Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

Learn from the mob professor

It's been a fantastic three months for those of us gripped by the dynamics of crowds. First, we had student demonstrations here in Britain spiralling out of control; then, we saw Tunisians link arms to push out their corrupt regime; finally, millions took to the streets of Egyptian cities, pitting their sheer weight of numbers against the sclerotic - but still vicious - government of Hosni Mubarak.

Perhaps the most celebrated analyst of the crowd was the Nobel laureate Elias Canetti, whose 1960 magnum opus, Crowds and Power, aimed to do for modern mass movements what Frazer's Golden Bough did for "primitive" ritual. To Canetti, both socialism and capitalism were political systems defined by "the modern frenzy of increase", in which production led to ever bigger crowds of goods and consumers.

This sense of industrialised society as a crowd, at root, directs Canetti to his definition of power as the coincidence of the desires of the ruler(s) and the ruled.

By this view, it's easy to understand the presence of crowds of people on the streets as symptomatic of a disjunction between the two: only when the crowd has been reabsorbed into the social fabric has synchronous equilibrium been achieved. In Canetti's jargon, the crowd in Tahrir Square was "stagnating", whereas the crowds of the quiescent Cairene unemployed before the revolt could be characterised as "rhythmic".

Dubstep revolutions

Canetti showed a nice understanding of how masses of people make their own political weather when he caustically observed that "fire unites a theatre more than a play can" - but his vision was underscored by the apocalyptic mood music of mutually assured destruction. "Rulers tremble today," he wrote, not "because they are rulers but as the equals of everyone else . . . Either everyone will survive or no one."

Fifty years on, and with examples of people power toppling regimes from Iran to Russia and Ukraine and - almost - back again, we've come to believe that there is an inherent "goodness" to the crowd. At least, this is what we believe in the west, where, apart from kettled teens jiggling to dubstep and lobbing firecrackers, the mob has become a purely recreational event. Our crowds hold up lighters and sway in stadiums; their mobs do away with tyrants, replacing rulers we were happy to do business with, one hopes, others we're even happier to do business with.

One man who experienced an epiphany while holding up a lighter at a stadium-rock gig was the inappropriately named Professor Keith Still. This mathematician was moved to invent the science - if it is one - of "crowd dynamics", a discipline he teaches at Bucks New University and on a course at the UK Cabinet Office Emergency Planning College.

A few weeks ago, I heard Still speaking on the radio about his work for the Saudi Arabian government, ensuring that the millions of pilgrims descending on Mecca for the Haj don't crush each other to death. I was struck by the technicality of Still's exposition and so, when crowds took to the streets across the Middle East, it seemed to me that he was the person to consult, rather than some woolly-minded foreign-policy expert.

Fatal attraction

I sent Professor Still a suitably humble email: "I appreciate that your methodology is not able to tell us whether or not crowd power will oust Mubarak but, nonetheless, it does occur to me that there is some kind of metric at work in the interaction between largely unarmed demonstrators, passive troops and active police - I wondered if you had any comment?" As quickly as a stampeding mob came back the prof's reply: "We have
a range of models for assessing risk to the crowd and this is the sort of application we use for training purposes. I'm not sure I could comment further, other than that the type of work I do is related to understanding crowd behaviour and anticipating action/ reaction in this kind of situation." He then referred me to his website.

Rather than being chagrined, I was gratified. There's a fabulous section on Still's site that details incidents of "crowd crazing", when businesses hype up crowds for sales and openings. One fatal "crazing" happened in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, in 2004, when 20,000 people turned up for the opening of a new Ikea. I dare say Still's crowd dynamics might have prevented this - but only Canetti could have explained it.

4 comments

Floyd hayes's picture

@mc -I agree. Although, he's the only writer who has come close to kicking me in the balls. Read his short story, "five swing walk" and you'll know what I mean! I'm still recovering...

Contextcatcher's picture

"Canetti showed a nice understanding..."

That's an understatement... "Crowds and Power" reflects, as a broken mirror, peoples behaviour. The puzzling reader can put the parts together...there are a lot of Canetti's describings you can relate to or identify with. For instance this simple phrase of him: hidden in the important hood piece about transformation:
"Every complete unknown language is a kind of acoustic mask; as soon one learns it, it becomes a face, understandable and soon familiar".
It's his philosophical key for awareness. His one and only novel "Auto da Fé"(1935) was his dark (self!)conscious lock without this briljant light reflecting key. He was a remarkable headstrong thinker. Concrete and not losing himself in abstractions... like many (modern) thinkers tend to do.

MRS JOY CAMPBELL's picture

Dearly Beloved,

Please read this slowly and carefully, as it may be one of the most
important emails you ever get.I am Mrs JOY CAMPBELL, I was married
to Late Eric CAMPBELL.He used to work with Shell Petroleum Development
Company London and was also a seasoned contractor in the West African
Region.He died on Monday,31 July, 2010 in Paris. We were married for
seven years without a child.

After his death I decided not to re-marry or get a child outside my
matrimonial home.When my late husband was alive,he deposited the sum
of GBP 5.2 Million in a bank in London,which is now wasting and
languishing there. My Doctor told me that I would not last long due to
my complicated health issues,I have cancer.Having known my condition I
decided to donate this funds to better the lives of the less
privileged.I need an honest and trust worthy individual that will
utilize this money in accordance with my instruction.I want the funds
to be used in funding religious organizations,orphanages and less
privileged ropagating the word of God.

I took this decision because I don't have any child that will inherit
this money and my husband's relatives are very unkind to me and I
don't want my husband's hard earned money to be misused.I am not
afraid of death hence I know where I am going.I know that I am going
to be in the bosom of the Lord. As soon as I receive your reply I
shall give you the contact of the Bank,and my Attorney in London.For
legitimacy,he will also issue you a letter of authorization that will
empower you as the original-beneficiary of this fund.

I will like you to provide me with your information so that I can
forward it to my attorney so that he will start processing of your
transfer into your account. So I will like you to send this
information below.

1) Full name
2) Age and marital status.
3) Banking information
4) Mobile number and occupation
5) And your home address.

With all this I will forward it to my attorney
who will help you because my health condition it not sound.

I want you to always pray for me,Any delay in your reply will give me
room in sourcing for another individual for this same purpose.If you
are not interested,kindly pardon me for contacting you. You can reach
me with my alternate email address(joycampbell12@yahoo.com) or
Email: joycampbell25@yahoo.com

Thanks,
Yours sincerely,
MRS JOY CAMPBELL

MC's picture

Will Self is an amazing writer. He should blog more, totally excellent and I wish I could dissect the world the way he does. Anyone who can make me read a full article on cafe expresso has a talent I want!

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets