On being mixed-race

I grew up thinking of myself as equally English and Pakistani, writes Samira Shackle. Was I wrong?

When I meet people for the first time, it's not unusual for them to ask, "Where are you from?" If I reply, "London," they say, "Oh, no, where are you from from," or, "Where are you actually from?" It's a polite way of seeking an explanation for my colour. Most of the time, I don't find it offensive - I am half Pakistani and half English and look racially ambiguous.

If you are mixed-race (as one in ten British children now is), you don't slot neatly into racial or national categories. The conversation above tends to continue, "Do you go back home often?" - which feels strange, as until now I have visited Pakistan only as a baby and "home" is Queen's Park in north London. Having one English parent makes you as much English as anything else - arguably more English than not, if you live here - yet most people's default position is to define you by your difference.

It isn't necessarily a bad thing to show interest in someone's background. It becomes corrosive only when it is tied to a non-inclusive sense of Englishness that is hostile to "the other" and suggests that, because you have a mixed heritage, you cannot share ownership of the place where you live.

It was not until I went to university that I encountered the idea that Englishness is bound to ethnicity. I was brought up to think of myself as equally English and Pakistani, taking pride in both traditions and spending time with my extended family on both sides. Though I pass easily for European, I have always been happy to identify myself as Pakistani, too. This idea of mixed or multiple national and racial identities developed as I grew up in the borough of Brent in north-west London, which is the most ethnically diverse area in England and Wales. According to the Office for National Statistics, there is an 85 per cent chance that any two people chosen at random here will be from different ethnic groups (there is just a 2 per cent chance in the least diverse town, Easington, County Durham). In Brent, immigrants from across the world do not live in cloistered communities but use the same schools and shops.

It was quite a jump to go from here to Oxford. At university, I was suddenly exposed to white people who had only known other white people and made it clear that they perceived a difference between us. Mostly, this wasn't out-and-out racism and it was quite minor: a friend would constantly mention that I was Pakistani, which suggested that he couldn't get it off his mind; another friend rounded on me for saying that I wasn't keen on popular names, such as James or Rachel - "Those English names are my heritage," she snapped, which felt like a slap in the face because that English heritage was mine, too. Another friend affected a Peter Sellers-style Indian accent when talking about my dad, even though my father is English. It was painful to realise that, while I took my own Englishness for granted, others - close friends - called it into question because of my mother's birthplace.

Mixed-race Britons are all over billboards, buses and the TV as the acceptable face of diversity. They represent the fastest-growing ethnic group in Britain (young people are six times more likely than adults to be mixed) but they are frequently left out of serious discussions on race. Clearly, many still struggle with where to place us. My mum used to hate filling in forms that made her define her children as "other". Perhaps the newer category of "mixed: white and Asian" means that the parameters of what it means to be English are expanding.

Home truths

In 2002, an Ipsos MORI poll found that 86 per cent of Britons disagreed with the statement that to be truly British, you have to be white. Most make a distinction between "British" and "English" - the former is considered more inclusive and less tied to ethnicity. For me, Englishness is inclusive, too. Nearly all of my closest friends as I grew up were from either mixed backgrounds or different ethnic groups. Our parents might have cooked different food or worn different clothes but our upbringings were largely the same. It never felt like a big deal to have family from Pakistan, Guyana, Egypt or Zambia, because the similarities between us far outweighed the differences: we shared a language, an education, a self-deprecating and sarcastic humour and a powerful identification with London. Class background - a very English thing - also came into it.

My brother's wife is half Portuguese and half Irish, which makes their children doubly mixed. Their nine-year-old daughter finds this confus­ing. She once asked whether she was Portuguese or Pakistani, because a kid in the playground had told her that she couldn't be both. Why shouldn't she be able to identify as English if she wants to, despite having only one grandparent who is ethnically so? Neither she nor her parents have ever lived anywhere else.

Growing up somewhere makes it home. It is highly likely that you will share in the cultural identity of a place even if you haven't consciously taken it as your own. I know mixed-race people who have had less positive experiences than my own and who choose to define themselves by their non-British heritage.

Yet the two need not be mutually exclusive. Difference can form a strong part of your self-identification - a Populus poll in February found that Asian and black Britons are significantly more likely than their white counterparts to define themselves by ethnicity and religion - without it detracting from your Englishness or Britishness.

Samira Shackle is a staff writer for the NS

15 comments

NKC's picture

I too am mixed race, a term that does not really define us persons of duel heritage.
I have always disliked the terms mixed race or half-caste.
I feel these terms defines us being a of less worth than other persons.

My mother is English and my father Pakistani, I experienced a lot of prejudice growing up. due to this and truely not feeling excepted or included by British society it made it hard for me to find my own identity.

When growing up having a duel heritage you can find prejudice on both sides,
and for me it inspired me to write my own article on this same subject, Being of both English and Pakistani descent.

Your own article reflects my own feelings and questions, how both we and our society sees and identifies us.

It was enjoyable to read about others whom are from simalar backgrounds.

