Saving capitalism? The price could be democracy
Greece is faced with severe austerity measures. Why shouldn't its people have their say?
By Richard Morris Published 05 November 2011 10:11
Right now everyone seems to be getting terribly excited about saving capitalism. Which is fair enough, in the face of global meltdown.
However, it seems to me that the price of saving capitalism is increasingly likely to be "democracy". Which would be a shame as I'm a big fan of democracy. On the whole, I think it's a good thing.
"What insight," I hear you cry, "what understanding of the basic tenants of human rights".
No? Well, consider this.
Let's start with Occupy London (or Wall Street, Oakland, Tunbridge Wells, wherever). Apart from the fact that some folk think they make the place look a bit untidy, the main issue people have with the Occupy crowd is "that they don't have any answers".
They have a list of things they don't want -- but not a list of things they do.
And I say, so what? What's wrong with just asking the questions? The Occupy folk aren't standing for elected office, nor claiming to be able to solve the problems of the global economy. The finest economic minds in the world, plus George Osborne, haven't cracked that one. So it seems a bit unreasonable to expect some bloke in a tent who just thinks that taxpayers' money shouldn't be shuffled through to bankers in the form of bonuses, to then have all the answers to the greatest economic crisis since the 1930s. If it was that easy, we'd all just pop into Millets and seek the opinion of the man on the till.
We'll ask the questions. It's the job of our elected elders and betters to answer them.
And now it would also seem we're not allowed to mark our representatives' homework either. Hence every democratically elected politician in the world goes white as a sheet at the thought of asking the Greek people if they're happy with the deal done on their behalf.
Funnily enough, I'm not a huge fan of referendums at the drop of a hat. I rather like Edmund Burke's view of democracy: "Your representative owes you, not his industry only, but his judgment; and he betrays, instead of serving you, if he sacrifices it to your opinion."
But there's a time and a place for everything. And when years of extreme austerity measures stretch out before a population, pensions are slashed, public spending is squeezed, every ministry has an independent "observer" installed from Brussels, and none of it ever featured in any sort of manifesto proposal -- well, asking the people if they are up for it doesn't seem so bad? Does it?
So, we seem to be in a world where asking questions without knowing the answers, or questioning the answers you've been given, is seen as a thoroughly bad thing. Which to me is an affront to democracy.
Still, at least no-one's raising the spectre of war or postulating about the chances of a military coup to force things through.
Oh? Lordy.
Richard Morris blogs at A View From Ham Common, named Best New Blog at the 2011 Lib Dem Conference.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















31 comments
Democratic Socialism were markets are regulated and wealth is distributed to the many is the only way forward. Unelected technocrats are only a small step away from facist dictatorship.
I havent heard anyone talk about abolishing the "fractional reserve banking" system yet......
Surely that should be top of the list and will make a big difference
Spot on.
I'll take Good Democracy over Bad Capitalism every time.
Maybe, just maybe, we need a global meltdown to force a change .. not for this generation for whom it will be a terrible disaster, but for generations to come.
Too much wealth and power is concentrated in too few hands. If that fact can be acknowledged by the majority change will come when they reject it.
I would rather save democracy!!!!
Sorry for the weekend pedantry, but surely it should be "the basic tenets of human rights", and not "tenants", unless human rights are now occupied too? Thanks for the article...
Why hasn't it occurred to anyone that the Greek Prime Minister may have simply had the most rare of commodities among politicians - integrity. As soon as I heard the news that his cabinet colleague, the Minister of Finance, perhaps the most important regarding this particular question, had 'changed his mind' overnight, the first thing that occurred to me was someone had got to him. The entire cabinet had been behind the Prime Minister on the day he announced his intention to put the issue to those he represents by referendum. Then, suddenly, overnight as we listened to tales of how livid and furious the world-saving heroes of Germany and France were at the audacious temerity and gob-smacking ingratitude of the Greek buffoon to do the requisite knee-fall and grovel as appropriate the next morning his Finance Minister had 'changed his mind'.
I can't help wondering if in deliberations around the cabinet table Mr. Pompandreou hadn't inspired his colleagues to believe his people, if given a choice, might choose to turn their backs on their masters, accept severely reduced standards of living taking them back some fifty years to a time when they should have started working harder and smoking less, roll up their sleeves, put their shoulders to the wheel, stop contemplating their navels and mixing metaphors, and get on with the collective hard work required to turn their nation around and become something they could be proud of.
