delay the moment of impact. Your entire existence becomes concertinaed into the space between the blow and the pain, and nothing will ever, or can ever be the same again. With vast international pressure why can’t there be agreement between all sides that Gazan children and mothers should be safely housed? That no more Gazan children shall go without their mothers, and no more Gazan mothers told that they have lost their children.

In the first instance, let us work as hard as we are able towards bringing an end to the mounting deaths of the innocent on both sides. And then hold those responsible to account…

Jocelyn Hurndall Development Director Friends of Birzeit University

51 comments

Amihai's picture

"What if Israel defended its citizens the way the British, the French, the Americans and the Russians did? When German rockets hit British cities during the World War II, Prime Minister Winston Churchill retaliated by bombing German cities, killing thousands of German civilians, and promised to continue until Germany's unconditional surrender.

"The United States did the same following the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. The French did much worse in Algeria and the Russians showed no concern for civilian life in Chechnya or Georgia.

"The IDF, on the other hand, has gone to extraordinary lengths to minimize civilian casualties, despite the reality that Hamas deliberately fires its rockets from densely populated civilian areas and hides its rocket launchers in schools, hospitals and mosques".

So writes Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz:

http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1170359815127&pagename=JPost%...

Petite Anglaise's picture

There is discussion today in The Guardian about how international justice could be brought to bear on the crimes of the democratic State of Israel,

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/jan/14/israel-gaza-un-court-palestine

"Questions are also being raised as to whether the international criminal court, which deals with war crimes and crimes against humanity, would have any jurisdiction to hear cases against perpetrators of the alleged crimes on both sides of the conflict. Neither Israel nor the Palestinian territories are signatories to the Rome statute, which brings states within the jurisdiction of the ICC. More likely, experts say, is the establishment of ad-hoc tribunals of the kind created to deal with the war in the former Yugoslavia and the genocide in Rwanda. "If there were the political will there could be an ad-hoc tribunal established to hear allegations of war crimes," Falk said. "This could be done by the general assembly acting under article 22 of the UN charter which gives them the authority to establish subsidiary bodies.""

Power to the elbow of the UNGA - bring it on!

writeon's picture

Amihai,

Obviously if Israel committed warcrimes on the scale of the countries Alan Dershowitz mentions, terror bombing of virtually defenceless cities and their civilian populations, this would be a monumental crime of historic proportions. But even though Israel isn't committing warcrimes on the same scale as the allies during world war two, it's still arguably, and I believe clearly involved in warcrimes in Gaza and because Israel is a democracy, of a kind, either Israeli or international courts should prosicute Israeli politicians and military leaders.

Israeli leaders have over the last few weeks not only given orders for warcrimes, they have also spoken openly about giving orders for military attacks using language which are admissions of warcrimes, and not just once but over and over again. But of course Israel is a special case and is outside the normal laws applied to other democracies.

How is it possible to call oneself a democracy and have leaders that are proud, almost boastful, war-criminals?

And yes, I'd also put the individuals guilty of firing rockets into Israel on trial for warcrimes too. Perhaps we could have one big trial for all of them?

margeryzdf's picture

Wow, what a lot of hate-filled messages from Zionist media puppets. Not unexpected, sadly.

Thank you for sharing your experiences, Jocelyn. Your article is deeply moving and inspiring. Peace be with you.

ali8ea's picture

Amiha.
So we can feel thankfull and so can the Palestinian prisoners that only up to 500 women and children have been killed because the israeli butchering machine has spared the rest!! You are assuming that the other 500 that have been killed which are male were all Hamas fighters. So from this we can say that any male in the Gaza prison is fair game to be butchered and if he happens to be sheltering with his family when a bomb hits then "well the Hamas animals hide behind women and children". You and your fellow deniars of war crimes have de-humanised the Palestinian people by your sick lies and distortions of the truth that you hope the world will not care how many innocent Palestinian lives are lost. Your government has refused press access so the truth will not come out. Exactly as the US military did in Falluja in Iraq. Today the spokesman for the UN who visited the hospitals has spoken of children with bullet holes to their heads and bodies. Already got your script of denial and accusation of "it was the Hamas animals" ready for this one have you? The only animals who live in the middle east are the israeli animals who carry on with the constant killing of Palestinian children. How many Palestinian children and the older generation walk round with only one eye when they have been shot in the face by israeli animals with rubber bullets? How many Palestinian children are orphans because of the sanctioned assassination of "militants" that also killed hundreds of innocent Palestinians who happened to be trying to carry on with some type of existance in the Palestinian prisons. This is the type reason that resistance exists. If the Palestinian people are denied a homeland on the borders as decreed by the UN then they should be given the rights as the rest of Israel and allowed to vote in the upcomming elections.

