The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Ed Miliband calls for the break-up of the Murdoch Empire

Labour leader steps up campaign on media, as poll shows his personal rating is up seven points in a

Ed Miliband has called for Rupert Murdoch's influence on the British media to be scaled back.

In an interview with the Observer, he said: "I think that we've got to look at the situation whereby one person can own more than 20 per cent of the newspaper market, the Sky platform and Sky News. I think it's unhealthy because that amount of power in one person's hands has clearly led to abuses of power within his organisation. If you want to minimise the abuses of power then that kind of concentration of power is frankly quite dangerous."

MIliband describes how he heard the news that Milly Dowler's phone had been hacked by the News of the World. He says that Ed Balls received a text message with the news, and "I literally could not believe it. I could not believe it was true. I could not believe that it had happened."

He adds that he hopes the media landscape has now shifted, and the next election will be fought differently. "So many people have believed that you can't win without Murdoch, you can't win without the Sun. But now the reverse might be the case. I think the endorsement of Murdoch will be a pretty double-edged one at the next general election."

A poll for the Independent on puts the Labour leader's personal approval rating up seven points on a month ago (from 18 per cent to 27 per cent).

Miliband's intervention follows a turbulent 48 hours for News Corporation and for the Metropolitan police, as the latter came under scrutiny for the close friendship between officers Sir Paul Stephenson and John Yates and former News of the World deputy editor Neil Wallis, who has now been arrested in connection with the phone-hacking enquiry.

Friday saw the resignation of News International Chief Executive Rebekah Brooks and Les Hinton, the chief executive of Dow Jones -- one of Rupert Murdoch's key lieutenants in America. He joined News Corp when a teenager, working on Murdoch's first paper, the Adelaide News.

Murdoch himself spent the afternoon with the parents of murder victim Milly Dowler, whose phone was hacked by the News of the World. The Dowler family's lawyer said Murdoch "held his head in his hands" as he said sorry several times.The News Corp chief took out personally signed adverts in all Britain's major newspapers to apologise for the NoW's actions.

In a series of dramatic developments, it was also revealed:

  • David Cameron invited his former communications chief Andy Coulson to Chequers in March, after he had resigned from No 10 over the hacking scandal.
  • Ed Miliband said Sir Paul Stephenson, the head of the Metropolitan Police, had questions to answer about the hiring of ex-NoW executive Neil Wallis as an adviser after he left the paper. It has emerged that both Stephenson and fellow Met officer John Yates were friends with Wallis, who has now been arrested in the course of the hacking enquiry.
  • The FBI have reportedly begun an investigation into allegations that the phones of 9/11 victims were hacked.
  • The actor Jude Law is to sue The Sun over allegations it hacked his phone while he was in New York, potentially drawing News International into an investigation by the American authorities. He is already suing the NoW. News International have called the claim "a deeply cynical and deliberately mischievous attempt to draw The Sun into the phone-hacking issue".

Although Brooks's resignation may appease public anger, the departure of Hinton is seen by some as even more significant. He worked for News Corp for more than 50 years, and is the only person from the US operation to resign in connection with the phone-hacking scandal.

Hinton told a parliamentary committee in 2009 that there was no evidence the hacking was widespread. In his resignation statement yesterday, he said: "In September 2009, I told the committee there had never been any evidence delivered to me that suggested the conduct had spread beyond one journalist. If others had evidence that wrongdoing went further, I was not told about it."

After an apology for "the pain caused to innocent people", he added: "I want to express my gratitude to Rupert for a wonderful working life. My admiration and respect for him are unbounded. He has built a magnificent business since I first joined 52 years ago and it has been an honour making my contribution."

In Brooks statement, meanwhile, she spoke of the "deep sense of responsibility for the people we have hurt". She added:

I want to reiterate how sorry I am for what we now know to have taken place.

I have believed that the right and responsible action has been to lead us through the heat of the crisis. However my desire to remain on the bridge has made me a focal point of the debate.

This is now detracting attention from all our honest endeavours to fix the problems of the past.

Therefore I have given Rupert and James Murdoch my resignation. While it has been a subject of discussion, this time my resignation has been accepted.

Rupert's wisdom, kindness and incisive advice has guided me throughout my career and James is an inspirational leader who has shown me great loyalty and friendship.

I would like to thank them both for their support.

Last week, Brooks offered her resignation to Rupert Murdoch but was refused. When he flew to London last week, he said that she was his "first priority".

This follows mounting pressure from key figures in and around News Corp. The Daily Telegraph reported that Murdoch's daughter Elisabeth had expressed rage about Brooks' position, telling friends that she had "f*cked the company".