The problem with that idea is that it stinks of a statesman's gamble and a statesman to a politician is an intolerable phenomena. Why do you think there haven't been any since Ghandi? It makes everyone look bad - sets the bar too high. I wonder, I just wonder, if, while the heroes were all furious and livid, someone didn't approach Mr. Pompandreou's Finance Minister and say, 'Hey, look - this is all very fine and well and you could make history as the first country to sort yourselves out, thus leading the way bla, bla, bla, but wouldn't you rather have some money?' Everyone has their price, apparently. I wonder how much it would have cost Merkel and Sarkozy to get the Finance Minister to change his mind?
I cannot believe the vitriolic rascism being spouted by B.SMALL above.
I am not Greek but am still offended by such hateful bile.
B SMALL - tell me, have you ever visited the planet Earth?
In 1968 a French worker in his 50s was heard to say, 'I've been waiting since 1936 for this opportunity to come again. I never knew I'd have to wait so long.'
I know exactly how he felt. Let's not throw away this opportunity to push capitalism over the cliff now we've got the chance. Especially as it's already done half the job for us.
B. SMALL - the person who uses CAPITALS to make his/her predictable boss-class opinions sound ORIGINAL. They're the small change of the Rotary Club B. SMALL. They're what the chaps say at the golf club.
Livers, it's hardly racism. Let's face it, the Greek public sector is overmanned, bloated, inefficient and overpaid, mainly as a constitutional requirement. Such a featherbedded welfare state is hardly likely to vote for austerity and hard work, despite its absence being the main reason for the Greek crisis, not the banker boogyman, nor capitalism either.
Nice blog.
Shame about B.Small...the trolls get everywhere these days. (Sits back and waits for next uppercase onslaught, which won't get read, either)
B.SMALL - You should be ashamed for your blatant xenophobia and racism. It is offensive, inflammatory and unhelpful.
Livers - You cannot be offended by B.SMALL's writing since it was not directed at you, but you can, however, find it offensive. Playing the 'offended' card dilutes the effect on those who are actually i the position to be offended, ie the Greeks (and Japanese and Americans, to a lesser extent).
I think we have to acknowledge that the game is up for capitalism, at least in its current form. Greed is not good, and an economic model where we are all in hock to the banks and the nebulous 'markets' is unsustainable. Just like the protesters, I do not know what the answers are, but I do know that what we have at the moment is broken and we need a model of economics which is realistic. Unfortunately for us in the UK (and, truth be told, in every other country in the world) we are ruled by those who represent only the 1% and their associated vested interests.
Parasite. 'Boogyman'? You mean as in "Sunshine, moonlight, good times."? Nothing wrong with some boogie ;-)
the rule of capital and markets is incompatible with popular rule: the idea that the Greek demos could have a say in arrangements made for them by their lords and masters provoked outrage among the elite.
The spin opinion makers put on this is fascinating to watch: last night the tv news did a vox pop from Athens, reporting that "many people" were worried that a referendum would result in a 'no' vote.
Livers, whilst agreeing that B Small should go and rest in a small dark room for a while, hopefully airtight!
The sad fact is that in all my travels I've never met any people as adept as doing as little as possible except for cash. They really do have to realise that they now have to join the rest of us in our belt tightening.
@Ranting Lunatic - "the lazy, starve and die, the industrious live well and long in china and russia"
You want to subject people to the laws of evolution? Do away with society altogether, and any principle of collective co-operation, and let the strong survive and the weak perish? That's fair enough, but let us do away with all law. I fancy my chances against an investment banker on a level playing field. Don't you understand we have socialism already, but it's only for the rich (bailouts anyone?). The poor are told to fend for themselves in the capitalist utopia.
"all of them show the sacrifice that WHITE-ANGLO-SAXON-CULTURED MEN AND WOMEN MADE"
Do you know how many Indians died in that war you historically illiterate moron? Do you know how many Africans, people in the Arab states, Chinese, and others who were not white fought and died for your freedom to spout such ignorant garbage?
The "FACTUAL REALITY" of your "proclaimations" are more like the bizarre rantings of someone sporting a sandwich board and a bout of delusionals caused by severe psychosis. If this is indeed the case I mean no sarcasm when I say I feel empathy with your plight.
Reall good article. What on earth is this guy doing in the Lib Dems?!
The Greeks should have been given a referendum. It is often remarked that the Greek political class is reviled. This is because it is seen as being the tool of the European elite.
Which of course it is.
http://representingthemambo.wordpress.com/2011/11/03/shocking-news-from-...
