The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

The under-reported Italian revolution

In Bologna, the student city in the ideological heartland of the Italian left, the youth are rising

The young man grips the megaphone, lamplight illuminating his features as he speaks animatedly in Spanish about the need to "find jobs and overthrow the government". The ring of faces clap and cheer as he rounds off, beer bottles held aloft as someone in the crowd shouts out, "Bravo!" Because this isn't Madrid, or Barcelona, or even Spain. This is the city of Bologna, in Italy, finally making its voice heard.

The significance of Silvio Berlusconi's unprecedented election defeat on 31 May in both his home town of Milan and the usually safe seat of Naples cannot be overstated, as it points to the real possibility of political reform in the country.

But this result, rather than being a harbinger of change, merely marks the most recent (albeit most concrete) manifestation of the turning tide of public opinion in Italy. This is a tide that the population of Bologna – the student city in the ideological heartland of the Italian left – has been riding for years.

According to the national statistics office, in 2010 one in five young Italians was classified as Neet (not in education, employment or training), the highest proportion of "idle" youths in the European Union.

So is it any wonder that the push for change in the country is being driven by this generation of "lost" youths?

Corruption and philandering aside, it is becoming increasingly clear to the average young Italian that their prime minister has failed them. Miserably. And they have had enough.

Hope is in the air

While Spain's "indignados" have made international headlines, there's a quieter series of revolutions taking place in Italy.

One such "revolution" is currently running its headquarters from a pile of sleeping bags and cushions in the city's main square, watched over by the erotic statue of Neptune, his strategically placed hand and entourage of scantily clad nymphs a favourite with tourists. But the tourists visiting now have something rather different to take holiday snaps of.

On 20 May, and inspired by events in Spain and the Middle East, several hundred protesters took to the streets of Bologna in a peaceful (and mostly unreported) occupation of Piazza del Nettuno, Neptune's Piazza, in the city centre.

Squatting on the stone cobbles with the others, squeezed between the cold, naked statues and this beating mass of humanity, I too couldn't help but be overcome by a feeling of hope. The atmosphere was jubilant; the crowd infected by their own sense of power and the sensation that they are taking control of their lives.

That was twelve days ago. They are still there, and as I write this post I speak on the phone to Antonio, one of the protest's organisers, who describes the scene to me.

"There are 30 or 40 of us here permanently, sleeping in the street," he says, "but during the day, and especially in the evenings, as many as two or three hundred people come and join us.

"People are tired of being on the periphery of their own lives," he goes on. "Citizens want to feel that they are protagonists on the political stage."

The system cannot hold

Scenes like this are becoming increasingly frequent in Bologna, where friends on the radical scene speak animatedly to me about recent demonstrations – numbering thousands of individuals – that shut down traffic around the city after protesters spilled out on to the motorway.

Across the rest of the country, too, copycat protests are springing up in the most unlikely places. A photograph in La Repubblica, one of Italy's few newspapers that are not part of Berlusconi's media empire, shows a protester on the Spanish Steps in Rome holding a placard that reads: "We are not against the system, the system is against us."

The tide may be turning, but it is a slow and uncertain transition from a handful of committed activists sleeping on the streets to a full-scale political revolution. For those camped out in the squares of cities across Italy, Europe and the Middle East, one can only hope that the social and political winds that brought them there continue to blow in their favour, and do not turn against them.

"We need to do this," Antonio tells me. "The people need us."

Emanuelle Degli Esposti is a freelance journalist currently living and working in London. She has written for the Sunday Express, the Daily Telegraph and the Economist online.

19 comments

Fergus Pickering's picture

You're joking, aren't you? An Italian revolution - you mean like Mussolini's?
Italians are good at many things, cooking, painting, wearing nice clothes. Don't expect them to do politics too.

Nixon is Lord's picture

Latin Europe (except France)should never have been allowed into the EU; they lied they way in and now they're angry that circumstances have found them out and they're aren't any jobs for permanent students "with a good pension".

City Hobgoblin's picture

When you say that the significance of recent election results in Italy 'cannot be understated' that literally means that it is so unimportant that it would be impossible to define something less important.

I think you meant the opposite (cannot be overstated, or, perhaps, should not be under-estimated).

Kate's picture

@Fergus Pickering:

Perhaps if you took the time to actually understand Italian politics rather than just spewing out crass stereotypes, you would be able to come up with a more informed, sensible contribution. You may like to start your research by looking at how Mussolini was overthrown...

Fergus Pickering's picture

Have you ever thought Kate, why stereotypes exist? Thought not. Heard of the Mafia, have you? There's an Italian stereotype if you like.

Mussolini was popular as long as he was winning

anne warren's picture

No I was not looking for evidence in mainstream media. Upon reading the original article I was annoyed by the lack of evidence (see my first post on 1/6) and did a quick trawl though MSM and some alternative sources. Found nothing.
Cristina then provided links and I reported what I found in them (See my second post on 2/6).
What I am objecting to is no evidence whatsoever beyond hearsay
to support what is written in Ms Degli Esposito's article and as such I object to it being passed off as reporting or journalism.
If Ms Degli Espositi had expressed a personal opinion I would have had no problem.
I have no objections to the protest in itself - if it is happening - which, as things stand at present- appears extremely dubious.

