Return to: Home | Arts & Culture | Media

South Africa's new struggle

John Pilger

Published 10 April 2008

The ANC government has allowed the world's most voracious companies to escape reparations for poisoning the land and its people

When I returned to South Africa following the fall of apartheid, I asked Ahmed Kathrada to take me to Robben Island. Known affectionately as Kathy, he wore dark glasses to cover eyes damaged by the glare of the limestone where he and Nelson Mandela had wielded a pick for decades. He showed me his cell, five feet by five feet, where "the light was burning bright, day and night". I wondered how he had emerged from a quarter-century of incarceration as a sane, rounded, tolerant and gracious human being. His reasons included the teachings of Gandhi and the support of his loved ones, but, above all, "there was the struggle, without which nothing changes".

This sense of struggle is back in South Africa. The other day, I met the writer Breyten Brey tenbach, who spent eight years in prison under the apartheid regime. Speaking at the Time of the Writer festival in Durban, he evoked the "dreams" of the great liberation fighters Steve Biko and Robert Sobukwe. "How are we going to stop this seemingly irrevocable 'progress' of South Africa to a totalitarian one-party state?" he asked.

It is a question many ask in a country that now typifies an economic apartheid imposed across the world under a cover of "economic growth" and liberal, corporate jargon. For "democracy", read socialism for the rich and capitalism for the poor. For "governance" and "modernity", read a system of division and plunder designed and approved in Washington, Brussels and Davos - a system in which, says the South African finance minister, Trevor Manuel, "winners flourish". And he speaks from a country where inequality and poverty are described as "desperate", where the ANC government has allowed the world's most voracious companies to escape reparations for poisoning the land and its people, and which has been suckered by British arms companies into buying 24 Hawk fighter jets at £17m each, "by far the most expensive option", according to a House of Commons report.

Britain's Department for International Development has played a notorious role. Although required by law not to spend money other than on poverty reduction, DfID is, in reality, a privatising agency that greases the way for multi nationals to take over public services. In 2004, the department paid the Adam Smith Institute, an extreme right-wing think tank, £6.3m for plans to "reform" the "public sector" in South Africa, promoting "business-to-business" links between Brit ish and South African companies whose singular interest is profit.

Once the wretched Robert Mugabe is gone, Zimbabwe will get the same treatment. Offering a billion pounds' worth of "aid", the British government will lead the return of capital, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund to restore what was, long before Mugabe's wrecking, one of the most exploited and unequal societies in Africa. The new heist was outlined on 5 April at the amusingly titled Progressive Governance Conference in Britain, one of Tony Blair's legacies, where "left-of-centre" leaders pretend to be crisis managers instead of, as is often the case, the cause of the crisis. (In 1999, Blair flew twice to South Africa to promote the now scandalous arms deal.)

The South African president, Thabo Mbeki, is said to have been recruited to get rid of the obstacle that is Mugabe, but he is cautious, no doubt recalling that Mugabe, on his last visit to South Africa, received an embarrassing ovation from the black crowd. This was not so much an endorsement of his despotism as a reminder that most South Africans had not forgotten one of the ANC's "unbreakable promises" - that almost a third of arable land would be redistributed by 2000. Today the figure is less than 4 per cent.

Meanwhile, the evictions continue, along with urban dispossession, water disconnections and the ubiquitous indignity of begging. "Our country belongs to all who live in it," say the opening words of the ANC's Freedom Charter, declared more than half a century ago. Recently, the South African police calculated that the number of protests across the country had doubled in two years to more than 10,000 a year. This may be the highest rate of dissent in the world. Once again, like Kathy, they are calling it "struggle".

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

15 comments from readers

maryb
10 April 2008 at 12:44

Brilliant stuff John. The dreams that were held out to the black South African have never materialised except for a select few. I have a stepson in Capetown which is a very beautiful place but underneath all the gloss and glitz of the whites' lifestyle, you know that it is existing alongside extreme poverty is the squatter camps. The occupants have seen no change at all.

