The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

David Miliband emerges with the speech of his life

The elder Miliband returns to the spotlight with an eloquent and gutsy address.

I've just returned from the conference hall, where David Miliband has made by far the best conference speech he's ever delivered. It was passionate, gutsy, thoughtful and eloquent. He joked that he had plenty of material to work with, referring to one computer file named "Saturday: version 7" and another named "Tuesday: version: 23".

Miliband was careful not to stray too far from his brief, but parts of the address were transparently lifted from the leader's speech he never delivered. He made an effective appeal for party unity and declared: "No more cliques, no more factions, no more soap opera." And, in a neat riposte to Bob Crow et al, he quoted Labour's fourth leader, John Robert Clynes, who said Labour politicians went into politics "not to practise class war, but to end it".

He described Ed as a "special person", of whom he was "incredibly proud", and, to his supporters, he insisted: "Don't worry, I'll be fine". But there was no hint either way of his intentions.

At the heart of the speech was an eloquent defence of what Miliband called "hard-headed internationalism". On Afghanistan, he said: "We're not an occupying army, we're trying to prevent an occupation." But he qualified this by reminding delegates that foreign armies never end civil wars.

And, like his brother, he promised to support David Cameron if he did the right thing. "When he takes risks for peace, we will be the first to congratulate him every step of the way," he said.

Listening to Miliband, many recalled the New Labour years when Gordon Brown would deliver a barnstorming speech on the Monday, taunting Tony Blair to outdo him on the Tuesday.

Yet there are important differences: Ed defeated David in an open and fair contest and there is still genuine warmth between the brothers.

But the younger Miliband will still have his work cut out trying to top this tomorrow.

40 comments

Rose's picture

I hate Ed Miliband. He is so ungrateful and so sneaky and such a false person about his brother. I'll never vote Labour. I don't ever want to see Ed in No 10. He is so glad that he kicked out his brother. He has always been spying on his brother. Please collect all the pictures and examine Ed Miliband's eyes on his brother. Ed Miliband is an embarassment to the Jewish community.

The Milibands will be my new story. No one will vote for Labour after this.

I hope Ed Miliband loses the next election, and that will serve him right. David Cameron, bring your whole extended family in No 10 because you should stay there for a long time. I like you better because you like people.

Ed Miliband is a loser in heart. The labour party comes across as stupid, any body can fool the labour party management. A labour party now not fit for purpose! Ed was so jealous of his brother. Someone will kick Ed Miliband out.

What kind of a labour party is this. A Labour party with very poor family values and very poor morals.

David Miliband should go and make millions around the world like Tony Blair or go and work with President Obama.

David Vinter's picture

Giving the best speech of your life is no good if you have no power to carry it out!
By the way, everyone I know is hard working, unless their retired. At which time they work growing their own vegetables.And helping grandchildren with maths and english.

Bill Fraser's picture

A nauseating, stilted 'New Labour'
speech would be a more accurate description.

nobody's picture

"We're not an occupying army, we're trying to prevent an occupation."

War is Peace.

Geraint's picture

Allie is either a Tory troll, or one of those bitter Blairites that don't truly get, or understnad the Labour Party.

The fact is that Ed Miliband is the right man to lead the Labour Party, and he is best placed to lead Labour to victory at the next election, and I believe he will. He has demosrrated his strengths and abiltiy already, and the idiots under-estimating him are in for a huge disapointment.

Nick's picture

All you gloom and doom merchants might like to know that a poll just announced on the Paxman show puts Labour in the lead at 40% The Tories at 39% and the Liberals trailing way behind at 12%. Seems like the Red Ed title isn't really doing the trick either, see the newspapers tomorrow.

Chris's picture

"and the idiots under-estimating him are in for a huge disappointment."

You couldn't be further from the truth. I honestly hope - really hope - that he becomes a great leader and I am totally wrong.