Bob Jackson's picture

Daniele, take a squiz at your passport. The very first page says you're a citizen (or did - mine hasn't been updated, so you may have surrendered your rights in the interim, but that's your problem). Indeed, one of the slogans at George VI's coronation was "every citizen is king under a citizen king". Charter 88 dreamed up that "subject" mullarky about the time of the Hong Kong handover, so you could all feel good about ditching those Chinese who were British subjects, not citizens. It was the most successful racist campaign in British history. It kept them all over there.

You may not have noticed, but both the British and US political systems seem irreparably broken. Why destroy the bit that still works?

lusina's picture

Berlusconi has become a curse on Italy. His media power has strangled Italy, and he has had it his way for so long as a result of this grip on media that he now lives in a world of his own immune to criticism and the attacks on him. He still smiles despite so serious political setbacks. Italy will only move forward once it frees itself of Berlusconi. But the prospects are not good given that the opposition is fragmented and weak.

Daniele1's picture

Pickering:
Kate is right, if your only contribution is to come up with some xenophobic bollocks, don't bother!
For a Brit to make fun of other people's lack of revolutionary zeal, it is rich indeed! when did the Brits revolt against anything? they still bow to a Royal family for Christ sake!They are not even citizens yet but mere subjects to an old woman...Pathetic!

John's picture

I was in Bologna on the evening of May 28th and saw a guy on top of the Neptune statue. It was unclear what he was trying to accomplish, and police were in the process of getting him down with the help of the fire department.
Did he eventually come down peacefully? What was he trying to accomplish by climbing the status?

What was the super-long line of religous officialys that flowed through the square?

anne warren's picture

I am no Berlusconi supporter. Many Italians are dissatisfied with the current political set-up and, like me, would certainly welcome change in Italy. I do however distinguish between journalism, reporting and story-telling.
Can Ms Degli Esposti provide any evidence of a “a quieter series of revolutions taking place in Italy” beyond speaking “on the phone to Antonio”, being “ overcome by a feeling of hope” and listening to animated comments from “friends on the radical scene”?
Although by no means au fait with the Italian radical press I found no reports of this “Bologna occupation” in a quick online trawl through mainstream Italian press and some alternative sources including Indymedia Italia.

Cristina's picture

Anne,
A couple of links for you:

http://bologna.repubblica.it/cronaca/2011/05/20/news/indignados_sotto_al...

http://bologna.repubblica.it/cronaca/2011/05/20/foto/giovani_indignati_s...

http://bologna.repubblica.it/cronaca/2011/05/20/news/gli_indignati_scend...

http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002451197631

http://www.beppegrillo.it/movimento/

They're all in Italian but I think that in itself proves the point of this article - that the protests in Italy are going largely unreported in the wider press.

anne warren's picture

Many thanks for the links Cristina. The ones from the Bologna edition of Repubblica were dated 20th May. They described (and showed) a group of Spanish students with some Italian students demonstrating on 20 May in support of the Spanish sit-ins.
No news of current ongoing occupation of the square.
Could mot access Facebook as am not a member.
The Beppe Grillo site had a report and comments on Greeks occupying Syntagma Square in Athens.
Could not find any news of 10 day ongoing occupation of Bologna Square.
Ms Degli Espositi wrote the 20 May protest
" was twelve days ago. They are still there"
Has anyone else seen them?

David Vinter's picture

Simply crying out for a job will do nothing, Europe is unfortunately losing basic jobs to Africa, India , amd China. Europe and America on the other hand are replacing laboir with capital! in 1900 it would have taken 100 + farmworkers to harvest what one man in air coditioned comfort can acheive in a day. The biggest textile factory in the UK works 20 hours per day with a total of 24 workers, including designers, salesmen and the finance staff.What Henry Ford started is still going ever faster. The jobs that there will be are personal, or very highly skilled. A degree will need to be technical, there is little call for poets!

Cristina's picture

Anne - I understand your point, but this is the 'blog' section of the NS and therefore exactly where this article should be if, as you say, it is only expressing a "personal opinion" and is "based on hearsay".

But from my understanding, the protest is happening (on however smal a scale) and therefore should be reported on.

Frank's picture

I agree with Anne Warren. Although in the last elections (referendum and local election) the majority of Italian people voted against Berlusconi, I can't see any ongoing revolution.

Captain Sensible's picture

Yep life is a ministrone!

Cristina's picture

About time the Italian gioventu took some responsibility and tried to control of their own future. Long overdue!

Fousayfousa's picture

@ Anne Warren.
Let me get this right - you were looking for evedance of anti Berlusconi demonstrastions in mainstream media?? Are you seriously wondering why you can't find anything there!?? I think Ms Degli Espositi has done well to report this and to bring it to people's attention.

Latest tweets