Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Councillors face a vicious cycle of expectation, indignation and bitter apathy

Six months into the job, I'm trying to do things differently.

The queue for my last council surgery stretched around the hall. I sighed at the sight. Not because I mind hard work, but because I'm not sure how much the council can do to help. Since my by-election in May, I've found myself spending large amounts of time answering calls from Peckham constituents who are upset with a system that feels remote and often fails to deliver in the cuts. I do all of this on an email system that makes MS-DOS look like some kind of high-tech fantasy. I sometimes find myself writing to officers not because I believe they can make a difference, but because I want residents to know that I've tried.

But there is a deeper problem here, beyond resources. For many of the people in my constituency, the council has become the only vehicle they can see to improve their position. Ringing the council's phone, bidding for housing on inflated waiting lists, seeing through complaints that take years to resolve, has become a full time occupation. There is a vicious cycle of expectation, indignation and bitter apathy from people who have lost faith in their ability to change things for themselves. As a new councillor serving as a secretary to this bureaucracy, I suddenly realised I was in danger of feeding into that.

That's why I'm trying to do things differently. It's an experiment that starts with a new opening question. "What can the council do for you?" has become "what can we do for each other?" Don't get me wrong, I am under no illusions that many people are in need of professional support and material help, but in many cases, people are capable of more than we give them credit for.

So when a single mum entered my surgery saying she was suffering from anti-social behaviour on her estate, I didn't ask her if she'd reported it to the council's overstretched helpline. I asked if she could get her neighbours together. She can't write, but she's a born leader who will make a difference. Unlike officers, residents are there 24/7 - they can keep an eye out for each other. As a group, they also become harder for the council to ignore. This is not some fluffy version of the Big Society. Anyone who knows the Friends of Warwick Gardens or the Peckham Residents Network in my ward knows that networks achieve things. Similarly the power of the residents on the Consort estate, who gave young people a safe place to party this Halloween, was better than anything the council could have organised.

Achieving change in this way can make a bigger difference, because it stops one of the biggest problems in my ward: isolation. For many elderly, disabled and workless people, interacting with the council is one of the few chances that they get to meet another human being. When that interaction is reduced to complaining about something they feel entitled to, it can be humiliating. Meeting other people and working with them to create change builds confidence in a way that some council services don't. As Maurice Glasman says in my book, if Blue Labour had a slogan, it would be "relationships are transformational".

Of course a lot of people don't have the confidence to meet their neighbours alone, but councillors can help with that. They can introduce the youth worker to the young unemployed guy on the estate who thought about running a football club but didn't know how. They can make sure that the head of the mosque knows the mum who sits on the board of the local school. They can play a part in great initiatives like the Peckham Network, supported by the Peckham Settlement, which are already encouraging residents to knock on five doors and invite their neighbours around for tea and a conversation about how to make things better.

If people think I'm anti-state they have misunderstood. Many council services are necessary and worthwhile, and I'm well aware I need a councillor allowance to do the work I do. Nor is it to slam my fellow councillors and officers in Southwark, many of whom are doing a much better job than this newbie. I'm simply saying that when you become a councillor, it's easy to think your role is just about bureaucracy and complaints.

The best politicians know that to be a good councillor, you need to be a community organiser. Labour Values is full of positive examples and Movement for Change is starting some phenomenal work around the country. Caroline Badley's work in Edgbaston and Sam Tarry's in Barking and Dagenham is famous for a reason. These people get that government shouldn't be something that is done to you - it should be something we do together.

Tags: Blue Labour

4 comments

Nigel's picture

A really wonderful approach you've laid out here, which if adopted widely could make a massive difference. Councils are too remote and monolithic, and politics is seen as done for and on behalf of the constituents, rather than in collaboration with them. Changing that will be a long slow process though - I think inertia and "this is how it's always been" is pervasive force in councils, and you being a newbie is precisely why you're able to have these insights and change how things are done. Where the newbie badge with pride, it's an asset not a liability!

swatantra nandanwar's picture

Wish you all the luck in the world. Its a fresh approach and much needed. Its time to break the 'dependancy culture' that unfortunately we've sleep walked into. Councils and councillors in the end can do little; the answer lies in the behavoural change and empowermnent of local commnities and activits out there to change their daily lives.
Councils can't solve the graffitti and antisocial problems alone; its up to the residents, the strret the neighbourhood. Even if you threw loads of money at the problems it wouldn't solve them. The prtestirsat St Pauls have shown us a different approach to soving problems. But we need to do that on a local level as well. Good luck; you'll need it, to over come the intransigence in your own colleagues.

Asim Haneef's picture

Evo Morales, the President of Bolivia once said in an interview that before becoming president he expected to walk in and finally change the system to something fair and just, that he'd sweep out the old and replace it with the new. However, when he finally got the keys to do the job, he recalls feeling like he was confronted with a reality in which him and everyone he was working with had multiple layers of handcuffs missing any keys. He spent so much time breaking and opening handcuffs that by the end of his term, he'd not made any real gains at all, just merely spent all his time removing and breaking handcuffs.

I imagine that a lot of politics is like that, there's an overwhelming desire to change and help, yet your hands are tied. I know you're doing your best, and you're right - the problem is deeper than just resources etc, it's structurally and perhaps culturally unsound - and that requires a solution not just imposed top-down via laws, but places, spaces and attitudes for new friendships and relationships to emerge. I once asked Hazel Blears (when she was talking about kids on estates etc) how many of these kids she had spoken to...she said 'lots' and then I asked her how many she had invited back to her home for a coffee and chat, the answer was none.

There's still a massive disconnect, and community is a big part of the solution, but it can't be forced, perhaps just facilitated, and it has to be more than cosmetic, that's key.

I think we all need to find ways to work together better.

Mr Raine's picture

Some interesting ideas placed in this article, I believe there is more that we can do for ourselves as communities but more often than not we don't know how to or where to begin. Maybe as a "newbie" Ms Davis, you are having to now deal with problems and oversights fron the previous Councillor in your ward, its possible to believe that with hard work and effort you will manage to change the lives of the people who have elected you to help, in theory that is one way that have started to help themselves, but electing someone they believe will make a change, just maybe if you help as much as you can they will realise they made the right choice and do more to help themselves. It sounds like you care and as you say you "don't mind hard work" so keep striving and you will succede.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets