Occupation from within: the Arab Bedouin in Israel
At the beginning of this year the Israeli government announced a that will displace more than 70 000 Arab Bedouin from their ancestral lands.
By Rebecca Greig Published 31 August 2012 10:48
The Negev desert is a good place to bury dogs. The dog cemetery of Tsan Yatir provides a final resting place for beloved canines. Arab Bedouin humans are not so lucky. Increasingly they are discovering that the Israeli state has no place for them - dead or alive.
Following the news this week that an Israeli court has ruled the death of ISM activist Rachel Corrie, who was killed protesting the demolition of Palestinian homes in Gaza, to be "a regrettable accident", we should remember it's not only Palestinians living in the Occupied Territories who have come to fear Israeli forces. Israeli citizens are being forced out of their homes by dint of their ethnicity. In September 2011, the Israeli government approved the Prawer Plan for mass expulsion of the Arab Bedouin community in the Naqab (Negev) desert. At the beginning of this year the government announced its plan to establish ten new exclusively Jewish settlements along the Green Line demolishing 35 "unrecognised" villages and displacing more than 70 000 Arab Bedouin from their ancestral lands.
Following a 5am start I made the journey from Ramallah in the West Bank to Be’er Sheva in southern Israel to meet with local Bedouin leaders and Arab Minority Rights group Nadalah who are fighting the Prawer Plan every step of the way. The steps are seldom simple and fraught with the challenges that are inevitable when the state is your enemy. My journey was no exception. To get from Ramallah to the Naqab you have to cross the Green Line. It’s a funny thing the Green Line. At times it is impenetrable: to the Palestinians living in the Occupied Territories she is the Sphinx, devouring those who do not give the answer she requires. To Jewish Israeli citizens she is a sylph, dissolving in the wind whenever political expediency demands it.
Four hours, three buses, one train and a checkpoint later I arrived in the dusty heart of the Naqab to meet with Dr Thabet Abu Rass, the director of the Naqab Project at Adalah, who was keen to emphasise the parity between Arab Bedouin in Israel and Palestinian citizens in the West Bank and Gaza. “This is the occupation within”, he told me. “The state of Israel refuses to recognize them as a legitimate community and deliberately withholds basic services, such as water, electricity, sewage, schools and healthcare”.
Arab Bedouin have been inhabitants of the Naqab desert since the seventh century but have faced a state policy of displacement for over 60 years. Today, 70,000 Arab Bedouin citizens live in 35 villages that either predate the establishment of the State in 1948, or were created by Israeli military order in the early 1950s. The state of Israel considers the villages “unrecognized” and the inhabitants “trespassers on State land,” so denies access to state infrastructure to “encourage” the Bedouin to give up their land and establish new Jewish settlements in their place.
Settlements are not only happening in the Occupied Territories, they are being built in the strategically important area of the Naqab to create a contiguous Jewish bloc south of the West Bank, the only difference being that these settlements are technically legal since they are built within the Green Line.
In an unprecedented move, in July the European Parliament called on Israel to put a hold on these policies of dispossession. According to Rawia Aburabia of the Association for Civil Rights in Israel, "the attempt to enshrine the Prawer Plan into law is a farce… it is a step that takes us back to the military regime." It is hard to object when the Prawer Plan recalls the more absurdist aspects of Joseph Heller’s Catch-22. You have to marvel at the evil genius of a system which demolishes people’s homes and then charges them for it. For the princely sum of 20,000-25,000 shekels (between £3,100 and £3,900) the Israeli government will reduce your house to rubble. This is leading to increasing numbers of “self-demolitions”, when people, threatened with demolition orders, are choosing to demolish their own homes at a personal cost of 15,000 (£2,350) shekels. Last year more than 1,000 houses were demolished and this year there have been over 120 official demolitions with many more self-demolitions.
Attiyah Alathamin, an Arab Bedouin from the "unrecognized" village of Khashem Zane, told me his story. “I built a home for my son and his wife when they got married. Shortly afterwards the Israeli government presented me with a demolition order and rather than pay the 25,000 shekels they were demanding I paid 15,000 to have it demolished myself.” Attiyah’s story is not unique.
Saleem Abu-el-Quian lives in the village of Umm el-Hieran which was established by military order in 1954. The state of Israel considers the some 500 residents to be trespassers and plans to destroy the village and transfer the population to the urban township of Hura in order to establish the exclusively Jewish town of "Hiran" on the ruins of Umm el-Hieran. He tells me that his son received notice of his reserve army duty on the same day that he was given a demolition order on his home. “Our children are fighting in the army and yet we are not getting anything in return. We have no school, no doctor’s clinic”.
The future for the Abu-el-Quian family and Umm el-Hieran is uncertain.
In November 2010, the prime minister’s office cancelled the planning authorities' partial recognition of the village. On 6 September there will be a court hearing in Be’er Sheva to appeal against the demolition order. On 11 September there will be a meeting for the National Committee for Planning and Building to discuss the development of the Jewish settlement of Hiran. Twenty caravans of Israeli settlers are camped out in nearby Yatir Forest waiting to move in.