Meanwhile, News Corp's second largest shareholder, Prince Al-Waleed bin Talal Al Saud, told the BBC's Newsnight on Thursday that Brooks should resign if there was any suggestion that she knew about phone-hacking at News of the World. He said: "I will not accept to deal with a company that has a lady or a man that has any sliver of doubts on her or his integrity."

Tom Mockridge, the head of Sky Italia, will replace Brooks as chief executive of News International with immediate effect.

31 comments

skiptonman's picture

Lets see if the the laws of our country apply to everyone ..

David's picture

I'm just waiting for the first opinion piece telling us that the anger against her is a actually a hatred of successful women. Probably by Greer or Burchill.

andyg's picture

"Feed the children of the poor and punish the wrongdoer".

Citizen Robespierre's picture

if any one cares what another idealistic youthful fool thinks of this i just made my first blog on it; http://mtwopence.blogspot.com/
tell me if its crap or not

Tom's picture

Good move on her part. Now, any chance that Murdoch will sell ALL of his newspaper holdings in the U.K.?

Not likely. First, in this lousy economy, what's his asking price? Second, would the U.K. media market change that much if all Murdoch papers had new owners? No. Why? Because the corporate owners are convinced that rightwing content (w/T&A shots on page 3) is the ONLY thing that sells. If that's not true, then why do so many presenters (at the BBC and elsewhere) keep saying, don't you think American papers are deadfully dull?

Indu Pendent's picture

@matt

Foxy, does the sun ever shine in there?

It stinks that Cameron went out for a meal with Rebekah. Assuming it wasnt for casual sex the aim must have been media manipulation. Just corrupt.

But the Browns corted a long term friendship with Rupert and Rebekah. Sarah arranged Rebekah's 40th birthday
- because they were best friends
- because it was politically expedient and gave Gordon inside access to the press
- because Sarah was well connected and used the party to exploit further influence

The issue with Cameron going out for a meal with Rebekah is actually more damaging looking at it slightly differently - it makes him look like a pathetic little boy trying to be a big grown up politician by liaising with the big dogs. Just like as Ed Milliband chasing the bandwagon to look good.

BTW Can you name any politicians who were close allies of Gordon when he was smoozing with Rebekah before 2008 when the worst of the corruption took place (a clue is: Nazi who is a vial sponge)? They are going to be damaged by the inquiry as they will have been involved.

Red Rag's picture

I have always believed, it's not the execution that counts....it's the timing.....http://redrag1.blogspot.com/2011/07/red-rag-back-to-future.html

Robert's picture

Rupert's wisdom, kindness and incisive advice has guided me throughout my career and James is an inspirational leader who has shown me great loyalty and friendship.

Well I would have put it some what different, but rats leaving ship might be a better view

Livers's picture

What changed since last week, I mean it isn't as if Brooks wasn't at the centre of the storm then either?

Drakula's picture

In that sordid fraternity it is usually the captains who are the first to flee the ship at the 11th hour !!!

Steve's picture

Les Hinton married Kath Raymond, an aide to Gordon Brown. This incestuous Brown/Brooks/Murdoch relationship gets more intriguing the further you dig.

Oh, and I see Matthew Fox is taking the black marker to recent Labour history again. Stalin would be proud. Definitely a Labour employee or official.

Ivan Miletitch's picture

Good riddance... but uncle Rupert was quite clever to keep the safety fuse in place long enough, now getting rid of it - thats his hope - we'll give him some breathing space. But I'm sure we'll soon find that the Sun was/is using the same dirty tricks & sniffing money, US lawyers will make it their duty to dig & dig until they find something over there too...watch this space, not the end yet!

Lou's picture

Indeed Steve, she was a policy advisor for less than a year and had worked with Blunkett before that.

Rebekah Brooks' husband is an old Etonian friend of Cameron's; are we therefore to make a conspiracy theory out of that too?

To paraphrase yourself, this incestuous Cameron/Brooks/Murdoch relationship gets more intriguing....

Lou's picture

Or The Sun's political editor of the last 2 years,Tom Newton-Dunn, who's another Etonian friend of Cameron?

You see there's nothing politically partisan about this whole sordid affair. They've all been in it together, up to their necks and as bad as each other. No one on either the left or the right can claim any sort of moral high ground where getting down and dirty with News Inc is concerned.

The Left's Revenge's picture

GOTCHA!

