Why should Pakistan trust us?
Distrust lies at the heart of the west’s relationship with Afghanistan and Pakistan -- but this is n
By Nick Dearden Published 28 July 2010 17:37
For western governments to lecture the likes of Pakistan about democracy and stability, as David Cameron did this morning, must seem a cruel joke to many in that country. Our part of the world has a long history of generously lending money to fuel violence, prop up undemocratic, often brutal regimes and exacerbate poverty.
Pakistan is a country with only 54 per cent literacy, and where 38 per cent of small children are underweight, yet it spends nearly $3bn a year servicing debts -- almost three times what the government spends on health.
Loans have flowed freely into Pakistan in order to keep favoured military governments in power, most recently that General Pervez Musharraf, when Pakistan's debt increased from $32bn to $49bn.
A recent $7.6bn International Monetary Fund loan, needed so that the country can keep paying off its old debts, is conditioned on reducing budget deficits, eliminating electricity subsidies and increasing indirect taxation. As usual, ordinary people will pay for the west's "largesse" that kept in power governments subservient to western interests.
Such injustice doesn't stop at Pakistan. Consider Indonesia, where 61 per cent of the population live on less than $2 a day. Like with India, as David Cameron reminded us this morning, fighting poverty in Indonesia will be central to the success of the Millennium Development Goals. But just like India, this seems a second-order priority compared to selling scores of Hawk fighter jets to the country.
Indonesia still owes the UK over $500m for Hawk jets and other military equipment sold to the brutal General Suharto. Suharto was guilty of crimes against humanity by any standard, killing up to a million political activists in his first year in office.
Today, Indonesia pays over $2.5m every hour to service its $150bn debts -- much run up by Suharto. Is it surprising if Indonesians think their lives matter less than the financial and strategic interests of the west?
Afghanistan has been rushed through the debt cancellation process to prevent any embarrassing examination of past lending, but has been forced to privatise its banks and will doubtless return to the same state of heavy indebtedness in years to come -- it serves the government, which needs the finances to hold on to power, and it serves the west, which needs the debts to keep control after the soldiers leave.
Control of these countries can be maintained through this same, deeply unjust economic system, through playing one faction off against another, through fighting when everything else fails to work. Democracy, stability and trust, however, require something far bolder, but not impossible.
It is possible to stop lending in such deeply unjust ways. It is possible to cancel debts based on loans that should never have been lent. It is possible to stop forcing countries to pay what they are unable to afford, or to force them to make their economies work in our interests simply because we can.
As repayments on deeply toxic debts continue to drain Muslim countries of their wealth, we need to realise that the debts, or reparations, if you prefer, that our governments owe the Muslim world are vast and rising. Trust will not be possible until they are paid.
The Jubilee Debt Campaign's "Fuelling Injustice: the Impact of Third World Debt on Muslim Countries" is available at jubileedebtcampaign.org.uk.
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Online writers:
- Steven Baxter
- Rowenna Davis
- David Allen Green
- Mehdi Hasan
- Nelson Jones
- Gavin Kelly
- Helen Lewis
- Laurie Penny
- The V Spot
- Alex Hern
- Martha Gill
- Alan White
- Samira Shackle
- Alex Andreou
- Nicky Woolf in America
- Bim Adewunmi
- Glosswitch
- Kate Mossman on pop
- Ryan Gilbey on Film
- Martin Robbins
- Rafael Behr
- Eleanor Margolis
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Advertising
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists




















14 comments
magician3all
arabonly
anime3as
animok3a
delegnt3a
mexaty3a
animeta7a
mexaty3a
animes3t
mexa2at
3arb-anime
anim5k
albrqn3t
mexat3an
top3film
z7may
z7mhat
ta7ata
animeyate
mnhosat
mokmsyat
animeca3fe
mazaryte
animeyzo
animesnipat
anime-bnatc
banatm5dern
star5at
monaystat
mal7zat
zol7at
kol7at
animoyat
foxyat
maz7kat
3solaty
kool7at
ta7oy
mal7oy
zalyta
ma7aryat
sokolat
barn7ty
tey5at
d5olat
caloyat
anim3snipe
sadt3ars
animeonlye
nsf7
3solat
mnoms
magicians4all
animexyt
mexyt
delegnet
magician3all
arabonly
anime3as
animok3a
delegnt3a
mexaty3a
animeta7a
mexaty3a
animes3t
mexa2at
3arb-anime
anim5k
albrqn3t
mexat3an
top3film
z7may
z7mhat
ta7ata
animeyate
mnhosat
mokmsyat
animeca3fe
mazaryte
animeyzo
animesnipat
anime-bnatc
banatm5dern
star5at
monaystat
mal7zat
zol7at
kol7at
animoyat
foxyat
maz7kat
3solaty
kool7at
ta7oy
mal7oy
zalyta
ma7aryat
sokolat
barn7ty
tey5at
d5olat
caloyat
anim3snipe
sadt3ars
animeonlye
nsf7
3solat
mnoms
magicians4all
animexyt
mexyt
delegnet
حلقات مسلسل عمر
مسلسلات رمضان 1433
حلقات مسلسل الفاروق عمر
وادي الذئاب
مسلسل وادي الذئاب
منتديات
رمزيات بلاك بيري 2013
برودكاست حزين
حلقات مسلسل سنه اولى جامعة
رمزيات مسلسل سنه اولى جامعه
مسلسلات تركية
اكسسوارات بنات بالخرز
فساتين سهرة 2013
فساتين سهرة 2012
فساتين سهرة
موديلات قصيرة للسهرة
ازياء 2013
خلفيات بلاك بيري 2013
خلفيات بلاك بيري حزينة
خلفيات بلاك بيري بدون خقوق
فساتين ايلي صعب
مسلسلات تركيه 2013
فساتين ايلي صعب 2013
العاب 2013
8ame
Games Flash 2013
العاب قيم
العاب طبخ
العاب ترتيب المنزل
قيم كوم
العاب دبابات
العاب قتالية
العاب بلياردو
العاب دورا
العاب كرة السلة
8ame.com
العاب
العاب فلاش
العاب فلاشية
العاب 2012
العاب فلاش 2012
العاب فلاشية 2012
العاب 2013
العاب فلاش 2013
العاب بنات
العاب بنات
العاب بنات 2012
العاب بنات 2013
العاب اكشن
العاب اكشن 2012
العاب اكشن 2013
العاب بن تن
العاب بن تن 2012
العاب بن تن 2013
العاب باربي
العاب باربي 2012
العاب باربي 2013
العاب تصويب
العاب رياضة
العاب رياضة 2012
العاب رياضة 2013
العاب قتال
العاب قتال 2012
العاب قتال 2013
العاب سيارات
العاب سيارات 2012
العاب سيارات 2013
العاب اطفال
العاب اطفال 2012
العاب اطفال 2013
العاب سريعة
العاب سريعة 2012
العاب سريعة 2013
العاب منوعه
العاب منوعه 2012
العاب منوعه 2013
العاب ورق
العاب ورق 2012
العاب ورق 2013
العاب بلوت
العاب بلوت 2012
العاب بلوت 2013
العاب بالوت
العاب بالوت 2012
العاب بالوت 2013
العاب سونيك
العاب سونيك 2012
العاب سونيك 2013
العاب حربية
العاب حربية 2012
العاب حربية 2013
العاب اي فون
العاب اي فون 2012
العاب اي فون 2013
العاب ايفون
العاب ايفون 2012
العاب ايفون 2013
العاب اي باد
العاب اي باد 2012
العاب اي باد 2013
العاب سبونج بوب
العاب سبونج بوب 2012
العاب سبونج بوب 2013
العاب كراش
العاب كراش 2012
العاب كراش 2013
العاب ماريو
العاب ماريو 2012
العاب ماريو 2013
العاب زومبي
العاب زومبي 2012
العاب زومبي 2013
العاب سهلة
العاب سهلة 2012
العاب سهلة 2013
العاب مسلية
العاب مسلية 2012
العاب مسلية 2013
العاب مغامرات
العاب مغامرات 2012
العاب مغامرات 2013
شات امير الصمت
دردشة امير الصمت
امير الصمت
شات عطر قطر
دردشة عطر قطر
عطر قطر
شات دنيا تضيق
دردشة دنيا تضيق
دنيا تضيق
شات دجلة توب
دردشة دجلة توب
دجلة توب
نايس ماسك
مدونة نايس ماسك
nicemask
بلاك بيري 1433
بلاك بيري 2012
بلاك بيري 2013
بلاك بيري
اي فون
اي فون 2012
اي فون 2013
القران الكريم
قران كريم
quran
tvquran
bbislam.com
bbislam
I am against the sale of Hawks to dictatorships like Indonesia and Saudia Arabia. But India has the problem with Pakistan Russia and Iran etc on its borders, and democracy has to be preserved in the region. India are the upholders of democracy. So we must support India.
