CommentPlus: pick of the papers

The ten must-read pieces from this morning's papers.

1. Revealed: the great scandal no one's noticed (Times)

Daniel Finkelstein criticises Gordon Brown's refusal to announce a spending review in bad times -- a cynical move, given the political potency.

Read the CommentPlus summary.

2. Chancellors can't do that much (Independent)

Hamish McRae maintains that Budgets matter for what they do to public finances, not what they do to the economy. In the short and medium term, all governments have to work with the economy as it is.

3. Today the tooth fairy turns cuts into efficiency savings (Guardian)

Efficiency savings have become the ultimate political get-out-of-jail-free card to liberate us from a £175bn deficit, writes Simon Jenkins, but if things were that easy, they would have happened.

Read the CommentPlus summary.

4. Israel must sack the head of Mossad for this grave insult to Britain (Daily Telegraph)

Con Coughlin says that the Foreign Office decision to expel an important Israeli diplomat is bad for Anglo-Israeli relations, but the blame lies squarely with Israel for the cavalier way in which it abused the passports of a friendly country.

Read the CommentPlus summary.

5. There's a charming symmetry to the latest New Labour scandal (Independent)

Matthew Norman recalls that Labour's arrival in power was marked by the party trousering a million from Bernie Ecclestone in return for changing policy. As such, there is symmetry in the way the lobbying scandal today may help hasten its departure.

6. Let us hear about political women, not politicians' wives (Guardian)

Most voters know more than they want to about Samantha Cameron or Sarah Brown, writes Anne Perkins -- but the belief still lingers that, for women at least, family and a political career are mutually exclusive.

7. Running the country shouldn't be child's play (Times)

Taking a different tack is Alice Thomson, who asks whether we really want sleep-deprived parents -- male or female -- taking decisions that affect 60 million of us.

Read the CommentPlus summary.

8. Google row reveals China's dictatorial attitude (Daily Telegraph)

China's centrally dictated, totalitarian approach to capitalism is fundamentally at odds with the liberal, democratic free-market tradition that exists in America, says Jeremy Warner.

Read the CommentPlus summary.

9. As Biko knew, powerlessness in actual lives is the hurdle justice must clear (Guardian)

The Nobel Prize-winning economist Amartya Sen argues that the state must ensure not only that individual freedoms exist, but that everyone has the ability to experience them.

10. Ethiopia: an aid success story or a tyranny? (Times)

Our money is eradicating poverty, says Camilla Cavendish, discussing the BBC's allegations about Ethiopian aid. But this money may also be used to prop up a repressive regime.

Read the CommentPlus summary.

Sign up now to CommentPlus for the pick of the day's opinion, comment and analysis in your inbox at 8am, every week day.

Show Hide image

Owen Smith promises to be a "cold-eyed revolutionary" - but tiptoes round Brexit

The Labour leader challenger takes Jeremy Corbyn on at his own anti-austerity game. 

Owen Smith may be challenging Jeremy Corbyn for the Labour leadership but it seems he has learnt a thing or two from his former boss. 

One year on from abstaining from the Tory Welfare Bill - a decision he now says he regrets - Smith attacked the former Chancellor George Osborne’s austerity policies from Orgreave, a former steel plant which was pivotal during the miners’ strike.  

Listing frustrations from library cuts to delayed trains, Smith declared: “Behind all of these frustrations is one cause – austerity.”

Borrowing the rhetoric that served Corbyn so well, he banged the drum about pay, labour rights and fair taxes. 

Indeed, a spokesman from Jeremy for Labour popped up to say as much: “We welcome Owen’s focus on equality of outcome, reindustrialisation and workers' rights - and his support for policies announced in recent months by Jeremy Corbyn and John McDonnell.”

On policy, though, Smith showed a touch of his own. 

His description of the Department for Work and Pensions as “a byword for cruelty and insecurity” resonates with the deep fear many benefit claimants feel for this faceless but all powerful authority. His promise to scrap it will not go unnoticed.

Another promise, to end the public sector pay freeze, is timely given widespread expectations that withdrawing from the EU’s single market will push up prices. 

He also appealed to the unions with a pledge to scrap the “vicious and vindictive” Trade Union Act. 

The policies may be Corbynite, but where Smith stands out is his determination to be specific and practical. He is selling himself as the Corbyn who actually gets things done. Asked about what he would replace zero-hours contracts with, he responded: "Well it could be one [hour]. But it can't be zero."

As he concluded his speech, he promised “revolution” but continued:

“Not some misty eyed romanticism about a revolution to overthrow capitalism.

“But a cold-eyed, practical, socialist revolution, through a radical Labour Government that puts in place the laws and the levers that can genuinely even things up.”

Smith’s speech, though, steered clear of grappling with the big issues of Brexit. He stands in favour of a second referendum on the Brexit deal, which may appease Labour's inner city voters but could frustrate others who voted Leave.

On the free movement of people – widely viewed as a dividing line between Labour’s Corbynite members and the wider voting population - he has been vague. He has previously expressed support for the "progressive case against freedom of movement" and criticised Corbyn for failing to understand patriotism. But this is not the same as drawing up policy. Whether he can come up with strong views on immigration and still appeal to both voter bases will be his biggest challenge of all. 

Owen Smith's 20 policies

1.      A pledge to focus on equality of outcome, not equality of opportunity 
2.      Scrapping the DWP and replacing it with a Ministry for Labour and a Department for Social Security
3.      Introducing modern wages councils for hotel, shop and care workers to strengthen terms and conditions
4.      Banning zero hour contracts
5.      Ending the public sector pay freeze
6.      Extending the right to information and consultation to cover all workplaces with more than 50 employees
7.      Ensuring workers’ representation on remuneration committees
8.      Repealing the Trade Union Act
9.      Increase spending on the NHS by 4 per cent in real-terms in every year of the next parliament
10.  Commit to bringing NHS funding up to the European average within the first term of a Labour Government
11.  Greater spending on schools and libraries
12.  Re-instate the 50p top rate of income tax
13.  Reverse the reductions in Corporation Tax due to take place over the next four years
14.  Reverse cuts to Inheritance Tax announced in the Summer Budget
15.  Reverse cuts to Capital Gains Tax announced in the Summer Budget
16.  Introduce a new wealth Tax on the top 1 per cent earners
17.  A British New Deal unveiling £200bn of investment over five years
18.  A commitment to invest tens of billions in the North of England, and to bring forward High Speed 3
19.  A pledge to build 300,000 homes in every year of the next parliament – 1.5 million over five years
20.  Ending the scandal of fuel poverty by investing in efficient energy