PMQs sketch: This was the crimson tide personified
Ed M's questions turned the perma-tanned PM into a red-faced bad temper on legs.
By Peter McHugh Published 30 November 2011 17:49
The Prime Minister's plea for people to bring their children to work on strike day did not fall on deaf ears in the House of Commons, which packed both Government and Opposition benches with them for a juvenile version of PMQs.
As the nation's pubic sector workers froze their bits off in demonstrations all over the country, this group on the public payroll gathered in the warmth of the Chamber to offer either support, or a Baroness-Trumpington-salute to the strikers.
You could tell the world had moved on -- in the 24 hours since they, and we, were told we were on our way to hell in a handcart -- by the absence from the event of yesterday's chief-gloomster, Chancellor George. One wondered if he had taken advantage of the lack of passport control staff to flee the country and certainly, the presence in his place on a school day of chief secretary Danny Alexander only added to the air of unreality.
But the real import of the absence of George was to be seen on the effect to his friend the Prime Minister, suddenly on his own in front of the brutish hordes of Labour with only Danny and Nick Clegg to hold him up -- the job usually done by George with a strategically placed hand.
With his best pal apparently on the run, Dave lost it big time and so spectacularly that at one stage it looked as if the Prime Minister's head would be delivered literally to the strikers.
Lift Off came within minutes of the whistle blowing. All eyes were on Ed Miliband who had found himself in difficulties of his own in recent weeks, trying to condemn whilst supporting the strikers.
Ed did it cleverly again today by managing to be on both sides at once, taking the moral high-ground. Dave is not a big fan of cleverness, and proceeded to greet it by transforming himself in front of our eyes from a normal perma-tanned PM into a red-faced finger-stabbing bad temper on legs. He was aided in this endeavour by the massed voices of the Tory choir up on the terraces, who love it when their man shows his true boot-boy colours.
Ed was "irresponsible, left-wing and weak," said Dave, as he reminded the Labour leader he had been less than consistent on the strike. Obviously stung by the charge of being left-wing, Ed drew his own finger from its scabbard and tried to poke Dave's eye out over the Despatch Box.
The Labour side accompanied their leader's cut and thrust with further cries of "crimson tide"; the description flung at the PM as new and deeper hues emerge from his shirt collar as his over-excitement increased.
This was enough to bring Speaker Bercow to his feet for the first of many occasions during the session, as he accused the Tory side of "orchestrated barracking" -- a charge that made Labour increase its volume clearly seeking the same compliment.
Both leaders continued to swap insults with the Prime Minister, happy to point out more than once that the pension proposals leading to today's strikes had been drawn up by former Labour Minister Lord Hutton.
Any hope that the PM might get a grip on himself totally disappeared when his personal red rag Ed Balls joined in by calling on him to calm down. Had he not had guy ropes secretly attached, Dave might clearly have left the floor at that moment. With Ed B's head nodding so furiously that you feared it too could take off, Ed M said Plan A had failed; the poorest were picking up the bills, and never again could he say we were all in this together.
There were rare moments of light relief. A historical time-warp called Jacob Rees-Mogg got up to languidly opine that Dave should follow Ronnie Reagan's modern approach to trade unions and sack the strikers. Even Dave ignored him.
The PM revealed his own staff were helping break the strike leaving some wondering if George really had been smuggled out of the country. By now the Speaker had been on his feet more times than the Leader of the Opposition, and so PMQs destined to end at 12.30pm to give MPs a chance to get as decent seat for lunch.
Amber Rudd got in just before the menus to ask Cameron to condemn Labour MPs who he said had asked permission of the GMB union to cross a picket line outside the Commons to attend PMQs.
Outside, the strikers got out their sandwiches and wondered what all the noise had been about.
Peter McHugh is the former Director of Programmes at GMTV and Chief Executive Officer of Quiddity Productions.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















21 comments
I do believe if Jacob Rees Mogg stood for Mayor of London tomorrow he'd win hands down. Londoners love a toff and a bounder, the more vacuous the better.
May be worth noting that mid-rage Cameron told an outright lie:
"It is this Government who have... introduced free nursery care for two, three and four-year-olds."
No it didn't. Labour introduced the Nursery Education Grant for 3-4 yr olds in 1997
See http://thoughcowardsflinch.com/2011/11/30/is-this-camerons-biggest-pmqs-...
Cameron A cheap Tesco wine in a goblet of old gold.
Ed Miliband jumping on the popular Bandwaggon of the day as usual!
