Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Has the Daily Mail gone too far?

Headline links teenager's tragic death to teachers' strike.

Daily Mail headline links teenager's death to teachers' strike.

Once again, the Daily Mail has drawn the ire of Twitter users after a particularly tasteless headline on its website equated the tragic death of teenager Sophie Howard with yesterday's teachers' strike. The teenager was hit by a falling branch, but, the Mail reminds us, was "out with friends on the day her school was closed because of nationwide industrial action."

As one commenter puts it:

This article is absolutely deplorable. Who honestly thought that it was in the least bit acceptable to take the death of a 13 year old girl and turn it into some kind of political point scoring exercise? Absolutely disgusting Daily Mail. I cannot believe you would print something so unashamedly distasteful.

Do you agree?

Tags: Daily Mail

42 comments

Feneon's picture

This reminds me of one of the questions to test moral maturity. It concerns a boy who has stolen some apples, crosses a bridge, which collapses, and he is drowned. The children are asked whether the bridge would have collapsed if the boy had not stolen the apples. The very young say 'no' - it collapsed because he was bad. Moral maturity comes some time after the age of 11 when children say there was no moral connection, it is mere circumstance. Conclusion, the Wail is stuck at a very low level of moral reasoning.

Daniele1's picture

Luddite:
Stop presuming. You know nothing about me and I am the first to deplore the lack of discipline in schools, which by the way, is not the doing of teachers but of successive governments which have taken all power from teachers through ludicrous rules and regulations which have in effect rendered adults, not only teachers, unable to control children.
And yes good teachers are leaving the profession because they are unable to teach.So please Luddite stop talking shit.
Hazeyboo is right. The paper wouldn't have made a headline with "girl killed while she was truanting" It wouldn't have served their purpose.The British press is beyond the pale.

Bedd Gelert's picture

Not sure what all the fuss is about here, to be honest. Anyone who thinks this is an 'outlier' or unusual clearly doesn't enjoy the pleasure of laughing at the online version of the DM very often.

Okay, like a seventies club entertainer going on the telly 'they clean it up a bit' for the 'family version' disributed to newsagents.

But tosh like this, and worse, appears on the Daily Mail website, er, 'daily'. That goes a long way to explaining why it is just about the most popular English language news site in the world.

A wise man once pointed out that no-one went bust underestimating the public's intelligence.

Dave C's picture

The Daily Mail have softened the headline still further. It now reads:

"Tears for girl, 13, crushed to death by a falling branch as she sat on park bench

"Complaints had been made to the council about 'dangerous' tree"

It now quotes her parents as saying, "Our beloved daughter's death was a tragic incident, which occurred only 24 hours ago, and we do not want it to be connected to any other events."

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2010193/Teachers-strike-Sophie-H...

It's rather belated, but the Daily Mail has eventually done the right thing. It's a pity they employed someone with such poor judgement who wrote the first draft of the article.

poliphobis's picture

Change to the D. Express - oops!, they seem to have a similar version of the story.

Lou's picture

The BBC News 24 reporter said something similar along the lines of ...and the reason she was here was because her school was closed due to the strikes.

It's terrible journalism on both parts, making spurious links to score politcal points against the public sector workers.

Jeevan's picture

Not only is it completely illogical (cause and effect?), it's utterly disgusting in its disrespect.

This is too far, even for the Mail.

mittfh's picture

Apparently they're not the only ones - the Twitterverse is reporting The Telegraph and The Mirror with similar headlines, *sigh*.

sri lankan girl's picture

very tastelss although i must admit i expect nothing less

PaulWilks's picture

So maybe we should look back at the day of the Royal wedding (which obviously the Mail frothed over extensively), identify a child's death- and blame it directly on Kate Middleton.

It's ridiculous. Has the Mail gone too far? Yes. Will they change the way they report news? No. Would they do it again. Yes. Will lots of Mail reader subconsciously blame the death of a girl on the strikes. Yes.

The Mail should be held accountable for the stories they publish and be forced to reconcile the ignorance they propagate.

Paul Mingus's picture

Daily Fail are just keeping up to their usual high standards of ground breaking journalism.

Graeme Hancocks's picture

What do you expect from the Daily Mail? Personally I wouldnt use the Mail - or indeed most UK newspapers - to wipe my arse.

samfromstroud's picture

@Paul Wilks

Nicely put. That model could be extrapolated across any number of pseudo-patriotic, bullshit events, championed by the 'voice of middle England'. Let's run with it...

Dw's picture

If the Government had privatized all the forest, the tree would have been cut down and the girl would have survived.

Clearly the opposition to the forest sell-off is responsible for this girl's death.

Dave C's picture

The Mail have obviously listened and softened their tone. The headline now reads:

"Girl, 13, crushed to death by a falling branch as she sat on park bench on the day her teachers went out on strike"

with a new subhead:

"Complaints had been made to the council about 'dangerous' tree"

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2010193/Teachers-strike-Sophie-H...

NS readers may wish to go to the article and make their comments there.

Fergus Pickering's picture

All papers print lies. The Guardian prints lies. Papers print what their readers want to read. That's how it works. No happy readers, no paper. For every Guardian reader there are - what? - ten Daily Mail readers. The only solution seems to be a cull, nazi style, doesn't it?

Steve's picture

What about all the children who get knocked down going to, or returning from, school? That must be sirs' fault as well.

Calling occupants's picture

Earth to B.SMALL, are you receiving me?

mittfh's picture

B Small, you're evidently only counting teacher-pupil contact time. Add on time to plan and prepare the lessons before teaching them, then evaluating how the lesson went afterwards - not to mention assessing the pupils. Take a relatively small class size of 20, and 20 hours contact per week. That's 400 hours worth of work to sift through and assess each week - not to mention any revision of lesson plans needed in light of what the pupils did or did not achieve. There's also several batches of parents evenings a year and the increasing trend for "twilight" Insets. Oh, and there's also supervision of pupils during lunchtime, lunchtime clubs, after school clubs, registration, tutorials... all of which increase the length of the real working day.

helen_back's picture

*Calling occupants* That comment did made me laugh !

Sam's picture

The Sun used my friend's killer to make a political point. He was released after 6 years because he was deemed mentally ill.

The Sun only mentioned mentioned my friend's name once in the article and it was pretty emotionally difficult to see him used merely as a pawn in the The Sun's agenda.

The right-wing media always says that people don't respect victim's enough, well from my experience neither do they.

Bill white's picture

Truth is teachers are some of the most overpaid, under worked bunch of people you will ever come across.No wonder we have such badly educated children.Its all about money and holidays.
PS the truth hurts

David Wood's picture

If such a tragedy had happened on the day of the Royal Wedding would the Mail have made the same link?

Tim's picture

B.SMALL, I work in a school. I arrive every morning at 7:15 and leave at around 5:45. So, lets for arguments sake say that I work 10 hours a day. Over the course of the school year this equates to around 1900 hours(50hoursx38weeks). The average working week is 36 hours over a 52 week year (I'm not counting any holidays here). 36x52=1872 hours.

I am also not including the days of the holiday, time in the evening working or any days of the weekend which teachers also work.(I don't know any teachers who don't work at least part of every weekend either marking or preparing work for Monday).

I hope my calculations are accurate. But my basic point is that teachers work hard and have long hours. I am sure that many other people in other professions also work equally hard, but I think there is a misconception that we don't work very long hours, and I think this is inaccurate.

John Smith's picture

Although the Mail's article is the worst example of sensationalist journalism. I find it ridiculous how much teachers are paid in combination with their unbelievable holiday entitlements, compared to other Civil Servants such as Police Officers, Fire Fighters and Nurses.

Jakdaw's picture

I would love to know what Bill White and those of a similar opinion do or did in the Real World. My daughter is giving every hour she can training to become on of these "over paid and underworked" people - I honestly believe that idiots like this have had little or no contact with Education since they stumbled out of school for the last time. It's a real, tough World, Bill and others.

Daley Mayall's picture

The fact remains, would that poor child still be alive today if her school had been open for business as usual?
In the real world of the private sector, my pension was scaled back because the fund became unaffordable for my employer. The same is going to happen to the public sector pensions too, strikes or no strikes.
The revenue generating sectors of the economy pay for the likes of teachers, don't therefore expect to keep better pensions than those who are footing the bill!

Nick9's picture

The Daily Mail is deplorable in its reporting standards. Its speaks volumes of how utterly deplorable a government we have that it needs sensationalist headlines like this garbage to promote its dubious policies.

