Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Dean of St Paul's Cathedral resigns

Graeme Knowles steps down with immediate effect, following the resignation of Giles Fraser last week.

St Paul's has been thrown into crisis with the news that the Dean, Graeme Knowles, had resigned with immediate effect. The Church Times broke the story. According to the Guardian's Peter Walker, the Bishop of London has said that the loss of Knowles is a "tragedy".

This comes just days after the resignation of Canon Chancellor Giles Fraser, who objected to the decision for St Paul's to take legal action against the Occupy the London Stock Exchange protesters camped outside the building.

On Friday, Knowles announced that the cathedral would seek an injunction against the protesters, provoking a barrage of criticism. Fraser said that eviction would constitute "violence in the name of the Church".

On resigning, Knowles said that "since the arrival of the protesters' camp outside the cathedral, we have all been put under a great deal of strain and have faced what would appear to be some insurmountable issues". He added:

It has become increasingly clear to me that, as criticism of the cathedral has mounted in the press, media and in public opinion, my position as Dean of St Paul's was becoming untenable.

In order to give the opportunity for a fresh approach to the complex and vital questions facing St Paul's, I have thought it best to stand down as dean, to allow new leadership to be exercised. I do this with great sadness, but I now believe that I am no longer the right person to lead the Chapter of this great cathedral.

The Archbishop of Canterbury made the following statement:

The announcement today of the resignation of the Dean of St Paul's, coming as it does in the wake of the resignation of Canon Giles Fraser last week, is very sad news. The events of the last couple of weeks have shown very clearly how decisions made in good faith by good people under unusual pressure can have utterly unforeseen and unwelcome consequences, and the clergy of St Paul's deserve our understanding in these circumstances.

Graeme Knowles has been a very distinguished Dean of St Paul's, who has done a great deal to strengthen the pastoral and intellectual life of the Cathedral and its involvement in the life of London. He will be much missed, and I wish him and Susan well in whatever lies ahead.

He added:

The urgent larger issues raised by the protesters at St Paul's remain very much on the table and we need - as a Church and as society as a whole - to work to make sure that they are properly addressed.

More follows...

 

Tags: Occupy London

9 comments

ex Anglican's picture

Frankly, I'm baffled! Just about grasped why Giles Fraser felt he had to resign, but....
Just the sort of whiffliness that finally made me leave the C of E.
Also baffled about why the protesters are still there. Not a very exciting protest, and the weather's getting nippy.

David's picture

I don't think he was all that Anglican / CoE what with the pink trimmings on his rather RC single-breasted cassock and his penchant for sporting a zucchetto...! Perhaps a return to the 39 Articles, KJV and BCP (and the use of the High Altar at Choral Holy Communion on Sundays) would be welcomed; at least it would mirror the Bishop's hard line outside !!

Nixon is Lord's picture

Maybe he just likes to dress up and pretend he's been ordained. The whole "smells and bells"; "look at me-I wear a beanie and have red around my buttons and even use incense" pre-Raphaellite pseudo-Catholic thing.
The Orthodox and Catholics think he's just an overdressed choir member.

David's picture

If I recall correctly, he was also formerly Bishop of Sodor and Man (no anagrams please...), so when Chatres goes, there'll probably be a Deanery somewhere for him too!

In fact St. Paul's has form when it comes to appointing ex-Bishops to the D&C: the Precentor in the 80s was a former bishop of Oxford (Wolocombe sp?), though he oversaw something else far more 'resign-able' but that's for another day....

swatantra nandanwar's picture

Obviously internal politics working away feverishly in the background with 2 camps, one for the protestors and the other for a bit of peace and quiet and order. Straight ourt of a Trollope novel. The protesters won't make the slightest bit of difference to Capitalism, but they've inflicted some collateral damage on the Established Church.
The Dean should not have resigned but seen the Injunction through and have it tested in the Courts.

Rhodes the visit's picture

Congratulations, protesters. Not a single banker with so much as a farthing off their bonus, but two clerics - both of whom publicly agree with you - resigned in the centre of the City. Still, I'm sure you've held another splendid seminar agreeing with each other. The fact that I agree with most of it too doesn't detract from the sheer intellectual onanism of this whole exercise. Feeble.

another David's picture

What a pity. I suppose that means he won’t be able to reply to my letter to him (well, to be fair, to the Dean and Chapter) in May 2009….

What really irks me though is this: has he resigned because Fraser’s stance is the proper one to take as a Christian, or because Fraser’s resignation has shown that he (Knowles) has been found wanting as a Christian?

Clearly “clearing a(nother) path” was all that was formally needed to satisfy any of the cathedral’s H&C concerns (though why did this take a week?!) and the fact that the protesters are now to be evicted using force (if need be) is now an alarm one too many for the cathedral authorities – or it is if they cannot pass the blame on to the Corporation London!

Knowles should either have resigned immediately force was mooted or stand by his guns to see this one out. As it stands, though, he looks both weak and ineffective and has given the protesters even more ammunition and will-power!

Will they still be there by the time of the Lord Mayor’s Show, I wonder..?!

Richard's picture

Weirdness is afoot on this of all days...

It is the simplest of decisions with but a few logical options.

(1) Support the protest and allow the protest to remain.
(2) Oppose and evict the protest.
(3) Oppose the protest and allow it to remain.

Yet St Pauls have chosen illogically to:

(4) Support the protest and evict it.

Initially this was because of 'health and safety' but since the then the protesters have reorganised so as not to impede access and have said they are willing to respond to any specific health and safety issue.

Did Dean, Graeme Knowles resign because like Fraser he does not believe the protesters should be violently evicted yet is being forced into supporting eviction by unknown forces (the government | corporation of London | police | bankers)

or

Is he resigning because he supports eviction but doesn't want the blame for violence?

Can you journalists find out for us please?

saltyseadog1's picture

Hon on earth can any church (a place of sanctuary) allow people to be forcibly moved and retain any sort of credibility. I am not particularly religious but if Jesus does come back methinks there will be more than moneylenders being chucked out on their ear from his fathers house!!!.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets