The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Vince Cable's leaked letter: the reaction

The Business Secretary's harsh criticism of government economic policy hurts because it is true.

In a remarkable leaked letter, the Business Secretary Vince Cable has ripped apart the government's strategy on growth and other key economic policies.

The four page letter (which you can read in full here) was published yesterday by the BBC. Date 8th February and addressed to David Cameron and Nick Clegg, the private letter warns that "market forces are insufficient for creating the long term industrial capacities we need" and says there is "no connected approach across government". In a brutally frank assessment, Cable writes:

I sense however that there is still something important missing: a compelling vision of where the country is heading beyond sorting out the fiscal mess; and a clear and confident message abut how we will earn our living in future... We can be more strategic and the economic backdrop will increase demands that we are ambitious.

He makes several suggestions, the most radical of which is that the majority taxpayer owned Royal Bank of Scotland is broken up to create a "British Business Bank with a clean balance sheet and a mandate to expand lending rapidly to sound business".

But, predictably, it is not Cable's suggestions which have drawn the most attention, but his tough criticism of the way his own government -- and in places, his own department -- have handled the economy. This lays bare tensions in the coalition, at a particularly crucial time as the Budget draws near.

There was some irritation in the Treasury at the timing of the leak, as tense negotiations over the Budget continue. Downing Street and the Deputy Prime Minister's office both downplayed the importance of Cable's intervention, but a range of Conservative MPs - amongst whom the Business Secretary is already unpopular - expressed their annoyance.

Brian Binley, a Tory member of the Business Select Committee, summed up the feelings of many, telling the Times (£):

I am bitterly disappointed that the man put in charge of the growth agenda feels there is a problem with the agenda.

I find him a pleasant person to deal with. But if he is disappointed by the lack of growth, he is in as good a place as anybody in the Commons to make that clear. If he is struggling to do that, perhaps he should step aside and allow someone else to have a go."

Commentators across the political spectrum have been quick to notice that Cable's suggestions -- interventionism, patriotism, and supporting winners -- closely echo Labour's line. Yesterday, Ed Miliband gave a speech on "industrial activism". My colleague George Eaton noted the concordance between the views touted publically by Miliband and Cable yesterday.

This letter will strike a nerve with Tory top command precisely because it is close to the bone. The charge they are most sensitive to is that they have failed to articulate a strategy for growth, or indeed any economic strategy beyond deficit reduction. It is more damaging because it comes from within the government, even if it is from Cable, Liberal Democrat and eternal discontent. Yet, on the other hand, many Conservative commentators are raising the question: as Business Secretary, isn't Cable at least partly responsible for creating this situation? The shadow business secretary Chuka Umunna has been fast to say that the letter shows that "David Cameron and George Osborne have become roadblocks to the modernisation and reform needed to create a more productive economy."

The blame game will continue in Westminster, but outside it is largely irrelevant. What matters is that these criticisms sting because they are founded in fact, and the government does not have any decisive answers.

9 comments

Mel Davis's picture

Lib Dems desperately trying to persuade us that they are doing something in government, when in fact, they are doing NOTHING at all except helping the tories destroy the heart of this country.

Mr Danger's picture

The deficit is the heart of this country? Who knew.

Anton Jury's picture

The deficit is at the heart of many countries all around the world. Many countries all around the world would have been able to sort out their deficits/finances if the greedy banker, financial institutions and others had not have been so dishonest causing the worldwide financial crisis.

Will Slater's picture

I don't buy it

This is all part of the "differentiation" that the Lib Dems are pushing

Just a load of spin

rob andersen's picture

hehe... a few good numbers, a hope that an agreement has neen arrivedv at on Europe and everyone forgets how totally precarious the situation has been for 3 years.
What is it that paramedics do when they arrive on the scene? Stabilise the patient... and now we see questions as to why brain surgery wasn't performad AS WELL!!
Clowns

Mrs.Josephine Hyde-Hartley's picture

"market forces are insufficient for creating the long term industrial capacities we need"

I daresay the forces of the free market move in mysterious ways. Why does it really matter if on the face of it, there is no connected government strategy apparent? Why must officialdom always find ways to count and predict everything that may or may not happen? Why won't officials simply "be told" instead?

I should imagine the great moment of take off, so to speak ,for any exhausted economy will occur when we all stop trying to do what we think the market wants and allow whatever the market wants to be done by us, through us and in us , first. Amen.

Perhaps everyone should stop minding each others business and mind our own business instead..thus allowing the private lives of ordinary members of the public- even the so-called dreaded NEETS - to flourish.

Why not give every person of working age - unless we have retired already - a flat rate universal public benefit - like eg a child benefit - no means testing - so we can do with it whatever we want.

I daresay the economy would breath a huge sigh of relief and chill out - leading to a more natural inclination towards creativity and innovation.

Mr Danger's picture

I live in council housing, collect benefits, send my kids to state school, use the NHS, and expect to retire on a state pension.

The deficit? Nothing to do with me, its the bankers!

Tesco Shelf Stacker's picture

Will Slater - "I don't buy it ... Just a load of spin"

Absolutely, letter was most probably leaked deliberately. It won't be the first time he has been accused of engaging in political spin.

I don't trust the f*ckers an inch!

Fergus Pickering's picture

What fuckers? Any fuckers? Or just this fucker?

Latest tweets