GP: "It is too difficult for ill people to claim benefits"

"The government withholding funds from sick and needy people through a bureaucratic claim system."

Protestors campaign against ATOS, a company responsible for assessing benefit cl
Protestors campaign against ATOS, a company responsible for assessing benefit claimants. Photograph: Getty Images

The British Medical Journal has a piece from a GP, Dr Anne Dyson, who writes that it is too difficult for ill people to claim benefits (£):

I have worked in the NHS as a principal and partner in general practice providing primary care for patients since 1986. I have met patients who have told me of the difficulties they’d had claiming sickness benefits, but I had previously had no personal experience of the system. . .

I was shocked by the bureaucracy of a system that is supposed to be a safety net for people who fall sick through no fault of their own and have paid national insurance contributions all their lives. Fortunately, I am not reliant on receiving any state benefits for my living expenses because I have sufficient private provision, but I am sure that many of my patients are not in such a lucky position. Furthermore, I do not feel ill or unwell as such, otherwise I might not have had the strength and perseverance to persist with my claim. And nor do I have hearing loss or a speech impairment, which would make a telephone interview impossible. I am also organised enough to know where to find my birth and marriage certificates and so on.

It is a scandal that the system is so complicated: it is likely to fail the very people who are most in need of help. I suspect this may be a deliberate government ploy to reduce the number of benefit claims and reduce the overall cost of welfare. If so this should be publicised and shown for what it is: the government withholding funds from sick and needy people through a bureaucratic claim system.

It's a view which is rarely allowed into the media, yet this is the natural end point of arguments that we should be more aggressive in withdrawing sickness benefits from people who "don't need them". In order to do that, you have to subject thousands of people who do need them to batteries of tests designed to prove that they aren't fraudulently claiming. And all of this in a system which suffers very low levels of fraud. The DWP estimated that the disability living allowance – no longer granted, due to reforms by the department – had a fraud rate of just 0.5 per cent.

2 comments

Posh Tosh's picture

Sorry for the typing mistakes, as sometimes things are too painful to concentrate - try my best though!

According to the staff I should have died in 1992/3 a year after I stood as a parliamentary candidate.

Still here but just and see parasites at the top and others shipped in for free treatment by their own doctors friends here, all of them I have spoken to state they agreed the journey months before and were told which doctor to see at the hospital.

Can we have all out tax and NHS payments back please before freeloaders that do not pay have eroded them?

Posh Tosh's picture

I have my class a drug, some a little old, and when they stop my benefist for a genetic cancer that is incurable in a few weeks will take the bottleand a few other things saved.

I will post it on the internet when happening.

Funny how the drug addicts that have never worked get amblance cover to hospital, see them there all the time, yet when I have a bowel blockage and have been told by the top surgeon at MRI that I need to get there straight away, either have to get a taxi there and may wait in a corridor for four hours, and when the pain has ceased, and no treatment given come back home.

I was born with the condition worked for most of my life and been a soldier, a civil servant and a councillor -yet now they have doctos imported for convenience so they can explain, that my bowel blockage is indeed an infection.

Having had the condition several times since 1981 when had my bowel removed, well most often Dr Jo's advice as a senior surgeon is overuled, by those that do not have a clue about my condition. I have a gentic condition that is rare - muppets imported for finacial savings do not have that experience she has. Very often told to go back home with paracetomol, yet dehydrate within hours. The condition can last for 48 hours in absolute pain and as Dr Jo the dsurgeon has stated need to be seen as soon as it starts.

Seems the foreign doctors cannot get hold of her number as they chat about everything back home.

Now my method of getting to the hospital where I am treated if the staff speak English, by taxi £27 each way, is to be stopped.

I wish I could have an interpreter to be able to speak to all the night staff - refused because I am English and have paid all my NHs dues, and then see druugies and nonepayers getting a free ride off my money!

Latest tweets