It was the branch that done it; - that's what killed the poor girl, trying to relate causation to the strike is just sinking to the gutter level this vial paper belongs to.

The right wing press have labelled those on welfare and the public servants as objects of hatred, it's high time it stopped.

It's time there was more control over what tripe these papers print.

Nick9's picture

What's with the IQ test every time we post on NS? what worries me is I've got one or two of them wrong; -back to school Nick!

Benedict's picture

@Nick

Have you noticed that since they introduced the maths tests, we've haven't heard anything from Buckskins?

It's a such a pity.

hairyhorace's picture

Feneon.
The bridge collapse had nothing to do with apples, or the poor boy being naughty.
I have it on good authority that immediately prior to the incident Eric Pickles had walked over it.

Bardh Gwerin's picture

The 'Daily Mail' was a mendacious fascist rag 80 years ago, and it's a mendacious fascist rag today.

Daley Mayall's picture

Daniele, my CEO and most of the main board of my company are in the same scheme - all sharing the revisions to career averaged earnings, increase of 3% contributions and working another two years.
I am not "pathetic", it's just that because I don't buy into your deluded and irrational views on state sector pensions you resort to insults.
The gravy train now arriving at platform 1 is terminating!

martybee's picture

The Mail had to get frothy mouthed about something,,,the strikes had no effect, SNAFU...ask Angus....no,, Danny, (why do I hate that boy??)

Robin Levett's picture

@Bill White/John Smith/B.SMALL:

Could you get your story straight? Are the teachers incompetent (unable to keep discipline), or do they have superhuman abilities to soak up curriculum changes, advances in their subject, changes to their teaching responsibilities and professional development generally without any conscious effort or expenditure of time; and to deliver lessons without any time or effort spent planning them?

(I'm not a teacher, nor have I played one on TV; but I have delivered professional training).

andym's picture

The fact is that teachers were on strike and most parents were working leaving kids on trust.
This was a pure accident but the fact of the matter is that had teachers not been on strinke she would have been sat safe in her classroom.
The thing that public sector workers are not getting is that the non-public sector do not have any sympathy with them (other than political motives) and see these reforms as bringing this pampered group into the real world with the rest of us.

Daniele1's picture

To all the envious poor private sectors losers, tell you what. Why don't you go and get yourself a degree then a PGCE then become a teacher and have a dream lifestyle and fantastic holidays for the rest of your life (probably until you are 70). Of course you will have to control AND educate some kids , 30 at a time,that the Police and the courts can't control but hey! think of that life of luxury!
Daily Mayall:
Why don't you find out how much your employer's pension is worth? A packet I reckon because he probably has stolen his employees' pensions telling them there was no more money in the kitty.You are pathetic!

Daniele1's picture

B.SMALL:
Tell you what. Get educated and become a teacher. Do the job for a year and then come back to us and tell us again what a nice cushy job it is.
What a knob-head you are!
When I see somebody buy a "Daily Mail" I always have this urge to give them my opinion on their choice of "news". One day I will.Obviously the lies they print are popular, the morons buy this paper every minute. Why would they change their tune?That is the depressing part.

Suzanne's picture

In sense it could work for public sector workers. Such a blatant, transparent smear should demonstrate to the public that any pretence the Mail has as a news provider is nonsense. The Mail and it's slightly loftier cousin The Telegraph are simply instruments of our right wing establishment and are fit for toilet paper and not much else.

Luddite's picture

Let's be brutally honest here the public sector strikes went off unnoticed by millions. Daniele there's very little discipline is most states schools these days, because of well meaning liberals like yourself, its the reason why a once noble profession as being turned into a shitty past time for many good teachers.

Daniele1's picture

The great private pension scandal is still not out. Private sector workers still believe the lies of their employers that pensions for them are not affordable while the top executives have pots of money put away for themselves.How gullible can British workers be?
Emplyers used to say paid holidays would ruin the country when they were
first forced to give them to their workers. Same for maternity leave, same for every scrap of workers'right. The right to strike had to be fought by people with great courage.
And today what have we got? people who are too wimpish and too brainwashed by the "Daily Mail" to demand their basic right to a decent pension. Worse they resent the workers in the public sector who still have some kind of pension.How pathetic is that?

Hazeyboo's picture

Ridiculous equation. What would the headline read if she'd been truanting? An unfortunate accident, my sympathies are with Sophie's family and friends.

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets