Clegg ahead in first post-debate polls
Lib Dem leader the big winner according to pollsters but what was your verdict?
By George Eaton Published 16 April 2010 0:22
It's always wise to be wary of instant reaction polls but tonight they're all pointing to one conclusion: Nick Clegg won the first leaders' debate.
Gordon Brown held his own tonight (there was no "car-crash moment") so Labour will be disappointed that he's a distant third in two of the three polls. But given how poor his personal ratings were to start with, that's probably no surprise.
Here are the figures:
YouGov/Sun poll
Brown 19%
Cameron 29%
Clegg 51%
ComRes/ITV News poll: Who won the debate?
Brown 20%
Cameron 26%
Clegg 43%
Which party leader would you say you trust most to make any necessary cuts to public services?
Brown 28%
Cameron 36%
Clegg 36%
Which one of the three main parties do you think has the best policies on immigration?
Conservative 37%
Labour 20%
Lib Dem 35%
Final Sky News poll
Brown 32%
Cameron 31%
Clegg 37%
UPDATE: Clegg also leads in two more post-debate polls.
Angus Reid
Brown 19%
Cameron 21%
Clegg 46%
Populus/Times
Brown 17%
Cameron 22%
Clegg 61%
Latest tweets
More from New Statesman
- Tools and services:
- Polls
- Predictions
- Jobs
- Archive
- Magazine
- PDF edition
- RSS feeds
- Subscribe
- Special supplements
- Stockists

















25 comments
gordon - his policies make sense economically, seems honest
clegg - fresh, not really sure what his policies are, other than opposing the other two
cameron - slimy and horrible economic policies.
I too, thought the debate was excellent and think it's obvious that Nick Clegg has benefited from being seen on an equal footing with his rivals. If the result of the forthcoming election is a hung parliament, I believe it could be a good thing! If the Lib-Dems are in a position to do a deal, it seems to me that their natural allies would be Labour. Gordon Brown is now committed to constitutional reform and this is something the Lib-Dems yearn for and I'm sure would be top of their wish list in any power broking situation. However, if the Tories emerge as the largest party, I can't see DavCam&Co going for it... but never underestimate the machinations of the Tories when they're trying to get their sweaty palms back on the levers of power!!
None of them evinced any imagination. Politics as we know it has had its day (in so far as it ever expressed the wishes of the people!). Social democracy demands that the people have a voice - and NOT of the limited Cameronian type!
Cameron and Clegg are clearly strong TV performers, its what they do day in day out, but we need someone who can deal with the big economic issues that face the country not scoring political points on national television.
Did the people polled watched the debate? Cameron was truly awful.
Clegg was best but Cameron was def the worst.
Both Brown and Cameron underestimated Clegg (even tried to use him to score bonus points- "I'm sure Nick agrees with me that...") and whilst they were busy wrestling with each other, Clegg took the debate by the scruff of the neck. In response to "Duffy", we live in a nation where more people vote for the X factor than the general election, meaning that by playing the media friendly guy card they can win that way, unfortuantely, but I totally agree that it is wrong that politicians should stoop to such tactics. However, I felt that Clegg was only marginally better than Brown, with both of them having discredited Cameron enough for him to finish looking the far weakest. Unfortunately for Brown, he might have done too much wrong already for his voters to forget.
I cannot believe the general consensus that Nick Clegg was the clear winner in the debate. To me, he just seemed to be trying to hard and therefore was not natural. He was over animated, his body language was at times sloppy (hand in pocket) and to be frank after 60 minutes the timbre/tone of his voice began to grate. Personally I had Mr Clegg dead last.
I think Nick Clegg had a style that made him seem the most honest and he presented his policies in a way that will appeal to a lot of people whether they understand them full or not.
Cameron was quite vague but i don't think he performed badly.
Gordon Brown was terrible, he sounded a little desperate for one more chance and had no real answer for 13 years of poor Labour government. He also looked grey and shifty next to the other two.
Well done Nick Clegg.
listening to the view of listeners and watchers on the world service they seemed to think that Brown was a clear winner - appearing, surprisingly human and the only one of the candidates to make the audience laugh
Had I been a UK citizen I would go for Cleg. I like the changes Brown wants to make with regard to the House of Lords, and the requirement of a 50% minimum vote, but why has not been implemented yet? Cameron will be bad news, but I would not be surprised if he under your crazy voting system still scrapes home.
So personality politics arrives in the UK from across the Atlantic.
As differences between the parties have been eroded, the personality of the leaders (& wives) naturally comes to the fore as a means of differentiating. You have to differentiate somehow. Personality politics therefore is a feature of politocracy.
http://reflectionsondemocracy.wordpress.com/
@Callum Millar
Far more people vote at general elections than have ever done on TV talent contests
Brown was excellent. Clegg wasnt bad either. Cameron was ridiculous. I wonder how many people's votes will change on the back of the debate.
@andyf
They said 'I agree with Nick' mostly. Seems most of the audience did too.
One has been, one who will never be and one wants to be. Clegg could not loose all he could say was I disagree with the others ,all Brown could do was fawn over Clegg for me Cameron was the best of a load of rubbish. Surely people will not be swayed by such a pathetic event all done by and for the media this country is in a very sad state bankrupt, with little or no manufacturing left all our reserves sold off, a disasterous legacy for our children and we fought two world wars for this , thank you Gorden Brown and as the famous saying goes will the last man leaving turn the lights out they are already on dim
Personally, PM Brown did really well rather than Mr. Cameron. If fact far better than David Cameron. First Price go to Nick Clegg.Second,Gordon Brown and Third to David Cameron
The whole thing was too much of a set piece for my liking.Clegg was in the best position to win the debate and he did so .Brown wasn't held to account enough for the last thirteen years of disaster.Cameron did OK but would havedone better if he'd made more of Brown's awful record.My vote will go to Cameron because he has the best policies.However,none of them go anywhere near far enough for me on immigration,repatriation,crimeor standards in public life.
Brown was the only one who seemed human and not a Blairbot.
The absence of Paxman, Wark, Humphries et al was the biggest revelation for me. Unimpeded by big-ego presenters trying to trip them up over trivia and prevent them at all costs from stating their case, we finally heard what the politicans had to say - and I think all of them came across pretty well.
Thought the debate was excellent last night but i can not understand how popel can say Brown seemed the only human one!!! Why now is he only just adressing all the problems the party has had 13 years to sort these issues out and nothing has been done. He was never voted in by the public in the first place if people think Britain has improved under Brown they must be living in a different britain than i am. Clegg was surprisingly good and thought cameron held his own
I have never been a fan of the old socialists but new labour is closer to the middle of the road and whereas I would noy previously have voted for labour I would vote for Gordon Brown as he seems to be the only one with fire in his belly. Who cares if he is bad tempered. It shows he really cares.Although the current financial crisis happened on his watch all the other world leaders made the same mistakes. So what we needed is someone with the courage and experience to salvage the economy and Gordon Brown has that. He is not perfect but he is honest and a devout politician and I like his sometimes grumpy style rather than the soft polished style of the other contenders.
Post new comment