Simon Barber
10 April 2008 at 13:21

Polls, including one released just last week, continue to show that black South Africans remain highly upbeat about the future. The success of the Daily Sun, a newspaper aimed squarely at the black working and middle class, is a good proxy for the post-apartheid economic transformation Pilger fails to see, but which fuels the optimism of the long-denied majority. The Daily Sun, launched in 2002, is now the largest seeling paper in the country, and perhaps the continent south of the sahara. Yes, there is still a great deal of poverty and unemployment remains intolerably high. And yes, some in the political elite have found it hard to shed a tendency toward democratic centralism. Interestingly, the ANC grassroots rejected such tendencies rather resoundingly at Polokwane last December. True, they picked a leader, Jacob Zuma, whom many see as flawed. But this space needs watching. I'm confident that South African will continue to surprise on the upside. Of course, given the stereotypes we have to deal with as an African country, some people will be surprised whenever we do anything right.

jvanderkliss
11 April 2008 at 05:41

South Africa is headed to a dark and dreadful place, but some people in the UK are unwilling to admit this fact. It was you liberal Britts that allowed the once bueatiful Rhodesia to fall to a black dictator who at the time was labeled in your press as a "liberator." It is not surprising that SA is now under a one party system of corrupt and incompetent former servants and radicals. Crime, once confined to the black townships, has now engulfed the entire country. The UK is now getting a taste of this misery as more and more illegal African immigrants land on its shores and move into its cities. Anyone who points out this fact in automatically labeled a fascist racist. Well, sometimes the truth hurts. We South Africans were better off before 1994 and I am not afraid to point this out.

alexweir1949
11 April 2008 at 10:24

The ANC and Mbeki are massively corrupt. But the West, the Whites and the rich Blacks love them, and it is very much business as usual. What South Africa needs is a Poor People's Party - which would scoop 65% of the vote overnight and displace the ANC from power. But South Africa, like so many African countries, is stuck in racial and/or tribal politics, and has no conception of left-wing, centrist or right-wing politics. It will also be necessary for South Africa to adopt a modern voting system which is fraud-proof - such a system does exist on paper, but the West wishes to stymie this system. Alex Weir, Harare

Murphy
11 April 2008 at 11:59

At the heart of Zimbabwe’s present impasse is the failure of President Mugabe and ZANU-PF to return the arable land to the indigenous Zimbabweans and implement appropriate developmental policies soon after the fall of the settler-colonial regime of Ian Smith. Up until the war veterans took it upon themselves to lead the repossession of the land from white colonists, Mugabe’s policies that economically disempowered the bulk of the indigenous Zimbabweans made him a darling of the UK and many of its western allies. With the failure of South Africa to empower the aborigines economically, pressure from the UK and its western allies has been upon President Mbeki,so far a darling of the neo-liberal west, to rewrite the Zimbabwean chapter. As John Pilger’s piece highlights, the immense pressure on the ANC to change its disempowering neo-liberal economic policies from the domestic uprisings of the bourgeoning social movement, explains the constraints to which President Mbeki’s policy towards Zimbabwe is subjected.

Mojalefa Murphy

Toronto

Christie01
11 April 2008 at 19:35

Is there any substance to this viewpoint? It is very easy to make bold statements and accusations without the tedium of the burden of proof, but that hardly adds to any intelligent debate on the subject. One would think that an informed approach would be to highlight real issues while at least attempting to offer some way forward. Regarding Mugabe as a hero of our times, and panning every other attempt to help African countries is not productive. Nor does it help to hint at a global conspiracy theory which aims to perpetuate inequality world wide, in favour, of the rich nations, of course. If the above article is an example of unearthing facts with steely attention and laying bare the filthy truth, then I wonder about the value system used in assessing effective journalism. It is a sad day when a once renowned journalist has to resort to rhetoric and diatribe to fill column centimetres. What starts out almost as a human interest piece ("he wore dark glasses to cover..." etc.) ends up as a mere rant. Poor show... Even Michael Moore does a more convincing job.

G Jeffreys
11 April 2008 at 23:19

I spent a long time as an anti-aparthied activist in the 1980s. It is hard to remember the repression of that era. Everyone lived in fear of the Special Branch and the Total Onslaught but no one would have believed that we would now be overun by crime, corrution, Aids and incompetance whilst perpetuating the old racial and socio-economic inequalities. Then, everyone knew that the end of aparthied would require major social change.

Where are those activists of times gone by? Will I ever see my beloved homeland again?

antileft
13 April 2008 at 14:47

Oh pilger when will you learn that business is the solution and not the problem? I bet the reason you clearly deliberately avoid writing about "solutions" in every article is because youre a die-hard 1960s commie and even you are aware that your beliefs sound a bit silly now.

