Voices

Views from elsewhere

Syndicate contentRSS

The haunting images from Syria moved me to action

The media has a right - and even a duty - to publish graphic images.

Protestors chant slogans against Syrian President Bashar al-Assad
Protestors chant slogans against Syrian President Bashar al-Assad as they carry a mock coffin. Photograph: Getty Images.

What do you do when you see a picture of a toddler with his hands tied and his throat cut? A week ago on Saturday I was scrolling through the #Syria hashtag on my Twitter feed when pictures of the Houla massacre started coming through. That night I looked at many of them. I shook, sobbed but I kept looking. 

I’ve seen worse in the days since then: video footage not of dead children but of dying ones. A young boy, his throat slashed, appears to be dead but suddenly gasps for breath. Someone gently, so gently, undresses him. Another gasp, Then silence. A chubby baby in a nappy, bleeding from stab wounds, screams in agony. The screaming goes on and on. A tiny newborn lies still in its blanket, then gulps for air. Is still again, for a long time. Another gulp. But weaker now. 

There is enormous controversy about whether the media should publish this kind of material. In this country, they don't; last week’s Times front page showing a close up of dead boy was exceptional in every sense, but it did not show the physical destruction of a child’s body wreaked by shells, bullets and knives. That was left to Martin Fletcher’s extraordinary accompanying words  - and to read his simple description of the children’s corpses was to shudder and despair. 

But nothing he or I write conveys the violation of a child’s body slashed and stabbed and smashed that an image can sear into your understanding of what one human being can do to another.  Pictures and footage of Houla's dead and dying children - and the many others killed before them - can be seen on YouTube and via Twitter, and I think people should sometimes choose to look.

I look out of respect, because that child felt terror and pain; for me, to look at that image - or watch footage of their terrible dying - is to begin the process of attempting to acknowledge what they went through, to fully know that until minutes before they had been laughing and squabbling and refusing to eat their tea just as my children do, and to value the incalculably precious life that has been stolen from them. 

The media in some countries runs this kind of material as standard, and it leads to charges that people become inured to the horror of violent death. I’m sure that’s the case. The impact of the Times’s front page derives from the rarity of using such an image so prominently. I imagine the team which put that page together agonised about whether to go with that picture, or to use of the more graphic ones, or indeed to show an image of a dead child at all. 

In this country, we don’t face the prospect of being killed in our own homes and streets. We rarely confront the prospect or consequence of violent death. Our unfamiliarity is a privilege - seeing it occasionally, though it’s nothing like living it, makes others’ pain harder to ignore. 

My pain on looking is, by comparison, of no relevance - except, importantly, in terms of what such feelings might galvanise me to do. Looking - and choosing to keep looking - at this kind of image must prompt action, else it becomes not only emotionally devastating but ultimately pornographic and disrespectful.

I've not known what to do for months now, but last Saturday night, I knew I had to do something or I would always be ashamed.

On Sunday 10 June, at noon till 2pm, the 'Stop Killing Children' protest will be held outside the Syrian embassy, 8 Belgrave Square, London. Please join us. Bring your kids. It's not enough. I don't know what is. But doing something must be better than doing nothing. And without me seeing those pictures, this wouldn’t be happening.

Follow protest updates on #stopkillingSyrianchildren and on the Facebook Event page (which includes some of the type of imagery described in this column)

13 comments

MalloryTailor's picture

The whole Syrian massacre reminds me of events that always precede war. All wars require a lie to be told. With the Vietnam war it is the gulf of Tomkin. With the first gulf war it was the Iraqi soldiers throwing Kuwaiti babies out of incubators story (all based on a lie told by the daughter of the Kuwaiti ambassador in Washington). With the second gulf war it was the yellow cake and WMDs. With the Kosovo war it was the non existent concentration camp and the alleged masses graves of civilians. http://www.squidoo.com/best-mixer-reviews

islamophobe's picture

Wogs killing wogs. Who gives a damn? Not me.

Spoba24's picture

You sure they are Syrians? They look like dead Iraqis or Dead Palestinians to me . After all these Arab Islamists Scum bags look the same to me and the BBC.

Antone de Hock's picture

What a curious campaign based on uncoroborated heresay. The whole Syrian massacre reminds me of events that always precede war. All wars require a lie to be told. With the vietnam war it is the gulf of tonkin. With the first gulf war it was the iraqi soldiers throwing kuwaiti babies out of incubators story (all based on a lie told by the daughter of the kuwaiti ambassador in Washington). With the second gulf war it was the yellow cake and WMDs. With the kossovan war it was the non existant concentration camp and the alleged masss graves of civilians. Later turned out they were all combat soldiers. That's what happens in a civil war. Mrs Tickle seems to be falling into that trap whether it is through her own ignorance or she is a party to that lie. The Houla massacre was a false flag attack. It bears all the hallmarks. The massacre of the innocents. Now who would do that I wonder. Government forces or islamic millitant rebels armed and trained with plenty of help from the KLA, by the mad mullahs of Saudi Arabia and the zionists of NATO in unholy alliance. Watch this space. If Assad falls Syria will turn into a unimagined blood bath. See the unreported slaughter of Africans by the Lybian rebels. Watch the massacre of the Christians in Syria and the imposition of an islamic state to rival our 'ally' Saudi Arabia in terms of barefaced brutality. I pity the journalist who lies to further an agenda. They are no longer journalists. They are propagandists for an illegitmate corrupt cornucopia of evil which succesivve governments in this country have clearly demonstrated. Divide and conquer. Maybe in Mrs Tickle's name. Not in mine thank you.

