The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Boris, the police and the pre-dawn raid

Heavy-handed, politicised policing leaves our communities less secure.

Boris Johnson with Met police commissioner Bernard Hogan-Howe in September, outside Scotland Yard
Source: Getty Images

A pre-dawn raid under Operation Hawk saw a mother woken by banging and shouting this week. Officers charged into her flat with rolling cameras, bright lights and none other than the mayor Boris Johnson when she was half dressed. They were looking for suspected drugs on her eighteen-year-old son, and they had brought along the BBC to make a high-profile point about it. Safe to say they didn't find what they were after, and left the South London flat without any arrests.

This raid was just one of over 500 actions taken across London on Thursday as apart of Operation Hawk. Led by the new Scotland Yard commissioner Bernard Hogan-Howe, the sweeping crack down came with its own Twitter hashtag and fleet of journalists. It was a perfect opportunity for the new commissioner to make his mark and give Boris some publicity in the process. According to the Met's news feed, some progress was made. Over 200 premises were searched with 278 suspects arrested and 39 weapons seized.

But in a number of areas including Peckham and Chiswick, officers brought back little but damaged community relations. As for bringing along Boris, this was a flagrant and dangerous example of politicising the police.

The night it happened I knocked on the door of the raided flat in Peckham and found the mother still shaken. I explained I was a councillor for the area who lived down the road. She talked off the record to me about her experiences, but didn't want to be quoted. She was shocked with the existing coverage as it was. The BBC reported Boris being asked to wait outside her home because there was a "scantily-clad lady" inside.

Power has no idea how humiliating it can be.

But this is not about whether it was justifiable to break into this particular home. It's obvious that raids are sometimes necessary, and they can't always be expected to deliver results. Many of my constituents continue to complain that the police don't do enough. But to bring along a mayor and a set of camera crews on a raid is unnecessary and degrading. It reduces important police work to a press affair for the mayor, who joked about the need to "bring in the heavies" with a coy smile.

"It was disgraceful," one neighbour outside the Peckham block who has lived there for sixteen years but didn't want to be named told me, "We didn't know what they were doing. Boris has never come here before and now his black land rover was parked up with its tinted windows and they were having a press conference outside here."

"I'm not surprised people were frightened. I've never had trouble in this area but coverage like that gives it a bad name. I don't know what they were doing to be honest. I only found out about it by looking at Youtube when I got to work."

I spoke to a number of other neighbours who said the same thing, most of whom were still understandably frightened and didn't want to speak out. A lady living below the suspected flat opened the door a crack and said the raid woke up her small kids. She said she had never had problems with upstairs before, but raids like that begin to breed suspicion amongst neighbours.

Hogan-Howe said the aim was to "put the doors in as quickly as possible, right around London". He said this could have "positive effects" even when they find nothing. But he underestimates just how corrosive such raids can be in areas that are already suspicious of police. Yes some will be pleased to see action being taken, but many will be left with nothing but the story of a bewildered mother and the signs of a smashed door. They will ask why other methods were not used first, and why different areas with less stereotypes were not chosen for a public raid.

What makes all this even more infuriating is that Boris Johnson is presiding over massive cuts to police numbers. In Southwark we are losing our community police officers and being forced to cut safer neighbourhood teams. Presumably we are going to have to rely on these grand, top-down show cases to offer demonstrations of strength, rather than building community knowledge that is better able to handle these concerns sensitively. If you ask me, this heavy-handed image will leave us less secure in reality. And I still want to know who is going to pay for that door.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

12 comments

Chintoo's picture

Great to see Boris's 'Put In The Door' campaign. Back Boris 2012

I feel much saver in London knowing Boris is fighting crime.

jankaas's picture

delighted to hear the new Scotland Yard commissioner Bernard Hogan-Howe has his own Twitter hashtag.

but will he inhale?

Rowenna Davis's picture

@Swatandra @Ian @Matthew completely agree!

@Politico I completely agree we have to do stories outside of London, and if you google my work you'll see I make every effort to do that. But reporting outside of London doesn't mean ignoring stories when they happen on your doorstep in the capital.