ali8ea's picture

Zen.
Do you live on the same planet as the rest of the world. In the space of 8 weeks of fighting in Lebanon and the Gaza prison camp, the murderous israeli army haave so far killed over 2000 civilians. Is this all made up? If the israeli military were to be believed then no innocent civilians have died. You must be sub human to even think this. On the ground are UN and independant observers who clarify what is going on but because denial is your chosen subject they are wrong. It is people like you who should be held to account. It is your kind that keeps this open wound festering. Every time there is a chance of peace, you and your kind come along and start scratching the wound again.
Since Oslo, as you wish to quote, you say 377 Israeli civilians have been killed by Palestinians. Why have you omitted to mention the 5000 Palestinians who have been killed by israelis since the year 2000 alone? God knows how many have been killed in the previous 7yrs when Israel would not budge an inch to ensure the Oslo accord would work.

Amihai's picture

Note, this conflict in Gaza can stop now. All that Hamas need to do is what the entire international community, i.e. UN, EU, US, Russia, Arab states, PA presidency, has expected of it since January 2006:

1) Cease all acts of terror and violence, as called for by previously singed agreements with Israel

2) Adhere to previously signed agreements with Israel, including the non-delivery of illicit weapons and explosives into Gaza

3) Recognize Israel's right to exist, instead of calling for it, both by creed and deed, to be erased off the face of the earth and with it its people and all traces of Jewish civilization in this national homeland of the Jewish people.

And, I would add, the release of Gilad Shalit.

But Hamas has chosen a different route than peace and economic development. It has set out to bring about that for which its Charter call.

What would your country do - I am not British, obviously - if for eight years its citizens were being attacked daily by rockets and mortar shells? What would your country do even after eight months of such attacks, after eight days of such agression??!!

margeryzdf's picture

"Resistance" is an argument that terrorists may use to convice the desperate to embrace the politics of despair. Just the same way the Israelis may use the argument of "defence" to convince people to embrace the politics of brute force. Neither is really justified, if we're honest.

And, whilst we'd like to describe those who kill and terrorise and torture as animals, they are inescapably human beings. We have to live with that fact and somehow work through it. The soldier, the terrorist, the doctor, the child: they are all human. The three religions that have caused so much pain and suffering in the middle east all know this in their hearts. I just pray they start listening to their hearts, and soon.

Zen's picture

Brewster 19:29

Human beings? I thought you said many commentators here are (to quote you): "hate filled Zionist media puppets". Clearly from this statement only people who agree with you are human.

Make up your mind please you are confusing me.

writeon's picture

Brewster,

Human beings are capable of extraordinary acts of violence, unspeakable crimes, terror.

My grandmother used to pull a cart around from farm to farm, pulled by her three daughters. They knew where Jewish families were hiding. Fascists shot all four of them in the back of the head and dumped them in a ditch.

On the other hand we have Tom Hurndall. Humans are also capable of great acts of kindness, mercy, self-sacrifice and love. One can also be murdered for love, like Tom. What was truly shameful was the lack of real vigour from the British Government in forcing the Israelis to punish the people responsible for Tom's murder, they dragged their feet, and Jack Straw, huffed and puffed, but did nothing. He could have called the British ambassdor home, he could have withdrawn credit facilities, he could have stood up and demanded action. He acted like servant confronting his master, afraid of his own shadow, truly pathetic.

If Hamas are called terrorists, what does one call the Israeli attacks on Gaza? We have to acknowledge the different scale of the two sides terrorism. One is a dwarf, the other a giant. Mega-terrorism State terrorism? Can a state really be defined as democratic and at the same time terrorise and kill hundreds and hundreds of people who are more or less defenceless? And if one examines Israeli ministers statements carefully, they actually admit what they are doing, targetting civilians. I am not making this up. I swear it's true.

Think of Tom as just another innocent victim of a awsomely powerful war-machine that kills whenever and whoever it wants to and nobody can stop it, in fact we support this killing machine, this killing state. A state that can kill Tom and kill hundreds of Palestinians with the same blunt disregard and impunity. And just like with Tom our craven politicians daren't say a real word of criticism. History allowed to repeat itself over and over again, only the river of blood just flows faster and faster towards hell

Latest tweets