Colindale
13 April 2008 at 20:49

The disparity between rich and poor, between black and white, increases exponentially. In every major town and city from Paarl and Stellenbosch to Cape Town and Jo'burg, there stands in the main street huge showrooms where the expensive luxury cars of the world - Porsche, Volvo, BMW and Mercedes sell at a fast rate to primarily white businessmen. Less than a half a mile down the road lie the shanty towns and the townships whose inhabitants struggle to find food and jobs in the land for which Steve Biko gave his life. Where is the orderly redistribution of land that should have been carried out over the past decade with appropriate compensation? Why have those still in makeshift corrugated iron huts without sanitation not been rehoused? Why are the infrastructures of the black townships so bad and the white residential areas so beautiful. Why did Mandiba spend 27 years locked away? Why were so many lives lost? Why is SA's mineral wealth still effectively in foreign hands? Why are there virtually no black faces to be seen in the restaurants? Why are shopping malls white retail parks? Why are there no black guests at South African hotels? Why?

writeon
13 April 2008 at 21:12

colindale,

The short answer to you 'question' is very simple, class trumps race in a market system, where money is the ultimate soicio-economic prerequisite, but I imagine you already know this.

Whilst the most obvious and absurd characteristics of the white dominated Aparthied system have been abolished, in much the same way as the worst aspects of racial discrimination in the United States have *formerly* been removed, the fundamental, structural, cultural, inequalities; still remain intact for the majority.

If the current system of 'market-democracy' continues unchanged and unchanneled one will see no real change in the distribution of wealth and power in society, except very superficially, decade after decade. In ten or twenty years one will visit South Africa and the same vast disparities of wealth and opportunity will prevail. This is the way 'market-democracy' functions/disfunctions.

antileft
14 April 2008 at 03:51

"class trumps race in a market syste"

Bingo! You got it. Capitalism is anti-racism. Couldnt agree more.

colindale
14 April 2008 at 07:36

Writeon:

Redistribution of wealth comes about through taxation and government policy. It comes about through ensuring that the control and ownership of natural resources are retained within the state. It comes about through the provision of education. It come about with the provision of medical treatment for all and an independent judiciary. And finally, it comes about through free and fair elections and the control of corruption. I do not expect all these in SA at this time but I do expect progress and this is lacking.

antileft
14 April 2008 at 08:45

"It comes about through ensuring that the control and ownership of natural resources are retained within the state."

BS. In Venezuela (not to mention the gulf states) the companies that are involved in natural resources are being taken over by the state and it's becomming more and more unequal. More often than not, when you increase the size and power of the state, you increase corruption, which produces the worst kind of inequality- that which enriches people who dont produce at the expense of those who do (and the poor).

colindale
16 April 2008 at 08:14

antileft:

In right-wing, democratic Israel, ( 'the only democracy in the Middle East' ), corruption is endemic right through the political system. Retaining control of natural resources has no correlation with the level of corruption.

Chris Stylianou
04 July 2008 at 12:50

Thabo Mbeki and his goverment must shoulder all the blame for the current situation in South and Southern Africa. This country and its people are starting to behave like a absent parent family. Their is no leadership and as a result of this disfunctional leadership the population has become disfunctional. We would never have had to endure the peasant revolt that took place at Polokwane if Mbeki and his cabal had take the lead in a decisive manner. Accepetd that their time had passed and ensured that the next generation of ANC leaders where in place to continue leading. Unless Zuma takes a firm stand and discipline is restored in not only the ANC as a party but also the govering organs of state and the population as a whole we are headed in the same direction as the rest of Southern Africa .

How can the rest of the world take this region seriously with its attitudes toward issues such as Zimbabwe, HIV, Violence , Zenophobia etc

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

About the writer

John Pilger

John Pilger, renowned investigative journalist and documentary film-maker, is one of only two to have twice won British journalism's top award; his documentaries have won academy awards in both the UK and the US. In a New Statesman survey of the 50 heroes of our time, Pilger came fourth behind Aung San Suu Kyi and Nelson Mandela. "John Pilger," wrote Harold Pinter, "unearths, with steely attention facts, the filthy truth. I salute him."

Read More

Vote!

Will China rule the world?

Suggest a question

View comments

© New Statesman 1913 – 2009

Tracker