Full transcript | George Osborne | Speech to Conservative Spring Conference | Cardiff | 5 March 2011

The Chancellor trails his budget in speech to the Tories' spring conference.

The Chancellor George Osborne has just finished speaking to the Conservatives' spring conference in Cardiff. Osborne promised that he will deliver an "unashamedly pro-growth budget" on 23 March (a claim I'm certain the NS's economics editor David Blanchflower will look forward to testing when the time comes). He also announced that the budget will contain provisions for the creation of enterprise zones and appeared to hint that the increase in fuel duty will be cancelled. Here's a transcript of the entire speech:

Ladies and Gentlemen, we begin our Spring Conference here in Wales celebrating all we have achieved since we last met a year ago - and conscious of the heavy responsibilities we shoulder in the year ahead.

Twelve months ago, we were in opposition - agitating for change, anxious for the fate of our country, angry at the damage a disastrous Labour government was doing to our economy.

Twelve months later, we are in government - delivering change, improving our country, and pulling our nation back from the precipice of the economic calamity on which we found it teetering.

Twelve months ago, we were governed by a Labour Prime Minister whose manifest unsuitability to lead our country was apparent not only to the whole of the country but, we know now, to the whole of his Cabinet too.

Twelve months later, we have in David Cameron a Conservative Prime Minister whose strength and conviction and compassion is clear for all to see.

Twelve months ago we had just three Welsh Conservative MPs.

Twelve months later we have almost three times that number, from Cardiff to Carmarthen West, from Montgomeryshire to Aberconwy and the Vale of Glamorgan.

What a great result you had here in the Principality.

What a testament to you, Cheryl, and Nick and everyone here who worked so hard.

Thanks to you all, the voice of Welsh Conservatives is today heard loud and clear in the Palace of Westminster.

Now, with the referendum on the Assembly powers delivered within our first year in office - exactly as we promised - and with the result an emphatic 'yes', we can look at the financing arrangements and the Holtham floor.

But first, let us all make sure the voice of Welsh Conservatives is also heard loud and clear in Cardiff Bay after May 5th.

Let's take the fight to Labour who have been in power here for too long.

What I want to talk to you about today is not the successes of the past, but the trials that lie ahead.

And my message is simple.

We are on a hard road to a better future.

We have to be realistic about where we're coming from - and optimistic about where we're going.

They say that to govern is to choose.

And on that day last May, when we won more seats than in any general election since the War and we became - after thirteen long years of opposition - the contender for government, we faced choices.

Choices the consequences of which we live with today.

Great as our advance had been, we didn't have an overall majority.

We chose to form a Coalition with another political party, the Liberal Democrats - rather than trying to govern with a parliamentary minority.

We decided to put our party differences aside and work together in the national interest.

And yes, of course, that choice meant compromise.

But it was a choice that has given this country - at one of those times in our history when she needs it most - a strong, decisive government, able to lead, able to reform, able to pass its laws without the nightly threat of Commons defeat and the paralyzing daily risk of collapse.

Let us imagine the damage our economy would suffer if the Chancellor of the Exchequer was standing here before you, less than three weeks before he delivers his Budget speech, unable to know whether the Budget measures he announced would survive a parliamentary vote and make it into law.

And we made another choice.

We chose to offer a referendum on AV - because without that offer, there would be no coalition and no strong government.

And the consequence is a referendum in just over eight weeks time.

But this Party has never been afraid of letting the people decide.

Let me shock you: on AV, I agree with Nick Clegg.

It is, as he says, a 'miserable little compromise'.

Let us go out there, over the next eight weeks, and make the case against the alternative vote.

It is unfair on voters.

It means politicians are unaccountable.

And the party leader who gets the most votes can end up losing.

If you don't believe me, just ask David Miliband.

So we chose to have a referendum - now let's make sure on May 5th the British people choose to keep the voting system that served this country so well for so long.

There's another, very important choice we made last May.

A choice whose consequences we are living with each and every day, here in Wales and across Britain.

We chose the hard road to a better future, and we chose it over the easy way to ruin.

Our nation was on the brink of bankruptcy.

One pound in every four we spent was borrowed.

Our families were more indebted, our banks were more over-borrowed, the government deficit we inherited was higher than any other major country in the world.

The model of growth pursued over the last decade was fundamentally broken.

That note left by Labour's departing Treasury Minister said it all: there was no money left.

And confronted with this situation - with the world looking into our eyes, judging whether we had the mettle to deal with the enormity of the problems we had inherited - it would have been easy to pull the bedcovers over our heads and hope somehow the problems would go away.

We didn't do that.

We faced up to the task in hand.

Within two weeks, we had made immediate savings to this year's spending plans - and brought Britain a breathing space in the European debt storm.

