Return to: Home | Politics | Human Rights

It could have been me

Guido Fawkes

Published 16 August 2007

For sending an email exposing Chinese government spin, Shi Tao is in the third year of a ten-year prison sentence, while his family endures relentless official harassment

I use webmail all the time, receiving something like 300 emails a day, sending probably 30 a day. Running a popular political gossip site means that the content of the emails often contains information which, if not an actual state secret, is something that people in the government would rather was not revealed. On a good day my website annoys Downing Street and the party spin machines. Annoys them immensely.

It goes without saying that I don't expect my email service provider to hand over the contents of my emails and the IP address revealing my geographic location to the authorities. In fact, without a second thought, implicitly, I rely on my email provider to protect the confidentiality of my sources and myself.

At 39, Shi Tao is a couple of years younger than me. He is three years into a ten-year prison sentence, after being arrested in 2004 in connection with an email sent from his Yahoo! email account. This email, to a Chinese pro-democracy website based in the United States, contained an article revealing the Chinese government's instructions to Chinese journalists on how to spin the 15th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square crackdown. Government spin - just the sort of thing I love exposing.

Yahoo! gave his account information to the Chinese authorities, which helped them to identify Shi and led to his arrest on charges of "illegally providing state secrets to foreign entities". "State secrets" are only vaguely defined in Chinese law: whether something constitutes a "state secret" can be an arbitrary and politically motivated decision, enabling the Chinese authorities to detain those peacefully exercising their right to freedom of expression.

Yahoo! handed over information that was used as evidence during the trial which resulted in Shi's imprisonment. Just before the trial, Shi's defence lawyer, Guo Guoting, an experienced human rights lawyer, had his licence to practise law suspended. Not surprisingly, Guo considered this to be an attempt by the authorities to prevent him from defending Shi.

Yahoo! accepts that the case "raises profound and troubling questions about basic human rights", but distances itself from responsibility, saying it was legally obliged to comply with the demand for information. Amnesty International argues that Yahoo!'s actions were not justifiable: companies should respect human rights wherever they operate.

According to Amnesty, Shi has been doing forced labour in Chishan Prison even as the authorities are extending the punishment to his family. Shi's wife was questioned daily by Public Security Bureau officials and was persistently pressured by her work unit to divorce him, which she eventually did. His brother and uncle have also been under surveillance and harassed at home and at work; and his mother, Gao Qinsheng, is closely monitored and harassed as she continues to petition for her son's release.

Gao is a brave woman: two months ago she accepted on his behalf from the World Association of Newspapers the award of the 2007 Golden Pen of Freedom. With tears in her eyes, she waved her fist at the Chinese state and raged against her son's shackles.

Amnesty International considers Shi Tao to be a prisoner of conscience, imprisoned solely for the peaceful exercise of his right to freedom of expression.

I worked in Hong Kong at one time, and if I had been writing at the time, the same could have happened to me. The Chinese already block my website.

Guido Fawkes runs a British political blog

To take action on behalf of Shi Tao, go to http://www.amnesty.org.uk/cases or text the word "FREEDOM", together with your name and email address, to 64118

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

4 comments from readers

Nick Dearden, Amnesty International UK
17 August 2007 at 12:45

It isn't only in China that this is happening. Around the world countries are copying the "China Model" - extensive internet use for business and economic reasons (China will soon have the highest number of bloggers of any country in the world) while clamping down on the political potential the internet opens. According to the Open Net Initiative at least 25 countries now filter the internet. Moreover the number of countries that repressing activists in other ways (arresting and imprisoning for instance) is growing all the time. In other words this new way in which governments (with corporate help) view the internet is becoming a threat to all of us - and to the development of the internet. Lots more news on the current "state of the world" and ways to take action at http://irrepressible.info/news.

Tony Ryals
18 August 2007 at 03:11

Because you mention the case of the Chinese journalist turned in by Yahoo!

and that it can't happen here.....Well I hope you are correct however I have had my Yahoo email accounts deleted numerous times by Yahoo! because I complain about

stock fraud on their messge boardsd - or used to.

And further there is reason to believe that U.S. governmment employees and insiders

to the Beltway or Washington,D.C. not only have Yahoo! accounts to avoid their email from falling into the public record.I believe some of the pressure to remove my posts and conficate my email of the Yahoo SRA International stock 'message board' came from employees who have a monopoly on U.S. government 'IT' but are also greatly owned by the CIA's In-Q-Tel 'non-profit' penny stock operations.

Also Overstock.com's CEO Patrick Byrne who runs a U.S. penny stock con site and is sponsor of NCANS a strange group of penny stock promotors who claim their worthless U.S. penny stock companies are 'naked shorted' and who has given to the Republican Party and far right causes has also been able to have my posts deleted and email confiscated as has Charles Schwab.

Anywaythere is more to investigate re Yahoo!

and U.S. citizen harrassment as well.

Tony Ryals

nanoubix
02 September 2007 at 13:21

I am closing down my Yahoo a/c as I read this. Any suggestion for a self-respecting free/cheap mail service provider?

keeef
12 July 2008 at 01:53

Yahoo! have a huge mafia problem. See here http://endmafia.com

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before you can comment on the website

Read More

Vote!

Should we build new nuclear power plants?

Suggest a question

View comments

© New Statesman 1913 – 2009

Tracker