Darren Canning's picture

Is their not usually a boost in the polls for the party having its conference due to the extra publicity?

Nick's picture

It could be that Darren, but it didn't happen for the Liberals when their conference was on with all their publicity. Fact is people don't warm to Cameron and certainly not to Clegg anymore, so they may just look at Ed M and thinks he's a more trusted alternative, who knows. I just hope!

Nick's picture

If Labour supporters, whatever variant they may be, don't get behind our new leader, how can we expect anyone else to vote for us? We've got a leader now and unless you want this wretched coalition to stay put, start supporting your new leader!

Clem the Gem's picture

Agreed Nick, the sooner we unite and start developing policies and tactics to win, the better.
To those who have come through the last seven years unchastened - where have you been? the world has moved on, and the unspoken support of Tony, not to mention Mandys' vocal cheering did for David. It would be hard to find two people more detested by a large number of the British people right now.
The New Labour mantras do not hold true after the Banking Crisis, and we need a new set of credible left of centre policies to help us win in 2015. Lets get to work people...
http://clemthegem.wordpress.com/

Darren Canning's picture

@ Nick, supporting Labour does not mean blindly underwriting it's Leader. No Leader tells thde party what to think he must convince the party and be ready to listen to the party. In the end he is our representative as much as our leader. The party remains whether the leader does or not, the same is not true the other way round.

Geraint's picture

I agree with Nick

Geraint's picture

Although, to be honest, it is only a very small minority of bitter Blairites that are throwing their toys out of their prams. Most people seem to be uniting behind the new leader.

These bitter Blairites need to either get behind the new leader and stop sulking that their man lost. This is not the Labour way.

If you dont support Ed, then at least give him a chance, that would be the Labour way to do, that would be the right thing to do. Don't blindly follow the right wing press.

Robert Taggart's picture

I disagree with Nicky !

Nick's picture

To be honest I wasn't an Ed supporter, I thought It would be David. I was also, for a while, a Blairite, but as Clem says 'the world has moved on', and as it did, I changed my view. I think your are right Geraint, there are a small number of pram rockers out there who can't get used to their man not getting number 1 spot.

I've listened to a lot of what Ed says and do you know what, the more I hear, the more I like what it is he says. I'm far from blindly following my leader Darren, I'm listening to what the party has said. I think the public will warm more to Ed because he's not some smarmy showman like Cameron or naive Clegg. Ed talks a lot of sense over the upholding of the party viewpoint on social welfare and taking the coalition to task on the cuts, I think he'll do that constructively and not just ambush everything the coalition does or says. The fact he's the quiet and more unspoken one is probably what will help rather than hinder him, it will help forge links again with the 5 million voters we lost, not in the most recent election but in the one before. I believe Ed will turn out out to be a lot more appealing to the electorate than people think; I definitely don't think he'll become the Union's puppet, although he will listen to what they say.

At the end of the day, Ed did adopt a strategy to win the top job, David had the same chance and he lost. There were the same rules for both, so as far as strategy goes Ed got it right. That's good because no shadow leader ever became PM without a good strategy; he gets my support 100% because we have to unite, that is the only way we will ever win.

Allie's picture

Reading some of these bizarre posts makes me think that there are some complete weirdo's on this site!

Rose's picture

David's speech was fantastic. He is the real new Leader. It was so obvious.

The Unions broke the rules and posted Ed's picture only out with the ballots. The unions are corrupt and therefore do not have any credibility. I have lost my respect for the unions who did this.

Ed is there as leader by corruption. So he can never be the 'real leader' Enjoy his time while t last.

I hope David does not join the cabinet. Ed is determined to get him in and the sack him. Ed stole David's football when they were younger. I think Ed needs to change his religion and become a christian. He can then go to confession and evelop some humility and honesty that he really hates his brother David. I can understand why he hates David-David is just so good.

