The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Britain's most important relationship is now with Germany

David Cameron should have paid more attention to European diplomacy and been nicer to Angela Merkel

I mentioned in my column this week that Nick Clegg had been despatched to Brussels to work his polyglot, Euro-expert "Heineken" act - reaching the diplomatic parts other ministers cannot reach. An important part of that process, I gather, is trying to steer the UK's EU partners away from radical treaty change in response to the single currency crisis.

As I've written before, the ultimate demand the markets seem to be making of the eurozone is that Germany stand behind the troubled southern states be deed more than word. That certainly means tougher rules inside the eurozone; it probably also means institutional harmonisation - the "remorseless logic" of deeper fiscal integration that George Osborne has talked about.

But if that turns into a massive EU treaty re-negotiation (or even a less than massive one), Conservative Eurosceptics would demand that David Cameron threaten to wield a veto and demand "repatriation of powers" in return, and possibly a full renegotiation of Britain's EU status. Any new EU treaty would also be subject to powerful demands for a referendum - and not just in the UK. It could trigger a process that might unravel the Union. Not surprisingly, Clegg doesn't like the sound of this. He is a genuine pro-European and he also knows that a treaty renegotiation would put an intolerable strain on coalition relations. There was a passage in his speech on Wednesday that got less attention than it deserved, I thought:

I fully support the goal of better oversight, but I also feel that it is right to caution against returning to the EU's founding texts without first seeing if we can meet these objectives through other means. Our priorities are stability and growth - and they are urgent. To sit around tables for months on end, agonising over this article or that one, becoming engulfed in endless institutional introspection, would be a huge political distraction from the economic task at hand. The danger is that fixating on the treaties will obscure what is really needed. Treaty change should not be a surrogate for political will.

That is the public version. In private I'm fairly sure Clegg will be more explicit with his continental partners about the dangers that a new treaty would pose in terms of stoking up destructive Europhobia back home.

The key relationship here is with Germany. It is the Germans who will want to see the euro made stable with serious rules-based institutional reform as the quid pro quo for putting their domestic finances on the line and for allowing the ECB to betray (as Berlin sees it) the sound money traditions of the old Bundesbank, printing money for a bail out. One official I spoke to says the German cabinet is talking about "pretty ambitious" treaty changes. But a source close to the Deputy Prime Minister says they can be persuaded otherwise.

Either way, Britain's future relationship with the European Union more than ever now relies on the effectiveness of our diplomatic relations with Germany.

A final thought: Knowing all this, I wonder if David Cameron ever regrets pulling the Conservative party out of the European People's Party grouping in the European Parliament. It was a gesture to appease his party's sceptics and a commitment he made in order to be elected Tory leader. He must have thought at the time it was a free hit. (He wasn't then much interested in Europe, thinking the whole issue was toxic and best avoided.)

But Angela Merkel was very angry at the move - her CDU party is in the EPP and she felt snubbed by the Tories' formation of a different group with some decidedly marginal, smaller and more nationalistic European parties. It took quite a lot of effort to persuade the German Chancellor that Cameron was a mature European politician who understood how the EU actually worked. Diplomats and ministers will privately admit that the decision to quit the EPP cost the Tories - and by extension the UK - influence in Europe. There was, for example, a dinner for senior EPP figures on the eve of the last emergency European Council summit. On the guest list: Jose Manuel Barosso, Angela Merkel, Nicholas Sarkozy, Herman van Rompuy ... and no one from Britain.

12 comments

SantosRenard's picture

The Left's curious embrace of the EU (reminiscent of the Left's curious embrace of Stalinism) needs to come to an end. The Conservative Eurosceptics might not be your favourite people, but they were right about the Euro being bad economics and they are right about the EU being antidemocratic. http://www.widecalfboot.org/

Anthony's picture

I'm a proud little englander , Up the little englanders !!!! Rejoice in are little island country a country thats given the world so much, all with are little englander mentality, LONG LIVE LITTLE ENGLAND !!!!

matthew fox's picture

England isn't little, but it does have a lot of small minded people.

Cameron's playing a hand badly, surprise, surprise.