@John I think there is a difference between commenting on a raid reported by the papers after it has happened, which is perfectly justifiable, and walking into a family home with officers and cameras to boost your ratings before an election.

@Jankaas let's hope so!

Nigel's picture

A great piece, going behind that headline that even the BBC treated as though it was under the control of Boris's press office. The heroic police, the quirky but hands-on mayor, and the "others" - the people whose home was smashed in, who are somehow nothing, almost incidental to the story, not anyone any of us are expected to empathise with or think about in other but judgemental terms.

The reality was a politicised police force raiding a home in which no one had committed a crime, and a dilettante politician who treats being mayor as an amusing little hobby.

We need Ken - he may not be perfect but at least we'll never see him bumble into a smashed council flat like it's a Bullingdon Club surprise safari.

swatantra's picture

This Anti Crime Blitz seems to have worked in Merseyside. I bet the residents were pretty relieved to get rid of some of the drugpushers and handlers of stolen goods, and the raids might have trawled in a few terrorists as well which could be an added bonus. The pity is that the drug pushers and pimps will be back in 3 months, because the neighbourhood is powerless or to intimidated to do anything about the villans in their midst.
People who actually live on the Estates will tell you how it really is.
But what was infuriating was the prescence of the blonde mophead ready for any photo op prior to the Mayrial elections.

Ian's picture

I think Boris could pay for the door with the "peanuts" he earns for his Telegraph scribblings.

matthew fox's picture

No one is criticising the police for tackling drug crime, but at the same time, you have to work with the communities.

There is no reason why Boris and the media need to tag along with the police raid.

Drug dealing is a blight and needs sorting, but getting addicts off drugs is just as important.

Andreas's picture

The media and PR are CRUCIAL in any modern, effective policing organisation. Ask Bill Bratton.

This sort of policing is scary and imposing, but it works.

Politico's picture

"Many of my constituents continue to complain that the police don't do enough"

These would be comments made by a parliamentary member not a district councillor. You are not there yet Rowenna.

The Labour Party is suffering from a bout of LLL "Lets Listen to London syndrome.
London is not solely Labour. It is a convenience for those to enter politics who use the city as a convenience to pretend they are Labour to get on.

The Oxford education gives it away somewhat.

I wish to make this clear. It would be sensible for any bloggist or columnist to be aware of the community in which they serve. However there is a whole world outside London. The News Statesman must ensure that the articles reach out to all society in the UK and the wider community not just Peckham and not just a convenience in reaching into the good books of Red Ken.

Livingstone should now wind up and give somebody else the chance of going for Mayor. If this is the best candidate that Labour have in London. There are problems in the Labour Party.

What Rowenna should be investigating is why the Labour Leader and the Labour shadow cabinet is quite happy to support Occupy London whose protesters include unemployed can't work won't work, benefit claimants, anarchists, evidence lately of needle users, alcoholic and smokers, et al but will not public support hardworking families with values, law abiding citizens who have not the time to protest, over their pensions.

The unions will turn off from Labour unless he comes out and supports the stance over pensions.

WHY ARE YOU NOT TALIKING ABOUT THAT??

Politico's picture

Thank you Rowenna. To be fair you do practice what you preach with reference to serving the community in which you reside. This is to be commended.

Do do you know if you google or twitter you will find evidence of individuals now practising and doing less preaching.

Sometimes the media can change the way our representatives behave and perform. Every little helps.

A personal apology from preachers goes a long long way to moving forward.

A something for something society or more of the same. Thats the the choice.

Well done Rowenna

Politico's picture

For a local issue it is not a bad article

John P Reid's picture

YEs boris playing to the galleries by attending these raid, but it's not political policing, know loads of Labour councillors who are aware of raids in their areas that the local press are attending, go along for the photo oppurtunity, surely the polce who want the communities support use teh pres sin this sense and us as teh electorate who want to know if teh Police are doing a good job, read these papers, If Rowenna wants ot criticise political policing , criticise either LVINGSTONE WASTING MONEY or Boris taking police from outer london to inner london

Latest tweets