Dave C's picture

I watched the highlights of David Miliband's speech on Today at Conference. It struck me as workmanlike but nothing very special.

mjyfdzez's picture

Translating the DroneBot from Newspeak into Cleartext:

"Labour politicians want not to practise class war, but to end it" -- filthy lies, these traitors always aimed to make it unilateral, namely one that only their Ruling Class chums are allowed to fight.

"He described Ed as a 'special person'" -- obviously a fraternal code for 'fucking spastic'.

"calls for 'hard-headed internationalism'" -- a euphemism for pig-headed neo-imperialism in the wind-shadow of Uncle Sam as he plumbs the depths of moral, fiscal and intellectual bankruptcy.

"We're not an occupying army in Afghanistan" -- those whom the gods will destroy, they first make mad.

"our foreign armies never end civil wars" -- as we pyromaniac loons are too busy starting new ones.

"When Cameron takes risks for peace, we will be with him all the way" -- Right, lads, double-time lockstep for the march on Tehran, them lippy bastards could bloody well be doing with a quick dose of 'Democratic Cruise(missile)Aid' followed by a nice, cleansing 'civil war' before the damned Chinks grab all our gas buried under their soil.

Ah yes, indeed, more stirring gaseous revolutions from the fetid bowels of the New Labour Zombie. Enough to make any sane voter puke his ring for a thousand years.

Grab the hint, Davey. Just. Die. Now.

mjyfdzez's picture

@ Allie, #1 comment,

no, sorry, in fact your hands are still sore from all that chaffing as you vigourously pumped the Boy's unlubricated ego-shaft during a lame and predictable tirade.

Well done, I fancy at the end he was sweating from every pore in his body, or at least one pore in particular ... ";0)

jie4v7i14's picture

Not bad speech, but what he said was only to be expected.

But as Alastair Campbell pointed out in his blog, to expect "no more soap operas" with our mainstream spinning media (Sky and tribe, etc. esp.) about is fantasy really.

Allie's picture

David's Speech was amazing, I was there in person and the atmosphere was electric - in fact my hands are still sore from all that clapping.
David is the labour's real leader, that speech demonstrated that clearly.

gwenhwyfaer's picture

The whole memo on party unity just completely passed you by, Allie, didn't it?

frenetic's picture

You Blairites just won't give up will you?, you took over the party in what was basically a coup, now times have changed. I am on the left but I think E/M is genuine, believes in social justice, (the real kind, not the Purnellian version)and is a breath of fresh air after the lies/evasions and petty brutalities of the Blair era.

John Wills's picture

Come on Allie. My vote too went to Dave M too but it's now a done deal. Ed M is the leader and we must now move on and support him with all our energies. Labour (not Ed M or Dave M) has its work cut out for it in the months and years ahead. This Coalition is going to wreck people's lives, there is no doubt, and we must be a party fit, for those damaged by their actions, to receive them. They must be able to trust us like no party has ever been trusted before in the last 20 years. Blair and Brown lost the voters's trust, this Coalition has already, after just a few months, abandoned their respective manifestos. We need to step up, be honest, be truthful and be trustworthy.

VB Rodriguez's picture

These great leaders of the workers party- why have none of them had a proper job? How can you represent a party of the people when your entire life has been in Westminster? Labour party supporters are the first to throw this charge at Cameron et el, for being elitist? surely that's better than champagne socialist?

Allie's picture

John Willis, Ed isn't going to be PM lets not kid ourselves. The party conference is quite sombre this year and there are many who are not happy by this result - with Ed in charge we will not get back into power, sorry.

Dave C's picture

Allie wrote, "Ed isn't going to be PM lets not kid ourselves."

You can't possibly predict what's going to happen in May 2015, if the Lib-Dem/Tory coalition lasts that long. Osborne's cuts over the next four years aren't going to be popular, even with Daily Mail readers.