It is quite bad hiding behing hard-working people with fake horror at all the cuts you ruined the economy, did not regulate the banks and you created the non-jobs in the public sector they have no shame
I suppose it is the Lesser of two evil's today as they have no economic credibility it is a case better Red then politically dead Ed doesnot wish to be insignificant even if Ed Balls is.
Give over Bonwick-Jones, you are as usual the ever crushing ill-informrd total bore.
I know you just hate when Cameron shows his true lying arrogant colours. Perhaps the opposition should change tack instead of shouting "crimson tide" try substituting OTC (One Term Cameron) the useless bag of fetid wind.
Blimey swatantra nandanwar, you're so right on that one.
i thought cameron did badly, and ed miliband, though still looking a bit too much like he ought still to be in school, seemed to genuinely feel strongly about the issue he was asking questions about, which seemed to work.
the idea that cameron can't handle pmqs without osborne is a bit worrying, who is whose puppet in this relationship?
maybe ed balls' charm offensive in his independent interview the other day, where he said nice things about osborne, is a secret divide and rule strategy.
Labour have come un-stuck they hoped the Goverment would have sorted out the economy by the time of the next election and it would no longer be an issue only one they managed to avoid by lying, but now we know things are much worse and will take an extra couple of years to deal with and whoever is the goverment in 2015 will need to continue to make savage cuts (even Labour)And would anyone give the matches back to the man who started the fire Mr Ed Balls, a man with no shame or credibility, and the class war thing -Very grown-up! that will help with the economy One term Cameron i don't think so better the devil we know especially so late in the day!
Cameron is out of his depth, but he is not alone in this pathetic joke of a government. Osborne shows how poor he is yesterday, Maude is a clown, again being caught out on C4 news. Bonwick-Jones, your men are toast.
Cameron saying 'left wing' as an insult about Ed Miliband was a weak jibe. Especially as Ed is not left wing. Ed Miliband going on about George Osborne and his skiing holiday was utterly pathetic and quite insulting to the people on strike, in it's stupidity. As though harriet harman(gentry and married to over paid union boss) is going to go without or any of the other free loading labourites. Very poor politics.
It looks like Conservatives don't understand, they are robbing low incomes families by failing to increase by inflation, the value of tax credits.
Osborne is now robbing Luke and Peter to pay Paul.
This Bonwick-Jones person is probably a spotty teenager with their hand permanently down their trousers. Give over uber bore.
These so called politicians are an insult to all of us. Not only do they fail to carry out the jobs they are supposed to be doing, for us - they weren't even given the jobs by us in the first place.
Now they have the cheek to behave like priviledged morons locked in some kind of public relations battle consisting of all guff and no substance.
Mrs. Dot Dash-Jones is right full stop. Ed Milliband is a complete bandwaggon jumper. Hanging around, hinting at what he might say, testing the water first.
Yawn sincerely,
Blah.
Ed Clever? My we are easily pleased, he is so clever he compared a dinner ladies weekly pay favourably to Goerge Osbornes annual ski trip. What a plum.
Bonwick-Jones. Do tell us what "fire" Ed Balls started in the last government? I think you'll find he was Education Secretary, and a far better one than that slimeball Gove.
As to your tired old Tory quip about "non-jobs", there's no such thing, except in the financial sector, where gambling has replaced work.
http://cuttingedge2.forumotion.co.uk/
I see Mrs,M L Bonwick-Jones turns up again to give us all the benefit of her profound insight and wisdom. Pity she can't spell, punctuate or put a sentence together. Is she real or is it some clown in conservative central office?
Cameron is just awful. Such a nasty bit of goods. I think EM does well. I thought his comment about Gideon's ski trip and dinner ladies pay rather good - except I should imagine that the ski trip far more than most of us in a month, let alone a week.
matthew fox: Look here 1%.. Why not take the low paid out of tax altogether, and don't forget 1% it was your loathsome Labour party that taxed the working poor the most...
You really do need to stop drinking the meths it's pickling your idiotic brain. As for your last pathetic statement it was your vile Labour party that stole from Peter to pay Paul...
What I saw yesterday was Cameron displaying the same ignorant arrogant out of touch verbage spouted by those grotesque bully boys of the Thatcher years.
I not with interest that neither Luddite nor Bonwick-Jones seem to understand how to use their own language. This is illiteracy only serves to highlight how vapid their arguments tend to be.
Calling someone left wing should be an insult.
Blimey - just caught up with the Bonwick-Jones stuff. All the usual tired arguments, which are about as unconvincing as a Tory with a charity collection box while wearing a T-shirt bearing the legend 'Make Poverty History'...