The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Petrol pandemonium

The government has changed its advice, but why did we panic in the first place? A psychologist expla

Petrol pandemonium
Photo: Getty Images

Any rational person in the UK who doesn't want to be left without petrol has probably topped their vehicle up recently or at least thought about doing so. After all, the people running the country, before changing their advice today, had advised drivers to do this, amid fears of a country-wide strike by tanker drivers.

When consumer behaviour changes on a mass scale in this way, the media usually work up a lather, pronouncing that the country is in the grip of "panic buying" or "mass hysteria". In fact, most drivers are behaving calmly, doing the sensible thing based on the information they've received.

The situation began a few days ago when, for political and practical purposes, the coalition government started to publicise the strike threat and talk about the contingency plans they were putting in place. The last thing any government wants is to be blamed for not planning ahead or to be accused of not giving people due warning. By putting contingencies in place and encouraging stockpiling, the coalition also presumably hoped to undermine the potential impact of a strike, thereby dissuading the tanker drivers from fulfilling their threats in the first place.

Unfortunately, the government's early announcements and warnings invoked three of the most powerful principles in the social psychology of persuasion, as outlined by the doyen of the field, Robert Cialdini, Regents' Professor Emeritus of Psychology and Marketing at Arizona State University, in his book Influence: Science and Practice.

The first of these is "authority" - we tend to listen to people we perceive as knowledgeable or having privileged information. Despite the lousy reputation of politicians, when several members of the coalition said repeatedly that fuel could run low, many people believed them and started changing their buying habits.

Second is the "scarcity principle" - we instinctively want what we can't have and value highly that which is rare. Once people started to believe that fuel is in short supply and that it could run out, they immediately wanted it more and were willing to work harder to get it, for example by queuing or taking unplanned detours to forecourts. For other examples of this effect in action, just look at the way parents behave around Christmas time when rumours emerge that a trendy toy is due to sell out; or consider the way Concorde tickets became hot property the moment it was announced the jet would soon fly no more.

The last relevant factor is known as "social proof" or "social norms" and is perhaps the most powerful of all. Time and again research has shown that we tend to look at how other people are behaving (or how we think they're behaving) to help choose how we should behave ourselves. Take the context of binge drinking by university students, where it's been found that most undergrads massively overestimate how much their peers drink and then use this mistaken yardstick to guide their own drinking patterns.

With regard to the fuel situation, many people probably decided that they weren't too concerned and some may still feel that way. But the sight on the news of people queuing for fuel is incredibly compelling. Because it's human nature to copy each other, if we see that everyone else is filling up, we're likely to do the same. Twenty-four hour rolling news online and TV makes this factor more powerful today than ever before.

The net result of all this is that some fuel pumps around the country are running dry even though the strike may not even happen. Of course, lack of fuel in the pumps serves to fuel the news story, creating a self-perpetuating situation - though to call it hysteria or panic is hyperbole. Only now the message has been communicated from trusted sources that there's plenty of fuel, and that most people aren't stockpiling, will normal service likely be resumed.

Dr Christian Jarrett is a psychologist and author of The Rough Guide To Psychology

5 comments

sandi's picture

Downing Street and the Cabinet Office minister Francis Maude were under fire from Tories, senior Liberal Democrats and motoring organisations amid anger that the government had created panic petrol buying across Britain
As queues snaked out of petrol stations around Britain, prompting police in one county to ask for the temporary closure of forecourts, recriminations started flying after Maude's warning earlier this week that lives were being placed at risk by the planned strike by fuel tanker drivers, and that motorists should stockpile petrol klinikpsikis.wordpress.com/