Allie's picture

To all, come to Manchester, look at the glum expressions on the faces of the MP's and party members, and see for yourself that we already believe we have lost.
I'm staunch labour, have been since I was a teenager - but I am also a realistic, and to all those Ed supporters I mean no disrespect to him. If I don't respond anymore its because my iphone battery is nearly dead

Zole's picture

Allie, I think your "iphone battery's" been dead for a long, long time.

I think you'll find there wasn't a great deal of difference in the proportion of support Ed and Dave received from MPs and party members.

This is a breath of fresh air; finally moving on from slippery, quasi-Thatcherite Blairism. Labour can now re-position iyself as a GENUINE Centre-Left party !

Richard's picture

Allie don't be so glum. There really is not much to choose between Ed or David. which ever of them won the leadership there would still be a long road to climb. Ed is a very smart bright and capable politician do not be fooled as the Tories were with Balir and the bambi jibes.
Listen to the speech on tuesday ther will be ideas and words that could have come from either of them.
Conference is a bit down will grant you but thats due to much more than the leadership election there are many bruised and battered activist who fought tooth and nail in the GE who have not yet been recharged but they will be very soon. There is a sense of gloom at the helplessness regarding the cuts to come and the carnage around th corner.
Wait for the opinion polls at Christmas and see the bounce in their steps return.

Azza's picture

Time will tell what this young man will offer, for once I thought we picked the wrong brother. David is such an intelligent man, with a vision, i can see why the tories are really scared of him, hang in there David your time is coming.

mjyfdzez's picture

@ Allie,

it's weirdoes, son, get it right

---
'Hey you, you're such a pedant,
you've got as much brains as a dead ant,
as much imagination as a caravan site ...
.........................................
but I still love you!
Oo, oo, ooh, how swee-ee-et
to be an idiot,
how sweet.'

writeoff's picture

Do I detect a touch of Stockholm Syndrome in Mr Eaton's writings since he went to the Labour Conference?

They were wittering on about taking the party to the centre ground of politics again this morning. I despair. I want DM out of the Shadow Cabinet, he will only be a force for the cosy neo-thatcherism that blew up in New Labour's face and rightly cost them dear.

Ganesh's picture

EM is going to struggle. Too callow. Interesting personality though... greater love hath no man than that he lay down his brother's life for his personal aggrandisement.

Winniethepooh's picture

Allie - we saw what it was like with you in power and we didn't like it. It would have been more of the same David. Perhaps it will still be the same with Ed. It's the mum, of Jews for Justice who should be in charge - that would really shake things up. Not voting Labour again, once bitten, twice shy. These shaymans are mere glove puppets of The Machine.

Chris's picture

@frentic

Nope - the "Blairites" just won't give up... wanting to win.

"Blairites" just mean those members willing to make massive compromise to win - and yes - that's a good thing and *essential* in modern politics. It's better to be in power than to sit in 'principled opposition' where you can do nothing. Did the years before "Blairism" not tell you that?!

Grass roots Conservatives are already becoming furious with Cameron now for not being a true Conservative - just check the comments on Conservative home. The days of left and right are over - it's whether you want a centre left or centre right Government, or prefer to sit on the sidelines.

(Before people start attacking me, I disagreed massively with the horrific mistake that was Iraq, but Blairs *electoral* strategy was correct.)

The funny thing here is that Ed is not 'RedEd' anyway - he will be just as "Blairite" as what has gone before, just without the gravitas, authority, experience and ability to connect that DavidMili had. In the media age you need these attributes and electing Ed was a massive error - mark my words - we shall see...

The reason he is now leader is thanks to the trade unions - hardworking people, who are shrouded in ideology but have, on the whole, zero political sense and zero political judgement. Once Ed has had months of sky-high poll ratings due to the cuts, he will be revealed for what he is - totally unelectable.

It's a sad day for Labour.

Dennis Keim's picture

Civil wars are only solved by political negotiations, David Miliband? That would be news to most Americans. Probably the folks in Sri Lanka too.

Latest tweets