Within five weeks we had launched fundamental reforms to Labour's failed system of regulating banks - protecting the taxpayer, putting the Bank of England in charge and making sure that never again is a bank too important to fail.

Within fifty days, we had produced an emergency Budget that won credibility around the world and brought stability at home.

Within five months, we published a comprehensive plan to tackle the largest budget deficit in our nation's peacetime history - and do it in a way that protected our NHS and our schools.

And it's shameful that the Labour/Nationalist Welsh Assembly Government is cutting the NHS budget when I've given them the resources to protect it.

We took the steps to bring our country back from the brink, out of the financial danger zone.

We can be immensely proud of having had the courage to do that.

And the benefits of what we have achieved are real, tangible to everyone.

Not just in the avoidance of crisis or the absence of the daily dread of the world bond markets

But in the fact that our fiscal policy allows our independent Bank of England to keep interest rates lower than they would otherwise be.

Today, Britain has a budget deficit greater than that of Spain or Portugal.

But our businesses and families can borrow at interest rates similar to those of Germany and France.

That is the boost we have provided to our economy.

Has it been easy? No.

Has it been popular? Not with everyone.

Was there an alternative? No there was not.

It's a good test of the credibility of your political opponents to imagine what would happen if we actually listened to their analysis and followed their advice.

Labour deny there's a structural deficit.

No credible organization in the world agrees with them.

They say the cuts can be delayed.

Their own former Chancellor, Alistair Darling, says the cuts should start right from this April.

Their great idea is to say that in four years time we should have the same budget deficit as Portugal has today.

Just imagine if this country did what Labour suggest.

Imagine if I was to actually stand up on Budget Day and say I'm abandoning the plan - if I said that we're not going to tackle the deficit.

Now imagine the reaction.

The panic in the markets.

The credit rating downgraded.

And yes, the sky high market interest rates.

Think what that would bring.

The investment cancelled.

The businesses destroyed.

The jobs lost.

Britain next in the queue behind Ireland and Greece.

Here is a truth universally acknowledged: every Labour Government destroys our economy and brings us to the brink of bankruptcy.

We are not going to let that happen to our country again.

Ed Balls, and Ed Miliband, don't want to confront the truth about what needs to be done to clean up the mess - because they can't handle the truth: it's their mess.

Of course they had different responsibilities.

Ed Balls should have taken more care in writing Gordon Brown's budgets.

And Ed Miliband should have taken more care in photocopying them.

But they can't handle the fact that they were the two people at the Treasury when it all went wrong.

That they were the two people who went on a reckless gambling spree with this country's finances;

who placed all our bets on the City of London and saw the taxpayer pay the price

who borrowed and borrowed and borrowed on our nation's credit card, and mortgaged our children's future.

who destroyed our manufacturing industry, suffocated our small businesses with red tape, taxed those who went out looking for work to pay more benefits to whose who didn't.

Miliband and Balls.

Two left-wing politicians who don't understand anyone who wants to get up and get on, anyone who want a better life for their family, anyone who want to create wealth, and start a business, and create jobs, and leave something to their children.

Anti-enterprise. Anti-business. Anti-aspiration.

Anti everything that creates growth and jobs.

That's Miliband and Balls.

They've brought our country to the brink of bankruptcy in the past and they do it all again if they ever got the chance.

And we're not going to let that happen.

Enough of them and their past.

What lies ahead for our country?

I said at the beginning that we have to be realistic about where we're coming from - and optimistic about where we're going.

Britain is coming out of the deepest recession since the 1930s and the biggest banking crisis in our history.

We spend 120 million pounds every day just paying the interest on the national debt.

That's why I warned and warned again last year that recovery was always going to be challenging and choppy.

And then there are the headwinds that are not in Britain's, or any one country's, control.

The soaring cost of world food.

The painful rise in the world price of oil, pushed higher still by the crisis in Libya.

The Jasmine revolution seems like a desert storm that has swept out of a clear blue sky.

But it has been long in its coming.

While we are all righty focused on the threat from Islamic extremists, Conservatives have always understood that there is a far more powerful force.

The desire of people everywhere to be free.

Not just something for the people of London, Edinburgh and Cardiff to enjoy.

But on the streets of Tripoli and Benghazi, in the internet cafes of Tunis and Cairo - they want the same thing as we want.

To have a voice and be heard. To have a stake in our world. To leave something better to our children.

They want what we want. Freedom.

There is no one precise model for all countries and all the governments.

But let's be clear.

Freedom and peace are not alternatives - they are indivisible.

Democracy and stability are not alternatives - they are indivisible.

British interests and the values of liberty and open society are not alternatives - they are indivisible.