Not so Pakistan which ahas abused its trust since its inception.
Camerons straight talking against Israel and now Pakistan will win him many friends. Its a welcome approach.
India and Turkey are Naive if they were to believe that some words coming from an inexperienced politician that only managed to score 28% of the general vote to get elected will change anything, when the time comes who next to be lectured. Britain and America will back who they want at the time they want. Pathetic really. It's the general public that suffers. India and Turkey need to become stronger by supporting regional powers who actually have an interest with the host nation becoming financially stable.
I think people have realised just how two faced Pakistan has been all this time. They are getting fed up with terrorism emanating from Pakistan and encouraged by Pakistan. The fact is Pakistan is not to be trusted at all.
If we are to bring peace and security to the world then both Pakistan and Israel need sorting out first.
Sad to say but Posh Dave has placed himself where the left should have been for the last decade or so.
Pakistan's horrific record not only on attacks both towards India and Afghanistan, but also the horrors it's perpetrated on the US/UK forces behalf.
Pakistan deserves to be harshly condemned, just as Israel does.
How long must the rest of us continue to pay in blood and treasure for the Crimes of The British Empire.
I think people have realised just how two faced Pakistan has been all this time. louis vuitton/links of london ring/gucci sunglasses/schmuck They are getting fed up with terrorism emanating from Pakistan and encouraged by Pakistan. The fact is Pakistan is not to be trusted at all.
Nick Dearden says:
"reparations.....that our governments owe the Muslim world are vast and rising".
Well, not as great as the reparations Britain owes the HINDU WORLD......There was more than a century and a half of looting by the British of Hindu India.
Don't forget the Hindu World, please, when you write so emotionally about the grievances of the "Muslim World".
Not many people will remember that in 1980 the USA and the UK boycotted the Moscow Olympics in 1980 - as a protest against the Russian occupation of Afghanistan! We also managed to persuade 56 other countries to do the same. I propose a similar but more widespread boycot on the London Olympics. Our occupation is no more justified than that of the Russians. If Brits want a full attendance at the Olympics we must force the relevant governments to withdraw. There is a lot less than 2 years to rectify the situation. Nelson
======= http://clothesmall.org =========
Best regards for you all,
Looking forward to your visiting.
========= http://clothesmall.org =========
Nick, I disagree with your calling Musharraf's government as "authoritarian". You must not assign all dictators the same clumsy profile.
His dictatorship was ironically more democratic than years of faux democracy. State hegemony on the media was finally broken and his regime did not reek of the kleptomania that Zardari's does.
Democracy is Pakistan is not real. Feudal lords instruct the majority of people- rural, poor, illiterate and at the feudal's mercy- to vote for feudal parties. The two biggest parties- the PPP and PML-N are feudal outfits whose leaders are both feudal lords. Today, these artificially mandated politicians are looting the country dry.
This Western obsession with democracy is far from the poor Pakistani's concerns of food and shelter. My plea to those in the West- please wake up from your ideological slumber!
Pakistan is playing by exactly the same rules everyone else is: look after your national interest first.
Karzai is warming up to India, then suddenly to Pakistan. That's two faced in my opinion. India is coming closer to US, but at the same time it's undermining the US's efforts to create a stable Afghanistan. It does so by aiding the Northern Alliance to fight the Pasthuns and by creating terrorism in Pakistan. US wants to support Pakistan as an ally, but signs a nuclear deal with India.
The same story is repeated again and again by all parties involved but only Pakistan get's bashed.