Lox's picture

Pro-European is a pretty debased phrase, isn't it? It seems to be used as a synonym for pro-EU. There's a real arrogance there that identifies the interests of the EU with those of Europe. The former is the manifestation of the dogma that increasing integration of European political, social and economic cultures is inevitably good, and the latter means nothing if it doesn't mean the people of Europe-most of whom approve of a few common cultural fundamentals (secularism and universal suffrage, for example: which by themselves differentiate Europe from much of the rest of the world) but still have a commitment to their nation states. That Europe is stronger than the EU, thankfully. Whether it's this year, or in five or ten years, the whole stinking, elitist, anti-democratic mess will fall apart.

Shinsei67's picture

It would be nice to think that in such dangerous times Merkel didn't concern herself greatly with a (stupid) decision Cameron had to take for purely domestic purposes.

Luddite's picture

Let's stop navel-gazing and start thinking globally. Or... there again, we could always take little Europeans attitude such as Nick's, and keep pretending Europe matters!!

Adam's picture

Nick Clegg and readers of this publication (see this poll in 2008: http://www.newstatesman.com/polls/1401) would have had us join the Euro, which no living person now thinks was good economics or would have been a good idea. So let's eat a bit of humble pie, no?

The Left's curious embrace of the EU (reminiscent of the Left's curious embrace of Stalinism) needs to come to an end. The Conservative Eurosceptics might not be your favourite people, but they were right about the Euro being bad economics and they are right about the EU being antidemocratic.

Anglea Merkel and Germany have far bigger problems than David Cameron not being nice. They're living out the nightmare scenario that we could easily have found ourselves in, a scenario which the supra-national EU institutions are woefully inadequate to handle and which is threatening to pull under Italy and now France.

The EU committed itself and all European economies to a course of action which has ended in the question: revolutionary integration (and loss of national sovereignty) or the abyss? This integration cannot morally happen without treaty changes and those treaty changes cannot happen without democratic ascent. (It is unlikely that Germany itself, with its constitutional court's approval needed, will agree to the changes needed). So Clegg asking not to rock the boat is besides the point, the boat is going under: small change is not an option, it's time to abandon ship.

Ste's picture

David, German politicians are behind Tobin Tax and everybody knows it is very dangerous for the city.

You have to deal asap and conservative Eurosceptics will ruin us, if we are out of EU. act now.

Francis Codjoe's picture

The fact is both Cameron and Clegg are not well informed on European integration. They have no clue why the EU exists. Had these political pygmies done their homework, they would have learnt that the EU is doomed. Because European leaders have ignored the crucial advice Schuman and Adenauer offered to them concerning the survival of the European project. Secondly Cameron and Clegg would also have discovered that it was a brilliant British lawyer - the Prince of Scotland Yard - who wrote about EU - how it would develop its character and future prospects even before Monnet and Schuman - the french founding fathers of EU - were born in 1888 and 1886. The Prince warned Britain would become a province of Europe and would not be sasved if Britain joined a confederation of European nations which would develop through a great European crisis. Everuything he wrote about EU has cvome to pass. Had Cameron examined the works of this British Plice Officer, the Eurozone crisis would no have surprised him. Rather it would have conmvinced him to withdraw Britain from the EU. The Prince described the EU – ‘the vile confederacy of the latter days’ . He has been proved righty.
The British are fed up with selfish and unprincipled politicians. Cameron and Clegg must stop treating us like fools. Why are they persisting that we should remain in the crooked and anti-democratic EU? If they are intelligent and well informed on EU, they must make their argument in a popular debate not resorting to flimpsy excuses to drag Britons into the doomed European Titanic. Merkel herself has no idea why the EU developed from the ashes of the Second World War. The Germans and the French must carry on with ther project to its doom.

Awake!'s picture

agreed- we do a lot of business with the germans, and it's this high end transactions that's going to deliver high end jobs.
Cameron had to make a stand , and in the world of real politik i don't think Merkel will remember She would be pretty pissed off if we'd had a referendum just at this time though, if we'd driven the nail in th coffin of europe- hell, they might even have chucked us out of the common market- NOT a good thing. So he's walking a fine line, and it's just about right- the seeds of europes downfall are already sewn, let it implode by itself, all the while being supportive, so that in the ensuing order we're right there at the centre of it, no one able to blame us for their farcical execution of an 'integration'.

swatantra's picture

As my dad used to say: always be nice to people, because you never know when you may need to borrow money off of them.
Dave and euroskeptiks, please note.

Luddite's picture

My beautiful mother, always said to all her children. "Always look for the good in people and try to forgive the bad".. swatantra nandanwar. The time of borrowing and living beyond ones means is over. She also told me that....

Latest tweets