The British people and the cause of freedom - we are indivisible.

As Chancellor I also believe political freedom will bring over time - as it always does - economic prosperity.

Our world will become a freer and richer place.

But in the short term it adds to the challenge.

I know how hard the rises in world oil prices are hurting families in Britain.

When it costs £1.30 for a litre of petrol; £80 to fill up a family car; I know people feel squeezed.

And I say this to people watching:

I hear you.

This April I'm freezing council tax, cutting income taxes for 23 million people and increasing child tax credits payments to the low paid.

But we've got another of the Labour Party's pre-prepared rises in petrol tax also coming this April - one penny above inflation.

I won't take risks with economic stability, or wreck the public finances.

But I promise you I am doing everything I can to find a way to help.

Help the people that this Government will always help: people who work hard, who save, who want to provide for their family without depending on the state for everything.

We are on your side.

For Conservatives understand something absolutely fundamental about Britain that socialists have never understood - and never will.

Governments don't create growth by themselves.

It's people who create growth.

It's the strivers, the entrepreneurs, the engineers, the innovators, the savers, who create growth.

To learn a new skill, to get a new job, to start a new business, to want to leave something to your children.

These are the most natural human impulses of all.

And that is why for all the realism about our past and present, I am so optimistic about the future.

For if you take those impulses of millions who strive to get on, bring them together and make those impulses a reality, then you will have a bigger economy and a better society.

In the last ten months we've delivered a great deal to help.

We've cut the tax rates on businesses large and small.

Funded new apprentices.

Stopped Labour's hated jobs tax, and reduced employment costs for millions.

We've lifted nearly a million of the low paid out of tax altogether.

We've funded new transport and new broadband - including here in Wales with rural broadband to Pwllheli and the great announcement this week of the electrification of the line to Cardiff.

But today in Britain there are still too many obstacles standing in the way of people of enterprise and aspiration; too many forces of stagnation determined to frustrate those who want to get on.

In my Budget in less than three weeks time, we will confront the forces of stagnation that stand in the way of success; bring down the barriers that stop Britain getting back on its feet.

The Budget is going to be unashamedly pro-growth, pro-enterprise and pro-aspiration.

It will look at the planning delays, the new regulations, the bureaucracy and the costs that hold business back and stop jobs being created.

Not just in London, or the South East - but across Britain.

Do you know one of the greatest scandals of the Labour years?

For every ten jobs created by business in the south, just one job was created in the north and the midlands.

Here in Wales, the gap with the richer part of our nation grew greater.

84,000 manufacturing jobs were lost.

We have to go in a different direction.

However important financial services may be, we can't place all our bets as Labour did on the City of London.

We need other parts of Britain, and other sectors of our economy, to grow and succeed.

Wouldn't it be good if Britain made things again?

We want to see a manufacturing revival.

In the world economy's race to top, we want Britain to be the winner.

Today I confirm that in the Budget we will introduce new enterprise zones across parts of Britain that have missed out in the last ten years.

They will be centres for new businesses and new jobs where taxes will be even lower and more restrictions on growth removed.

They will be in places in our land with great potential - but which need that extra push from government and local communities working together.

I am delighted that Nick Bourne and the Welsh Conservatives have said they want to make these new enterprise zones work here in Wales too.

We need to set people free again.

The entrepreneur who can't get finance from the bank, and doesn't know where else to turn.

The small business owner who wants to hire her first member of staff, but worries she'll go bust if she gets taken to an employment tribunal.

The local manufacturing company that wants to expand its workshop, but can't because the town hall bureaucrats won't give them permission.

The friends at work that quit their jobs at the big firm, and risk everything on their new start up - and search in vein for an enterprise zone, where the rates are low and the planning controls don't stand in the way.

The student who nurtures a secret ambition to be an engineer, but thinks her friends will laugh at her - "Britain doesn't make things anymore" they tell her.

The sales director that dreams of breaking into new markets abroad, but can't find anyone to show him how.

The nurse, the doctor, the teacher, the police officer, the council worker - who sees every day how things could be done better, and money could be well spent, if only they were allowed to use their common sense and do the things they were trained to do.

The postal worker and the train driver who serve their community with pride, see their country needs their help, and sees instead their union taking them out on strike.

The multi-national chief executive that looks around the world for where to invest in a new green energy project and create hundreds of jobs - but can't justify to their board the risks of investing in Britain.

The young woman, setting out on life, with a great idea for a new business - but who sees nothing but obstacles in her path.

The young man, who wants to get off benefits and into a job, and make something of his life, but can't see the point if the Government takes away more than 90 pence for every pound he earns.

These people - all of them - are the people who are going to build a better future for Britain.