Silican's picture

It was once, allegedly, the case that the first casualty of war was the truth. Maybe it was always thus, but it seems that the first acts of war are now the lies. Lies however have a way of finding you out. First it was the massacre at Houla that was caused by artillery bombardment. Then there weren't enough bodies or horror to run with that lie, so it became the US style (minus uniforms) massacre of individuals at close quarters - slit throats and gunshots to the head - the poster children for war. But war on whom. Now we have a town, supposedly under the absolute control of the Assad government. Completely surrounded with Assad's troops (and his cunningly disguised killers - though why they need disguises is not really clear) free to roam at will and kill every living thing. Everyone in it is dead. But wait. Those fools. They forgot to kill the people who gathered all the bodies, put them on ice and filmed them at their leisure. Then they compounded their unbelievable incompetence and let them out to broadcast this to the world. But Ms Tickle knows that this was done by the Assad regime. How does she know? Well obviously, because Hilary Clinton and Obama, those paragons of virtue (drones don't kill babies do they Ms Tickle) say so and that is good enough for her. Well we all know, or should by now, who suffers when the West starts to write the script or 'sort out' a problem that it creates and then loses control over. The democracy that glows daily in the embers of burning Iraqi bodies, the democracy that grows in Honduras fertilised by the thousands of bodies murdered by US trained, equipped and supported death squads, the democracy that gives such joy to the hundreds of Afghans dying every week so they can bask in the glory of being able to elect an 'Islamofascist' equivalent of Mitt Romney, to borrow the enlightened Western notion of any Muslim who does not think Baywatch is the apex of civilisation. What the success of these lies proves is that ignorance is the most dangerous weapon of mass destruction. And ignorance, as a weapon of mass destruction, is at it most lethal when it is dressed, ever so eloquently, as love. But the love Ms Tickle demonstrates is as blind as it is deadly.

JJJ's picture

A post revealing someone's diseased mind.

melrabang's picture

I have live almost half of my entire life here in the Middle East and what is happening now in Syria is not new to me. I have survived the first the Gulf war in 1991 and have seen the tragic end of Saddam Husein's rule in Iraq through the intervention of the western power. Why is it this time the Western power has suddenly lost its interest in this conflict? Is it because there no money to be made in Syria, because they don't have what Iraq has, "OIL".

how to lose tummy fat fast

JJJ's picture

'Tragic end of Saddam Husein's rule in Iraq' LOL!

Are you normal, or just another propagandist for the Baathists?

melrabang's picture

I have live almost half of my entire life here in the Middle East and what is happening now in Syria is not new to me. I have survived the first the Gulf war in 1991 and have seen the tragic end of Saddam Husein's rule in Iraq through the intervention of the western power. Why is it this time the Western power has suddenly lost its interest in this conflict? Is it because there no money to be made in Syria, because they don't have what Iraq has, "OIL".

how to lose tummy fat fast

Emma Suleiman 's picture

This is not the first massacre by Assad, His father killed entire families in Hama 82 and now since the Syrian revolution started there has been many child massacres in Homs by Assad thugs! Sorry to say that we don't have Islamist in Syria, we have conservative people like another country in the world but the real criminal is Assad and his thus... hence the revolution now!

Emma Suleiman 's picture

This is not the first massacre by Assad, His father killed entire families in Hama 82 and now since the Syrian revolution started there has been many child massacres in Homs by Assad thugs! Sorry to say that we don't have Islamist in Syria, we have conservative people like another country in the world but the real criminal is Assad and his thus... hence the revolution now!

Alya damascus's picture

These crimes has not been committed by the Islamists.. and i am not defending the Islamsits as i am against them too, but one should do some research before starting to point fingers.. The one who commit these crimes are the army of Alasad Regime.. and the reason why is because we are "the Syrian people" demonstrating in the streets against the regime.. and that is not allowed in the prospect of a dictator.. the regime has never been elected before.. been there since 40 years by force.. and the massacre of Hola is not the only one that has been committed by them since they took over the country, they are bunch of gangs and we don't have the freedom even to talk our minds out.. I can bring you lot of documents about the regime crimes and its already known to the whole world.. one of them is the massacre of Hama.. Do your math yourself

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hama_massacre

Frederick.'s picture

So what's new Louise? Islamists have been slaughtering thousands of innocent Hindus, Sikhs, Jews and Christians in exactly the same way for decades.

Latest tweets