Dr Thabet Abu Rass is not giving up just yet. "We will challenge it in the courts. We will challenge it on the ground...There is a call for more co-resistance and less co-existence". Nadia Ben-Youssef, a lawyer specializing in Arab minority rights tells me that the Bedouin are tackling the state head-on with the same methods of non-violent resistance used by Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank. “There is a growing belief that you can challenge the state on your feet. Arab Bedouin have told me ‘The government can demolish my home a hundred times, I will rebuild it 100 times. I will not be the one to lose my ancestors’ land’”.
Rebecca Greig is a feature writer for Palestine Business Focus Magazine and a freelance journalist based in the West Bank.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists





















8 comments
It may come as a surprise to some, especially to those who have turned "Israel" as a pass time entertainment activity whereby "Israel" is humiliated, demonize, de-legitimized and its very demise is sought.
Well, this poster is not one who relies on "narratives", i.e. short fictional stories designed for political and masochistic purposes. Fact and rational approach guides me in submitting that the case of the nomadic community in Israel - it just happened to be Arab, but it could be any other theoretically - is one of hundreds, perhaps thousands of similar cases where the modern liberal democratic state, but mostly the industrialized state, tries to usher the nomadic community into modernity.
Reality is that in Israel, for the most part, this process has been fairly successful. Several "Bedouin" (nomad) towns have been in existence for some time in which their residents, gradually, adopt to the "urban" way of life. This is reflected in the economic activities in which families are engaged, in the level of literacy that has been rising dramatically during the past half a century. It is reflected in the fact that members of these societies are found in academe in Israel, in the military, in government at various levels . But, mostly, it is reflected in the structure of the family and the position of each member in it.
It is a process to move away from nomadic way of life that can't sustain a family to life in a properly governed village or town and integrate in the life of the larger society. Some go through it faster, while others still cling to values, material and otherwise, that can't be sustained, especially when what they consider to be "valuable" is legally not theirs, such as vast areas of the land on which they used to roam.
Unless we examine this phenomenon within the proper context of time, place and circumstances, and use all the research tools available to us, what we are going to continue to get from people who pretend to understand this phenomenon is new and improved versions of the "let us hate Israel" pass time activity.....
rebecca grieg has artfully posted a photo of a "poor barefooted bedouin" - why did she not send photos of the beautiful villas and villages springing up - i live in holon in a 5 room flat - one needs to be honest and not distrort the facts
1. the Bedouin regiment loyally guards our southern border and some of the officers and men have been very courageous.
2. Many are now well educated and are doctors, engineers and one is the head of a faculty in beer sheva university.
i teach in Ariel university many arabs, druze and this semester i have a great student from a northern beduin village who proudly told me that all the men serve in the IDF and she also wanted to but her father was wary of "family honor"
your reporters had better find out what is happening in: Syria, Iraq, Pakistan, LIbya, Mali and other areas of democracy and civil liberties.
rebecca grieg has artfully posted a photo of a "poor barefooted bedouin" - why did she not send photos of the beautiful villas and villages springing up - i live in holon in a 5 room flat - one needs to be honest and not distrort the facts
1. the Bedouin regiment loyally guards our southern border and some of the officers and men have been very courageous.
2. Many are now well educated and are doctors, engineers and one is the head of a faculty in beer sheva university.
i teach in Ariel university many arabs, druze and this semester i have a great student from a northern beduin village who proudly told me that all the men serve in the IDF and she also wanted to but her father was wary of "family honor"
your reporters had better find out what is happening in: Syria, Iraq, Pakistan, LIbya, Mali and other areas of democracy and civil liberties.
"Around 300 Bedouins living in Israel's Negev desert have been made homeless after police raided their village and razed their homes.
Israeli activists said 1,500 police arrived in Al-Arakib village at dawn.
They destroyed 30 to 40 makeshift homes and uprooted hundreds of olive trees belonging to the villagers, they said.
Police spokesman Mickey Rosenfeld said the homes had been "illegally built" and were destroyed in line with a court ruling issued 11 years ago.
"Several hundred people were taken back to the Rahat area where they originally came from," he told the AFP news agency, referring to a nearby Bedouin town in Israel's arid south".
bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-10777040
In the Jewish State only Jews are allowed to build illegal settlements on land that does not belong to them with the full approval of their fascist government.
At the moment Arminius it's your Egyptian co-religionist Islamist scumbags that are butchering their co-religionist beduin terrorist friends in the Sinai. Try making sense of that? maybe it's something in your racist homicidal Koran that drives you Islamist madmen to killing each other.
Told you before, I am FCofS and most of my co-religionist live here in Scotland. You give an interesting if disturbing insight into the mindset of an EDL Pakibasher. Arab mistreatment of other Arabs in no way excuses the many excesses of the Israeli state around the World except to Zionist apologists.
Funny how the Islamist NS persists in publishing false anti-Israel propaganda whilst totally ignoring the savage persecution of Christians in Islamist state like fascist apartheid Pakistan ? is the prosecution and incarceration of an 11 year old Christian girl falsely charged with the burning of the racist Koran not a newsworthy topic worthy of coverage?
The Islamist NS????? The BBC has regulary reported Israeli mistreatment of the Bedouin so does this mean that the BBC is now Islamist?