The Staggers

The New Statesman’s rolling politics blog

Syndicate contentRSS

New Labour poster challenges Cameron’s "Big Society"

New poster declares: “If you’re there for him, he won’t be there for you.”

dcfbc921-8e56-cb44-4978-6a38cbe8f3e5

Here's the new Labour poster, launched at this morning's press conference. It's certainly an improvement on that disastrous Gene Hunt mock-up, and it picks up on a recurring criticism of the Conservatives, namely: who has time for Cameron's Big Society?

It was a point best made by Channel 4's Gary Gibbon at yesterday's manifesto launch. He asked: "What's the evidence that people want to be prised away from their telly or garden to do all this stuff?"

It's one thing to believe that a Conservative government would stimulate a dramatic rise in civic engagement, quite another to believe that this could act as a plausible substitute for the state.

David Cameron's hope that the Big Society will replace Big Government is reminiscent of the old Marxist belief that the state will "wither away" as a result of victorious socialism. We all know how that turned out.

Moreover, given that Cameron claimed, absurdly, that "big government" was responsible for the financial crisis and opposed the fiscal stimulus, it's reasonable to doubt his belief in the power of government.

With the polls still showing a lack of popular enthusiasm for Cameron, the Tories clearly need a big idea to woo the electorate. But I'm really not sure the "Big Society" is it.

Join us for the first TV leaders' debate this Thursday.

8 comments

jayger's picture

The poster is weak. There is nothing for the electorate to relate too in the three line message. A one liner, would have been better. Tories wont be phased by it. Very forgetable IMO.

Robert's picture

On the contrary - anyone who has been in an abusive relationship where they have loved their partner more than their partner loved them will understand this poster in a flash.

And they will be unwilling to go there again.

ACMJ's picture

A very true message on the poster
The point of the matter is that in the David Cameron , "people's party" David Cameron wants his ministers and backbenchers to do as little as possible for even more money . "Giving power back to teh people" is nothing more than a CAM SCAM to continue the corrupt ways of some mps. What more can one expect from a party leader who is the mouth piece for Lord Ashcoft?

Robert's picture

That's better.

Terry Balfour.'s picture

Rather akward!

orderfromcha0s's picture

Not appreciating the slight on Marx there. I thought the left was meant to stick together? To what exactly does "we all know how that turned out" refer? I've never seen victorious socialism. Otherwise, good point about Cameron, the right just abandons people.

damianneum's picture

It wasn't meant as a slight on Marx (whose analysis of capitalism retains immense force). I was just pointing out that, far from withering away, the state only grew ever larger under communism.

Chris's picture

Agreed - this poster is much better. What were they thinking, linking him with a popular TV series in the previous poster? As for the Big Society idea, it's hard to imagine just how that will work. I just can't see it.

Latest tweets