Mr. Divine's picture

What do you think it's like for me being the First Seal? How can I possibly fit in anywhere?

JD's picture

As another mixed-race person (British-Malaysian from near Birmingham), a lot of this really resonates with me and my experiences.

I currently live in village in a little house my English grandparent built, and I hate the fact that though I have more of a family connection to this village than many of my fellow villagers, due to the colour of my skin I still get looked at like I shouldn't be here, that I'm not English enough for a picture-postcard English village.

Incidentally charlesfrith -- it's very easy to say with good intentions "You're a human being. I'm a human being. That's all that matters." Perhaps you are lucky enough that that's all that needs to matter for you in your daily life, but in mine, the colour of my skin and my racial appearance have a marked effect on how people treat me and respond to me. I'd really like it to not matter, but I have no choice when it's my daily reality.

mixedcouplesrock's picture

I'm not a mixed-race child myself, but I'm in a relationship with a man from different race. That means sometimes people stare on us on streets. We don't really care because what builds a relationship is the love and understanding, not on skin colour. Visit our mixed-race couples community and support us: www.facebook.com/mixedcouplesrock

Assia W.'s picture

I get asked where I'm from all the time. I'm white. I'm a British citizen. I speak Anglais perfectly with a clean, public school accent. I was born in Russia. People hone in on the fact that I don't have a regional accent and can't place me. They also hone in on the fact that I've unashamedly kept certain parts of " Russsianness" about me, i.e a lack of embarassment in front of emotion and a willing, open and non- superficial friendliness which most English Brits, for some reason, can't stand. I am fed up of always being interrogated and asked where I'm from and then have it disputed that though I settled in Britain as a child and grew up with both British and my own culture I can, nevertheless
never be " British", not even referred to as " British" out of politeness and respect for the way how I identify myself as being -i.e a Brit. I really do think the question " Where are you from" is a terribly rude one, especially if it comes from a stranger, someone who in theory has no right to pry into nor, certainly, dispute your private background. We are all British here. I just wish the Brits
( the indigenous Brits, I mean) themselves would remember that once in a while. I'm sure we'd have a much more accepting, friendly and integrated society then. We read all the time in the newspapers how foreigners 'fail' to integrate into British society. Well, here's a piece of news - it's not always the foreigner's fault. There are some of us, who, no matter how integrated, are fed up of being treated as 'different' and 'foreign' because we feel like we belong but is there anyone who'll listen to us?
You're lucky, being mixed race and belonging to an ethnic group which is in comparison to mine, so much
better accepted in this society. I envy you. I can't even shout " Racist!" at someone who challenges my identity because I'm white, lol.

RK's picture

I too am mixed race my dad is from Guyana and of Asian decent and my mother is white English (although her mum was from Ireland) so of course understand and have experienced the same conversations as you. Very often being questioned by asians as to how I came by my sirname.
I feel that often people giving themselves there own labels doesnt help for example rather than describe yourself as English (which you are as you were born in this country) you describe yourself as half and half. When I am asked the same question I will always answer that I am English if people ask me more I will then describe where my parents and often grandparents are from.
I am very much of the mind each to there own but I do feel that if people from non-white or mixed families who are born in England described themselves as English it would certainly help race relations as would give the feeling of greater intergration to all.
After all surely what gives a person Englishness is not simply genetics but is about the experiences we all have in common from living in the England. I have far more in common with someone who has lived in England all their lives no matter what there ethnicity than I do with someone who has lived in Guyana all their lives with the same background as myself.

yazz's picture

My father is from Pakistan and mother white irish. I faced discrimination from both side. I now accept that I am ME and people are always shocked when I tell them I am half white.

Sciamachy's picture

t's interesting that you get asked "Where are you from?" so much. I'm half Irish, & have only been over there 3 or 4 times, but apart from skin colour, our situations are the same. As a white guy I don't get asked that kind of question - I think it'd grate after a while. I had quite enough of people hassling me for being Irish when I was a kid. If anyone does ask me where I'm from it's usually a fellow diaspora Irish type, and it's more like "Where are your folks from?" - Ireland being small enough in size & population that with a bit of examination you usually find out you're distantly related if your folks were from the same area.

Sandio's picture

I have Irish roots but find my blood-group links me to Basque country and the Breton, hence the inclusive idea of Britain, with the Anglo-French heritage. The old British/English distinction is worth noticing for what it means to different people. But its being inverted by devolution, with England treated as the metropole. Now English reverts to the Ancient sense of Anglish, which extended to the Independents before the Civil War, and reached through Singapore to old Canton in China.

sk's picture

I constantly get asked the 'where are you from?' question both by strangers and people I already know. I normally answer London, then when they look confused I clarify this by saying north London. They normally then look even more confused and ask no where are your parents from?
If i'm in a good mood, this refusal for people to accept that where I am from is something that I get to choose, makes me laugh. I don't mind explaining to people my mixed and confusing heritage. I love having such a varied background, with family and friends all over the world- I have cousins across 3 continents. But at the end of the day, I'm from London.

Latest tweets