Welcome to the New Statesman website. Please sign in or register to participate in the conversation.

The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

Blair on why he refused to sack Brown as chancellor

Tony says Gordon was “maddening” while at the Treasury, yet also “strong, capable and brilliant”.

Tony Blair's office has just released the first extracts from his memoirs online and the selection includes a fascinating account of why Blair refused to sack or demote Gordon Brown.

Blair's explanation is a mixture of the pragmatic and the principled. He argues that sacking Brown as chancellor would have severely "destabilised" the government and that his ascent to the office of prime minister "would probably have been even faster" (that "even faster" suggests that Blair still feels his time in Downing Street was unfairly curtailed).

However, Blair goes on to say that he genuinely believed Brown "was the best chancellor for the country", describing him as being "head and shoulders above the others".

He writes:

If I had decided he really was unfit to remain as chancellor I would have dismissed him, even if it had hastened my own dismissal. My failure to do so was not a lack of courage. Nor was it simply about managing a complex situation. It was because I believed, despite it all, despite my own feelings at times, that he was the best chancellor for the country.

He adds:

Later, when I ran through possible replacements, I still bumped up against the same uncomfortable but -- I thought -- incontrovertible -- reality. He was head and shoulders above the others. Only towards the very end did the thoroughgoing New Labour people start to emerge who had sufficient seniority and experience to have taken his place.

The extract concludes, however, with Blair employing a version of Lyndon B Johnson's adage that "it's better to have them inside the tent pissing out than outside pissing in".

He writes:

I came to the conclusion that having him inside and constrained was better than outside and let loose or, worse, becoming the figurehead of a far more damaging force well to the left.

Then there's an honest and sincere tribute to Brown's strengths:

So was he difficult, at times maddening? Yes. But he was also strong, capable and brilliant, and those were qualities for which I never lost respect.

Yet there's a rather more damning verdict on Brown's own time as prime minister:

Political calculation, yes. Political feelings, no. Analytical intelligence, absolutely. Emotional intelligence, zero.

Tags: Gordon Brown  Tony Blair

4 comments

jeremiah's picture

Blair didn't sack Brown because he had roots in the party, unlike Tone.

Brown might have been a crap PM but he has been involved in Labour politics for 40 years.

I don't honestly why Blair joined the Labour party. I remember hearing of him being taken to dinner by several Tory MPs in 1983. They wanted to know why he joined Labour.

I don't know if they got an answer but I would like to know it.

9xzulug's picture

i ask myself why did mr blair listen to the yarn of mr bush,who only wanted to finish the job his father started.DOMINATION AT ALL COSTS FOR OIL.plausible answers are not the whole truth and nothing but the truth but it seems new world order is.we as a nation were misled into a religious war disguised.OIL,BLACK GOLD was and is still the agenda because certain western nations require it to function.mp's are masters at PR(propaganda rubbish).ILLUMANTI golden rule is divide n conquer and may the best legalised mafia control the gullible masses to gain as we all know the MONEY,CASH,DOSH.look at the mess we have now CHRISTIANS V MUSLIMS right across the world.what a pathetic idelogical mess we are in.and still we have politicians vying for control sending ordinary people dying in their name but playing a so called patriotic front to the rest of us.HELLO WAKE UP AND SMELL THE COFFEE,BEFORE IT GOES COLD.

Arthur Williamson's picture

Has Tony Blair mentioned (in his book) the fact Gordon Brown did (selflessly) step aside in the 1994 election which helped Tony Blair become Labour leader in the first place?

David Wearing1's picture

"Political calculation, yes. Political feelings, no. Analytical intelligence, absolutely. Emotional intelligence, zero."

That's one up on Mr Tony then, who was endowed only fleetingly with the first

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Latest tweets