B.SMALL-MINDED wrote:
[quote]I am your WORST NIGHTMARE, an old Anglo- Saxon engineer,
Who has watched his country, trying to recover from the GERMANS AND THEIR BESTIAL REGIME[/u]
A bit later this was followed by:
[quote]Get yourself an EDUCATION IN HISTORY[/u]
Well, my understanding of history is that the Angles and Saxons were both tribes that came from the land that is now Germany, so feel free to pop over to the motherland at any time to spout your drivel to your own Germanic people whom you are so proud to be one of yet simultaneously hate.
Failing that, do take care when handling fireworks tonight. You're the last of a dying breed, and we all need someone who inspires us to never be like them.
PS. Engineers really are my worst nightmare. I don't like spanners.
B.SMALL HAS A SMALL DICK. I SHOULD KNOW AS I LOOK AT IT EVERYDAY, AND HE LETS ME TOUCH IT.
What is ironic is all these anti-European Brits demanding a referendum to get out of the EU and being outraged at the audacity of a Greek PM proposing a referendum to his people before they embark on an era of extreme austerity.
Obviously democracy, that was invented by them, does not apply to the Greeks. What hypocrisy!
The people who rants against the Greek people speak out of total ignorance.Their image of Greece is a tourist resort as I doubt they ever ventured in the real Greece and met real people. For their information, the Greeks are people who work extremely hard, some of them have 2 or 3 jobs to make ends meet.Coming from a nation who have millions of people who have never worked a day in their lives but prefer to live on benefits, your judgement of other people is disgusting and stinks of hate and pure xenophobia.Britain is such a hard working country that it has to import immigrants to do jobs the natives won't do.
British tolerance, another big myth.
And I am not referring to the nutter B.SMALL, but to other commenters who seem to agree with his sentiments somehow.
Why is it that racism is now finally unacceptable but that xenophobia remains OK. If you replaced the word "Greek" with the word "black" or "African" everybody would realize how odious those comments above really are.
Xenophobia towards other Europeans is now the refuge of racists who get away with the most outrageous comments because they talk about other white people.Why is that OK?
Where is that new moderation policy NS?? Why is it that in that policy you have provision for "racism" "homophobia" "misogyny" but not "Xenophobia"?
HELLO!!! Who lied about the state of their finances before joining the Euro club.. Who avoids paying £22 billion per year tax. This isn't about Xenophobia this is about bad and irresponsible government.
It's that time again when elimination of capitalism as a totally failed system is being seriously discussed for the first time in nearly a hundred years, but let's not forget, it's essential we understand that Marxism or socialism are NOT!! viable options. Both have failed miserably in the recent past because they are unworkable systems of societal coordination.
The referendum would have been smart, the people could have decided if they were willing to accept austerity with bailout cash and stay in euro or default, either way the people would have decided and it would have made future planning easier.
@Luddite
Who said anything about Marxism?
Capitalism is failing badly. Getting that acknowledged is the first huge step, then we might want to understand why it is failing.
Once that has happened we can move onto alternatives or improvements.
These things take time, hell, its taken 100 years just to get a public dialogue focussed on the problem.
The Greeks shouldn't have to pay taxes to support their state infrastructure, that's the job of taxpayers in more affluent countries like the UK. Greek tax evasion is morally acceptable, UK tax avoidance isn't.
Before I even looked at the comments my first thought was end fractional reserve banking, this is the basis of this mess, however bankers with the assistance of politicians and the financial markets have done other greedy things beside this which has increased the rate of debt and theft of the public's money, also the lack of democracy is what has got us into this mess not the other way round. Love to everyone and pay attention to the new unelected leaders of Italy and Greece they have strong banking ties......
Governments of National Unity have a pretty poor track record: a) they aren't democratic, decrease accountability and by their very nature stifle open debate b) they usually involved politicians stitching up the population and c) traditionally end up with the nation united against them.
So people of Greece watch out! this new government won't be working for you but for nick and angela.
Livers your right, your fucking right, but where is your alternative?
Working people are in the main indifferent, we are too busy working long hour's making end's meet.. to be engage in left-wing middle-class concerns.
The problem with Greece is that all the population had to vote for was a choice between the most politically corrupt government in the EU or the second most. The third being Italy.
Greece is the cradle of democracy, but they have been sold a dummy by their political class who made huge bucks from entry to the Eurozone, knowing that though disaster lay down the line, thay wouldn't be the ones ultimately paying for it.
Much like our own dear banking system.
Oh and for those involved in the protests at St Pauls? Good on you!