Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Will Cameron's deal with Merkel placate his party's sceptics?

German agreement to relax the working time directive is a real concession but maybe Tory backbenchers just want confrontation

An outline is emerging of a deal between David Cameron and Angela Merkel over plans to revise the treaties that underpin the European Union.

It appears that over lunch at the end of last week, two leaders discussed the possibility of Britain refraining from serious obstruction to German plans for new rules governing how euro member countries manage their budgets. In exchange, Germany would not object to Britain seeking relaxation of the working time directive - the EU-wide regulations designed to limit the number of hours per week employees work and protect entitlements such as paid leave.

Leaving aside the question of whether Britain would really be better off or happier with a more dilute version of the directive (the UK already has the right to opt out of aspects of it) and looking purely in terms of what is diplomatically feasible for the UK, this seems like a decent compromise. Britain is not a euro member country and already has a reputation for surly reluctance when it comes to the "European project". The way the European debate has unfolded in Westminster in recent weeks has left our continental partners in no doubt that we do not see ourselves as integral players in the EU game. We want concessions on "repatriation of power" - largely so that the prime minister can show symbolic trophies to an implacably euro-phobic wing of his party - and must threaten to be obstructive in order to get them.

For countries that are in the euro and for whom the debate about fiscal integration and more rigorous rules of enforcement is existential, Britain's implicit threat to hold the process hostage must be classified somewhere on a spectrum between absurd and vindictive. David Cameron surely understands this (no doubt Merkel made it clear). He cannot veto a new EU treaty incorporating new eurozone rules without very seriously damaging Britain's diplomatic relations on the continent. What he needs is some kind of concession that is big enough to look like a loosening of ties with Brussels so that, when a revised treaty is agreed by the European Council, Tory backbenchers don't go berserk and demand a referendum on it.

The Working Time Directive is a good candidate. The Tories have always hated European influence on labour protection. Conveniently, the Lib Dems are also hostile to this particular bit of European regulation, so there is no risk of coalition tension. Merkel can be relaxed about it since it is marginal to her concerns and has no immediate bearing on budget discipline in the euro zone.

So the big question is whether it would be enough to persuade Tory backbenchers that Cameron is honouring his pledge to use treaty negotiations as the vehicle for repatriation of powers. If they sneer at this deal and insist that the Prime Minister go back for more, it would suggest that compromise is not really on their agenda at all and what they are really after is a kind of show-down that would make Britain's participation in EU structures as currently configured impossible.

Tags: Europe

9 comments

matthew fox's picture

Cameron and Osborne haven't done an honest day's work in their lives.

I wonder if Inbrew has found that article showing Lagarde and the credit rating agencies criticising public sector pensions.

Awake!'s picture

@ Vasey
didn't quite understand your argument as to why the govt should put a limit on how many hours i should work. In the meantime, enjoy your fantasy world where everyone can do less than the minimum required to maintain a decent welfare state which then needs to be funded by borrowing.

Des Demona's picture

@Vasey

In time you will discover there is such a thing as irony.

Arturo Bandini's picture

Why stop there? Surely the Tories can offer some other small compromises in exchange for the return of indentured servitude and child labour?

What else would we be prepared to give up to keep the Tory right haapy? Let's abolish trial by jury and instead give localism a boost by allowing mobs to burn paedos in the streets.

Time to "think outside the box". Come on Compassionate Conservatives, you can do it!

Des Demona's picture

I would gladly be told by my employer that I have to work longer hours or I will be replaced with someone who will rather than having some Frenchman telling me what to do!

Well done David Cameron - a tremendous boost for us workers. That's showing those Frogs and Krauts. I wonder, while you're at it could you get rid of those pesky ECHR do-gooders?
I would gladly have my humsan rights violated rather than be told what to do by a Frenchman.

Indu Pendent's picture

Great. British are natural grafters: other Europeans dont understand us.

So UK people who dont want to work extra time or give up some of their holidays are free not to.

But for most other UK people, if we want to try a bit harder for our kids we are allow to without the French telling us they will let us do to serve their own national ineterest.

John Angle's picture

Call me Dave, sadly never follows through with anything.

Have a nice one.. http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=ov8FeODxyXU

Awake!'s picture

'We want concessions on "repatriation of power" - largely so that the prime minister can show symbolic trophies to an implacably euro-phobic wing of his party '
Really- u don't think that generally the average joe dosen't want this as well??

And merkel is happy to concede here- why do u think that is?? As her pawns begin to shape her empire u don't think that reform to this dumb rule might suit her as well?? (yawn)
Asd Indu points out, if people want to work harder and longer for whateer reason, shoudn't they be allowed to?
It was a stupid law in the first place- if people don't want the hours, don't apply for the job, surely- I mean we're talking 8 hours a day here, it's not slavery is it. It was akin to greec e joining the euro.
Dumb law, sweeties for voters to support the gravy train of euroland MP's-see where it has left us...

Mr Vasey's Nasal Gravy's picture

Trolls- (Indu Pendent, Awake and Des Demona) If you are school children, your comments are forgivable as, in time, you will discover that there is a world beyond the end of your nose. You may also discover that some rules are there for a reason. In the meantime, enjoy your fantasy world where everyone can work tirelessly for a pittance at the whim of benevolent employers who have nothing but their best interests at heart.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets