Government will drop case against Chagos Islanders, says Cable
A letter from the Business Secretary signals a significant turnaround in government policy.
By Sean Carey Published 13 September 2010 16:37
Are the dreams of the exiled Chagos Islanders about to be realised? This letter sent by Vince Cable to a constituent certainly implies that the coalition government's policy has changed dramatically.
Before the election, both William Hague and Nick Clegg made promises that the right of return of the Islanders to their homeland, which lies around 1200 miles north of Mauritius, would be restored. However, these appeared to unravel in the last few weeks. The Foreign Office minister responsible for the overseas territories, Henry Bellingham, was sticking rigidly to the FCO line that the Government would continue to contest the case brought by Olivier Bancoult, leader of the Chagos Refugees Group, before the European Court of Human Rights. Now this seems to have changed.
Cable told the New Statesman in January 2009 that he was appalled at the treatment dished out by successive governments to the Islanders.
"Let's not forget that this is a long-standing injustice which involves a group of British citizens who were ruthlessly dispossessed of their homeland for reasons of military expediency," said Cable commenting on the fate of the 2000 islanders removed by the British authorities between 1968 and 1973 and dumped in Mauritius and the Seychelles.
"Many will say that it doesn't matter because the number of people affected is relatively small but I disagree. We are dealing with real people here. Worse, the whole thing has been enveloped in secrecy and denial by successive UK governments."
The Chagos Archipelago, which consists of over 50 islands, in the British Indian Ocean Territory, was designated as a Marine Protected Area by the previous Labour government.
UPDATE: The NS has just been contacted by the Department of Business, Innovation and Skills, which claims that that the letter shown above was issued by Dr Cable's constituency office in error, and a new letter will be sent out. This story isn't going away any time soon, it would seem.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















14 comments
Bullocks, $4000.oo Us appx 2000 pounds is not a compensation after 40 years that the US have paying 11 billion dolars a year for. So look for the real thruth in the story.
Bullocks, $4000.oo Us appx 2000 pounds is not a compensation after 40 years that the US have paying 11 billion dolars a year for. So look for the real thruth in the story.
No double standard Tiangoman - one group of islanders were in the way of geopolitical war games, the other were a useful excuse for them. The govt. (including and especially whitehall) don't give a flying fish about actual people. Unless it's a race thing. It might be a race thing.
I believe that the government is preparing to change policy on the Chagos Islands and let the people return to their homes. This must happen soon, the exiles have been waiting too long already. The cost for the UK in fighting these people who are claiming nothing more than the right to live in their home, has been enormous. Write to your MP and demand that Britain behaves as a civilised country and not as tyrant.
It's the right time to let these people return to their homeland and don't forget that may of them are in their 60's-80's. what's a tragedy!
Let's hope this is really true. It's an amazing volte face considering Henry Bellingham's recent statement, but fantastic news if that is genuinely the case and a settlement will actually take place. How awful, I may actually have to support this government whilst they sort it out since, spin aside, Cable is right - Labour have done nothing for the Chagossians and David Milliband is openly against a settlement.
Bob Soul says:" £14.5 million was paid out to 2000 residents".
Not so. The UK government provided £650,000 to Mauritius in 1972, and then a further £4 million in 1982 in "full and final settlement".Most Islanders signed the compensation agreement, but bear in mind that many of those living in Port Louis were penniless and had little or no alternative. There is a further and very important point. Many Chagossians were Creole speakers and illiterate. They had absolutely no idea when they put their thumbprints on the legal documents that they were signing away their right of return to their homeland. Hence the marathon legal case begun by Olivier Bancoult in 1998.
Were they properly compensated for the loss of their homeland? No. Many are now too elderly and may not wish to return.
"Were they properly compensated for the loss of their homeland? No. Many are now too elderly and may not wish to return."
£14.5m was paid out to 2,000 residents
'The Chagos Archipelago, which consists of over 50 islands, in the British Indian Ocean Territory, was designated as a Marine Protected Area by the previous Labour government'
Yes but let's not pretend the previous Labour Government were doing anything to help matters. By designating this space as a "Marine Protected Area', Labour simply put another hurdle between these unfortunate people and them reaching their homeland. This story is a terrible indictment on Britain.
While I have sympathy with the Chagosians plight, this will soon pale into insignificance compared to the millions that starve due to lack of fish protein, as fisheries collapse. The Chagos Archipelago Marine Reserve is an ambitious conservation measure for one of the worlds most diverse coral reefs. While controversial it is this type of measure that is essential if we are to protect biodiversity and begin to replenish fish stocks and protein for all.
I am so ashamed of successive Labour Governments treatment of these islanders. Millions were spent to fightr for the Faulkand islanders freedom and a few millions are being spent to deny the Chagossians the freedom. Why the double standard?
Give the Islanders their homeland back, kick out the 'CowBoys' !
Lets hope that this really is the beginning of the end of this sorry chapter in British and US history.
Keep watching, and keep up the pressure.
Post new comment