Return to: Home | Politics | Economy

Young, gifted and jobless: a generation in the red

Alyssa McDonald and Liana Wood

Published 27 November 2008

The under-35s are the most vulnerable

Young, gifted and jobless: a generation in the red

The current financial landscape is bleak for anyone. But the culture shock is biggest for the TIMIs: the increasing numbers of those in their twenties and early thirties who find themselves indebted, mortgaged and insecure about job prospects. TIMIs are the first generation to get easy loans, starting with student loans. In fact, because of booming numbers of credit providers, the average under-35 now owes more than £9,000 in credit-card debts, student loans and other borrowings. Their repayments average £206 a month, three times as much as the archetypal TIMI is investing in a pension.

Now they find themselves in the front line for redundancy.

Sarah Walker, aged 23, and one year into her career as a strategy consultant, was made redundant a week ago. Having worked hard and received positive appraisals in her City position, Sarah thought her job safe. It was not.

"They didn't explain why they'd picked me. At the time I was too shocked to ask. Now I'm starting to feel angry. After we'd worked so hard we deserved an explanation." About a third of Sarah's colleagues were made redundant on the same day, but those in the early years of their career were hardest hit. This is emerging as a pattern.

These twentysomethings, graduates, often with excellent degrees, high-achieving and socially successful, did not foresee misfortune. Graduating from top universities, many achieved Firsts, presided over the Union or captained the rowing team.

People who lived through the three-day weeks of the Seventies, or who remember the blight of the early Nineties, know what to expect. But these young workers believed their careers in the finance sector to be stable and lucrative. After all, they were prepared to work 80 hours a week.

Lucy, a 33-year-old buyer for a public museum, has at least had a decade of relative stability. But even she has been given a stark choice: either take voluntary redundancy or a role with "more work for the same amount of money".

Until recently, she says, the decision would have been easy: "There have been so many jobs out there. But maybe now there won't be. What's it going to be like out there if you don't get a job?"

Lucy's mortgage on a London flat has not gone up "too much" in recent months, but she has an outstanding £1,000 credit-card debt. "I'm throwing everything I have at it, because I don't want that burden."

Many would envy her, including 28-year-old Lisa, who works for an events company in Edinburgh. She cannot afford to pay off more than the minimum on her credit card now that her mortgage is up by £250 a month.

Nina, also 28, has been similarly hit by an increase in her mortgage payments. She left her job as a mortgage broker to go travelling last November. Two weeks ago she returned to find her trade in disarray. "The office I worked for had closed down and the only mortgages being sold are remortgages. People aren't buying," she says. "So I'm working in a call centre for American Express - I'm working in debt! When someone defaults on a payment I call them. That is one area still recruiting, so my job is secure for the time being."

But as with 20 per cent of her peers, Nina earns less than she spends. "I'm still training so I take home only £450 a month, and my outgoings are about £600 . . . in recent weeks I've been to one pub, to have one drink."

Still, she has company for evenings in front of the television: her flatmate Paul recently took voluntary redundancy. His firm, a car rental company he describes as "a sinking ship", offered redundancy to all employees. "I was in middle management, so I reckoned I'd be one of the first to go in a second round," he says. He was right: "I've been out for five weeks, and two or three weeks ago they made all their managers and supervisors redundant. And I don't think their redundancy packages were as good as mine."

Soon these sackings will be making their appearance in the national statistics, with many more expected. The TIMIs are on the verge of having to survive in a very different world from the one in which they grew up.

The under-35s who lose their jobs will inevitably find another, suggest some. But it could mean months, or even years, of struggling financially, of having to take a job way below their qualifications.

The generation which, since 1998, took on loans of £20,000 before it had even graduated has been ill-prepared for insecurity and poverty. It has been dealt a hand far different from the one it was promised. As these TIMIs take their place in the dole queue, with their pride sorely damaged, they feel let down. As one redundant banker put it: "It's a job that leaves no time for anything else; it becomes your life. Losing that overnight makes you think again about your choices."

