The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Cable and Murdoch: it’s war

Expect Murdoch and his henchmen to unleash the forces of hell on the Business Secretary.

In a remarkable demonstration of his independence from David Cameron, Vince Cable has just referred Rupert Murdoch's BSkyB bid to Ofcom on grounds of plurality. Following News International's full-throated support for the Conservatives, Murdoch had hoped that the deal would be nodded through, but he didn't reckon with Cable.

Ofcom will now be required to investigate the bid and report back by 31 December.

The takeover bid has split the cabinet along party lines, and Tory ministers are said to be relaxed about the deal. But the speed with which the Business Secretary has acted (BSkyB officially notified the European Commission of the takeover bid on Wednesday) suggests that he's fully aware of the threat to media plurality.

As Mark Thompson recently argued in his impressive MacTaggart Lecture, Murdoch's bid, if successful, would lead to a "concentration of cross-media ownership" that would be unacceptable in the United States or Australia.

As the owner of the Sun, the News of the World, the Times and the Sunday Times, Murdoch already controls 37.3 per cent of UK newspaper circulation and, based on revenue, Sky is now the country's largest broadcaster, with an annual income of £5.4bn. If successful, News Corp's bid for the 60.9 per cent of BSkyB that it does not own at present would have disastrous consequences for media plurality.

Once the deal is complete, we can expect Murdoch to bundle his newspapers with Sky subscriptions in an attempt to offset falling circulation. As the media analyst Claire Enders has predicted, by the middle of this decade, the News Corp head could control 50 per cent of the newspaper and television markets, a concentration of ownership that would make even Silvio Berlusconi blush.

That Murdoch has a history of editorial intervention is not strictly relevant: it would be undesirable for any individual or company, however benevolent, to achieve such power. But it certainly raises the stakes.

Following its eight week public-interest assessment, Ofcom is likely to recommend a full investigation by the Competition Commission – something that could block the deal altogether. In the meantime, expect Murdoch and his henchmen to unleash the forces of hell against Cable.

16 comments

thinkov's picture

vince cable is a tory

Norman Hewit's picture

Don't get too excited yet, just remember our Vincent turned arse about face over tuition fees.

thinkov's picture

the bastards are nicking Mad men

Niffy Nog's picture

What's that, 3 of the 33 mislaid vertebrae replaced?

earlydawn's picture

Given Ofcom's recent record on "media plurality" (the sports channel monopoly) then I imagine Murdoch is actually going to be quite nervous about this. I'd be willing to bet that Ofcom won't be too happy about this at all.

The formal bid also completely undermines the whole basis of James Murdoch's anti-BBC McTaggart lecture last year. If the bid suggested that NewsCorp were interested in doing even a fraction of what the BBC currently does then it would be promising. But it appears more to be another attempt to stave off the long-term decline of its print media arm. This is not necessarily a reason to obstruct it, but there doesn't appear to be any pretence that the operations would remain separate.

praha7's picture

Given his recent behaviour I can't imagine why anyone would have confidence in Cable.

I hope I'm proved wrong but I think that he will let it go through after Murdoch has made his usual promises which of course everybody except Cable will know he has no intention of keeping.

Yvonne's picture

Would that Mr. Cable had also demonstrated his independence in a similar manner over tuition fees.

writeoff's picture

Berlusconi's power is even greater - he controls 70% of TV advertising through one of his companies, so holds the purse strings of most of his rivals. The deal will benefit the Tories. It's odds on it's going to go through. They're as relaxed about rich people as Mandelson ever was.

Terry7's picture

Best politician in UK He was against Tie hike in tuition fees but the Lib Dems have always supported governance by coalition, which is what PR means, & can't complain when difficult choiceS must be made inevitably involving compromise on some Key issues.
They also know the desperate state of the nation's finances & that unpalatable choices are unavoidable.
Labour? Stated they'd shrink deficit by 50% over one parliament but still no details of HOW. Liars & deceivers. They'd just borrow & spend & destroy us

QuenzBuena's picture

so the stance against the bbc in favour of plurality is reversed in this instance.
the virtue of conservatism is if you don't have any principles you can't be inconsistent.

Benedict's picture

The worm turns.

Livers's picture

"the virtue of conservatism is if you don't have any principles you can't be inconsistent"

Spot on. Although, of course, Vince Cable is a Liberal.

jeremiah's picture

Cable is just doing this as a sop to his own party, and to extent the left.

That old bastard will get his way, he always does in this country!

Tweety's picture

If Murdoch gets his way, then expect the Mail, Telegraph, bbc and every other non Murdoch outlet to vent their fury on this coalition.

Like everything else, in Camerons eagerness to please Murdoch. He hasn't fully thought this through

bonk's picture

This deal had to be referred i'll wager it still goes ahead though i dont think Murdoch was silly enough to think it'd be "nodded through" it was never going to happen.

Peter's picture

I'm amazed you've been taken in by this. This suits both sides of the coalition perfectly. The tories aren't seen as being soft on Murdoch because it's been referred, and the Lib Dems and chiefly Cable as seen as being principled for once.

There is no particular stand being taken by Cable. He's just fulfilling his role and taking the hit from Murdoch for his Tory masters once again, whilst conveniently trying to pick up some brownie points with the left-of-centre.

Latest tweets