And in the Budget to come, and in the years ahead.


This Party.

This Government.

This Chancellor.

We are all going to be on your side.

Jonathan Derbyshire is Managing Editor of Prospect. He was formerly Culture Editor of the New Statesman.

Show Hide image

Is defeat in Stoke the beginning of the end for Paul Nuttall?

The Ukip leader was his party's unity candidate. But after his defeat in Stoke, the old divisions are beginning to show again

In a speech to Ukip’s spring conference in Bolton on February 17, the party’s once and probably future leader Nigel Farage laid down the gauntlet for his successor, Paul Nuttall. Stoke’s by-election was “fundamental” to the future of the party – and Nuttall had to win.
One week on, Nuttall has failed that test miserably and thrown the fundamental questions hanging over Ukip’s future into harsh relief. 

For all his bullish talk of supplanting Labour in its industrial heartlands, the Ukip leader only managed to increase the party’s vote share by 2.2 percentage points on 2015. This paltry increase came despite Stoke’s 70 per cent Brexit majority, and a media narrative that was, until the revelations around Nuttall and Hillsborough, talking the party’s chances up.
So what now for Nuttall? There is, for the time being, little chance of him resigning – and, in truth, few inside Ukip expected him to win. Nuttall was relying on two well-rehearsed lines as get-out-of-jail free cards very early on in the campaign. 

The first was that the seat was a lowly 72 on Ukip’s target list. The second was that he had been leader of party whose image had been tarnished by infighting both figurative and literal for all of 12 weeks – the real work of his project had yet to begin. 

The chances of that project ever succeeding were modest at the very best. After yesterday’s defeat, it looks even more unlikely. Nuttall had originally stated his intention to run in the likely by-election in Leigh, Greater Manchester, when Andy Burnham wins the Greater Manchester metro mayoralty as is expected in May (Wigan, the borough of which Leigh is part, voted 64 per cent for Brexit).

If he goes ahead and stands – which he may well do – he will have to overturn a Labour majority of over 14,000. That, even before the unedifying row over the veracity of his Hillsborough recollections, was always going to be a big challenge. If he goes for it and loses, his leadership – predicated as it is on his supposed ability to win votes in the north - will be dead in the water. 

Nuttall is not entirely to blame, but he is a big part of Ukip’s problem. I visited Stoke the day before The Guardian published its initial report on Nuttall’s Hillsborough claims, and even then Nuttall’s campaign manager admitted that he was unlikely to convince the “hard core” of Conservative voters to back him. 

There are manifold reasons for this, but chief among them is that Nuttall, despite his newfound love of tweed, is no Nigel Farage. Not only does he lack his name recognition and box office appeal, but the sad truth is that the Tory voters Ukip need to attract are much less likely to vote for a party led by a Scouser whose platform consists of reassuring working-class voters their NHS and benefits are safe.
It is Farage and his allies – most notably the party’s main donor Arron Banks – who hold the most power over Nuttall’s future. Banks, who Nuttall publicly disowned as a non-member after he said he was “sick to death” of people “milking” the Hillsborough disaster, said on the eve of the Stoke poll that Ukip had to “remain radical” if it wanted to keep receiving his money. Farage himself has said the party’s campaign ought to have been “clearer” on immigration. 

Senior party figures are already briefing against Nuttall and his team in the Telegraph, whose proprietors are chummy with the beer-swilling Farage-Banks axis. They deride him for his efforts to turn Ukip into “NiceKip” or “Nukip” in order to appeal to more women voters, and for the heavy-handedness of his pitch to Labour voters (“There were times when I wondered whether I’ve got a purple rosette or a red one on”, one told the paper). 

It is Nuttall’s policy advisers - the anti-Farage awkward squad of Suzanne Evans, MEP Patrick O’Flynn (who famously branded Farage "snarling, thin-skinned and aggressive") and former leadership candidate Lisa Duffy – come in for the harshest criticism. Herein lies the leader's almost impossible task. Despite having pitched to members as a unity candidate, the two sides’ visions for Ukip are irreconcilable – one urges him to emulate Trump (who Nuttall says he would not have voted for), and the other urges a more moderate tack. 

Endorsing his leader on Question Time last night, Ukip’s sole MP Douglas Carswell blamed the legacy of the party’s Tea Party-inspired 2015 general election campaign, which saw Farage complain about foreigners with HIV using the NHS in ITV’s leaders debate, for the party’s poor performance in Stoke. Others, such as MEP Bill Etheridge, say precisely the opposite – that Nuttall must be more like Farage. 

Neither side has yet called for Nuttall’s head. He insists he is “not going anywhere”. With his febrile party no stranger to abortive coup and counter-coup, he is unlikely to be the one who has the final say.