Alyssa McDonald and Liana Wood

The Britain that isn’t working

  • 1,825,000 number of unemployed, the highest since 1997
  • 1,000 number of workers joining the dole queue each day
  • 2,500,000 predicted number of claimants by 2010
  • 3,000,000 predicted number of unemployed by 2010
  • 540,115 number of under-35s claiming Jobseeker's Allowance
  • 494,180 number of under-35s claiming Incapacity Benefit or Severe Disablement Allowance
  • Research by Nick Stokeld Sources: ONS, TUC, ING, ING, DWP, DWP

Post this article to

  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • newsvine
  • Reddit

10 comments from readers

Nilsey105
27 November 2008 at 21:25

My deepest sympathy to all who have and are about to be made redundant.

As someone who fought against redundancy throughout the 60s, 70s, 80s, and 90s i can understand and empathise with you all.

The one thing that is different, so far, about this period is that it is haveing a greater effect upon the middle class white collar workers.

Perhaps it is just a matter of time before the blue collar working class are being hammered just as always. If this is going to be the case i believe the working class will cope with the situation far better then the middle class. The vast majority of those working class who have experienced redundancy on more than one occassion are hardened to the economic and psychological lows redundancy inflicts upon its recipients.

ITS NOT YOUR FAULT. IT IS THE FAULT OF THE ECONOMIC SYSTEM. THE SYSTEM DOES NOT CARE ABOUT INDIVIDUALS. IT IS A SYSTEM THAT WASTES SO MUCH TALENT AND DESTROYS GENERATIONS.

The shock and horror, and potential for total anarchy, of the riots in places such as Toxteth, Liverpool in 1981 gave rise the the Youth Opportunities Programme. This was an initiative of the then Tory goverment to get the unemployed youths off the streets and provide training for employment.

Irony of ironys there were no jobs. The Conservative government had destroyed the manufacturing base of Britain. People such as the ex chancellor Ken Clarke will have you believe it was the strong pound that was the tool that destroyed British industry. Dont you believe it they wanted to smash the Trade Union movement and so to achieve that end they destroyed British manufactureing.

Some of those teenagers i taught at that time, in an FE college, have not had a real job to this day. None had the opportunity of an apprenticeship and yet so many of them had an immense amount of talent. Collectively they were brilliant looking out for each other as you do.

Keep faith in yourselves, never loose heart its not your fault.

gnuneo
28 November 2008 at 03:47

so where now is new-Labour/Tory claims that "education pays for itself", the spin they used to drive home the end of free higher education?

it is now clear for all to see that there has been a deliberate continuation of Thatcherite Class war under both B'Liar and Brown - new-Labour are nothing more than slightly repackaged Tory feudalists, and they don't give two flying shits about equality, or a meritocratic society.

bear in mind that the Tory response to these cuts in education funding (that has led to such excruciating debt on students for a generation) was to say they would have cut further.

come next election, i would recommend we all vote something completely different from either wing of the Tory party - perhaps the Greens have some better ideas than impoverishing and indebting the poor to make the rich richer.

Camus
28 November 2008 at 17:34

What is missing in this report is the estimate of those who are working in one or more jobs at minimum wage or below, those who are working black to avoid tax and those who have simply been knocked out of the stats because they are 'too old to work anyway'. Where are the unions? Where are the protests? The Thatcher doctrine has atomised society and created the 'I'm all right Jack' attitude that was a feature of the fifties as I seem to have read somewhere. The graduates don't have many options - some may think about emigrating but from what I have heard the working conditions don't vary much wherever you go.

nationalbankuganda
29 November 2008 at 00:29

Gnuneo, I'm contemplating switching to the Lib Dems. True they seem just as paid up to the neo-liberal project as the other two parties, but their own vested interested in bringing in PR is something those on the left coincidentally share. This is not even a wasted vote for the smart money is on a hung parliament at the next election - even if ironically, the LDs lose seats. FPP has encouraged conservative bias in our political system. New Labour is a symptom of this, as FPP compels aspiring governments to capture a centre-ground that is more positioned to the right - that is, for swing votes in predominantly affluent constituencies. PR will switch the centre-ground back to its proper place, and will have to consider the interests of voters on more ordinary incomes.