qxeuogmkn's picture

http://valerij-morkovin.narod2.ru/hotihameni.html - утражестан свечи
http://valerij-morkovin.narod2.ru/zimowymofi.html - scania 142 руко
http://sascha-liubomirov.narod2.ru/widaqa.html - швейная машина fif
http://valerij-morkovin.narod2.ru/kofodeqi.html - должностная инструкция сестры-хозяйки терапевтического отделения
http://kladovtzev2012.narod2.ru/nilifoni.html - асус а6р
http://khasanov-roma2012.narod2.ru/wigefe.html - emachines 350 разборка
http://alescha-melnikoff2013.narod2.ru/newepilywo.html - thomson rr65q user manual
http://alescha-melnikoff2013.narod2.ru/waxikome.html - инструкция стиралка general electric
http://kladovtzev2012.narod2.ru/rofecoqesi.html - candy holiday 6
http://gaevsky-semen2012.narod2.ru/pyzoga.html - скачать бесплатно паспорт станка иэ-6009а
http://gaevsky-semen2012.narod2.ru/fytoxera.html - скачать схемы сборки конструктора брикс
http://valerij-morkovin.narod2.ru/negesoma.html - ремонт бцнм 3,5/17
http://trohin-gennadij.narod2.ru/raleboxi.html - ft 857трансивер
http://gaevsky-semen2012.narod2.ru/mecizynixi.html - инструкция по ремонту shtill ms-361
http://valerij-morkovin.narod2.ru/hyfygefi.html - chunghop rm-l968e
http://gaevsky-semen2012.narod2.ru/ximetyhy.html - seven color crystal boll что это
http://khasanov-roma2012.narod2.ru/lalifoxo.html - зитромед инструкция
http://sascha-liubomirov.narod2.ru/lyqice.html - инструкция пользователя hp 625
http://alescha-melnikoff2013.narod2.ru/qepicepati.html - смотреть инструкцию робосапиен
http://kladovtzev2012.narod2.ru/fowipoxi.html - должностная инструкция оператора 1с торговля+склад
http://trohin-gennadij.narod2.ru/cagawezy.html - onkyo tx-sr508 инструкция
http://valerij-morkovin.narod2.ru/fepofiniwy.html - perfect часы инструкция
http://sergey-cravczow.narod2.ru/qoceside.html - siemens siwamat 6143 manual
http://trohin-gennadij.narod2.ru/lemyfehexy.html - инструкция электронных часов
http://sergey-cravczow.narod2.ru/rywewama.html - как поставить навигатор на pioneer da-871
http://valerij-morkovin.narod2.ru/nefefi.html - швейная машинка тула 1
http://trohin-gennadij.narod2.ru/memafiri.html - tacho universal инструкция
http://sascha-liubomirov.narod2.ru/lekemidowo.html - lovato rid.gpl rge090
http://valerij-morkovin.narod2.ru/nimipi.html - t56vitebo01 anleitung
http://valerij-morkovin.narod2.ru/tegecepy.html - инструкция ardo inox 51 43
http://khasanov-roma2012.narod2.ru/fafiti.html - vellez инструкции
http://gaevsky-semen2012.narod2.ru/fazoqidy.html - canon 11121 e катридж
http://gaevsky-semen2012.narod2.ru/mepimi.html - инструкция по ремонту скутера lifan
http://gaevsky-semen2012.narod2.ru/mefohy.html - стенка юниор схема сборки
http://trohin-gennadij.narod2.ru/sodypa.html - инструкция по применению electrolux ehs60210p на русском
http://sascha-liubomirov.narod2.ru/kiqimaqe.html - инструкция gorenje ic 3400 dp
http://sascha-liubomirov.narod2.ru/kehodiwe.html - disassembly fly e135
http://trohin-gennadij.narod2.ru/qopihalawi.html - союз 130ас
http://khasanov-roma2012.narod2.ru/xidetydiby.html - bedienungsanleitung emtec h240
http://trohin-gennadij.narod2.ru/paconoxi.html - инструкция к сони псп 3004
http://alescha-melnikoff2013.narod2.ru/dyfesyhogi.html - скачать бесплатно руководство для пульта penguin rm-969rus
http://khasanov-roma2012.narod2.ru/ryqyborixe.html - инструкция brother xl-4010
http://khasanov-roma2012.narod2.ru/baqologo.html - bruksanvisning bosch wfm 4030
http://alescha-melnikoff2013.narod2.ru/cakyfe.html - aiwa nsx 550
http://kladovtzev2012.narod2.ru/tefefofode.html - сосефен
http://alescha-melnikoff2013.narod2.ru/toranywi.html - должностные обязанности мастера рмм
http://sascha-liubomirov.narod2.ru/kocodo.html - siemens hb86k572 инструкция
http://alescha-melnikoff2013.narod2.ru/micyfazi.html - инструкция на русском ga-8ipe1000-g (rev. 4.x)
http://khasanov-roma2012.narod2.ru/goforelo.html - охрана труда швейная промышленность
http://valerij-morkovin.narod2.ru/caqytilipi.html - silvercrest baby talker бесплатная инструкция

Andrew Chapman's picture

This is quite a good article. Many new questions emerge to the surface, all you need do is to read further information about the issues. Only then one can form a final view on a particular subject. Otherwise everything is seen only in the dimension of how to cum more black and white. The natural logic of pr agentura evaluating things before catering they were properly cognitively processed is a horrible mistake, made by those less intelligent. People should not throw away their common ubytovanie na slovensku sense easily. Anything and everything deserves appropriate time for making judgements.

Niko Holmen's picture

Hi just wanted to say that I like your article very much. Please keep up the good posts Thanks a ton! and Have a good day

skiptonman's picture

very interesting , so basically we are sheep !!

Latest tweets