Dave C's picture

The Munchkins have just the song for this occasion: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rHJoj9IqeKg

Tim Cavendish's picture

I submit that perhaps the main reason that both Rebekah Brooks and Les Hinton have resigned is this:

Apparently, in view of the furore in Washington, DC on Capitol Hill – and The chairman of the House Homeland Security Committee – Peter King’s request that the FBI investigate alleged hacking of 9/11 victims’ phones, and that the FBI has now opened a preliminary enquiry – both Brooks and Hinton received a personal telephone call from The Director of the FBI – Robert Mueller.

Is this the real reason (and the catalyst) for their resignations?

Even if it is proved to be the case and true, it does not make them immune in any way, from criminal and/or civil prosecution.

Tom's picture

What's one underlying reason for this "investigation"? Political opportunity.

In the States, the politicians are fighting over raising/not raising the debt ceiling. The real world says if you spend you pay. Now, everyone's desperate to not be blamed for "The Default that Cost Us the Election".

This means use anything possible to deflect the public's attention from the debt. Enter the Murdoch hacking scandal. Up until now, the neocons blindly went along with Murdoch's power because almost all of the MSM is corporate owned. Now though, a new "Congressional investigation" means political points and re-election. So screw Murdoch.

Anton Jury's picture

Sorry is just a word and this women knew exactly what she was doing.

mediumal57's picture

There is now no "lighting rod" to protect James (We've just had a nice expensive Mayfair nosh up and going home)Murdoch. One feels that this scandal is slowly but inevitably leading to the one scalp that most of us want.

mediumal57's picture

This whole cosy networking relationship thet grew up in the late 80's and 90's culminating in such an incestuous cabal of politicians and employees at News International working inside the Westminister Village Political Establishment isn't of itself anything to get alarmed at. What is alarming though is the unequal power bases and what was the clearly emerging unhealthy conflicts of interest which began to coalesce around some very influential people.

Rupert Murdoch though, has been involved closely with British Politics ever since the days Wilson/Callaghan and Thatcher Administrations. So let us not confine this to the last Labour Blair/Brown Governments and this present one.

Murdoch sought political influence for one reason and one reason alone. It gave him access to those people who had the power to decide on matters that would effect his business interests.

This is why I as a former Trade Union activist always used to (and still do in fact) get very annoyed at the Tories playing the Union Bogeyman Card to beat the up the Labour Party with. Hypocritical cant.

Tom Jeffries's picture

Read Rebekah Brooks new column in gingerfightback!

http://gingerfightback.com/ginger-whingers/rebekah-brooks-speaks-out/

Mr. Divine's picture

Your blog is weird Tom

Freeman2's picture

'Hi Becky, please let me organise your leaving do.'

David Lindsay's picture

We need to ban any person or other interest from owning or controlling more than one national daily newspaper. To ban any person or other interest from owning or controlling more than one national weekly newspaper. To ban any person or other interest from owning or controlling more than one television station. To re-regionalise ITV under a combination of municipal and mutual ownership. And to apply that same model (but with central government replacing local government, subject to very strict parliamentary scrutiny) to Channel Four.

And the television license fee should be made optional, with as many adults as wished to pay it at any given address free to do so, including those who did not own a television set but who greatly valued, for example, Radio Four. The Trustees would then be elected by and from among the license-payers. Candidates would have to be sufficiently independent to qualify in principle for the remuneration panels of their local authorities.

Each license-payer would vote for one, with the top two elected. The electoral areas would be Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland, and each of the nine English regions. The Chairman would be appointed by the relevant Secretary of State, with the approval of the relevant Select Committee. The term of office would be four years. You would not need to be a member of the Trust (i.e., a license-payer) to listen to or watch the BBC, just as you do not need to be a member of the National Trust to visit its properties, or a member of the Royal National Lifeboat Institution to be rescued by its boats.

Ed Miliband, over to you. You are going to be Prime Minister, and probably for quite a while. You might as well do something with it.

David's picture

Interesting that its the same day BBC journalists are on strike

Mr. Divine's picture

Words are so cheap.

Maybe she would like to donate all of her wealth to those that she has hurt.

Ian's picture

Next, Rebekah, you can apologise to Frank Bruno, those caught up in the sexual offenders row, and also to Liverpool fans for your treatment of their disdain re. the s*n Hillsborough lies.

Indu Pendent's picture

She's been given legal advice to quit.

It distances her from the US bribery charges which are being prepared against News International group directors (the payment of UK police triggers a serious criminal offence under US law).

Indu Pendent's picture

@Freeman
Sorry, Sarah Brown is already down for that after doing Rebekah's birthday party so well

matthew fox's picture

@Indu Pendent

Do you think Brooks will tell the hacking enquiry when that dinner date actually happened?

For the life of me, I don't understand why Cameron won't confirm when it happened, it is like he is hiding something.

Latest tweets