PacificGatePost
29 November 2008 at 07:00

For all those feeling lost in the morass

of the economic mess, your common

sense is more powerful than you think.

We have created monsters in the form

of omnipotent economists. They are

not what they seem.

-

http://pacificgatepost.blogspot.com/200

8/11/economists-our-new-philosopher-

kings.html

--

Perhaps society has simply

overplayed them.

gnuneo
29 November 2008 at 08:57

"but their own vested interested in bringing in PR is something those on the left coincidentally share."

with Clegg in charge, the chances of the LibDems, even *with* a hung parliament, forcing through PR is absolute zilch. The Greens would now make too many gains, and he would be given his orders not to rock the boat. In effect, with Clegg and PR i expect a lot of hot air *before* the election, and a lot of hot air *after* the election.

i would estimate there is at least half of the total electorate who have decided not to vote, and if even half of those switched to voting Green as a protest vote, that would be *quite* the wake-up call.

wouldn't be surprised to start hearing noises about "Govt of National Unity" at that point.

PGP: yes, pretty much.

Camus
30 November 2008 at 19:07

Doesn't seem as of there are many NS readers interested in the plight of the young graduates. the working world changes from day to day and we older ones have NO IDEA what to offer as advice because we don't have a clue. When I was fired I had six months to find another, better job. But that is history. Today I teach cooks and waiters and listen to their stories with mounting anger at the way they are bled white by the employers. the employers are not evil, they just have to meet certain targets, but in doing so they rip off young people who are just starting out. One cook told me he worked two hours over, missed his train home, cost him a week's wages to take a taxi and the next day into work after four hours sleep.

writeon
01 December 2008 at 16:27

Camus,

I've been in this world that you describe myself. I was of course a mere tourist in 'hell.' I could leave any time I felt like it. Which made me feel guilty and incredibly grateful for my platinum credit card. Was that really all that seperated me from them? A little piece of plastic with almost magical qualities to transform lives? Worst thing was I could never really know how it felt to be poor. I could only observe it at a safe distance. I was experiencing a facsimile of real life, not the real thing.

I began to feel a bit like a traveller in space and time from the future, and that's when I decided to leave and return to my own world. The one I've meticulously created for myself and my family, what often seems like an island off the coast somewhere.

Camus
02 December 2008 at 16:49

writeon: sounds as if you have a nice little pad in the Channel Islands or maybe Mallorca. What separated you from the working poor was not the card - it was the balance behind the card. If you don't know what it is to be poor, try spending a day in a city without any money and start to ask passerby for a bit of spare cash.

writeon
02 December 2008 at 22:28

Camus,

I do believe in doing research. I did this a long time ago, trying to get by with literally no money in London for a few days, sleeping rough. Mind you it was easier then. After only a couple of days I started to get scared. It was strange. I really felt that I was trapped, even though I knew I could walk away whenever I wanted, take out the magic card and walk into a nice, comfortable, warm, hotel; a meal, a hot bath and a clean, soft, bed. I always have spare cash in my pockets now if somebody asks for the price of cup of tea. And I did use the 'research' productively, sympathetically, pointedly and with a sense of solidarity.

I wanted the poor to have faces, names, hopes, dreams, stories; just like everyone else, not to be foregotten, become invisible as human beings, wiped out of our conciousness, unpeople. One does what one can, with what one has I suppose. I work in fiction with words, ideas and visions about people and the world we live in. I try to do my best with the weapons at my disposal.

Post your comment

Please note: you will need to login or register before your comment is displayed on the website

You may enter up to 2000 characters (about 300-350 words)

Characters left:

We want to encourage people to comment on our content and to exchange views with other readers and hope this will be done on a courteous basis. However, if you encounter posts which are offensive please let us know by emailing comments@newstatesman.co.uk and we will take swift action where necessary.

Read More

Vote!

Will China rule the world?

Suggest a question

View comments

© New Statesman 1913 – 2009

Tracker